Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Budget (Scotland) Act 2019 Amendment Regulations 2020 [Draft]

Wednesday 11 March 2020 Finance and Constitution Committee Subordinate legislation 60 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

60 contributions
Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

The second item on our agenda is to take evidence on the draft Budget (Scotland) Act 2019 Amendment Regulations 2020 from Ben Macpherson, the Minister for Public Finance and Migration, and Scott Mackay, the head of finance co-ordination, Scottish Government. Welcome to the meeting.

I invite the minister to make a short opening statement, if he wishes to do so.

Ben Macpherson SNP The Minister for Public Finance and Migration · Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

As the committee will know, the spring budget revision provides the final opportunity to formally amend the Scottish budget for 2019-20. This year’s spring budget revision deals with four different types of amendments to the budget. First, there are a few funding changes. Secondly, there are a significant number of technical adjustments that have no impact on spending power. Thirdly, there are some Whitehall transfers. Finally, there are some budget-neutral transfers of resources between portfolio budgets, including a modest budget redirection to ensure that we maximise our available budget. The net impact of all those changes is an increase in the approved budget of £1,108.5 million, from £43,094.8 million to £44,203.3 million.

Table 1.1 on page 5 of the supporting document shows the approved budgets following the autumn budget revision and the changes sought in the spring budget revision. The supporting document to the spring budget revision and the brief guide prepared by my officials provide background on the net changes.

The first set of changes increases the budget by £255.9 million and comprises funding that has been allocated over a number of lines as detailed in the brief guide.

The second, most significant, set of changes comprises a number of large technical adjustments to the budget. Those adjustments are mainly non-cash and therefore budget neutral—as they cannot be redeployed to support discretionary spend elsewhere. They have a net positive impact of £714.8 million on the overall aggregate position. It is necessary to reflect those adjustments to ensure that the budget is consistent with the accounting requirements and with the final outturn that will be reported in our annual accounts.

By far the largest of the adjustments relates to an increase to the annually managed expenditure provision for future national health service and teachers’ pensions costs. That flows mainly from past service costs for guaranteed minimum pensions equalisation relating to the full indexation of pensions in respect of members reaching state pension age after 6 April 2021. However, last year’s higher-than-expected pay award for teachers and the outcome of Court of Appeal rulings on the judicial pension scheme and the firefighters’ pension scheme discrimination claims have also contributed to the increase of £594.6 million.

With regard to Whitehall transfers and allocations from Her Majesty’s Treasury, there is a net positive impact on the budget of £138 million from a number of transfers, the most significant of which are the transfers of £80 million convergence funding for farmers from HM Treasury and the £35 million reserve claim to cover the costs of the changes to the personal injury discount rate.

The final part of the budget revision concerns the transfer of funds within and between portfolios to better align the budgets with profiled spend.

The main transfers between portfolios are noted in the supporting document and the guide to the SBR.

As we approach the financial year end, we will continue—in line with our usual practice—to monitor forecast outturn against budget and, wherever possible, we will seek to utilise any emerging underspends to ensure that we make optimum use of the resources available in 2019-20 and manage the necessary carry-forward to meet the additional spending commitments reflected in the budget agreement reached for 2020-21.

In line with the budget process review group’s recommendations, my officials have included in the brief guide that was sent to the committee an indication of the forecast outturn position as at 31 January. That is the latest position that was available when the brief guide was prepared and gives the committee the best view of the emerging underspend position. Provisional outturn figures will be announced by the Cabinet Secretary for Finance in early June.

The brief guide to the spring budget revision prepared by my officials sets out the background to and the details of the main proposed changes. I hope that colleagues have found the guide to be helpful.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

I guess that, when you took on the role of the Minister for Public Finance and Migration, you did not expect to have to deal with such procedural, technical transfer movements—and the numbers involved are considerable. The brief guide and how that is being developed is helping us—it is giving us a bit more transparency over what is going on and a bit more understanding.

However, over the years, this committee has faced a bit of a challenge when trying to scrutinise the funding position, particularly in relation to the Scotland reserve. It has not always been easy to work out what is happening because the picture constantly moves, although I guess that that is a normal part of the process.

Annex C of the brief guide provides the most up-to-date figure on the reserve, with a forecast closing balance of £106 million. I am not as interested in the movement therein as I am in what you can tell us today about how much of that reserve funding you will utilise to deal with the potential shortfall of £550 million in 2021-22 that will come out of the income tax reconciliation process later this year. I know that that figure is a projection at this stage, but I think that it will be pretty near the mark.

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

As you say, the reserve is a moving picture. There are considerations in respect of how the forecasting for that evolves. In short, the cabinet secretary will need to make a decision on the forecasting position that you mentioned as part of the 2021-22 budget process in due course.

The amount of reserve deployed in meeting future reconciliations will depend—as you would expect—on the overall funding for the 2021-22 budget. We do not yet have the United Kingdom Government spending plans for 2021-22, which await the outcome of the forthcoming UK spending review. Until we have a clearer position on that, it is difficult to be more precise.

Although about £100 million—after allowing for planned drawdown in 2020-21, as illustrated in annex C of the brief guide—is forecast as the Scotland reserve balance, that balance takes no account of any additional amounts that might emerge during the financial year.

As I alluded to in my opening statement, the cabinet secretary will need to consider the extent to which any resource borrowing may be deployed to offset the reconciliation impact. She will provide a statement to Parliament on the 2019-20 provisional outturn figures by portfolio in June, in accordance with the usual practice, which the committee will be used to. The statement will be accompanied by a breakdown of the Scotland reserve position.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

During the coming months, we might see some underspend in the budget that will be added to that Scotland reserve amount, so the figure will shift again. The committee is keen that the Government, in its medium-term financial strategy, which is due to be released in May, at least maps out a direction of travel on how it will deal with the reconciliation process. I hope that the Government will consider that point.

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

I note that point, which we will certainly consider.

Donald Cameron Con Highlands and Islands
link

Good morning, minister. I, too, want to ask about the reserve. I think that we all accept that the reserve fluctuates—you said that you expect that some additions will be made to it—and that forecasts get updated. Given that the £106 million figure is a long way below the spring budget revision forecast of, I think, £488 million, which is a decrease of about 80 per cent, and given that the amount has reduced from 2018-19 onwards, do you share my concern that the reserve has dwindled to a relatively small sum?

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

The £488.3 million figure, which appears at the bottom of table 1.7a on page 8 of the supporting document, shows an interim funding position. As I mentioned in my opening statement, what is provided in annex C of the Scottish Government brief guide is the most up-to-date position. The figures in that include the planned drawdown from the budget that the Parliament has just passed for the year ahead. However, there is also the impact of the negative consequentials that the UK Government imposed unexpectedly through its supplementary estimates. I refer the committee to the letter of 11 February from Kate Forbes, which goes into more detail on that point.

Donald Cameron Con Highlands and Islands
link

To reiterate what the convener has said about reconciliations, we have a troubling issue, as we all know. With the reserve at a relatively low point of £106 million, do you understand the significant anxiety that many have about how the Scottish Government will handle the reserve going forward?

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

The budgeting process is a movement between what becomes available and how we utilise underspend, and how that is rolled forward year by year.

As I said, annex C of the supporting document shows how the 2018-19 underspend is rolled forward and utilised; it also illustrates the drawdown that is being undertaken to implement the budget that the Parliament passed for 2020-21 and the negative consequentials that have had to be taken into account.

We need to go through a process of considering together those negative consequentials and the UK spending review and how we move the position forward. Scott Mackay might want to add something to that.

Scott Mackay Scottish Government
link

The £106 million highlighted at the bottom of the table in annex C allows for the planned drawdown in the 2020-21 budget, but it does not yet recognise any underspend that will emerge during the year. In the normal course of events, we would expect that figure to be augmented to a degree, at least.

Donald Cameron Con Highlands and Islands
link

I appreciate that you might not be able to answer this question, but do you have any idea of the sum of that augmentation? What additional sums might you garner?

Scott Mackay Scottish Government
link

The outturn varies year to year. We are showing £101 million as the likely emerging resource underspend at this point for 2019-20. It has been higher than that in previous years. However, as you said, we cannot predict the amount with any certainty at the moment.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

I want you to clarify what has been said to ensure that I understand it correctly. Usually, there is an underspend of about £200 million. If that transpired, the reserve would increase to £306 million. However, if I recall correctly, the maximum that can be drawn down from the reserve in any one year is £350 million.

Scott Mackay Scottish Government
link

That is correct. The maximum drawdown is £250 million of resource and £100 million of capital.

10:15

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

So that everyone understands the dynamic, that is not a big pot for dealing with the scale of the reconciliations.

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

The discussion thus far has been illuminating, as it always is when sifting through the finer details about the reserve, given that it is a bit of a moveable feast. Will the minister remind us of the constraints that are built into the reserve in terms of its size, how much can be drawn down and how it can be used? There are issues in relation to how the reserve can be deployed in terms of resource and capital.

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

We can work with a total of £700 million. Annually, we can use £250 million for resource and £100 million for capital. That constrains how we can use the reserve for the budgetary process. As the Scottish Government has illustrated in this year’s figures, it is used to best effect for the provision of the public services that we all want to invest in and improve.

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

Looking to the future, we all know that the fiscal framework will need to be reviewed at some point. Does the Government have any views now on what parameters it would ideally like to have at its disposal for the reserve?

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

It is not for me to speak on behalf of the Cabinet Secretary for Finance at this time, although she commented in last week’s stage 3 budget debate on the position of the Scottish Government as we go into the negotiations on the fiscal framework. The convener also spoke powerfully on those points in that debate. The negotiations will be extremely important for Parliament and for all our concerns for our constituents. The cabinet secretary is starting those conversations. In those early discussions, we have already asked the UK Government about the limits. That is one of the base points for taking forward those negotiations in the months ahead.

Alex Rowley Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Is the Scottish Government looking to speed up the fiscal framework negotiations and get them moving sooner rather than later, given the difficulty that the fiscal framework is causing?

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

Yes—the Cabinet Secretary for Finance was clear about that in the budget debate last week. We are keen to take those negotiations forward as soon as possible.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

A joint working party including Finance and Constitution Committee officials, Social Security Committee officials and the Government is working to draw together some themes on the challenges of the fiscal framework. That will come before the committee shortly and will give us more of the detail.

Alexander Burnett Con Aberdeenshire West
link

I have a small question on one of the additions. There is an £87 million addition to the rural services budget, which is labelled as convergence funding. It is clear that £80 million of that comes from the Whitehall transfer for convergence funding. Where does the additional £7 million come from?

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

The additional £7 million is from central Government funding in 2019-20, which allows the funding to farmers to be brought forward and allows a saving of that amount in 2020-21.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I, too, have a question on a minor issue, on which I would like more information. Page 58 in the supporting document shows a transfer of £7.5 million from the transport infrastructure and connectivity budget to the local government budget in relation to funding for an additional investment package in the Tay cities deal. Could you give us a bit more information on what that money will be spent on?

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

As you stated, the funding is for additional investment in the Tay cities deal. The transfer will enable early delivery of enabling works at the Michelin Scotland innovation parc and will help to secure private sector match funding. The project is a component of the Tay cities industrial investment programme, which is aligned with but is separate from the Tay cities deal.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

John Mason has a number of questions—

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

If we wanted more money in the reserves, we would have to cut our spending on health, local government, the police or whatever. That is the choice, is it not?

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Good. Thank you.

Page 11 of the supporting document deals with health and sport. Near the top of the list of proposed changes is a change of £50 million, which is described as

“Additional resource funding for health portfolio from Scottish Government”.

Can you provide any more detail on what that is for?

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

The allocation of that money follows the approach that was outlined in the Scottish Government’s medium-term financial strategy, which was published in May 2019. It will be used to support national health service boards.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Am I right that that money is not ring fenced and is just general funding?

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Page 26 of the supporting document deals with enterprise, trade and investment. At the top of the list of proposed changes is the figure of £45 million, which comprises £5 million of operating expenditure and £40 million of capital expenditure. The alignment of the table might be a bit out, but that change seems to be for

“Release of emerging/planned underspend to support priorities”.

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

Of that amount, £40 million is made up of financial transactions that have been returned to the centre from the Scottish national investment bank and further underspends that have emerged as a result of delays in committing to deals because of time being taken for sufficient scrutiny and due diligence on sign-off. We are fully committed to our programme with the Scottish national investment bank: the Government remains committed to the investment of £2 billion over 10 years to capitalise the bank. The change that Mr Mason has identified relates to the set-up—

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

So, that is partly a timing issue.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

Neil Bibby has a question on that specific area.

Neil Bibby Lab West Scotland
link

The £45 million is “to support priorities”. What priorities will it be used for?

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

I am not fully clear on that point, but I or Scott Mackay will write to you—unless Scott wants to comment now.

Scott Mackay Scottish Government
link

That money is not ring fenced for a particular purpose. It has flowed into the centre and forms part of the funding that is redistributed across the headings in the document.

Neil Bibby Lab West Scotland
link

The phrase “support priorities” suggests that there are priorities.

Scott Mackay Scottish Government
link

The supporting document details all the other additions that we have made, and the money to which you refer is part of the funding that supports those other additions. It is not really possible to point to a particular purpose for any single change.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Page 85 of the supporting document deals with social security. The largest figure there is £45.9 million of capital, which is described as

“Allocation of available funding to support capital projects”.

Are those information technology projects?

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

It was agreed at the start of the year that a budget transfer of up to £40 million for social security would be received through budget revision in the course of the year. We have also agreed a refreshed approach to capitalisation with central finance. The overall transfer of £45.9 million should therefore be viewed in conjunction with changes to our resource programme and operating costs budgets. Together, they represent an overall £38.7 million net budget transfer in. That will support key systems development for the social security programme. The key systems that are required include social programme management and the digital portal to support the wave 2 benefits.

Alex Rowley Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

It took a lot longer than anticipated to bring social security powers and capital investment powers to Scotland. One reason for that was complexity, but investment was also needed to build the systems. Are we building a system for 11 benefits, or are we building one that can take on more benefits as the powers are transferred from the Department for Work and Pensions to Scotland?

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

That is a question for the Cabinet Secretary for Social Security and Older People. However, I can reflect on my time on the Social Security Committee during the passage of the Social Security (Scotland) Bill. One of the complications was data, and how systems would be constructed and created to administer social security benefits, as we are determined to do, by linking with DWP data. There was a sense that we were learning from previous IT projects. Although we want to create an overall architecture, smaller IT projects are easier and are more efficient to implement. I do not want to speak on behalf of the Cabinet Secretary for Social Security and Older People. It would be more appropriate to seek detail from her.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

You mentioned pensions and teachers in your opening remarks. I suspect that when I was on the then Finance Committee I asked this question, but I have forgotten the answer. There are quite large figures under “Technical Changes”. Can you explain more? You said something about a higher pay increase. I am looking at the £408.5 million on page 108.

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

The additional net resource expenditure of £594.6 million has been added to the 2019 budget. As I said in my opening statement, that is annually managed expenditure and has therefore not been reported to HM Treasury. There is no impact on other Scottish Government budgets.

The increase is due to several factors. There is £400 million of past service costs for the guaranteed minimum pension, and there is equalisation relating to full indexation of pensions in respect of members reaching state pension age after 6 April 2021. There is £200 million each for the NHS pension scheme and the teachers pension scheme, along with the higher-than-expected pay award for teachers. The McCloud and Sargeant judgment and the increase in interest rates have increased resource costs by a further £194.6 million. The current service cost for 2019-20, expressed as a percentage of that pay, has increased from what was stated in the budget for 2019-20. The increase is mainly due, as I said, to the potential higher costs of benefits accruing in the future because of the judgment. That is partly offset by the increase in the discount rate, net of consumer prices index increases.

10:30

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

It sounds as if some actuaries were involved in that; it is beyond me. Is that amount a possible future liability, rather than an actual expense?

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

Yes. That will not impact on cash expenditure in-year.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

John Mason had a good kick at the ball, there.

Agenda item 3 is consideration of the motion on the order. I invite the minister to move motion S5M-21135.

Motion moved,

That the Finance and Constitution Committee recommends that the Budget (Scotland) Act 2019 Amendment Regulations 2020 draft be approved.—Ben Macpherson

Motion agreed to.

10:30 Meeting suspended.

10:33 On resuming—

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 60
  3. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.