The next continued petition for consideration today is PE1722, on parking charges at island lifeline ferry ports, which has been lodged by Dr Shiona Ruhemann on behalf of Iona Community Council, Mull Community Council and others. We last considered the petition in June, when we agreed to seek written views specifically on why island community impact assessments, as detailed in the Islands (Scotland) Act 2018, have not been brought into force, and why Argyll and Bute Council has introduced such parking charges in Iona and Mull.
Responses have been received from the Scottish Government, Argyll and Bute Council, CalMac Ferries, Shetland Islands Council, Orkney Islands Council, Maree Todd MSP, Liam McArthur MSP and the petitioner. Michael Russell MSP has also contacted the clerks to highlight his strong support for the action that is called for in the petition.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?
Argyll and Bute Council did not make an impact assessment. Although the statute has not been commenced, the council knows that the requirement for island community impact assessments is coming: it knows that they will have to be done. I completely understand where the community councils are coming from.
There has been some backtracking from Argyll and Bute Council, and it has given an apology and an admission that it did not carry out the process as it should have. That has not satisfied the petitioner, whose has stated that the concessions are a temporary measure. We have also heard a lot of representations from the other two islands authorities and from MSPs.
It is difficult to know where we should go with this, because we are talking about local authorities and what they feel they need to do. We should write to the Scottish Government because there are other things that the submissions have thrown up in relation to the Islands (Scotland) Act 2018 and Shetland Islands Council.
Gail Ross has highlighted an issue. There is a dilemma in that although local councils have a high degree of autonomy to set their own rules and regulations, island communities are, of course, particularly vulnerable in such circumstances because they have no choice but to use the services.
I agree with Gail Ross that we need to write to the Scottish Government to seek its views, especially given that we have had representations from nearly all the MSPs from the relevant communities. If we are going to maintain communities on the islands, they must be specifically supported. It seems to me that this is an issue that we should be able to resolve.
I am surprised that island community impact assessments have not been commenced, because they are absolutely the core bit of the 2018 act. It would be worth our while to ask why there has been a delay. It is reasonable to suggest that the council knows that the requirement is coming; if everybody knows that it is coming, why are assessments not already being done? It is significant that two Government ministers are arguing for the petitioner. I presume that they can use their influence.
The committee might not all agree, but I wonder what is underpinning this. Why would any local authority do that? There is a suggestion that it is because of pressure on budgets. My point in that regard is that in an island community impact assessment there has to be understanding of the specific funding needs of local authorities that include island and remote communities. I presume that that was the driver behind the legislation. We could flag that up to the Scottish Government, too.
Do members agree to write to the Scottish Government seeking its views on the matters that have been highlighted, and asking when it will commence the requirement for impact assessments to be carried out, and how it will address the specific issue of funding, which is a particular challenge for island communities?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.