I can speak to that. The new draft regulations are, in a number of respects, an improvement on the first draft. We are pleased to see that a number of matters have been moved on in a positive way.
There is still a lack of clarity, which could result in the aims of the regulations not being fully satisfied, in relation to whether references to “significant influence” and “control” capture all the correct scenarios and circumstances.
The Scottish Property Federation’s interest is in relation to commercial ownership of commercial land and buildings, typically in urban situations. It is important to make sure that the regulations and explanatory notes that accompany them allow for the scenarios that arise in such circumstances.
My concern is about circumstances in which there is influence that does not extend to legal power to direct, but which is nonetheless a strong influence that is exerted on the legal owners of the land—those whose name is on the title deeds.
For example, a shopping centre, office building or whatever might be owned by a Jersey unit trust—an offshore trust. That would be firmly within the regulations and is not an uncommon ownership scenario for tax-planning reasons, which are perfectly legitimate reasons to hold land. The Jersey trustees whose names are on the title are, however, not the people who in practice make the day-to-day decisions in relation to the land. Decisions in such a scenario are usually made by asset managers—typically, managers in a United Kingdom pension fund who have that locus by virtue of an asset management agreement that gives them responsibilities to look after the land, collect rent, find tenants and deal with everything that happens day to day, as well as to set broader strategy in respect of whether the asset should continue to be held or what else should happen to it.
The asset managers do not have power to make decisions on such things. They make recommendations to the trustees, who will invariably follow the recommendations. A recommendation to enter into a lease or to sell a property is followed, but legally it is not the pension fund asset manager who makes the decision.
It is not entirely clear how that would work in terms of how the defined terms “significant influence” and “control” are framed. The language talks about being “able to ensure” that an approach is followed, or having a power to “direct” activities. Those words do not appear to be on all fours with the scenario in which somebody is making recommendations that are expected to be followed but are not a legal power.