Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Public Services Reform (Registers of Scotland) Order 2020 [Draft]

Wednesday 11 March 2020 Finance and Constitution Committee About 10:30 Subordinate legislation 10 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

Agenda item 4 is consideration of the draft Public Services Reform (Registers of Scotland) Order 2020.

We will take evidence from Ben Macpherson, who is the Minister for Public Finance and Migration, Scott Mackay, who is the head of finance co-ordination, and John St Clair, who is a senior principal legal officer at the Scottish Government.

I invite the minister to make a short opening statement before we move to questions.

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

In 2019, in accordance with international standards, the Office for National Statistics reclassified Registers of Scotland as part of central Government, removing its status as a separate public corporation, under which it had been operating since 1996. This followed the reclassification of HM Land Registry in England. The primary reason for the change in status of both organisations is how their fees are now classified in the UK national accounts, which is as taxes rather than as fees.

That means that the legal powers that were conferred on the keeper of the registers of Scotland in the Public Finance and Accountability (Scotland) Act 2000 and the UK national budgeting regime are no longer aligned. In particular, as a Government body, Registers of Scotland will no longer have the power to accrue reserves and deploy them over a number of financial years.

The order will enable the keeper of the registers of Scotland to pass her existing accumulated reserves into the Scottish consolidated fund, so that they are not lost to the UK consolidated fund.

Scottish ministers therefore have no choice but to make the order to ensure that Registers of Scotland operates within the HM Treasury budgeting regime and is treated appropriately in the Scottish budget in future years.

On process and timing, the order is—of course—subject to the super-affirmative process. A draft was laid in November last year and was subject to a statutory consultation period. Following consultation with Registers of Scotland and its key stakeholders, the new draft order was laid at the end of January. There were nine responses to the consultation: because the number of responses was so limited, the explanatory document gives details of each of them. None of the responses questioned the legal basis of the draft order or suggested that an order could not be made. In fact, none made any comments on the actual text of the draft order.

On timing, I thank the committee for its approval of the slightly curtailed laying period, which is usual for this type of order, and which will—if approved—allow for the process to be completed before the end of the 2019-20 financial year. That is when the derogation period, during which HM Treasury allowed an exemption from applying the budget regime to Registers of Scotland, will come to an end. Although the organisation is self-financing, the order will mean that if, at any point in the future, income does not cover planned expenditure in a financial year, that can be addressed as part of the overall Scottish budget.

I confirm that the order need have no impact on the day-to-day activities of Registers of Scotland or its delivery of services to the public. It will simply bring Registers of Scotland into line with the internal accounting and budgeting of the rest of the Scottish Administration. I look forward to the committee’s questions.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

I am glad that we, and not HM Treasury, are getting the money. That will do for a starter.

In its letter, Registers of Scotland summarises the changes as

“transferring a number of risks from being wholly within the control of RoS to manage and mitigate, to being risks to be managed within the larger Scottish Government budgeting framework”

which the minister just mentioned. The letter also states that the keeper

“will therefore rely on the Scottish Government to provide the funding”

for a number of pieces of work such as warranty or cover for compensation payments, or cover for operating costs should any future market downturn impact on revenue that is generated through fees. With the coronavirus, such a situation in relation to fees could well emerge. What arrangements will ensure that the Scottish Government deals with any—in those circumstances, unexpected—liability that Registers of Scotland faces?

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

Under the order, there will be an arrangement whereby we will take responsibility for how we support Registers of Scotland as part of our overall responsibilities. As the committee would expect, we have been fully engaged with Registers of Scotland in advance of the order as part of the 2020-21 budget process and have—as the committee will be aware—provided funding of £12.4 million for next year. We will continue to engage with the keeper of the registers on Registers of Scotland’s funding position as circumstances develop, and we will provide what is necessary to allow Registers of Scotland to continue to deliver its important functions and priorities next year and in the future.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I will follow up on that point. When I was convener of the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee in the previous session of Parliament, it was the lead committee on the Land Registration etc (Scotland) Bill. As part of that process, we did some scrutiny of Registers of Scotland, at which point the level of reserves that were being held became an issue. I remember discussing the matter with the relevant minister, who was Fergus Ewing. We were told that the level of reserves that were held by Registers of Scotland was in part explained—as the convener alluded to—by its income being cyclical and very dependent on the health of the property market.

The costs of the organisation are relatively stable and it employs a large number of very experienced expert legal staff, so it cannot simply reduce costs. If there were to be a sudden drop-off in the property market caused by, for example, coronavirus, and Registers of Scotland’s income were to fall, it would have reserves to fall back on. It is a legitimate issue to raise: if suddenly Registers of Scotland had a big drop in income, would the Scottish Government guarantee it a protected level of income so that it would not have to look at reducing staff costs because its cushion of reserves was taken away?

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

That is a very important question. I agree about the levels of service and expertise that Registers of Scotland provides. As I said, as part of the Scottish Government’s budgeting process and in consultation with Registers of Scotland, we would make sure that there was a fair and appropriate arrangement for the funding that it requires, not just in relation to its costs and fluctuations in market revenue—to which Murdo Fraser referred—but in relation to priorities such as completion of the change in the land register from the register of sasines to the current modern approach. In terms of both service and priorities, the Scottish Government would make sure that appropriate funding would be provided.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Thank you for that helpful reassurance.

The Government is clearly benefiting from an unexpected windfall of £70 million to the Scottish budget. What will you spend that bonus on?

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

As I said in my opening remarks, the order is more of an accounting arrangement through which we will make sure that the rules are followed. The decision on where the resources will be applied—Scott Mackay will correct me if I am wrong—will be considered as part of the finance and budgeting process, as we have already discussed.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

Item 5 is consideration of the motion on the order. I invite the minister to move motion S5M-20852.

Motion moved,

That the Finance and Constitution Committee recommends that the Public Services Reform (Registers of Scotland) Order 2020 draft be approved.—Ben Macpherson

Motion agreed to.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

The committee will publish its report to Parliament in the coming days, setting out our decisions on both statutory instruments.

I thank the minister and his officials for giving evidence today.

Meeting closed at 10:42.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 60
  3. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.