It is depressing that the petitioner feels the need to bring this petition, because—as far as I can see—it comes from concerns about the way in which staff are treated. It aims to provide protection to staff. What does the fact that our staff need protection say about what is happening in our A and E departments and elsewhere?
The motivation behind the petition is very positive. The petitioner notes that there was a trial project in Northamptonshire, in which he says:
“body cameras ... had a positive experience and positive outcome for patients”.
There might also be an issue in relation to the stories we have heard about maltreatment of patients in certain circumstances and families’ confidence that patients are being treated properly. How is that brought out into the public domain?
The petitioner highlights a matter that is profoundly depressing. Vulnerable patients in particular circumstances could be abused and denied their rights and, equally, staff are under threat. I think that we recognise the challenge.
However, at this stage, the solution that is being offered is not one that the professions and those around about them feel is appropriate. I think that we are agreeing that we want to close the petition, under rule 15.7 of standing orders, on the basis that the Scottish Government has said that the costs of the proposal would be
“prohibitive for Health Boards and would not provide value for money”,
and on the basis that there are concerns on the part of the professionals involved.
However, we recognise that the underlying issues that prompted the petition are serious. I am confident that those issues are being addressed in the system, because the matter is clearly something that people want to consider, in the context of patients’ rights and the protection of staff.
Do we agree to close the petition?
Members indicated agreement.