Our final continued petition for consideration today is PE1596, on In Care Survivors Service Scotland, which was lodged by Paul Anderson, James McDermott and Chris Daly. At the previous consideration of the petition in September 2019, the committee agreed to take evidence from the Scottish Government. I welcome back the Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills to give evidence alongside Jamie MacDougall, deputy director, social care support. I invite the cabinet secretary to provide a brief opening statement before we move to questions.
Official Report · Committee
Continued Petitions
In Care Survivors Service (PE1596)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John Swinney SNP 46
- Johann Lamont Lab 31
- Brian Whittle Con 10
- Maurice Corry Con 7
- Gail Ross SNP 4
- Jamie MacDougall Scottish Government 2
The record
100 contributions
link
Thank you, convener. I welcome the opportunity to provide assurances to the petitioner and the committee of the Scottish Government’s on-going commitment to providing high-quality, sustainable and person-centred support to all survivors of childhood abuse.
Future Pathways provides support to survivors by working closely and successfully with a network of service providers across Scotland. I spent time recently with Future Pathways and with some of the survivors it supports. I appreciate that there have been challenges along the way. However, we have made very good progress on meeting those challenges.
What is clear to me is the commitment of the staff of Future Pathways to provide a high-quality service to survivors. At our meeting, the support co-ordinators emphasised how they work alongside people and that concept struck a chord with me. I will continue to encourage everyone who seeks to support survivors that we should be working collaboratively to ensure that our efforts are focused where they should be, on delivering support to survivors of childhood abuse.
My officials advise me that we are finalising the details of a contract between Future Pathways and Wellbeing Scotland. The aim of that agreement will be the same as many other agreements that are already in place: to ensure that survivors are able to access the support of their choice. A formal agreement between Future Pathway and Wellbeing Scotland will also improve the process of referrals between the organisations.
There are now over 1,200 people registered with Future Pathways, with a steady increase in registrations of approximately 35 per month. That, and the feedback from survivors, indicates to me that the support that is provided by Future Pathways is welcomed by survivors.
There have, of course, been criticisms from survivors, particularly about waiting lists. I have always been very clear that we must listen carefully to the voices of survivors across the range of actions that the Scottish Government is taking in response to the “Action Plan for Justice for Victims of Historic Abuse of Children in Care”. That is why I took action to address waiting lists, and I will continue to listen to feedback from survivors.
Let me conclude by assuring the committee that I have heard many encouraging personal stories from survivors on the positive impact that the person-centred rather than service-led approach has made on their lives. The Scottish Government is committed to ensuring that the support that survivors receive through Future Pathways is the right support for them.
Thank you very much. What do you think is the difference between a person-centred and a service-led approach? What does that refer to?
link
A person-centred approach is one in which we listen carefully to the experience and circumstances of survivors and help them to identify what assistance they require to progress. A service-led approach is one in which we, as the public sector, essentially say that we provide this service, that service and the next service, and hope that those services meet the needs of those individuals. In my experience, that works in many aspects of public services, but I am less confident that it does so in the case of many survivors of historical abuse. That is why I am more confident in the person-centred approach, in which the support co-ordinators are able to identify what is needed in dialogue with survivors—that is why I was taken by the comment from the support co-ordinators that they work alongside individuals to help them to gather together the support that they require to allow them to progress.
Is the implication of what you are saying that the service that was provided by Wellbeing Scotland was not person centred?
link
No. I am making an observation about public services in general. It is not a comment at all about Wellbeing Scotland; it is a comment about how I think public services tend to be organised. We decide what it is that we are doing and we go out and do it, but, given their complex experiences, I am not sure that that meets the needs of the survivors of historical abuse.
There was a move by the Scottish Government to what is called a brokerage model, and there were some concerns by people in the system already that that was not person centred. Some of the argument was about the role of Future Pathways and the role of Wellbeing Scotland which, it would be argued, was person-centred and trauma-informed and would go with somebody on a journey, whatever the holistic support that perhaps the petitioner has highlighted. Do you accept that there are concerns about that?
You have created the impression that there is a difference between person centred and service led. The argument that I think would be contended by the petitioner is that the petition was prompted by a concern that Wellbeing Scotland was not able to continue in its person-centred work, from which the petitioner had benefited.
link
That is an entirely fair characterisation of the petitioner’s perspective. What I would try to explain is that we listened carefully to survivors, who gave us the strong view that a person-centred approach was the way to proceed. I am not sure that I understand or could explain the difference between a person-centred model and a brokerage model, because I think they are one and the same thing.
Having listened to survivors, we went to procure a service to operate under that person-centred approach. Wellbeing Scotland in its previous identity did not tender for that. Several organisations came together under the umbrella of Future Pathways to offer that service. I accepted that we started off by saying, “We have procured this; let us now operate on this model,” which obviously created distress among people who were using the services of Wellbeing Scotland. I have taken the pragmatic decision of financially supporting Wellbeing Scotland to continue to support those with whom it has established relationships, to avoid causing any distress or disrupting the continuity of support for people who were previously using the services of Wellbeing Scotland and are currently still able to do so.
We will deal with the specifics of the relationship between Future Pathways and Wellbeing Scotland in a moment, but it feels to me that some of this is about the decision to establish Future Pathways, having listened to survivors. The implication of that is that your previous support for survivor strategy was not person centred. That is fundamentally not the case, because it came out of development of a strategy that recognised lifelong trauma and the way in which that would need to be supported in different ways, and organisations other than Wellbeing Scotland were engaged with that.
I am not sure whether the concerns that have been expressed by the petitioner are being understood by the Scottish Government. The implication is that the new Future Pathways model was a new thing with people at the centre of it, when in fact the argument is that there has been a change from a person-centred approach to one that directs people towards different kinds of services through a brokerage model.
10:45
link
As I said, convener, I am not sure that I could explain what the difference is between a brokerage model and a person-centred model because, fundamentally, it is about trying to answer the question of how we assemble the support that an individual survivor needs to help them to progress. It has always been the policy intention of the Government to enable us to create that. If, in the process of the procurement method that we took forward, it was suggested, inferred or assumed that there was a change in the direction of our approach, I hope that we have rectified that by the way in which we have acted subsequently.
Perhaps we will need further explanation of what that change was for, given that a lot of people in the system feel that the change was not created with the intention that you have identified. I do not think that the discussion is really about how an individual organisation has been treated, but we will look at the questions that may come out of that deeper question.
You mentioned that there is a contract in development now—is that correct?
link
Yes.
We heard that Future Pathways will not refer survivors to Wellbeing Scotland, as they were not able to agree a contract. Tell us a little a bit more about the contract that is in development.
link
Essentially, the purpose of the contract is to ensure that individuals are getting the support they require. I do not think that it would be healthy or appropriate for Future Pathways to be supporting an individual and Wellbeing Scotland supporting an individual, which would make no sense whatsoever. We have to have a certain amount of understanding of who is supporting whom to make sure that individuals can get the support they require.
As I indicated in my earlier answer to the convener, Wellbeing Scotland received financial support from the Government and so did Future Pathways. Between them, they should be able to meet the demand that there is within the community.
One of the barriers that we heard about appeared to be the level of personal information that Future Pathways was requesting about survivors, which seemed to be more specific than what was required by Wellbeing Scotland. Is it appropriate that Future Pathways can set higher thresholds for data than the Scottish Government? Why does it need that level of information?
link
I do not think that Future Pathways is asking for information that is inappropriate. What I have seen is that it is asking for basic contact information. Obviously, organisations need to have contact information to enable them to undertake their work. I certainly would not want people to feel put off accessing the service because of the information they had to provide but, from what I have seen, it looks to be pretty basic contact information.
If survivors are saying to us that they feel that the level of information is inappropriate, will you look at that?
link
I am happy to look at that, yes. Recently, I met some survivors who are using Future Pathways support and they did not raise that issue with me. It certainly was not raised with me by the support co-ordinators, who struck me as being devoted to trying to get good outcomes for the individuals concerned.
One of the things that have been flagged up is that some survivors are not comfortable giving postal addresses or access to national health service records. That was certainly the view of the Anchor centre, which has concerns about that. The issue is what is being done with the data.
link
Any organisation that holds data on an individual is bound by the requirements of the general data protection regulation. It has to hold that information for a purpose and can use it only for particular purposes. The onus is on the organisation to act within the law on the handling of any of that data.
Do you accept that survivors in particular lack trust in organisations that have let them down in the past or in a system that has let them down, so they have anxiety about being asked for information that they do not want to share? For example, Wellbeing Scotland allowed survivors to use false names until trust was established. If you are dealing with people who have no trust, is it reasonable to ask people for what you said was basic data? The suggestion is that they are being asked for a lot more than that; in particular, the question of access to NHS records is a concern.
link
I am advised that Future Pathways allows individuals to use pseudonyms and to offer basic contact information. In relation to further information, that would depend very much on whether that was relevant or required to provide access to other services.
If someone cannot access the service until they provide that information and folk do not have the trust to give that information, do you accept that that is a barrier?
link
I can see that, but what I also see is the energy and commitment of Future Pathways co-ordinators to build that trust, because they realise that they cannot properly support and assist individuals without it.
Therefore, providing that information should not be something that has to be done before that initial trust has been built.
link
I would not see it as being required for that.
That would be something that we could reflect back to Future Pathways.
link
Yes, I am happy to do so.
I wish a good morning to Jamie MacDougall, and thank the cabinet secretary for hanging in there for so long.
The convener and I met survivors. It looks to me as though what we are talking here about is two organisations having a power struggle, and in the centre of it are people with care issues that are very specific to them. One issue that has been raised with the committee by care survivors is the ability to access services anonymously. That can currently be done within Wellbeing Scotland but not Future Pathways. Would the cabinet secretary consider that and suggest to Future Pathways that if care survivors ask to access services anonymously they must be able to do that?
link
I am certainly happy to consider that and to raise it with Future Pathways. I have no problem with that.
I understand that Future Pathways accepts people accessing its services using a pseudonym and with partial contact details, so there is some acknowledgement of the situation, but I will clarify the position for the committee.
I am merely reporting to the cabinet secretary that care survivors’ perception is not what you have described, so that has to be addressed.
link
I will check on that.
Future Pathways repeatedly highlighted to the committee that a commitment was made that the support that 134 people would receive from Wellbeing Scotland as of 30 October 2016 would continue without disruption, and it communicated to us that it did not wish those support arrangements to change. Does that commitment hold?
link
I will go back to what I said to the convener earlier. We listened to the survivors who asked us to ensure that person-centred support would be put in place. We procured that as we are obliged to do for public expenditure and public services, and a consortium of organisations, representing Future Pathways, came forward. Wellbeing Scotland did not enter that procurement process. The contract was awarded to Future Pathways to develop a person-centred model. Essentially, we reached a position that fulfilled exactly what Mr Whittle is arguing for, and which I agree with. We procured such person-centred support and Future Pathways was contracted to deliver it.
Wellbeing Scotland then told us that it had people with whom it works who did not want to be disrupted—they did not want to have to create a new trusting relationship because they had such a relationship with Wellbeing Scotland and did not want to go elsewhere. Despite Wellbeing Scotland’s having not tendered for the contract, I took the pragmatic decision to support Wellbeing Scotland financially so that it could continue to support the individuals with whom it was working at that time. That commitment remains in place. Wellbeing Scotland is in receipt of £200,000 a year from the Government for its service.
To tie up loose ends, was Wellbeing Scotland invited to tender?
link
It was an open tender process; anyone could have come forward.
You know that Wellbeing Scotland did not want to dispense the discretionary fund and so did not tender. Why was the change made from the In Care Survivors Service Scotland, which worked for over seven years and used a person-centred approach in which one person would deal with a wide range of things? There was a change that you put out to tender. There was nothing inevitable about the Scottish Government putting the service out to tender: it was an active choice. We lack clarity on why that was done.
The committee should be aware that in moving from the agreement with Wellbeing Scotland, as Open Secret was, to the new model, we expanded the model extensively.
It did not need to be expanded in a brokerage model, however, did it? The model that was developed over seven years and which had come out of the strategy was effective, so organisations other than Wellbeing Scotland could have done it, with one person doing all the work with people. There was no obligation to move to a brokerage model; that was an active policy decision. We lack clarity on why that was done and what assessment was made of the impact on survivors. That is what the petition is about. The petitioners are saying that change in how the service was being developed had a direct impact on them—on their ability to access group work and to access services over a long period with a person who could take a holistic approach and was trauma informed. First, why was the change made and, secondly, to what extent was the impact on individual survivors assessed? The answer is not about the service being person-centred because it was—as I think you will agree—previously person-centred. Why was that change made?
The change was made because demand was outstripping supply. We have moved from an arrangement that cost about £200,000 a year to one that costs in the region of £3 million a year. That will give members a sense of the scale of expansion of the operation. As a result of that, only one set of organisations came forward to tender. A consortium came forward because no single organisation could provide the service at such scale. We are now actively supporting more than 1,200 people. As a result of the transition to Future Pathways and the agreements that Mr Swinney has set out, we are also directly supporting Wellbeing Scotland to continue to support individuals.
As a result of the expanded model, Future Pathways has in place agreements with more than 30 organisations. Individual survivors who come forward have access not only to the support that Wellbeing Scotland provides, but to the whole suite of organisations with which we have active agreements. That is the nature of the contract that we are trying to put in place.
11:00
As well as the Scottish Government directly grant funding Wellbeing Scotland to continue to support survivors, we are looking to put in place a contract with Future Pathways, at a set amount, so that Wellbeing Scotland has certainty about who it can employ in order to take on referrals. There is a difference in what Wellbeing Scotland provides to the Scottish Government in that we are grant funding it for the range of services that it provides. We are not interested in the details about what happens to every individual, per se.
However, in respect of the agreement between Future Pathways and Wellbeing Scotland, it is important that we understand what happens with individuals because we need to make sure that we are providing the right support to individuals, that we are not providing it twice and that we are not missing it. We need to know that what we are doing over there is the same as what we are doing over here. We are close to reaching agreement on that.
I hear what you say about expanding the amount of money. The question is how that money is directed towards meeting the needs of survivors: 30 organisations offering different things is not necessarily comparable to one organisation that can provide to an individual with a range of support for as long as they need it. However, we are not going to resolve that matter today.
We welcome the fact that you have expanded the service. However, you had a long and successful working relationship with Wellbeing Scotland. Why not expand that model with Wellbeing Scotland? With the greatest respect I say that what we are hearing in evidence is that there is a power struggle, which will obviously be detrimental to survivors who require services.
link
The question of scale is very material. It might not be possible for an organisation like Wellbeing Scotland to support the number—
You have not supported Wellbeing Scotland, cabinet secretary.
link
We have. We invited tenders, but Wellbeing Scotland did not tender. I cannot force people to tender.
The issue is what the tender asked for. I do not think that anybody has suggested that Wellbeing Scotland would do all the work itself. There was the old In Care Survivors Service Scotland. I presume that it need not be that just one organisation delivers the service. If the argument from Wellbeing Scotland is that it was precluded because of what the tender asked for, you cannot then say, “If it didn’t tender, there is nothing we can do about that”.
link
I am agreeing with the committee that person-centred support must be the consistent element in all this. We offered a contract to provide person-centred support—as the committee has suggested Wellbeing Scotland was providing, which I accept. Wellbeing Scotland decided not to tender and I could not oblige it to do so. Subsequently, I have pragmatically accepted that Wellbeing Scotland has existing relationships with survivors, so I have financially supported it to provide continuity.
I am interested in providing support for survivors—I am not the slightest bit interested in a power struggle, and do not care if there is a power struggle going on. I am interested in whether survivors are getting the support that they require. I accept that it would have been disruptive to have required all Wellbeing Scotland clients to transfer to Future Pathways, but I did not do that. I allowed Wellbeing Scotland to continue with direct financial support from the Government, to the tune of £200,000 a year, while also providing £3.7 million in financial support to Future Pathways.
I am at a bit of a loss to understand what the issue is. I want people to get the support that they require. We have had to expand the service substantially, so we have let a contract to do that. Wellbeing Scotland did not tender for that contract, but I have put in place money to enable Wellbeing Scotland to continue to provide services to the people whom it was supporting. All that we are trying to establish now, in the relationship between Future Pathways and Wellbeing Scotland, is that the organisations are not both supporting the same individuals, because that would make no sense whatsoever, if we believe in focusing support on every individual.
What I am saying is that, according to the evidence we have gathered from both organisations and from care survivors, there is a strained relationship between the two given that Wellbeing Scotland relies on Future Pathways to give it the support that it needs through referrals. The person-centred care that we all want to happen is not necessarily happening for all. In fact, we understand that Wellbeing Scotland has received no confirmation of its funding beyond March 2020. As the Wellbeing Scotland service will perhaps stop in 2020, there is anxiety among the care survivors it is currently supporting that they might have to change service. Do you recognise that, cabinet secretary?
link
We do not yet have a budget for beyond March 2020 in any part of the public sector, so there are obviously issues with funding.
Does that mean that no organisation has been given confirmation of its funding beyond March 2020?
link
I am saying simply that it is an issue.
Is it not possible for you to give that confirmation?
link
I am coming to that. Due to the delay to the budget, the Government is looking at what clarity we need to give to organisations to enable them to function effectively. This is not just about Wellbeing Scotland; it is about countless organisations that would have expected some funding clarity by now. The Government is in the process of looking at that question, and we will provide reassurance to organisations in due course.
With all due respect, I think you know full well that your budget is certainly not going to go down, so that is a moot point. The fact of the matter is that Wellbeing Scotland currently does not have any funding clarification beyond 2020 whereas Future Pathways does. People who are currently being supported by Wellbeing Scotland are concerned that their support will stop in March 2020.
link
I will take that issue away and clarify it.
Are you comfortable with the decision that you have made to substantially increase the cost to the public purse instead of using the existing capacity that Wellbeing Scotland could have given? It has explained to the committee that, had Future Pathways referred survivors to it, it could have helped to eradicate the waiting list earlier this year.
link
Yes, I am very comfortable with the decisions that we have made.
Can you explain how Future Pathways will be evaluated in relation to the work that it is providing to you and what will be considered as success in relation to Future Pathways now that you have taken that decision?
link
We have to consider the outcomes that are achieved for individuals. The fundamental judgment on the work of Future Pathways and Wellbeing Scotland is the outcomes that are being achieved for individuals and how they are being helped as a consequence of the services that are in place and the support that is being offered.
Do you have a feeling for how it is going so far?
link
I think that some very good outcomes are being achieved. Some people who have used the Future Pathways service are no longer using it, because they are feeling well supported within their community and feel that they have been assisted. For example, of the 1,273 people who were registered with Future Pathways in November 2019, 317 were not actively using the service at that time but are able to do so should they feel the necessity.
Were the 317 or so people who were not using the service getting a better result by using Future Pathways rather than Wellbeing Scotland?
link
I do not have comparable data for Wellbeing Scotland and Future Pathways.
I will ask about some anecdotal evidence we have had about payments from the discretionary fund. Are you confident that there is an effective process in place to evaluate requests for such payments? We have heard of people receiving quite significant appliances or whatever and then struggling to pay their rent or bills, with those items sometimes ending up being repossessed. Are you tracking that?
link
I would certainly want effective judgment in the making of commitments under the discretionary fund. We rely heavily on the judgment of support co-ordinators, in dialogue with a survivor, about what will assist that survivor to make the progress we would want all individuals to make. That is a fine judgment, not a precise science, and some decisions will not be the correct decisions—I have to accept that. We will consider the effectiveness of discretionary fund interventions as part of the work that I cited to Mr Corry about the outcomes achieved by individuals.
To what extent is the Scottish Government engaging with survivors?
link
We have a range of different engagements with survivors of abuse. On a personal level, I see individuals quite frequently. Also, the interaction review group has survivors on it. It is vital that we hear about the lived experience of survivors. I recently chaired the national steering group on trauma training, which includes survivors of abuse. We are trying to hear that voice consistently across the different policy interventions of Government.
Given what you have said, what expertise is there within the Scottish Government in understanding the complex trauma issues and needs of survivors? You have talked about how the Government is engaging with people who have experienced those issues.
link
We have professional civil servants who build expertise in a variety of different areas, and that work is supplemented by a range of advisory groups that we have. I have mentioned the national steering group on trauma training, which brings together a range of interested parties and those with lived experience to ensure that our steps, policies and processes are informed by that lived experience. We have to be always conscious of the importance of hearing those voices and acting upon them.
You also have to impart continuing professional development training to your officials for that. Your officials will benefit from having worked with care survivors and will, hopefully, sharpen their skills even further.
link
Training is available to our officials through different organisations, which enables them to be trauma informed. There is a lot of work going on within the Government, right across the board, to ensure that there is a wide understanding of the impact of adverse childhood experiences, and that is reflected across a range of different aspects of the Government’s policy agenda.
11:15
What about when a survivor does not consent to their data being shared and cannot, therefore, register with Future Pathways to be referred to Wellbeing Scotland? Is it of concern to you that, because of where the contract is, some people cannot access the services they would like to access?
link
The key point is whether an individual wishes to access some degree of support. If they do, I cannot see how we can provide that support without holding some basic information on them. That would not prevent their gaining access to the support that would be available under Future Pathways. If somebody was unwilling to give any contact details—I will have to check with Future Pathways whether that is its experience—I cannot see how—
They could do that with Wellbeing Scotland. Wellbeing Scotland is thoroughly audited. It is not as though it has pretend clients who do not really exist—they exist. It has managed a system through which it builds trust and gets more information. If a survivor is, because of the nature of their experience, reluctant to give more than what I think you are calling basic data, although it is perceived as being more than the basic data that they might have given in the past, they are excluded from services from which they would benefit. Do you accept that that is a problem?
link
I am advised that Future Pathways requires a name and contact details but that those can be a pseudonym and partial contact details. I do not see how that is different from what Wellbeing Scotland requires.
Do you accept that, if a survivor thinks it is different, there is a problem? We are working on assumption. Folk who want to receive support and have been getting support now feel they cannot access that support because they are reluctant to provide the evidence or data that is being asked of them—which, unless they are imagining things, is different from the data that was asked of them before.
link
Nobody who was getting support before cannot now get support because of this issue.
Wellbeing Scotland cannot get referrals because people are not registering with Future Pathways due to the perception that the level of data that is required of them is higher, greater, more substantial or more significant than it was in the past. Given the time constraints that we have—I appreciate that there is a lot to discuss here—could you clarify the situation for us?
link
I can tell the committee that there were 171 new referrals from Future Pathways to Wellbeing Scotland between October 2018 and October 2019. I do not understand the point that has been put to me, because referrals have been made.
I presume that those referrals involved people who agreed to give that level of data. This is a point that has been made to us.
link
I do not understand.
Maybe it would be easier for the Scottish Government to establish why there is concern. I understand that the issue has been flagged up already. If the request is reasonable and nothing has changed, why is anybody raising it as an issue?
link
If the committee furnishes me with the detail of what the issue is, I will have it explored. As there were 171 new referrals in 12 months from Future Pathways to Wellbeing Scotland, I am not sure that I understand what the problem is. If the committee writes to me about that, I will be happy to—
Do you accept that there is a problem if a survivor is saying that there is a problem?
link
I would like to see the detail of the issue before I comment. I have tried my best to deal with it today.
The committee is presenting something to you as a concern, not trying to find a way to ask a question that you do not have an answer to. I am sure that you would agree with me that, if somebody is saying that the level of data that is now required is different from before and that it is an inhibitor to somebody accessing services, that is a problem.
link
I would like to see the detail of the issue, because I do not understand how that can be a problem for somebody who previously used services. I have taken the pragmatic decision to continue to support Wellbeing Scotland, so existing clients can get support from Wellbeing Scotland—none of that has changed.
It may be an inhibitor for future applicants.
link
There were 171 new referrals from Future Pathways to Wellbeing Scotland between October 2018 and October 2019.
I want to clarify where I am coming from. It is not about the 171 new referrals; the concern is about whether others have not been able to be referred because of a particular issue. It is not about trying to catch anybody out. We are passing on to you things that have been reported to the committee.
link
I have said throughout the evidence session that I am very keen for any survivor of historic abuse to get the support that they require. I am prepared to look at the data requirements of Future Pathways, but I have been advised that it requires names and contact details and that pseudonyms and partial contact details will be acceptable. The organisation has to be able to get in touch with people. It has to know who it is dealing with.
With respect, I think that everybody knows that. The idea is that people are resisting access to services because they are not giving very basic data. There is an issue there that might relate to the nature of survivors. It has been flagged up to us that the new referrals that Wellbeing Scotland has received have been not for counselling but for finding records. I think that it is the Anchor centre that asks for access to NHS records. People cannot access that service. Those things are all bound up together.
I appreciate how much time you have already given us, cabinet secretary. We will not resolve the issue or deal with all the details now, but I ask you to recognise that the issue has been raised as a serious concern. It might be difficult to understand what the concern is, but I am looking for a commitment from you that you will at least look at the issue as a serious one for people.
link
A number of very specific points have been put to me in the latter part of this evidence session that involve a level of detail that I simply do not have in front of me today. If the committee wishes to send me a letter that sets out those detailed points, I will have them addressed.
My fundamental point is that I want survivors of historic abuse to be able to access services. The Government has substantively expanded the ability to do so, but if there are impediments to how people are able to access those services, I will want to consider how they might be addressed.
I appreciate that very much.
The request for information from Future Pathways says:
“Please tick this box to give permission for Future Pathways to collect and securely store personal information; including sensitive information that you provide, which is necessary for coordinating the services you may wish to access (No service can be provided without this box ticked).”
That is the question. Your suggestion that we write to you with details about that to get a response from you is extremely helpful.
My last question reflects what we have been wrestling with today and over a period of time. I think that you would accept that some adult survivors have significant concerns about the support that has been provided. If there is the sense of a breakdown of confidence, what would a way forward be for a possible solution to address the issues that the petition raises? Even if Future Pathways does not recognise those concerns—it might be entirely fair for it not to recognise them—the issue still has to be resolved, because it is a matter of confidence and trust in the organisation.
link
Obviously, Future Pathways supports a large number of people. It is a matter of fact that lots of people out there get support from it. That is my first point.
My second point is that I have sat down with support co-ordinators and found them to be a wonderful group of people who are deeply engaged in providing support to individuals. I found them to be hugely impressive and highly motivated, and I thought that they were a credit to the organisation. I want as many people as possible to have access to that support, because it is of enormous value to individuals. I heard that from survivors, as well. I do not accept that there is a breakdown of trust, because people are quite clearly using the service in abundance. Therefore, there must be a lot of people who trust the organisation for what it does.
As I said earlier, I accept that there are tensions between some of the organisations. If the committee wishes me to consider and try to address specific issues, I will happily consider them, but we should recognise that a large number of people are benefiting significantly from the excellent support that Future Pathways offers.
The committee would certainly agree that those on the front line in Future Pathways, as in other organisations, are doing a really important job. We have heard that for some survivors—maybe many survivors—the experience has been very positive. People can work extremely well even though the structure around about them can be challenging. However, people continue to be concerned. Frankly, I do not think that it is about tensions between organisations; rather, I think that it is about whether a service that was provided for survivors in the past will be available in the same way in the future. That is really what the petition explores.
I hear what you say, but we will want to write to you about some of the issues that have been flagged up. I think that the petitioner acknowledges the help that he has had from his co-ordinator. I suppose that the question is how we get to people who are not able to engage because of the way in which the structure operates and who are, in a sense, excluding themselves because of things that have been asked for from them.
On taking forward the petition, I think that we agree that we should write to the cabinet secretary. We very much appreciate the time that he has taken over the issue. Obviously, that will afford an opportunity for others to respond to the evidence session. We might hear from others, and we will reflect in a future meeting on the substantial evidence that we have heard today. Is that agreed?
Members indicated agreement.
The cabinet secretary is completely correct: our interest lies in adult survivors of abuse getting the support that they require with the easiest access possible. We have made some progress today, but there is still quite a bit of discrepancy in the evidence that we are getting. To me, there still seems to be a power struggle. My concern is that that is affecting the service that is being delivered.
The convener is right: we can write to the cabinet secretary about some things that he can consider and report back to us on. The solution does not seem that far away. It seems that we need to get a couple of people in a room and knock their heads together to get back to the person-centred approach that the cabinet secretary has said is so important.
link
For the record, I do not think that there is any need to get back to a person-centred approach, because there is a person-centred approach. However, if there are issues that the committee wishes me to explore further, I will explore them to try to reassure it.
The question is whether the changes in the way in which services are procured have created a challenge for some survivors in how the services are delivered. That has been explored.
I thank you very much for your attendance, cabinet secretary, and for the seriousness with which you have addressed all the petitions. You have certainly been extremely helpful with two of them in progressing matters, but there have been some challenges with this one. Given the pressure on you with your much broader responsibilities, your spending such an amount of time with the Public Petitions Committee is very much appreciated.
I thank everyone on the committee for making the year an excellent one for it. We have got through a lot of business. We have a particular role in being outward facing and responding to the huge range of concerns and interests of petitioners. I thank everybody for their personal support, and I thank the clerking team.
I wish everybody a very happy Christmas and all the very best for 2020. Our first meeting after Christmas will be on 16 January.
Meeting closed at 11:30.
In this meeting
Everything on 19 Dec 2019 →- 08:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 28
- 09:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 26
- 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 41
- 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 100
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.