The ninth and final continued petition for consideration is PE1731, which was lodged by Tom Taylor and which calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973 to permit audio recording of all public council meetings by members of the public.
When the committee considered the petition on 19 September 2019, it agreed to write to the Scottish Government, COSLA and all local authorities to seek their views on the action that is called for in the petition. Responses have been received from the Scottish Government, COSLA and 16 of the 32 local authorities. The clerk’s note summarises the responses.
Do members have comments or suggestions for action?
A number of local authorities have come back to us with concerns about how such recordings would be used, whether they could be tampered with to put forward a particular point of view and whether they might record sensitive or private information. However, the Scottish Government has stated that that does not happen in other places where public recording is permitted. Furthermore, the petitioners are talking only about public meetings, in which no private or sensitive information should be discussed in any case.
The Scottish Government has said that it has no objection in principle to the proposal. I think that our next step should be to write to the Scottish Government to find out whether it plans to implement the proposal and how it would work.
If we need to discuss sensitive information, we go into private session and the meeting is not recorded.
As Gail Ross said, the Scottish Government has said that it has no objection in principle to the request. I would be interested to find out how it is going to support the petition. I think that, in principle, the proposal is reasonable.
I was struck by the variety of responses from various local authorities, and I wonder whether at least part of the concern about the proposal is to do with funding. In circumstances in which there are—to put it kindly—huge pressures on budgets, local authorities might have decided that the proposal is not a priority and, on that basis, have come up with lots of reasons why they cannot do it. If that is the case, perhaps we could ask the Scottish Government whether some funding might be provided for the proposal in recognition of the extra costs that it might entail. I note that the recording of our meetings in Parliament is funded.
As a counter to that, I suggest that the local authorities that do not have webcasts and archived meetings because of funding issues should welcome the fact that members of the public want to come in and record the meetings, as that means that there will be a recording of them somewhere. I can see other reasons, too.
Yes. For example, in more remote areas, we can see the benefit of someone recording meetings, because it might not be possible for people to attend physically, but the recordings will enable them to engage with the process. There is that practical, democratic element, as well.
The subject came up a number of years ago when I was a councillor in Argyll and Bute Council. An issue of concern at that time was the cost of the proposal, and another was the content of the meetings. It was suggested that it would be fine to have recordings of full council meetings that were held in public, but that recording meetings that were held in private was another matter. There were similar issues around regulatory meetings and so on, such as meetings of the licensing board at which, for example, character references were discussed in relation to the issuing of taxi driver licences. Another worry that the council had concerned the possibility of recordings being tampered with. We wanted any recording to be a true one.
Although the council felt comfortable having recordings of public meetings, we felt that, if there was such recording, it should be done by the council, and that brought in the issue of financial constraints.
We agreed that the recording of meetings would be beneficial to people in island communities.
I might have slightly misrepresented the petition. It specifically asks that people should be able to record meetings. If the reservation about the proposal is that recordings might be falsely edited, perhaps there could be a fund that local authorities could access in order to provide recordings themselves. That might be part of the tension between the two ways of recording meetings.
I think that the committee feels that the proposal is a good idea in the interests of transparency. In light of its support for the petition, we could write to the Scottish Government to ask how it plans to take the proposal forward, and to suggest that it puts in place safeguards to address local authorities’ concerns.
On the point that we made about our meeting today being recorded, we should note that it is being officially recorded—the public are not allowed to record it. That is probably the standard that we want to promote.
Yes. We should ask whether the concerns about the fallback position that is proposed in the petition could be dealt with by having a more formal process. We could flag that issue up to the Scottish Government.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.