Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (National Guidance) (PE1548)

Thursday 19 December 2019 Public Petitions Committee About 09:45–10:30 Petitions 41 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

41 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The next continued petition is PE1548, on national guidance on restraint and seclusion in schools, lodged by Beth Morrison.

At our previous consideration of the petition in November 2019, the committee agreed to invite the Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills to give evidence at a future meeting. I am pleased to welcome back the cabinet secretary, and his Scottish Government official, Melanie Lowe, who is the supporting learners team leader.

Members will be aware of media reports earlier this week suggesting that the Government is changing its policy position on restraint and seclusion. I am sure that the cabinet secretary will speak about that as he provides his brief opening statement. We will then move to questions.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I am grateful for the opportunity to update the committee on the work in this area.

There have been a number of significant developments since my previous appearance in April 2017 to discuss the petition and the previous time that the committee discussed it on 7 November 2019. Over the past few months, we have made significant progress, reaching agreement with the Equality and Human Rights Commission and the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland that the Scottish Government will produce new national guidance that will provide a clear human rights-based policy on physical intervention and seclusion in Scottish schools. That will sit in the suite of documents in the “Included, Engaged and Involved” series that places at its core positive relationships and behaviour and early intervention and prevention to minimise the use of physical intervention and seclusion.

The approach has been agreed by the Scottish advisory group on relationships and behaviour in schools, which includes representatives from the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, the Association of Directors of Education in Scotland, all the main teaching unions, the Equality and Human Rights Commission and the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland.

The Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland report, “No Safe Place: Restraint and Seclusion in Scotland’s Schools”, made a number of recommendations to the Scottish Government. Although the Government agreed with many of the recommendations, we were unable to agree with them all. In our discussions it has become clear, by listening and engaging with stakeholders, that the guidance can be delivered in a way that meets everyone’s needs. The guidance that we develop will maintain the position that physical intervention and seclusion should only ever be used as a last resort and should never be used for disciplinary purposes.

I am pleased to confirm that we have reached agreement on the membership of the working group that will develop the guidance. The membership will ensure that key stakeholders representing a range of perspectives will contribute to its development.

We have also agreed a timescale for the development, consultation and publication of the guidance. I am pleased to confirm that we anticipate its publication in January 2021.

In order to establish the impact and effectiveness of the guidance, we will conduct a review of its implementation one year after publication. The review will be informed by a wide range of evidence and perspectives. Concurrently, we will work with partners to establish a standard data set for the recording and monitoring of the use of physical intervention and seclusion. The new data set will be used to inform improved practice across Scotland.

I look forward to working together with our key partners, to ensure that an effective approach continues to be adopted in Scotland’s schools when considering the use of physical intervention and seclusion. This new collaborative approach will provide additional clarity and evidence on the use of physical intervention and seclusion, supporting the appropriate use of approaches, extra reassurance to parents and strengthened support for children and young people.

10:00

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you very much for that. I am interested in testing what the change means—perhaps I am testing some of the comments that were given to us at the previous evidence session. You will be aware that the children’s commissioner and the petitioner are both clear that “Included, Engaged and Involved Part 2: A Positive Approach to Preventing and Managing School Exclusions” is a narrow framework of exclusion and behaviour management. The commissioner said:

“It is problematic to put the guidance within a narrow framework of exclusion and behaviour management.”—Official Report, Public Petitions Committee, 7 November 2019; c 3.

Is it now your position that you will take the guidance out of the “Included, Engaged and Involved” framework?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I do not intend to take it out of that framework, but I do intend to provide a more substantive set of guidance on these questions in the suite of material that is represented by the “Included, Engaged and Involved” framework.

I will explain what I mean by that. In some respects and for some time, we have not been, frankly, speaking the same language with the petitioner, the EHRC and the children’s commissioner. I have always wanted to make sure that any guidance that we put in place about restraint and seclusion is not apart from but very much part of our overall approach on supporting behaviour and the correct approaches to addressing behaviour in our schools.

I do not want restraint and seclusion to be separate from our overall approach but to be very much part of it. I do not think that we have properly set out our position to the petitioner, the EHRC and the children’s commissioner of our intention to do that in sufficient detail, with sufficient clarity, in order to address the issues that underpin the petition.

I said in my opening remarks that the guidance would sit in a suite of documents in the “Included, Engaged and Involved” series. I do not want in any way to minimise or trivialise the significance of the guidance that we are about to embark on. I recognise that we have to do substantive work in order to put in place substantive guidance, but I want that to be within a wider framework about how we support behaviour in our schools. For me, that is part of how we fulfil our commitment to all young people in school, to enable them to be included, engaged and involved.

There are particular issues that have to be addressed in relation to restraint and seclusion. I want to make sure that that is done properly and comprehensively. I hope that I have now put in place the mechanisms that enable us to do that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The argument is that, by placing the guidance inside a framework of exclusion and behaviour management, you are not addressing what the commissioner has argued for. The Office of the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland is of the view that the Scottish Government needs

“to produce something that addresses restraints in the context of additional support needs, child protection and safeguarding, and trauma-informed practice.”—Official Report, Public Petitions Committee, 7 November 2019; c 4.

This is not about dealing with poor behaviour and what action you are allowed to take; it is about recognising that behaviours are emerging from young people’s additional support needs, the trauma that they may be in and the fact that some of the restraints may be creating an even more difficult situation for them. To what extent will the commissioner’s view be embedded into the Government’s thinking?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

Let me be absolutely clear: I want to make sure that we fulfil that expectation of the commissioner. I also want to reassure you about another matter. We have to encourage a change in thinking about the coverage of the “Included, Engaged and Involved” series of materials. I do not want them to be seen as being about behaviour management. I want the “Included, Engaged and Involved” documentation to be viewed as, I suppose, the guarantees that we give to children and young people about how we ensure that they can be properly and fully included, engaged and involved in our education system.

That is about looking at the matter from a different perspective. That means not looking at it from the point of view that the series is about behaviour management, but in terms of how we give very solemn commitments to children and young people about how they can be included, engaged and involved in our education system.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

We heard some really distressing evidence at our previous session, when the petitioner highlighted the data that she had collected from 430 families across every local authority since June 2017. Every child involved has a disability. She stated that children are

“being injured, being dragged along corridors and being held forcefully enough to cause bruises, scratches, abrasions, broken limbs, noses and teeth.”—Official Report, Public Petitions Committee, 7 November 2019; c 14-15.

Can you give a guarantee to our children and young people that the updated guidance will ensure that that never happens again in schools?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I do not, under any circumstance, want any of the examples that were cited by the petitioner at that session to be the experience of children and young people in our schools. School must be a place of safety and reassurance to every child and young person in Scotland. Young people will not be able to learn effectively if that is not the case, particularly in addressing some of the issues the convener has put to me about the trauma and disadvantage that young people may have experienced. School must be for them, whatever else is happening in their life, a place of safety, security and reassurance.

All the examples that Gail Ross has put to me are not acceptable. We have to ensure that the practice is such that we do not have those experiences. The thinking behind the guidance will be heavily influenced by the importance of the de-escalation of circumstances, including ensuring that staff are properly trained and equipped in order to deliver de-escalation approaches.

I cannot say to the committee that there will never be a circumstance in which some form of restraint may be applied, because there may be issues of personal safety for a child or a member of staff involved. However, I can say that I do not think any of the issues that Gail Ross raised are in any way justifiable.

We have to ensure we have good practice in place. Earlier, I indicated that the guidance places at its core positive relationships and behaviour, early intervention and prevention to—I chose my words very deliberately in describing this crucial part—minimise the use of physical intervention and seclusion. That is not to say that it will not ever happen, but we have to ensure that, if it has to happen, it will do so only once all the other options have been exhausted and it will happen in a safe and appropriate fashion. A “safe and appropriate fashion” would not be the words that I would choose to describe the examples that Gail Ross has put to me.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Thank you. Have you ruled out making the guidance statutory?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

That has been one of the rather fraught issues that we have had to wrestle with. I have been at pains to explain this to both the Equality and Human Rights Commission and the children’s commissioner, and I am grateful for the fact that they have accepted the reality of the position that we are in today. I do not have the power currently to make statutory guidance in this area—I simply do not have the power in statute to do that.

The children’s commissioner asked me to make statutory guidance within six months, but before I could make statutory guidance I would have to have the statutory power to do that in the first place, and I cannot do that within six months. MSPs know how long it takes us to put primary legislation through the Parliament, and I would have to do that to make statutory guidance. From a standing start, that would take me at least a year, if not more, and then secondary legislation would have to follow. If we wanted to go down the statutory guidance route, we would be looking at the start of that process being at least 18 months away, at the very earliest, with the guidance coming probably a year after that.

By January 2021, I hope to have in place guidance that arises from good, open dialogue involving all relevant stakeholders, including children and young people who have experience in this area. That is quicker than it would take to formulate statutory guidance. I appreciate that the character of statutory guidance is different from that of the guidance that I am putting in place. However, I have secured the agreement of local government, ADES and our professional associations to work with us, along with children and young people, the EHRC and the children’s commissioner, to put guidance in place by January 2021. I am trying to move as quickly and as authoritatively as I can in the absence of a statutory power to act in the area. It is not that I am unwilling to exercise a statutory power; it is that I do not have such a power to exercise.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

How do we ensure that, rather than the guidance being another document that sits on a shelf gathering dust, all headteachers, teachers, school staff and everyone who is involved in schools are aware of it, actually read it and follow it?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I have gone through a very careful set of steps over the past few months to make sure that I could get to the point where I am today, sitting in front of the committee and saying that I have agreement to proceed on the basis that I have set out from Scotland’s local authorities, from ADES, from the professional associations that represent the teaching profession, from the EHRC and from the children’s commissioner. That gives me the widest possible agreement.

We then have to make sure that the guidance is translated into practical effect, that it is the subject of discussion at local level, and that it is understood in schools. I know from my experience around schools that it is perfectly possible to get strategic messages across to all schools in the country and to have them participate in all that effort. We just have to make sure that that happens. Crucially, we have all the necessary agreement in place to enable us to do that, as a consequence of what we have been doing for the past few months.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I will follow up on the issue of statutory guidance, At the evidence session with the children’s commissioner, it was suggested that there had been advice that making the guidance statutory was not going to be considered and was off the table. The First Minister later said that she would not resist the idea completely—it was not something that she would not consider. I hear what you say about timing and so on. Are you taking steps, or is it possible to take steps, to have that as a fall-back position—at least as an option—so that if your approach does not work, you could then move to bringing in statutory guidance? Have you explored what you would need to do now to take that power, so that if you were to realise in a year and a half that what looked like a way forward was not going to work, you would not then have to wait another 18 months? Is it possible to do that kind of belt-and-braces work now?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I know what would be involved because I have taken advice on the statutory position. I know what statute we would have to put in place to enable that to happen. I have said to the EHRC and the children’s commissioner that if, after the 12-month review of the implementation of the guidance, we do not see changes in practice, I would consider moving to statutory guidance.

I had not previously considered your question, which is whether I should just set that train in motion now to secure the statutory power in light of the possibility that the guidance is not seen to be effective at the review stage. Having now considered the point, that is the only thing that I could add to the measures that I am taking forward just now, given that I agreed with the EHRC and the children’s commissioner that we would work together to get the guidance in place, review it after 12 months, with very involved participation, to see how it prevails, and then consider the statutory question.

10:15

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

If the argument is that it will all take too long, the logic would be to take the power, as you do not have to exercise it. Will you reflect on that?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

Certainly, in the light of the question that you have put to me, I will reflect on it.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

In previous evidence sessions, the commissioner and the petitioner have stated that mistakes have been made when staff have been using restraint or seclusion. Bearing in mind the question from my colleague Gail Ross on what has happened to some children, do you regard it as important that there is proper training and support in the proactive strategies that you have talked about, alongside the development of guidance and so on? There is obviously an element of support for teachers and those who handle children.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

Those issues have significant importance—that will be part of the roll-out of the guidance that we take forward. I was keen to ensure that the guidance is part of the suite of documents in the “Included, Engaged and Involved” series because they are predicated on the importance of applying de-escalation approaches in all circumstances. That is the culture I want to prevail in Scottish education.

Tense situations and situations of conflict in our schools are best addressed by the de-escalation of the tensions involved. I think that that is better for everybody. It is better for children and young people, because if they experience some of the anxieties that were underpinned in the first question that the convener put to me, reacting in a way that does anything other than de-escalate the situation will be detrimental to them. That applies equally to members of staff. I am keen that we have the de-escalation approach that is reflected in our policy thinking and our policy approaches. It needs to be reflected in the training approaches that we take forward as well.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

Is enough emphasis being given to that in your thinking and deliberations around training and support in this area? I understand that some cases can be very difficult.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I carry responsibility at a policy level; responsibility at the operational level is carried by local authorities and schools. That is why I have gone through those steps. It is all very well for me to formulate a policy position, but I have to have the operational teams and groups in support of that direction as well. We have now reached a position where local government directors of education are entirely supportive of the direction of travel, as are the professional associations. They can provide members of staff with the guidance and support that they require to enable them to take forward the agenda. I am confident that we have all the ingredients in place to enable us to do that.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

What are the main issues that the directors of education or local authorities have come back to you with in trying to get that support to teachers?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

The challenge in our education system is that every teacher needs to know how to handle any given circumstance. Anything may just emerge in their classroom today—something might never ever have emerged in their classroom before but that might happen today. There are more than 52,000 teachers in our classrooms. My approach is about encouraging continuous professional learning within our teaching profession because the world is changing around us. Some of the challenges arising from the experience of children in our society today results in young people presenting with more complex circumstances and backgrounds than has been the case in the past. The teaching profession has to be equipped to deal with those issues. If that results in conflict, they need to be able to de-escalate that and to handle all those questions. That is why there has to be an atmosphere of continuous professional learning within the education profession.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Further to Maurice Corry’s questions, I have a couple of family members who are involved in the area—one as a teacher and one as a support teacher—so I am glad to hear that we are talking about support and training for teachers. I recognise, as I am sure the cabinet secretary does, the pressure situations in pupil-teacher interaction that we are speaking about.

The petitioner was critical of the membership of the Scottish Government’s short-life working group because it did not include people with learning disability expertise. I know that the cabinet secretary agrees with me that it is important to have lived experience in a working group. My question, which I ask on behalf of the petitioner, is why that expertise was not included in the working group.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

That is one of the areas where we have benefited from the dialogue that we have had with the EHRC and the children’s commissioner. I have seen the EHRC and the children’s commissioner, or their representatives, at least twice in the past few months. I have listened to their perspective, and I accept that we did not have, in our original approach, sufficient breadth around the table to assist us in that discussion. I have ensured that there will be lived experience around the table to enable us to hear those voices, and that is how we will proceed to develop the guidance.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

One of the key elements in developing policy will be data gathering and recording. The Commissioner for Children and Young People and the Education and Skills Committee have recommended to the Scottish Government that it considers ways to improve data gathering on the use of seclusion and restraint. Will you comment on that and say what action you will take to address those issues?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

A lot of data is collected on the area, but I do not think that it is collected in a comparable fashion at local authority level, so we will do some work on ensuring that there is compatibility and comparability in the data that is collected. As part of the agreement, we will ensure that local authorities fully participate in that approach.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

The petitioner has highlighted that the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child recommends that Governments should record and monitor all incidents of the use of restraint and seclusion. Given your answer and the Scottish Government’s commitment to incorporate the UNCRC into domestic law, can you give a commitment that data will be recorded and monitored in the way that you have indicated?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

The first part of that will be to make sure that we have comparable data across all local authorities, and we will take that forward as a consequence of the work that we are doing. Bearing in mind that, as I said in my introductory remarks, I want to minimise the use of seclusion and restraint, it is important that we properly monitor and interrogate any examples of that happening, because we do not want to see it happening unless it is an absolute last resort.

We have to be careful, however. One of the things that troubles me about the data issue relates to how that data is handled, and that is why I cannot say to the committee that there will never be restraint. I do not think that it will help the situation if we almost get to a point of having a league table that shows the worst local authorities for restraint, for example, because its use may be justified in any case. However many there are and however much we would like them not to happen, there may be a justification for the use of restraint. I am not sure that characterising restraint in that fashion will help to advance the objective of minimising its use, which we are all interested in.

I want to make sure that the data is available to be interrogated so that it can inform good practice and so that we can learn from it and try to find ways in which we can further minimise the use of restraint. I am not interested in collecting data so that we can have a league table and make some bodies and organisations feel that, somehow, despite the fact that they believe that they are delivering good practice—perhaps independently verifiable good practice—they are subjected to public criticism when that is not warranted. I accept that there is a fine line in all of that, but it is only right and proper that I express my unease to the committee on the question.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I agree with you that it is important that the way in which the data is recorded and interrogated does not cause undue pressure within an environment that is functioning properly. However, I think that you would agree that, if the data is recorded and utilised properly, it can highlight areas where there are issues.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I have absolutely no issue with what Mr Whittle has just said. I agree entirely with his comment, and that is why we will collect the data. However, I want the committee to be aware of the unease that I feel about how the data could be mishandled if that is not done in the way that Mr Whittle set out.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I think that you will get agreement on that point.

My final point on data gathering is on ensuring that the data is recorded in a way that means that it can be properly utilised. Will that require investment in a data processing and information technology collaboration platform? Will investment be required to bring all the local authorities together so that the data can be recorded in the way that you want it to be recorded?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

We already have the SEEMiS system, with which the committee will be familiar and which enables recording on a pupil-by-pupil basis around the country. Therefore, the major infrastructure is there. There may be additional elements that we need to consider adding to the system as the issue develops.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I have a quick supplementary on the back of the questions on data recording. In some of the evidence that we have heard, we have been told that the parents and families only found out about what was happening in school when the children came home with physical evidence such as bruises and so on. Will the data recording system be operated a way that involves families? How will we ensure that families are involved right at the outset, as opposed their involvement not happening until the child comes home?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

There is a pretty fundamental point in that question, which is about school and family dialogue. School and family dialogue should be very open. Whenever there is an incident that a school believes a family needs to know about, the family should be advised about that incident. Off and on, my wife and I get phone calls during the day about things that have gone on as a consequence of the antics of our son involving play equipment in the school playground—that dialogue is immediate. Good practice tells us that schools should be in contact with parents at the earliest and most appropriate opportunity.

In the formulation of the guidance, I hope that, by listening to the voices that I have said we will listen to, we will get the perspective that Ms Ross encourages us to have in taking forward the issue.

10:30

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is the end of our questions. We need to think about how we take the petition forward. I think that there is a sense of progress—the petitioner has been positive about that. I note that we have had the petition under consideration since February 2015.

I know that there is an independent review into the implementation of additional support for learning. I do not know whether there is a context there for the petition and for the specifics on the progress that have been identified by the cabinet secretary. Do members have suggestions on how we might take the petition forward?

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Given the evidence that we have heard today and the commitment that the cabinet secretary has given us on behalf of the Government, I think that a lot of the issues are being addressed. The issue is one that still needs to be monitored but we may have taken it as far as we can. I would like to refer the petition on to the Education and Skills Committee, which can keep it open and keep an eye on where the guidance is going and how it pans out.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We could put it in the context of additional support for learning, which I know that the Education and Skills Committee is looking at.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I agree with that. I add one caveat, which is that the continued input of the petitioner and those with lived experience is crucial. I would like to ensure that that input continues if we are to pass the petition on to another committee.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I seek members agreement to flag up to the Education and Skills Committee not only that we are referring the petition to it in the context of the review of the implementation of additional support for learning, but that there is benefit in positive engagement with the petitioner and those who have been involved in the debate. In addition, we should flag up that, if the guidance as it develops is not effective, the Government has made a commitment to look at what may be done to ensure that there is a means by which the guidance can be put on a statutory basis. Is that agreed?

Members indicated agreement.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We agree to refer the petition to the Education and Skills Committee under rule 15.6.2 of standing orders. We will write to the Education and Skills Committee in the terms that members have highlighted. We thank the Government for the presentation that it made today and the petitioner for her persistence in pursuing the matter over what has been quite a significant period of time. We thank the petitioner for her engagement with the committee.

I suspend the meeting briefly to allow the witnesses to leave the table.

10:32 Meeting suspended.

10:36 On resuming—

  1. 08:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 28
  2. 09:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 26
  3. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 41
  4. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 100

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.