The next continued petition is petition PE1667, by W Hunter Watson, on the review of mental health and incapacity legislation. The petition calls on the Scottish Government to conduct a wide review of Scottish mental health and incapacity legislation and when doing so to take due account of recent developments in international human rights law.
At our previous consideration of the petition in March 2019, the Minister for Mental Health gave evidence on the Scottish Government’s work to review mental health legislation. The minister outlined the work of a new review of mental health legislation to build on and complement the workstreams that were already under way. Those workstreams concerned adult support and protection legislation; a review to consider whether the provisions of the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003 fulfil the needs of people with learning disability and autism; and the Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Act 2000.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?
Forgive me if I am getting this wrong, but I would say that the review has been granted and is under way and we are expecting an interim report next May. In my opinion, the Government is doing what it has been asked to do, so I am satisfied that we can close the petition.
Mental health is a topic that has exercised the Parliament, not just this committee, during this parliamentary session, and rightly so. We are doing our own investigation in the mental health space, and the Government itself is doing work. In bringing this petition, the petitioner has, quite rightly, added to that workload. As Gail Ross said, the Government has taken this on board and is doing work in this area. In that respect, I think the petitioner has been successful and I am inclined to agree with Gail Ross that we have probably taken the petition as far as we are going to take it.
One of my concerns is about the reflection of the United Nations legislation and advice that is coming through at the moment. I flag up the fact that any Scottish Government investigation into this should reflect quite deeply on that in relation to its current process. Constituents have approached me on several occasions about this very issue and their real worry is about not carrying forward and carrying into legislation aspects of the UN charter on mental health. As long as that is taken on board, I am happy with it—that is my only slight query.
We can write to the Scottish Government, recognising that it is having this review, to say that those concerns have been highlighted. There are clearly people—including the petitioner, I am sure—who will be watching the progress of this work. If we feel there is a gap, there will be an opportunity to address it. That will be the role of the scrutinising committee and of the Parliament as a whole. Of course, if the petitioner felt that aspects were not being progressed, there would be an opportunity to return to the committee.
My sense from the committee is that we are agreeing to close the petition under rule 15.7 of standing orders on the basis that the Scottish Government is undertaking work that addresses the action called for in the petition. We are agreeing to write to the Scottish Government to highlight the points that Maurice Corry made and we recognise that there will be work done by the Parliament to test the commitment to deliver on the review against what people’s expectations of it were.
It is also about the delivery of some of the treatments—and the disparity between specialists in that regard. That is what has been coming through and constituents are keen to have it addressed. That links back to the point about the UN charter.
Again, we thank the petitioner and recognise the progress that has been made in part by the petition itself. Of course, the petitioner may have an opportunity at a later stage to reflect on the way in which the review has been delivered. We thank them for their engagement with the Public Petitions Committee.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.