Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Right to Buy Land to Further Sustainable Development (Eligible Land, Specified Types of Area and Restrictions on Transfers, Assignations and Dealing) (Scotland) Regulations 2020 [Draft]

Tuesday 3 March 2020 Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee About 11:15–12:30 Subordinate legislation 111 contributions · 15 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

111 contributions
Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

Item 4 is the draft regulations to establish a right to buy land to further sustainable development. We have a rather large panel for this round-table evidence session. It will not be as formal as an evidence session, so we have been able to invite a lot of guests, and 10 people will give evidence.

With that in mind, I remind witnesses that microphones are controlled by broadcasting; you do not have to press any buttons, because it is all done for you. The best way to make a point is to raise your finger and my clerks and I will make a list and get round to you. That also goes for members when they want to ask a question or intervene.

I will begin by introducing myself and we will then go round the table. My clerking team will stay in the background, as they do so beautifully. Just indicate who you are and who, if anyone, you are representing.

I am the convener.

Malcolm Combe University of Strathclyde
link

I am from the University of Strathclyde.

Rachel Oliphant Scottish Property Federation
link

I am from Pinsent Masons LLP and I represent the Scottish Property Federation.

Gemma Cooper NFU Scotland
link

I am from NFU Scotland.

Sandra Holmes Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

I am from Highlands and Islands Enterprise.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am an MSP for Mid Scotland and Fife.

Hamish Trench
link

I am from the Scottish Land Commission.

Jon Hollingdale Community Woodland Association
link

I am from the Community Woodland Association.

Annie McKee James Hutton Institute
link

I am from the James Hutton Institute.

Dr MacLeod
link

I am from Community Land Scotland.

Claudia Beamish Lab South Scotland
link

I am an MSP for South Scotland and shadow cabinet secretary for climate change, environment and land reform.

Gavin Mowat Scottish Land & Estates
link

I am from Scottish Land & Estates.

Diarmid Hearns National Trust for Scotland
link

I am from the National Trust for Scotland.

Finlay Carson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I am the MSP for Galloway and West Dumfries.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

I would like to start with the consultation process. I have the consultation documents in front of me. How content have you been with that process? Do you feel that the views and concerns that you put forward have been taken into account?

Who would like to go first? There is always that tricky moment before anyone wants to come in.

Gemma Cooper NFU Scotland
link

We are very content with the process that was undertaken. The Scottish Government has been good to deal with, and it looked at and took a lot from existing legislation. We are fairly content with the majority of things, because the Government has taken a pragmatic approach.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

This is the last piece in the right to buy jigsaw. Do you feel that your concerns about that gap have been addressed?

Rachel Oliphant Scottish Property Federation
link

Yes. We felt that we were well consulted and the Scottish Government community land team also engaged with us beforehand, particularly on abandoned, neglected or detrimental land, and took into account our concerns about ensuring that the prohibition on sale kicks in only once the notice appears in the register of applications by community bodies to buy land. When they deal with land, that addition makes it a lot easier for our members to know when the prohibition starts.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

Are there any other reflections?

Dr MacLeod
link

Community Land Scotland very much echoes those comments; the Scottish Government officials have been excellent in terms of their level of communication and the opportunities to input our views into the process, for what, as you say convener, is an important part of the jigsaw of community rights to buy.

Gavin Mowat Scottish Land & Estates
link

We are of the same opinion; we welcomed the engagement by Scottish Government and the fact that it drew a lot from its previous legislation, including on abandoned, neglected or detrimental land—a lot of that experience has come into this regulation.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

Are you content that the definition of sustainable development is nailed down enough to ensure that, if people want to apply for the right to buy, they know what they have to do to fulfil the criteria for sustainable development?

Diarmid Hearns National Trust for Scotland
link

One of our concerns is that sustainable development was not defined in the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003, nor is it in the text of the regulation. It is a challenge for both applicants and owners to know what the test for that is. There are good international definitions of the term, so it would be good to get some appending text to say what the Scottish Government means by sustainable development.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

And that could be some guidance around the definition of sustainable development and some examples of cases.

11:45

Malcolm Combe University of Strathclyde
link

The definition of sustainable development has been a recurring theme since the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003, parts 2 and 3 of which deal with the right to buy. The difficulty with definitions is that they can trap people as well as be useful. I will give an example that might seem strange from the insurance sector, where no definition is provided of what an insurance contract is. If a definition were to be provided, people would try to make sure that they did not fall within it, because that would allow them to work around it and to exclude themselves from regulation, for example.

The definition of sustainable development is a problem, but it has been recognised as a problem in previous iterations of the legislation. The question is whether now is the time to do something about it. Some people would argue that we are where we are and that, having not done anything about the issue in relation to the previous three community rights to buy, it would be incongruous to suddenly do something about it now and try to capture sustainable development in a form of wording that might leave some people dissatisfied. It is a prickly issue that is tough to resolve.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

Another issue is who will be the arbiter of whether someone conforms to what is meant by the phrase, which is undefined.

Rachel Oliphant Scottish Property Federation
link

I agree that it would not be helpful to define sustainable development in legislation, but more detailed guidance would be welcome, along with examples of what would fall within the definition.

Hamish Trench
link

I appreciate that it is always tempting to define sustainable development, but it is probably quite risky to do so in legislation. It seems to me that the meaning of sustainable development and, indeed, of the public interest are likely to shift over time. Given how important and fundamental this right to buy is, it needs to be able to reflect changing circumstances. Therefore, in my view, sufficient clarity should be provided on the relevant considerations in the regulations, but there should also be guidance that can change over time.

Jon Hollingdale Community Woodland Association
link

I think that what constitutes sustainable development will have to be judged on a case-by-case basis. It is not possible to define which activities or which piece of land would be suitable before knowing what the proposal was going to be. We probably all agree that Scotland needs more affordable housing and that the provision of affordable housing would further sustainable development, but it would not if it were provided on St Kilda, the top of the Cairngorm plateau or lots of other places. The judgment must be made on a case-by-case basis. If we try to make it before we get real applications that make real proposals, we will trap ourselves.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

That comes back to Malcolm Combe’s point, which was that a definition could exclude people unintentionally.

Annie McKee James Hutton Institute
link

I agree with all the points that have been made so far. The opportunity is here for communities to do something innovative. We want to open up that opportunity and be flexible in how we identify and understand sustainable development, but that conversation must take place at the local level and with ministers. Therefore, further guidance and worked case studies would definitely be helpful.

Dr MacLeod
link

One of the issues with sustainable development—I say this as someone who taught a number of courses on the subject at the University of Edinburgh, where it would be possible to have a three-day conference on the meaning of sustainable development—is how wide ranging its parameters are. Therefore, it would be unhelpful, as other colleagues have said, to have a statutory definition of it.

As far as the intent of legislation is concerned, the public interest is fundamentally important as the overarching determinant of how sustainable development is interpreted and implemented in practice, and I think that the regulations and the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2016 do a good job in providing some parameters, such as economic regeneration and other criteria. A case-by-case approach to interpretation allows for the concepts of the public interest and the common good to be moved from the policy intent to the practicalities of implementing and interpreting this right to buy in practice.

Diarmid Hearns National Trust for Scotland
link

The Scottish Government is already a signatory to the UK shared framework on sustainable development, which gives a lengthy description of what sustainable development constitutes. There is already an accepted definition of what sustainable development is.

In the Planning (Scotland) Act 2019, a purpose for planning was included in legislation for the first time, which included sustainable development. The 2019 act refers to the management of land

“in the long term public interest.”

We are getting clearer about how we are working towards the future. We are not talking about a short-term fix—we are trying to define such concepts and what they mean in practical terms—so it would be good to see a clear definition.

Finlay Carson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I will give an example and I would like to find out whether the witnesses think that it would count as sustainable development. There is a community of 30 houses in the middle of a wood that is a long way from anywhere, and the social landlord decides to put four of the houses on the market because it cannot afford to bring them up to the new insulation standards. The community wants to buy them to stop Airbnb people buying them and affecting their ability to send their children to the local school. Would that fit the criteria for the right to buy for sustainable development?

Sandra Holmes Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

It would. We must look at the context. If a small community loses people, that can have a significant impact on wider service provision. You cannot pin down sustainable development. It must be looked at case by case and in context.

Community buyout projects are diverse, from something as small as one building plot up to buying a whole island or estate. Getting a definition to encompass all those considerations would mean writing chapters.

As Malcolm Combe mentioned, there has been a consistent understanding of sustainable development since we first had the community right to buy and the crofting community right to buy. I am not aware of any challenges to the definition, or of any problems that have been created in practice. A number of community right to buy applications have gone successfully through the process.

Dr MacLeod
link

Communities may be a long way from anywhere, but they are all close to somewhere. We want fragile remote and rural communities to be able to sustain themselves and to develop sustainably. As Sandra Holmes said, access to services, especially to affordable housing, is very important. That is the life-blood of a community. Sustainable development is social, economic, cultural and environmental.

Jon Hollingdale Community Woodland Association
link

I agree with my colleagues. Finlay Carson’s example was about a landlord putting houses up for sale. We are talking about what would happen if a landlord refused to sell and also refused to do anything positive. In that situation, it would be clear that it would further sustainable development if the community were to take on houses that were not being brought up to spec.

Malcolm Combe University of Strathclyde
link

There might be an existing device in Scots law that could be used to help in that example. It is possible to insist on a rural housing burden being imposed under section 43 of the Title Conditions (Scotland) Act 2003. You have to encourage people to constitute a rural housing body so that there can be a burden in their favour, but it is a possible alternative to using this legislation.

Sandra Holmes reminded me of something that is important in existing community buyouts. As one of the lawyers in the room, I will mention human rights. The European convention on human rights is hardwired into the Scotland Act 1998. The existing community rights to buy, most notably in the Park litigation on the east coast of Lewis, involved discussion of human rights. The lack of a definition of sustainable development was not held to be an issue. I am simplifying grossly, but it was not a problem with reference to article 1 of the first protocol, which is about peaceful enjoyment of possessions, or with reference to article 6, which would deal with a landowner getting a fair hearing.

It is good to have a discussion about sustainable development, but having a definition of it is not required by the way in which human rights law has been interpreted to date in Scotland.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

Communities have a right to buy in order to have a sustainable development project. We have seen communities use all the land reform tools available to them to gain control of land. From speaking to constituents, I get the impression that that can be onerous. I would like to know how you think that this right to buy legislation might help.

Jon Hollingdale Community Woodland Association
link

The burden comes in two ways. The first is in the rules under part 5 of the 2016 act, which set significant tests for the community in relation to future harm and benefit and to the exercise of the right to buy being the only, or the most practical, way of furthering sustainable development. Then there are what we might call the process burdens. We think that, in order to get to the stage that is covered by part 5, community bodies will have had to go through the processes in part 2 of the 2003 act and have an existing community right to buy registration in order to have the prohibition on transfer—otherwise, it would be just too easy to avoid the legislation.

At the moment, there are probably vanishingly small numbers of eligible community bodies, because of the way in which the 2016 act has been framed. We cannot change that through the regulations, but it is notable that almost no community bodies out there already have in their constitutions the powers to use the legislation. In the first instance, such bodies will have to change their constitutions to enable them to do so, and then they will have to go through the part 2 processes, followed by those in part 5, so theirs will be a long and probably quite testing journey.

Annie McKee James Hutton Institute
link

My colleague Rob McMorran and others, including Malcolm Combe and Jon Hollingdale, carried out research for the Scottish Land Commission that reviewed community right to buy mechanisms and evidenced how onerous the earlier mechanism was. As Jon has already mentioned, bodies have to constitute themselves in a certain way and then work through part 2 in order to achieve part 5, which are all processes that rely heavily on community effort and volunteers. Anything that could support such processes more would be worth while. It would not necessarily make them easier, but it would provide opportunities for facilitated discussion with landowners or resources to work through them from a legal perspective, which would be a good thing if it encouraged greater community engagement with the land-owning sector.

Dr MacLeod
link

I agree that undertaking such processes is onerous for communities. In such circumstances there is not a willing seller, so it is understandable, for all sorts of reasons, that a high bar is set. However, it is important that it is not set too high. Ten years ago, I led post-legislative scrutiny of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003, on behalf of the Parliament. One of the clear findings from that study was that the demands that were placed on communities by part 2, and especially by part 3 on the crofting community right to buy, were extremely onerous. We have seen subsequent changes in the legislation since then. No one will ever get such matters right first time, but we need to be mindful that we do not make the challenges disproportionately difficult.

Rachel Oliphant Scottish Property Federation
link

I agree that such processes will be very onerous for community bodies. If I might speak about my personal experience, I live in a community that exercised the community right to buy under part 2. We were lucky, in that among our community were an architect, an accountant, a lawyer and lots of retired people who had the time to put our application together, sort out funding and subsequently maintain the property. We bought it in 2008, so we are now a good number of years on. Our bid has been very successful, and we very much appreciate having had such an opportunity, but I can see that it could be very hard for other communities without the resources that we had.

Rachel Oliphant Scottish Property Federation
link

However, I should say that the community land team is very helpful to everyone in such situations.

Hamish Trench
link

Calum MacLeod has already covered the first point that I was going to make, which is that, inevitably, the bar will be fairly high, given that this is compulsory. However, it is also helpful to consider the wider context. If our collective aim is to normalise community ownership as a realistic option for communities across Scotland, we will not achieve that through establishing rights to buy—those will never be the usual way in which every community will acquire land and buildings.

We should not underestimate the important role that the right to buy plays in shifting the dynamic and changing the culture and the balance of power in discussions. Our success is probably more because of the level of negotiated transfers that take place. However, clearly, where the backstop of the right to buy process is needed, it must be usable and accessible.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

It might not happen often, but the right to buy is always there if access has not been achieved through other means.

12:00

Sandra Holmes Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

I will build on Hamish Trench’s point. Any community buyout is a long journey if the right to buy is used, and it is an even longer journey if compulsory purchase is involved. Getting the appropriate balance of rights is an issue, but the fundamental point is that, although the process is onerous and a long journey for communities, it has to be workable. The crofting community right to buy was enacted in 2004 but to date has never been used to fruition. However, through bringing parties together, it has facilitated the transfer of crofting estates from private to community ownership. It would be great for a crofting community right to buy to be successful, just to prove that the legislation works. Likewise, it is imperative that this legislation is deemed to be workable in practice. If it is not, its presence in the background would be helpful, as Hamish Trench said, but it would not be the go-to legislation. I work with communities all the time and we would never see it as a starting point, but the leverage that it can offer to bring parties together is hugely beneficial. We now have all these rights to buy, but the vast majority of community purchases have happened through negotiation. That is the right place to be, but we need the right to buy to provide the wider framework and backdrop to encourage those facilitated purchases.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

It is the final piece in the jigsaw, but the other jigsaw pieces are probably more the go-to.

Gemma Cooper NFU Scotland
link

I agree with the majority of what has been said. It is important to emphasise that, for our members in particular, this will change the conversation. We have been speaking about a community right to buy, but this is actually a compulsory purchase, so it is potentially quite uncomfortable for our guys.

I agree that the hurdles need to be proportionate. I appreciate that the process is difficult at the moment, but when a community takes on an asset, that is permanent and it needs to be looked after long term, as my fellow speaker has identified. Having high hurdles is not necessarily a bad thing, because they relate to how serious the community is about looking after the asset in future.

I emphasise, as did Hamish Trench, that success is not measured on the number of times that the right to buy is used. It should be about negotiated transfers without having to use the right to buy, but it is obviously a backstop.

Rachel Oliphant Scottish Property Federation
link

Gemma Cooper has made the point that I was going to make. If the community cannot work together at the application stage, it will not be able to maintain the property in the future. It is good to establish at the outset that it has that ability.

Diarmid Hearns National Trust for Scotland
link

I agree with Hamish Trench. The process can be a bit onerous, but it is probably there as a backstop, rather than as a frontstop, as it were. It has changed the dynamic, including what the options are. For a charitable landowner, that might be not be ownership but might leasing an alternative site. The process opens up a discussion, and I would measure success not in terms of zero-sum transfer or non-transfer but in terms of different ways of doing things. Having the right to buy as a backstop is valuable.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

We will move on with some questions from Finlay Carson.

Finlay Carson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

This question is on a subject that has been contentious in the past. It is about the types of occupancy or possession relating to tenancies. Do the provisions on occupation or tenancies adequately cover all possible eventualities when we are looking at the right to buy? Malcolm Combe might want to answer with regard to human rights.

Malcolm Combe University of Strathclyde
link

The starting point would be that a sitting tenant, to an extent, will not be affected by the transfer of their landlord’s interest. In the response that was submitted while I was working at the University of Aberdeen, I made a point of saying that the regulations are drafted in such a way that they include an exhaustive list of the tenancies that are caught. I wonder whether the list should be non-exhaustive in case something has not been caught. My concern about the drafting is that there is a danger of being trapped in a definition.

As I said, for the currency of the lease, the tenant should not be directly affected by the transfer of the landlord’s interest, at least in law. There might be a different dynamic given the new personality that they have to engage with.

Finlay Carson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

The nature of a list is that attention is drawn to what is excluded and not what is included. Are the implications of the definitions of the likes of tied accommodation adequately understood?

Malcolm Combe University of Strathclyde
link

From my perspective, they are, but I say that as someone who has been swimming in legislation on private residential tenancies. I have written a bit about this with Professor Peter Robson from the University of Strathclyde, and there is plenty of case law in relation to the Rent Acts down the years and what can and cannot constitute tied accommodation. I am not hugely concerned about that point. I do not know whether anyone else wants to comment.

Gavin Mowat Scottish Land & Estates
link

A lawyer can understand the definition of tied accommodation, but I am not sure that communities have the same breadth of understanding. As we have heard, there might be experts in some communities but, by and large, I am not sure that it will be adequately understood across the board. That said, however, I am not sure that that is the main issue that we want to bring up.

From our point of view, the purpose of the regulations is to deliver sustainability. We understand that the Government is trying to fix the problem where tied accommodation is included in abandoned and neglected land. However, if we take tied accommodation as a part of a business rather than the whole of it, and we include that in a right to buy, we must consider the possible implications for the sustainability of the wider business. That needs to be considered in the regulations.

Dr MacLeod
link

As has been mentioned, community capacity is an issue. We know that it will vary between communities, but in the vast majority of community buyouts that are undertaken, there is a tapping of community capacity. In most instances, communities take control of the land and other assets as a means of delivering the housing, jobs and services that will ensure that those communities are sustainable in practice. That bottom-up element is important.

On tied accommodation, we quite often see that communities that have taken over assets and tracts of land have enabled businesses to come in through that new ownership model. Under community ownership, there is an important continuity, as opposed to a disjuncture.

Jon Hollingdale Community Woodland Association
link

The regulations and rules were more or less cut and pasted across from part 3A of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003, on the community right to buy abandoned, neglected or detrimental land. In the discussions when the bill that became that act was going through the Parliament, there was initially an idea that all tenancies would be excluded, but it was pointed out quite clearly that, if that was done, huge areas of Scotland would be ruled out from eligibility.

The important point on that, on tied accommodation and on the broader points that Gavin Mowat made is that everything would be subject to the sustainable development test. I suspect that a community that came forward and simply wanted to buy or acquire some houses that were tied accommodation with no other purpose would struggle to make a sustainable development case to the Scottish ministers. The test has to be included because, if the community wants to buy the whole estate, it will want to take the tied accommodation or other forms of tenancies with it.

The question has to be framed within the broader sustainable development test, and we need to consider why the community body seeks to acquire the housing that is under one of those forms of tenancy and the other bits of land that it wants to acquire, rather than just looking at the housing, because it would be really unlikely that ministers would ever approve such an application.

Annie McKee James Hutton Institute
link

Speaking as a non-lawyer, I suppose that I am a bit nervous about tied accommodation, because it possibly reinforces power relations that are quite traditional, which we may want to move away from. I would encourage the Government to include in the guidance document consideration of how employment and housing opportunities can be provided in parallel so that, if someone is offered a job, they are also—hopefully—offered a tenancy that is discrete from the job. We need more homes, especially in rural communities.

Finlay Carson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Jon Hollingdale suggested that much of the content of the regulations has been lifted and dropped from previous legislation. Are there any provisions in the regulations that are different from the other community rights to buy? If so, are there good reasons to include them?

Jon Hollingdale Community Woodland Association
link

There are additional provisions that do not appear in part 2 of the 2003 act, but most of the provisions in parts 3A and 5 of that act appear pretty much word for word. I am looking at Malcolm Combe, who will tell me if I have got that wrong

Malcolm Combe University of Strathclyde
link

They appear word for word. An omission that was made when the part 3A regulations were put in place was that there was no mention of tenancy at will, which is a particular type of tenancy that exists in some geographical locations in Scotland, although it is not common. That was possibly an oversight. Otherwise, they just track what is in the 2018 regulations.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

We will move on with some questions from Mark Ruskell.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I turn to the exclusions in the regulations. There are the section 4 exclusions in relation to an individual’s residence and its curtilage, which reminds me of the Ann Gloag case around access and the 2003 act. There is also an exemption for land that is ancillary to the person’s residence, and there are various exemptions on the keeping of pets, recreational and leisure activities, the growing of food and so on. What are your thoughts on those exclusions? Are they appropriately drawn? Do you see any issues regarding things that are not included? Are the exclusions drawn too broadly or too narrowly?

Dr MacLeod
link

I can see why the categories of exclusions have been included in regulation 4. We made the point in our submission to the Scottish Government consultation—others probably made the point, too—that we can see why the exclusions are there, but we need to be mindful of the need to ensure that there is no sharp practice, to use a non-legal term, in how they are interpreted. For example, is someone putting their pet sheep Dolly on to three different fields as a way of precluding an opportunity for a community to focus on a piece of land that it argues would contribute to its sustainable development?

We need to be mindful of how the categories of excluded land will be interpreted in practice. I imagine that the guidance and other documentation will be really important, as is the case in relation to the other community rights to buy, with regard to what the possibilities, or the lack of them, will be.

Hamish Trench
link

Our general view is that the exclusions seem entirely reasonable and understandable. Of course, there could be misuse, but we just need to be alert to that. I would be nervous about tightening the exclusions, because the other side of the coin is that the right to buy needs to be sufficiently applicable. It is important to ensure that the regulations will be usable in all sorts of different circumstances around Scotland. Given the criteria and the public interest test, there will be an ability to step in and spot any sharp practice or deliberate misuse. They seem to be pretty well framed, as far as we can tell.

Jon Hollingdale Community Woodland Association
link

It will be down to Scottish ministers to exercise their judgment on whether the exclusions are reasonable in any particular case. For example, a householder who has a private water supply that is drawn from several hundred metres away could conceivably have their own hydro scheme, and they could claim that the catchment of that is supplying the electricity to their house. I would not be keen on that being used as a reason to exclude several hundred or thousand acres from a community bid. However, Scottish ministers will have to tackle such things and make decisions as and when cases come forward. It would be very difficult to fix a rule in the regulations.

12:15

Malcolm Combe University of Strathclyde
link

Eight things are listed that will exclude land from eligibility for buying. The seventh item in regulation 4(b) is:

“access to the individual’s home, if the land is owned by the same person that owns that home.”

Where someone has a servitude of access to their home, a change in the ownership of the burdened area of land will not affect their access rights. As such, there is no need to exclude that from the operation of the right to buy. A couple of the other items in the list—those on the use of land for drainage and the storage of vehicles—also reflect rights that can be represented in Scots law by servitude rights. I made that point in the submission that I provided alongside Alisdair MacPherson and Donna McKenzie-Skene.

The tail of the seventh item in regulation 4(b), which states

“if the land is owned by the same person that owns that home”,

could also be applied to the third item, on drainage, and the second item, on the storage of vehicles. It is possible for those rights to exist in relation to land that is owned by someone else, rather than the homeowner. Arguably, we should have made that point back in 2018, because it would have applied equally to the regulations in relation to abandoned, neglected and detrimental land. I apologise for being two years late in that regard. Nonetheless, it is worth at least logging that now. I will be happy to speak further to that if the committee wants any clarification.

Diarmid Hearns National Trust for Scotland
link

We observe that the exclusions are narrowly drawn. There are exclusions for individuals, which we support, and for Government land, but there is nothing in the middle in relation to other forms of ownership. Speaking from a charitable perspective, I note that we own assets for public benefit, but local community groups might own assets for public benefit, too. That is not covered, and the question of who has the greater public interest has been left to the judgment of Scottish ministers.

In our case, we have the added burden of inalienability. Some parts of our ownership would be declared inalienable, which limits our ability to sell them. It goes to a parliamentary test. It seems that a big band of other types of public ownership have been left out and it is being left to Scottish ministers to make judgments.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

Finlay Carson has a question on that, so I will bring him in.

Finlay Carson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I want to consider the implications of the exclusion of land that is owned by the Government, the Crown and local authorities. We see many examples where decisions by local authorities are seen as not having been taken in the interests of communities that are directly affected. How will that work in practice? Is it a major exclusion that needs to be looked at? In relation to the Crown Estate, there has been a suggestion that communities should have the right to control foreshores and so on. What are the implications of those exclusions?

Jon Hollingdale Community Woodland Association
link

Scottish public authorities such as local authorities, Scottish Forestry and Scottish Natural Heritage are covered by the asset transfer provisions. As such, in most cases, communities will be much more likely to go through that process.

I suspect that the big omission is land in Scotland that is owned by UK bodies such as the Ministry of Defence and Network Rail. As they are not covered by the asset transfer provisions, that route is not available to communities, and now there is not this route. The Ministry of Defence is an odd one, because there have been a number of cases where communities have successfully used the right under part 2 of the 2003 act to buy land from Ministry of Defence estates. As such, I am not entirely clear why it is excluded.

Sandra Holmes Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

There are anomalies in the regulations when we compare and contrast them with the previous community rights to buy. I am not clear why land or assets that belong to UK ministers are excluded, and I cannot see any reference to that in the crofting community right to buy. Asset transfer is different, because it is to do with Scottish public authorities.

Land falls to the Crown if, for example, a company or an asset of a company has been dissolved and the company has not divested itself of its assets. If somebody died intestate, their assets will fall to the Crown. My understanding is that that is in the primary legislation, so it is perhaps beyond being changed at this stage. Bona vacantia and ultimus haeres are excluded, so the approach is consistent with part 3A of the 2003 act. However, as far as I can see, part 3A and part 2 of the 2003 act, which is about the community right to buy, do not exclude assets that belong to UK ministers.

Dr MacLeod
link

I reiterate and support Sandra Holmes’s point about not seeing the rationale for the exclusion of that type of land. Mr Carson mentioned foreshore rights. There are lots of examples involving that type of land where such rights would be helpful to communities.

There is a right to ask for the community asset transfer process to happen. However, the Scottish Land Commission research, which Annie McKee mentioned, clearly says that a lot of public authorities have quite a long way to go on the cultural position with regard to where, in whose hands and for whose benefit they see assets sitting, and we need to tackle that.

Finlay Carson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I have a daft-laddie question that Jon Hollingdale might be able to answer. Military defence land has been touched on; there are also UK properties that are now redundant, such as Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency properties and vehicle testing facilities. Is there a right to buy south of the border that does not apply to Scotland? Can communities there apply to take over those properties, whereas that is not covered in Scotland because there is different legislation here?

Jon Hollingdale Community Woodland Association
link

I am not an expert on the issue, and I am even less of an expert on legislation south of the border, but I do not think that there are any formal mechanisms for that.

Malcolm Combe University of Strathclyde
link

I am pretty sure that there are not. The nearest legislation to that is the Localism Act 2011, which gives communities a right to bid for six months. However, even that right to bid is just that: the landowner does not need to accept the bid. That allows them six months to get their show in order but not—not to torture the vehicle analogy too much—necessarily even on the road at the end of the day.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

Does Mark Ruskell want to come back in?

Claudia Beamish Lab South Scotland
link

I have a brief supplementary question about the exclusions. I think that I am correct in saying that, in its submission, Scottish Land & Estates highlighted concerns about local development plans in relation to part 5 of the Land Reform Act 2016. Do you have any comments to make on that?

Gavin Mowat Scottish Land & Estates
link

I think that it has been mentioned that the new planning act has a new purpose, which includes sustainable development and the public interest. In essence, if any local development plan allocation is made, it should be in the public interest and sustainable development should have been looked at. The initial thought was that, if something is in the local development plan, it is likely to already be in the public interest and the interests of sustainable development, so it perhaps will not meet one of the five tests for the regulations. We therefore thought that it might be better to include such things.

Dr MacLeod
link

I read that particular submission and the submission from the Scottish Property Federation with considerable interest. Community Land Scotland does not think that that is an appropriate approach to take, not least because, with the Planning (Scotland) Act 2019 and national performance framework 4, we have a policy agenda on rural repopulation and we have issues to do with local place plans and which organisations might be involved in shaping, developing and managing those plans. Local communities and community bodies could well be part of that process, so it would be detrimental to the sustainability of areas to follow that policy through.

On other exemptions, I think that it has been suggested that protected areas might also be exempt. I am not entirely clear about what protected areas are in this context, but, if we are talking about whether designations are environmental or otherwise or about local development plans, for example, that would be inconsistent with the applicability of any of the other community rights to buy that we already have.

Let us take national scenic areas as one example of that. Great swathes of Scotland’s rural land would be cut out from being eligible for this particular community right to buy. For the same reason, making second or empty homes ineligible flies in the face of rural sustainability and the need to get access to affordable homes and put empty homes back into the community.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

There could be a fundamental disagreement among the community about what a local authority, for example, wanted to do with its land. In my constituency, there is a fundamental disagreement about the local authority’s objectives for an area of land, which is based on environmental issues. There is a tension there that has not been addressed.

Dr MacLeod
link

That takes us back to the point about the public interest, because that is a public interest argument.

Annie McKee James Hutton Institute
link

Understanding the public interest is very difficult for people who volunteer in rural communities, and having to address that with the local authority could be quite a challenge. There needs to be more discussion about what sustainable development is at a local level and what is in the public interest. There needs to be a national conversation about that within the context of planning reform.

Hamish Trench
link

The Scottish Land Commission would not support the extension of exclusions to include such examples of development allocations or designated sites. That is partly because doing so would exclude very significant areas of land in Scotland, but it is fundamentally because that would be to prejudge the public interest. It would, in essence, undermine the point of the right to buy, which is precisely to look at and to weigh up the public interest in the specific local circumstances.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

We will move on to questions from Claudia Beamish.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

Actually, I will stop you there, because I have completely ignored Gavin Mowat and Jon Hollingdale, who wanted to come in on that last point.

Gavin Mowat Scottish Land & Estates
link

I take on board all the points that have been made. We wanted to emphasise the sustainable development angle particularly in cases in which an individual or a community cannot do something with a piece of land because it has been designated that sustainable development should be taken into consideration. Perhaps not every community has the capacity to understand that. I am quite happy for such issues to be defined more clearly in guidance rather than included as extra exclusions.

Jon Hollingdale Community Woodland Association
link

I presume that, when a case is brought to the Scottish ministers, allocation in local development plans will be one of the factors in their judging the public interest. There is a clear principle in part 2 of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2016, on the community right to buy, that communities cannot try to buy assets to frustrate development and prevent things from happening. However, in this case, it is more likely that communities would want to buy the asset in order to fulfil the allocation in the local development plan.

I have recently been working with a community that wants to create affordable housing. The local authority has said that the community has a site right next to its village that has been allocated for that but the landowner has no interest in developing that site for that purpose, so the community is stuck in limbo. The local authority has said, “Here is the land,” but the community cannot access it.

It is more likely that communities will want to buy an asset in order to deliver what is in their local development plan rather than to frustrate it.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

We will go back to Claudia Beamish, with my apologies.

Claudia Beamish Lab South Scotland
link

I would like to focus our minds on the types of area that are specified for the definition of a community. I shudder slightly when I recall the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2016, but that was passed some time ago and I hope that things have shaped up well. However, we will hear the panel’s views.

For the public record, I will set out the definition of the types of area by which a community may be defined—I am sure everyone in the room will know the definition. The definition includes

“an electoral ward, ... the area of a community council, ... a postcode area, ... a postcode district, ... a postcode sector, ... an island, ... a locality”

or settlement

“delineated on the maps included in the Population Estimates for Settlements and Localities in Scotland, Mid-2016”.

Do the provisions adequately cover all possible eventualities and situations in relation to communities that might want to use them? Is it possible that certain communities might be excluded? Are the provisions in keeping with other community rights to buy? If they differ, is there a good reason for their doing so? Of course, the communities of interest issue was raised previously, and there are other issues that the panel might want to highlight and comment on.

12:30

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

Annie McKee, I saw you nodding your head as Claudia Beamish was speaking about the definition of a community. Do you want to respond?

Annie McKee James Hutton Institute
link

How to define a community is an interesting part of social science. I do not know whether I have anything to add to the list—I would turn to the more legal heads in the room for that. I am really interested in whether the guidance could consider how communities might be able to work together. If they cross boundaries, for instance, or if they are part of a landscape, there may be an opportunity to overcome capacity limitations by forming visions for their place together.

Sandra Holmes Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

The legislation has been broadened. When it was first implemented, the definition of a community was quite narrow. That has been added to, which benefits communities, because most people tend to know what their natural community is.

I am not aware of any significant limitations in the current drafting of the definition, which has just been outlined, but there is some confusion for communities when new legislation comes in on top of existing legislation. I think that Jon Hollingdale pointed out that communities are having to redraft their constitutions to accommodate the new legislation.

We are coming to the end of the suite of rights to buy, and there are templates available to help communities, so I do not see the drafting of the legislation as a barrier. I think that it is pretty workable. I work with communities frequently, and most of them tend to use postcodes, but they have other options as well.

Jon Hollingdale Community Woodland Association
link

I understand that the definition is lifted from part 3A of the 2003 act, so it is the same set of rules. I think that the primary legislation allows communities to define themselves not just in terms of one electoral ward or one postcode sector but by parts and combinations.

My only query is why the definition is fixed at the localities and settlements of 2016. I appreciate that that is what is in the part 3A rules, but I think that National Records of Scotland updates its localities and settlements information every four years. If we are trying to future proof the regulations, we must recognise that, 10 years down the line, that localities and settlements information will be two or three iterations out of date.

I am not quite clear why that has been done. There is probably a good legal reason that I do not understand, but fixing the definition in 2016 seems strange.

Malcolm Combe University of Strathclyde
link

I flew a bit of a kite in my consultation response by proposing a slightly new-fangled way of defining a community by imagining an area of land that has been somehow fragmented or subdivided.

Let us imagine that a 100-acre site was split up 25 years ago and 40 acres were sold off, then someone from one area of the land wanted to reacquire the split-off area in order to consolidate what was fragmented back into the site as a whole. There would have been some historical co-management of that resource when the whole site was still together, and that person would be able to check the site’s history through Registers of Scotland. There could be a sunset rule with a cut-off after a certain number of years—maybe 100 years, or 20 years if it was thought that a shorter period would be appropriate. That could be another way to show what a community is, and the community right to buy would have a particular role to play in a shared overcoming of certain barriers to sustainable development if the land was previously part of the same ownership unit.

That proposal is not based on anything other than my having a stab in the dark as to whether it might be an issue. Committee members can look at my consultation response to get a bit more detail.

Diarmid Hearns National Trust for Scotland
link

It is in line with the general tenor of other rights to buy, but it comes from quite a rural perspective on what land reform is about. From a conservation perspective, a lot of these assets are very expensive and it takes quite an aggregation of interests to make something happen. Thinking about sport, recreation, religion and culture, we might require a city-scale—or even a regional-scale—community of interest to take on an asset. I think that the scale of the community of interest and how it gets represented is a missing piece of the jigsaw in land reform generally.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

We are rapidly running out of time, but Annie Wells has a couple of questions to put to you.

Annie Wells Con Glasgow
link

Thank you for coming to give evidence. I have taken my first step into this subject today, and it has been truly fascinating.

I have a couple of questions on restrictions on dealings while an application is pending, which would apply to

“any transfer of the ownership of the land that is subject to an application”

and

“any action taken with a view to a transfer of land”.

Do the provisions adequately cover all possible eventualities and situations in relation to the restriction of activities? Is it possible that the restrictions might impact on a landowner’s ability to undertake certain actions in relation to their land?

Jon Hollingdale Community Woodland Association
link

As I mentioned earlier, we expect—and always advise—community bodies to go through the part 2 prohibition process first, so they have an existing prohibition on transfer that closely matches what is in the regulations even before they get to the beginning of the part 5 process.

The rules that are there are probably fine. I suspect that, in almost all cases, the new rules will only duplicate what was there before to ensure that the landowner, if they are minded to avoid the part 5 rules, does not try to make the transfer of asset before the part 5 restriction on transfer comes into force. That happens only when the application is made to the Scottish ministers or when the thing goes up on the register, whereas the landowner sees the community body coming from a long way away, because it has to write more than six months in advance, hold a ballot and so on.

The part 2 prohibition comes into effect to prevent transfer beforehand and just carries forward as long as the community keeps its part 2 registration active.

Malcolm Combe University of Strathclyde
link

I have a quick point and acknowledge the role of my former colleague Donna McKenzie Skene in forming it. It is an insolvency law point. The proposed exceptions include vesting of the land as a result of sequestration and bankruptcy, but they do not cover trust deeds for creditors, because there is no vesting in that situation. I query whether that is deliberate. For those who like insolvency law, there is a bit more detail in our written submission. It is something to consider.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

I have a daft-lassie question: what is vesting?

Malcolm Combe University of Strathclyde
link

It is when the right goes across to the person who deals with the insolvency process. The point is that, if you set up a trust deed for creditors, you would not get the same vesting process as with a formal insolvency situation under the new bankruptcy legislation or any other insolvency process that was mandated in statute. It might not be very relevant in many situations—I am talking to a point that my former colleague Donna McKenzie Skene knows far more about than I do—but it is possible that there would be a slight gap.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

I thank everyone for their time this morning. It has been an interesting session that has flagged up a few things that we might want to look into.

12:38 Meeting continued in private until 12:55.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Interests Procedure · 2
  3. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 148
  4. 11:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 111

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.