Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“NHS Workforce Planning—Part 2: The Clinical Workforce in General Practice”

Thursday 12 September 2019 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 09:45–11:00 Committee business 113 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

113 contributions
Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Item 3 is consideration of another section 23 report, on NHS workforce planning.

I welcome the witnesses: Caroline Gardner, Auditor General for Scotland; Claire Sweeney, audit director; Mark Ferris, senior audit manager; and Dharshi Santhakumaran, audit manager; they are all from Audit Scotland. The Auditor General will make an opening statement.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Thank you, convener. Very briefly, this report is the second in a series of audits on NHS workforce planning. The first report focused on the secondary care workforce and was published in July 2017, while today’s report examines how effectively the Scottish Government is planning the general practice-based workforce to meet the needs of the Scottish population.

Primary care plays a crucial role in the Scottish Government’s vision to shift the balance of care. The Government has ambitious plans to change the way in which primary care services are delivered, with a focus on increasing the workforce and expanding the multidisciplinary teams who work with general practitioners. The ambition is clear, but the Government has not provided a clear analysis of how its plans for the workforce will achieve that ambition.

The Government has committed to having an additional 800 GPs in the workforce by 2027. It is not clear how the Government has calculated that that number will meet the demand in the long term, or how it relates to plans to increase the wider workforce to take pressure off GPs. The Government has put a range of measures in place to try to improve the recruitment and retention of GPs, but it is difficult to see how the target will be achieved, given trends in GP numbers and UK-wide workforce pressures.

The successful implementation of the new GP contract also depends on integration authorities being able to increase the multidisciplinary workforce. Integration authorities have set out their workforce projections for the next three years, but it is likely that some areas will struggle to recruit the numbers of pharmacists, nurses and physiotherapists needed. It is also likely that the expansion will have a knock-on effect on other parts of the health and social care workforce.

The Government’s ability to plan the workforce effectively has been hampered by a lack of data on primary care. Securing agreement that practices will submit data as part of the new contract is a positive step, but the details of what data will be collected have not yet been finalised. Without good baseline data, the Government will not be able to assess whether changes to primary care are having the desired impact.

Finally, there have been delays to a number of workforce planning outputs, including the national integrated health and social care workforce plan. When that plan is published, I hope to see more detailed scenario planning and a clearer assessment of the workforce needed to meet the future needs of the Scottish population.

As always, convener, my colleagues and I will do our best to answer the committee’s questions.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you very much, Auditor General. Anas Sarwar will open the questioning.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

Thank you, Auditor General, for that introduction. I will ask a few questions. It is the Scottish Government’s ambition to have 800 additional GPs within the 10 years of the strategy. How does it marry that ambition with the Royal College of General Practitioners’ view that we will be 850-odd GPs short by 2021?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I will ask Dharshi Santhakumaran to come in in a moment to give you more detail.

On page 25 of the report, we set out some of our concerns about the 800 GP target. First, the target is set in headcount terms. As we say in the report, we know that increasing numbers of GPs, particularly younger GPs, are planning to work on a less than full-time basis, so you need to train more people in order to have 800 people on a full-time equivalent basis. Secondly, the Government’s planning does not take account of what we know about retirement rates, the potential impact of European Union withdrawal and recruitment difficulties more widely.

In the report, we set out a range of estimates of what we think might happen in relation to the GP target. The estimates are generally on the optimistic case; it is possible we will have fewer GPs in place at that point. Dharshi Santhakumaran can give you some more background to that.

Dharshi Santhakumaran Audit Scotland
link

We have not seen any clear analysis of how the Scottish Government reached the 800 GP target, so we cannot really compare it with the RCGP’s suggestion that there will be a deficit of 856 GPs.

As for our projections, exhibit 8 in the report describes the most likely scenario. We looked at a number of factors. We looked at trends in the leavers and joiners in the GP workforce and we also took account of what we know about the number of GPs who are also registered in EU countries. The most likely scenario looks at what would happen if 10 per cent of those decided to leave the country. We also looked at increasing trends in part-time working.

We have more scenarios online that show both the best and worst cases: there is quite a big difference between those. In our worst-case scenario there would be a significantly bigger gap, and in the best-case scenario there would be a small surplus.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

What is clear from that is that, based on the current trends and outputs it looks as though we will not meet the Scottish Government’s target of 800 GPs, never mind the RCGP’s target.

Part of what is required is a remodelling and a culture change in primary care, and part of that culture change is getting patients to understand that they cannot always see a GP and that it is sometimes perhaps best to see a physiotherapist or an advanced specialist nurse or a mental health nurse. The issue is also how we build up a multidisciplinary team. Can you say a bit about whether progress has been made on culture change, and also on building an adequate workforce to fill GP places?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I will kick us off, and look to the team to fill in the gaps. You are absolutely right that the Government’s vision for health and social care is based on moving more care out of acute hospitals and into community-based settings. GPs, and the teams around them, play a key part in that. A GP practice is the best place to identify problems early, to help people manage their care, and to avoid the need for admission to hospital where it is not essential. To do that well, they will need to build the wider team of nurses, physiotherapists, allied healthcare professionals and other workers, such as community link workers, to be able to do that well.

That is one of the key elements of the new general medical services contract that came into effect in April 2018. It was intended to build that approach and to give responsibilities for working in a different way, so that GPs could be more effective by seeing the right patients.

We say in the report that there is some evidence that patients would be willing to see professionals other than GPs if patients understood the roles of those professionals and particularly if the patients’ previous experience had been good. An important recommendation from this report is that the Government, health boards and healthcare professionals more widely need to engage with people about why those changes are needed and say that it is not about cuts, it is about—

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

Sorry for interrupting you. We talked about the additional headcount of 800 GPs. Has there been an analysis of what additional headcount will be needed for each layer of the multidisciplinary team, so that we know how many people we are short and how many people we need to train up and bring into primary care?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We are not seeing something that goes beyond the commitments to train additional numbers of people and that sets out what you have described, which is an analysis that says, “Here is what the workforce of the future needs to look like to be able to do that.” We are seeing some of that at a local level, where it is being done by some individual integration authorities.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The integration authorities’ figures are much higher than the levels we have seen being recruited into the workforce in recent years.

I think that that engagement piece is really important—this was a key part of your question—for people to understand why things are changing and accept appointments with other healthcare professionals. That seems to us a key part of making it work. Claire Sweeney and Dharshi Santhakumaran will want to add to that.

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

It is perhaps worth making the point that workforce planning is not just about the primary care workforce, but about the impact on the rest of the system. We do not have good data about the numbers that need to be in place in general practice, but neither do we have a clear picture about what the implications of that are for the rest of the system. Changing what happens in a GP practice will have an impact on what is needed in, for example, secondary care, district nursing and, of course, in the workforce in social care services—people working in care homes and the like. We are not seeing the model in primary care, but that is just part of a bigger, more complex system that needs to be thought through.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

I have asked this question before on lots of different topics. If you add up the numbers, you are probably talking about needing a headcount of 2,000 or 3,000 people—perhaps even more. Do the numbers exist in Scotland to be able to deliver what we want to deliver? If not, what is the answer? Is it another remodelling? Is it international students? Is it migration? What is the answer?

10:15

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is a really good question and obviously links back to the committee’s earlier evidence session with the Funding Council about skills training. Exhibit 9 in the report sets out, for each of the allied health professions—pharmacists and so on—the increases in those staff groups that the integration authorities across Scotland think that they need over the next three years. In every case, the numbers that the authorities think they will need in future are much bigger than the increases that we have seen in the recent past and those people are not just there to appoint.

As Claire Sweeney said, there is a risk that as the primary care teams are increasing their numbers, they are recruiting staff from other bits of the health service, from pharmacists and community pharmacies or hospitals, for example. We know that it takes a while to train allied health professionals. It does not take as long as it takes to train doctors—it is generally three years, perhaps a little bit longer—but the planning for that needs to be happening now and the Government needs to understand what the cost implications are. It is likely that there will be a cost increase needed during the training period as we get numbers up, even if there are savings to be had from the acute sector once the primary care system is fulfilling that bigger role that is expected of it.

Mark Ferris Audit Scotland
link

Building on what the Auditor General said, we do not know the numbers, but we also do not know the costs of the primary care workforce at present. We do not know what the costs may be to train up all the GPs and the additional multidisciplinary teams, or what that will translate into in costs for the future workforce.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

Is there adequate interaction among NHS workforce planners, the Scottish Government and the Scottish Funding Council in relation to colleges and the university sector about the courses that we need, the number of places that we need, where and how soon we need them, and how many places need to be for Scotland-based students? We know that students are more likely to stay in-country if they are Scottish and are in a Scottish place. Is there adequate interaction? It does not feel like there is adequate interaction.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

NHS Education for Scotland plays a key role for the core NHS workforce. If the information that our report identifies a need for were there, NHS Education for Scotland would be able to do very much more to co-ordinate the training and ensure that the training places were in the right place. It has made some good progress this year with the data platform that will pull that information together.

People in some of the other roles, particularly the less professional roles—I mentioned community link workers and some of the other healthcare support workers—are and can be trained in further education colleges and other settings. I am not sure that we see much evidence of joined-up training around those roles. There is also an issue around expanding the early learning and childcare workforce to meet the Government’s commitment on that by next August. There is room for more joined-up skills planning in those non-clinical parts of the primary care workforce.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

My final area of questioning is about the business side of a GP practice. We know anecdotally that a lot of the pressure on GPs is from managing a business—from managing and maintaining property, managing human resources and suchlike. There is a drive now for the maintenance of GP practices, the responsibility for the rent and so on to be taken over by health boards. What are the cost implications and risks involved in that? Should we be looking at a model in which we take property away from individual GPs and GP practices and instead have NHS boards operate it in-house? What impact would relieving some of the pressure on GPs in that way have in encouraging more GPs to stay on and new GPs to come in?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There have been two big developments in that area recently. The first is the new GMS contract, one of whose aims is to share the risk relating to premises and so on between GP partners, the NHS centrally and health boards. As we say in the report, one of the challenges is that information to monitor the impact of that contract is not yet being collected, so we are watching to see what happens there.

The second development is that, as you know, more GP practices are being taken over by their NHS boards and more GPs are being employed directly rather than as partners. The evidence on that is not clear yet. Some GPs think that it costs more to provide primary care through a directly employed model. It is also possible that that model may reduce the ability for GP practices to respond flexibly to the needs of their local communities and the people they serve, but the truth is that we simply do not know yet what the impact is. It is another area that needs careful monitoring.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

Many GP practices will be older properties that are not well maintained. If we are going to move to multidisciplinary teams, that will require a larger workforce and more health centre-type buildings. Has any analysis been done of the potential capital investment that is required to build primary care hubs in communities across Scotland?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We highlight in the report the need for both more and different physical infrastructure for multidisciplinary teams and digital infrastructure. I will ask the team to pick that question up.

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

We recognise that capital is an increasing risk across the health and social care sector—there is no doubt about that. We will want to talk about that again in the NHS overview report this year. One of the issues is the extent to which workforce and capital plans are keeping pace with the move to health and social care integration and different models of care. The Scottish Government’s ambition to have a very different model of health and social care, and the development of GPs and GP practices and the like is key to making that work. If there are problems there, there will be issues with delivering the new models of care. I do not know that there is much more we could say about the detail around capital at a local level, but certainly it is something that we are keeping an eye on and are very interested in. It is a big risk.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

There are huge data gaps again. What Mark Ferris said was quite shocking. He said that the Scottish Government does not know how much this will cost and he reeled off about five areas where there is not enough data or information. It is quite astonishing.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is one of the key messages of the report. There is widespread consensus that the Government’s vision for the health service—to move more care into primary and community settings—is the right one. We cannot possibly do that unless we know what GPs and their teams are doing now, what we want them to be doing in future, how many we need for that and what it costs. As we have said before, there are particular data gaps in the primary and community care parts of the health and care service. I know that it is an issue of concern to the committee. It causes problems both in planning and in evaluating the changes that the Government is looking to make.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Why are there the data gaps? Does the Government not require this information to be recorded, or is it NHS boards that are not requiring it to be recorded? Where does the direction come from to capture the information that we need?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The position is complicated, as it often is. Part of the root cause is the fact that, as Mr Sarwar was saying, most GPs until now have been independent contractors and there has not been a requirement on them in recent years to provide some of the information that is needed. The Government has developed a programme called Scottish primary care information resource, which was intended to collect some of the activity data that is needed, but it is not fully doing that. Data gaps here are a problem. The team can give you more detail if that would be helpful.

Dharshi Santhakumaran Audit Scotland
link

As the Auditor General said, until the current GP contract, GPs, as independent contractors, were not obliged to submit practice data. Because of that, the only thing that we knew was the head count number of GPs. Everything else was estimated data based on a voluntary primary care workforce survey, which was run every two years. Because of that, we had a big gap in our understanding of the number of people in the wider team working in GP practices and the workforce costs. There has been a gap in activity data—the number of consultations and whether it was the GP or other members of the team who were having those consultations—because that data has not been collected since 2013. There is work under way to improve that and, as part of the new contract, practices will be obliged to submit data, but that is not yet happening.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

What is the significance of 2013? Were practices obliged to provide the data before 2013 and then were no longer obliged?

Dharshi Santhakumaran Audit Scotland
link

There was a sample of activity data collected from 6 per cent of practices up until that point, but they stopped collecting it because SPIRE was due to be fully deployed by that stage. It is not yet, so there has been a gap in that activity data.

Dharshi Santhakumaran Audit Scotland
link

Yes.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Following up on both lines of questioning, I have a straight question. Your report acknowledges that the Scottish Government is developing this approach to workforce planning but that progress is very slow. Why are we hearing about these data gaps? These are things that have been around since Alex Neil was in post.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

You are right. Progress has been slow. I think that the Government has recognised the importance of workforce planning for a long time. In exhibit 5 on page 20, we set out a number of the outputs that were planned and what has happened to them. Some of them were late and some are still outstanding. The first thing to say is that it is complex. We are talking about a lot of GP practices, which cover the whole of Scotland in a range of different places. As we said in our report in 2017 about the acute care workforce, there has not been enough priority placed on putting some of the building blocks in place. Why that is the case is a question for the Government. We highlight in the report that responsibility has been fragmented, although the Government is now committed to bringing responsibility for workforce planning together in one place. That is due to happen in November this year.

Data collection has often not been a priority. I know that that is something that the committee has commented on very recently. It is easy for data to look as though it is bureaucratic overhead or a bean counter’s obsession. My view—and I think that of the committee—is that it is essential if you are going to know what the priorities are, where to invest your money and what you are getting for it. We are not in a position to demonstrate that yet in relation to workforce planning.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Do you get any sense that this will change, or would you prefer that that was a question for the Scottish Government? Are you looking at this saying, “Okay, the Government has realised that there is an issue, so the pace of change will now increase”?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The Government recognises the issues. There is no doubt that the challenges are set out clearly in the workforce planning documents we have so far. As I say in the report and I said in my opening statement today, I hope that, when we see the integrated workforce plan for health and care, we will see some of the gaps addressed. There is no doubt that it will take longer to fill the data gaps, as that cannot be done immediately. A baseline needs to be set, but it is important that there are clear and urgent plans to do that.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You have a lot of recommendations on data collection in your report. Has the Government accepted those recommendations?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is a question the committee may want to ask of the Government. We have been through the normal clearance process, so we have cleared it for factual accuracy, but it is for the committee to confirm whether the Government accepts recommendations or not.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Still chewing on the question of GPs and so on, I think that the Government says that its commitments to train additional GPs, paramedics, nurses and so on are on track. I think that you have agreed with that as far as the training is concerned. The concern is whether the numbers are high enough; what are they based on? There seems to be no real answer for that. Am I correct?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

You have summarised that very well, Mr Beattie. Exhibit 7 sets out the commitments that the Government has made. The commitments to train additional professionals across the piece are on track or have been achieved. What we have not seen is something that connects the commitments that were made to the number of staff who were expected to be needed and we are concerned that achieving the additional 800 GPs will be very difficult under current circumstances.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Paul Gray told the committee:

“in general practice, we are now training two GPs for every one that we think we are going to need”.—Official Report, Public Audit and Post-legislative Committee, 9 November 2017; c 7.

Is that based on anything?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

You would need to ask the Government about that. As you would expect, we have probed very hard to understand the basis for the Government’s workforce commitments, but we have not seen anything that connects the figure of 800 to workforce need. We also know that the 800 is a head count and does not turn into the number of hours and the number of full-time equivalent GPs needed to provide care.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Arising from this is quite an important point relating to your previous report on NHS workforce planning. A key issue for the committee is obviously whether and the extent to which these recommendations have been implemented. Can you summarise what progress the Government has made towards implementing your previous recommendations?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have tried to summarise that in appendix 1, on pages 33 and 34 of the report. Claire, do you want to have a go at pulling out the key messages from that?

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

It is fair to say that there are recommendations in this report that are similar to those that were made in the previous report, and there are certainly areas that still need to be addressed. We were relying on the forthcoming workforce plan to include some of the details to address the recommendations in the first report.

10:30

Even when the data is not good and is not accurate, we still expect to see a level of scenario planning around it. We have been able to do that, as Dharshi Santhakumaran said, under worst-case, best-guess and best-case scenarios. There is information to allow workforce planning to happen even when it is not good information.

The information that is available around workforce planning is better for secondary care than it is for primary care services. That has always been the case, so the Government had more of a head start for secondary workforce planning, which was the basis of the first report, than it has had for the second report, on primary care.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Given the importance to the Government of moving towards, or putting more NHS resources into, primary care, is progress being made? It seems to be very patchy. Quite alarmingly, you mentioned that there is no evidence that it is the right policy, which I have not heard you say in the past.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is not quite what I said. I said that there is consensus that moving more care from secondary care into primary and community services is the right way to go for a range of reasons, not least Scotland’s ageing population and the fact that more of us are living longer with complex needs that cannot be cured through a stay in an acute hospital. The consensus is there. What we have not seen is the analysis that says, “Here is the workforce of GPs and all the other professionals who work with them that we will need in primary care to be able to do that.”

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I am sorry—I thought that you were hinting at the possibility that it was not working.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have been saying for a while that it is not happening fast enough. The report specifically says that we do not know what workforce we need to make it a reality.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I want to pick up on Colin Beattie’s line of questioning on GPs and part-time work. You said that you were not sure where the 800 figure had come from. Is 800 additional GPs too few?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We know that the Government has made a commitment to have 800 additional GPs, in terms of head count, by a particular date, which the team will confirm for me in a moment, but we have not seen an analysis that grounds that figure in an analysis of what primary care will be doing at that date. As I have said, we are also concerned that a head count of 800 is likely to amount to quite significantly fewer full-time-equivalent GPs than that, so more people will need to be trained to get that equivalent because of changing working patterns.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

When I read the report, the thing that really struck me was the increase in the number of younger GPs who are working part time. It seems to me that there is an obvious reason for that, which is that a lot of GPs—I do not know the current percentage—are female. Especially in the age bracket that you identify, females are working part time to juggle work with childcare. I do not think that the gender issue is covered in the report, but I might have missed it.

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

It is covered. I cannot quite recall the paragraph number, but the report mentions two issues that relate to the part-time factor. It is absolutely a gender issue in part, and the report makes mention of that. The second issue is to do with people who work in general practice who want to pursue portfolio careers, which means that being a GP might not be the only job that they do. Again, I cannot quite recall the paragraph number, but there is an issue with the workload that GPs face every day. Feedback from various surveys indicates that that has become more onerous.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

For me, that is an important point. Given that we have younger GPs who, in my experience, are increasingly women, surely we should be making it easier for them to work part time, either through systemic change or by putting that in the policy arrangements. It surprises me that there is not a bit more focus on that. Is there enough focus on the part of the Government on retaining those women in the workplace? The other figure that is relevant in this area is the 26 per cent of GPs who say that they will not be practising as GPs in five years’ time. I take Claire Sweeney’s point that there might be a bit of portfolio working going on, but is any work being done by the Government to retain those women in the workplace?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That latter question is one for the Government. However, what I would say is that the fact that we are seeing more younger GPs working part time probably reflects the fact that it is an attractive career choice for younger women doctors. They can work part time on a sessional basis, which means that they can maintain a career by fitting their work around the other parts of their life and their caring commitments in ways that are much harder to do in the acute sector. There is element of success there.

We think that the doctors who expect not to be working in primary care in five years’ time tend to be the older doctors. They are the ones who are thinking about reducing their hours or leaving, partly in response to pension taxation changes, which the committee has focused on previously. Having said that, I am sure that the Government, health boards and integration joint boards could be doing more to make general practice an attractive career for doctors in general, including young doctors with parental responsibilities.

I had another thought, but it has flown out of my head, so I will stop there.

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

The other point to make is about developing the rest of the primary workforce team so that they can support GPs to do the job that they do best. Work needs to be done to work out what the best model is to meet the needs of people locally, which will be different in different areas.

However, it is worth bearing in mind that, in general, the feedback from the public about how happy they are with general practice tends to be very positive. We have an exhibit in the report that sets out people’s views on whether they can get to see a GP or someone else in the practice when they really need to. Those satisfaction levels tend to be very high, so there is a lot that is good that is happening there. It is a case of protecting that over time as we move to new models of care.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Dharshi Santhakumaran, do you have anything to add?

Dharshi Santhakumaran Audit Scotland
link

In paragraph 21 of the report, we talk about some of the changes in working patterns, whereby younger GPs are more likely to work four to seven sessions a week, whereas the older GPs and partners are more likely to work eight or more sessions a week. We have seen a reduction in the number of GPs who are partners and an increase in the number of salaried GPs. As you say, that is partly because more women are coming into the workforce but, to a degree, we are also seeing an increase in the number of younger male GPs who want to work part time and who are less keen on taking on the responsibility of being a partner.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I have one bit of detail to add. Although we say that the Government is not taking account of those changes in working patterns in its own planning, we say in paragraph 56 of the report that the integration authorities in Ayrshire and Arran have done some of that analysis. They estimate that, for every full-time GP they need to have in the workforce in future, they need to be training 1.6 GPs now. We do not know that that would apply across Scotland, but it is obviously a useful benchmark to think about in the context of the head count figure of 800.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

To be fair to Paul Gray, given what he said about training two GPs for every one that will be needed, that has probably been taken into account.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I have a couple more questions on workforce, after which I will go on to pensions and tax.

Auditor General, in answer to one of the previous questions, you said that, in addition to more GPs working part time, which we think is mainly to do with the feminisation of the workforce, more GPs want to take on portfolio interests. I would have thought that that is likely to increase as we shift the emphasis to treatment in primary care rather than secondary care. My own GP, for example, as well as being a very good GP, has developed a specialised interest in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Do you agree that that trend—which I think has not been given proper significance even in the Ayrshire study—is likely to increase?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I think so, and I think that we should be seeing more of that. If we want primary care to be able to deal with more people with complex long-term conditions such as COPD, it makes perfect sense for GPs and other primary care professionals to work across primary care and hospitals and to follow patients as their needs change. That is why, as Claire Sweeney said, it is so important that the planning does not look just at primary care and secondary care, but looks to join that up and to bring in the social care picture, too.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

In order to get to the point at which people decide whether they want to be GPs, we must look at the pipeline before that. That starts with the number of people who apply to medical school every year. What is particularly relevant, for the reasons that Anas Sarwar outlined, is the number of Scotland-domiciled applicants, because they are far more likely to stay in Scotland than others are.

Do you have a figure for the number of Scotland-domiciled applicants to medical school who meet the entry criteria, but who are not offered a place, probably because of capping?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We do not have that information here, but I am very happy to go away and find out whether it is readily available. Obviously, the committee might want to explore that with the Government.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That would be very helpful, because that ought to be the starting point. If we do not have that pipeline, as well as not having enough GPs, we will not have enough practitioners of any specialism at the other end.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

For balance, we refer in paragraph 68 to some of the initiatives that the Government has put in place. There is a graduate entry medical training initiative, which is aimed particularly at primary care, and there are pre-medical entry courses, which are aimed at getting less advantaged students, who might previously not have applied to medical school, to get places.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

However, I think that that question is more one for the Government.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It is interesting how many applicants who meet the entry criteria are turned down every year.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Indeed.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

In paragraph 22 of your report, you say:

“Recent changes to pension and tax arrangements may have an impact on GP recruitment and retention.”

When the original tax changes were made in 2012, I raised this point with the then chancellor, George Osborne. I put it to you that there is perfectly clear evidence that these changes and subsequent changes in 2012 to the lifetime allowance and the pension scheme itself have had a detrimental impact in three ways. Apparently, today’s Daily Mail reports that one in four GPs is thinking of retiring early because of the tax pension arrangements. In yesterday’s Herald, there was a story about somebody in the health service—not a GP, I think—who turned down promotion because if he had taken the promotion and gone into a new additional pension band, he would have been taxed so much that he would have earned less money in the promoted position, net, than he would earn if he stayed where he was. I find the use of the word “may” in that paragraph a wee bit unusual because the evidence is clear that these changes have had a detrimental impact on the availability of not just GPs but other high-level specialists in the health service.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We cannot quantify the impact, but we hear exactly the same stories, anecdotes and individual experiences as you do. It applies to other highly paid public servants as well as to doctors. Clearly, there are more doctors and they can flex their working hours in ways that many other people cannot, so the impact is more visible.

However, as we have discussed previously, there is a real risk to the workforce, particularly because one in three GPs is already over 50. We know that those people are making hard decisions. My personal view is that whatever your view of the merits of reducing the amount of pension saving that can be carried out tax free, the way in which these taxes come into effect means that they are unpredictable and people do not know they have incurred a significant tax liability until they already have. That has particular behavioural effects on those who are affected.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

This is quite urgent, because the first thing that you should do when you have such a problem is to stop the rot. If we do not stop the rot of these idiotic pension and tax changes—ill-thought-out pension and tax changes, as we told the UK Government seven years ago—we will continue to see a drain of people away from the health service, not because they do not want to do the job or to stay in the job but because they cannot afford to do so.

Do you also agree that the changes are not just affecting retention and recruitment? There is clear evidence of that. I remember that when the lifetime allowance came down, a number of doctors in Glasgow approached me through the British Medical Association; there was a 40 per cent reduction in the availability of GPs prepared to do out of hours because, as they put it, “What is the point of doing out of hours? It just means we will need to retire even earlier, when we get to our 50s, because of how these pension changes and tax changes operate.”

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The anecdotal evidence suggests that the changes definitely affect people’s decisions about not just retirement but extra work. The two common areas we hear about are out-of-hours work and waiting times initiative work; previously, people would have done additional lists in hospital to bring down waiting times, but they are less likely to do that now. Mark Ferris may want to add something.

10:45

Mark Ferris Audit Scotland
link

Just to clarify, we said “may” in paragraph 22 because we were looking at two elements: the pension arrangements that you refer to—both the annual allowance and the lifetime allowance; and the tax arrangements for GPs as employers. As the committee is aware, the UK Government has increased the pension contributions by six percentage points, from 14.9 per cent to 20.9 per cent. We understand that the UK Government and the Scottish Government are putting in funding to cover that, which is why we had that “may” in the paragraph, to differentiate between the pension arrangements and the tax arrangements for GPs as employers.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That funding will help, but it does not solve the problem.

Finally, do you agree that the net effect of this has been to increase costs to the NHS? There is a pattern that I think you can prove—for example, GPs who are retiring early may retire from a practice on the Friday and then they often reappear in the practice the following week, perhaps doing three days a week as a locum instead of doing five days a week as a full-time GP. Locums are paid nearly twice the GP daily rate and of course they do not contribute to the pension scheme; they left because the pension scheme had run out of tax allowance. We then end up spending twice as much on these locums as we were paying them the previous week before they retired because of the pension scheme.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is absolutely clear that the moves over the past few years to reduce the available amount of tax-free pension savings have had unintended consequences. Those consequences are most visible and probably most severe in the health service and among doctors and GPs because of their working arrangements. It is a classic example of the importance of joined-up policy making.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

To go back to the issue of part-time working—and excuse me if I have missed some of the background—do you have detailed analysis of the 25 to 49 age group, the number of women within that group and the number who are working part time because of childcare?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

One of the problems is that we do not have that detailed analysis. One of the messages of the report is that we do not have good enough information about the make-up of the primary care workforce and what people are doing. Our information is based on surveys. The information on that topic comes from the primary care workforce survey data and the survey was last carried out in 2017.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

What sort of survey is it and what sort of reliability would you place on that data?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Dharshi Santhakumaran is the expert on this.

Dharshi Santhakumaran Audit Scotland
link

It is a voluntary survey, so the response rates vary. The response rate in 2017 was about 87 per cent, which is quite high, but in 2015 it was lower, at about 50-something per cent. That makes it difficult to get reliable trend data from the survey. There are national estimates—exhibit 3 in the report sets out the whole-time equivalent numbers, which are based on estimates from the workforce survey. We expect the requirement for practices to submit data as part of the new GP contract to include the data that was previously collected through the survey. The data should therefore be more comprehensive because all practices will have to submit that data.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

Do you know how many people are working purely part time and do not have portfolio careers, doing other things in the health service?

Dharshi Santhakumaran Audit Scotland
link

We do not know that.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

Presumably, a part-time person is required to be the same standard as a full-time person, in the sense that you cannot get a part-time qualification.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The training and registration requirements are the same.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

Does the Scottish Government see that there is an opportunity to get more resource into the health service through persuading part-time people to step up their hours a bit? I would have thought that that would be the easiest way to get more resource.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It may be one possible response to the issue, but the available survey data—in terms of the numbers and the feedback gathered in surveys such as the General Medical Council survey of trainee doctors—suggests that the new generation of doctors are keener on working part time than older GPs have been. That could be for a number of reasons; it could be partly to do with more women training as doctors and also to do with doctors being generally more open to sharing parental responsibilities, which means that younger fathers are taking parental leave or working part time. Working as a GP has traditionally been a way of working as a doctor that lends itself to part-time working, so it attracts people for whom that is a benefit.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

Clearly, there is a gap in the data, as you have said. We comment—and you comment—on data. How do you run a national health service without data?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

As the committee knows, we have repeatedly made the recommendation about improving the data. We have repeatedly said that data about the primary and community care service is much less good than the data about the acute sector, partly because, in the past, GPs have generally not been employed directly by health boards—direct employment has been quite rare—and partly because the arrangements for collecting data have changed over time and have not been adequate.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

I would have said that data has been collected with difficulty or badly, but perhaps you do not want to comment on that. Thank you.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I have only a couple of questions, Auditor General, one of which follows on from Colin Beattie’s question about past recommendations. You and members know that you spend a lot of time producing reports and making recommendations, which are generally pretty well accepted by the agencies that you refer to, including the Government. We like to follow things up and try to find out whether they have been done. I refer to appendix 1. I do not know who responded to the recommendations and stated the progress that has been made against them, but I find the words a little vague and waffly. Are you satisfied about the progress that is being made against the recommendations that you set out in July 2017?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The words in appendix 1 are ours, and they reflect the fact that it is hard to see progress in some areas. We have been told that things are under way, but the output is not yet visible and clear to us. As we have said throughout this session and in the report, it is critical to get things right if we are going to achieve the Government’s vision for the health and care system in future. It feels that urgent, focused collection of that data and using it to plan is not optional now; rather, it has to happen soon.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

One of your recommendations was that NHS boards should

“Improve the accuracy of budgeting for agency spending.”

The progress report on that says:

“An analysis of financial performance report data for the NHS in Scotland in 2018 found that 12 of 14 boards overspent against their pay budget.”

Is that enough to give us the assurance that we need about more accurate budgeting for agency spending?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is clear that that is an area in which progress has not been good enough. If boards were not overspending their pay budgets, we would think that they had better budgeting and better financial control in place. That said, as Mr Neil’s question suggested, if there are vacancies that are hard to fill, boards sometimes do not have any option but to pay for agency and locum staff. Therefore, there is a vicious circle that can be broken only by starting at the back end and knowing how many staff need to be trained and in place. That is why that issue is so important.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

My second question is about the public engagement side of the whole service redesign for primary care. A couple of members have touched on that. Are you happy that sufficient progress is being made on that? I think that Claire Sweeney said that there is good progress—that can be seen in the exhibit on page 17 of the report. Have the public been with us at an early enough stage during the whole service redesign? Could that have been achieved sooner? Is there anything to be said for the variety of methods that the public have to use to engage with GP practices across Scotland? The methods are very different. Sometimes people can phone and make advance appointments; sometimes they have to phone at a particular time; sometimes they can make appointments online; and sometimes they can turn up in person. Do we need to make the approach a bit more consistent to be able to drive a national message about getting public engagement in that type of service?

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

We thought quite long and hard about where the responsibility might lie for improving engagement with the public. In truth, I think that it sits in various places. There is something to be said about national engagement on some of the issues. We know—we said this in paragraph 33 of the report—that three quarters of people who were surveyed were likely to accept an appointment with somebody who was not a GP if they understood more about their role. That is quite a powerful message, and the message is that the public are open to that. We know that, where that happens, there is often good feedback about how it works for the public. The question has to be: how do we help the public to understand what the options might be?

I would go a bit further than that. There is something interesting about how the integration authorities, the Scottish Government and NHS boards work with local communities to understand what their needs are and how they might best be met. There are doubtless some things at the national level, but there is an important message about engagement with local communities and what works for them. What works in an island board would be very different from what people need to have in place in the central belt, for example. The conversation about that needs to happen more often.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

We know that the Scottish Government is “developing its approach”. Do you have any idea about when we will see the details of what the thinking is?

Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland
link

No. We have had an interest in that for quite a while. We recently published some work on community empowerment, which talked about the need to engage with communities in a deeper and better way across the public sector. We will want to keep following up the progress on that, but we know that there is a lot more to do in respect of the health and care system.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Auditor General, I was very interested in data in the UK Foundation Programme’s “Career Destinations Report 2017”, which I shared with you a few months ago. That report covered where doctors go on to work once they have completed their training. As you will remember, some of the figures for Scotland are quite startling. Let me remind you and the committee of them.

In 2017, across the UK, an average of 5.4 per cent of doctors completed their training in the UK and then left the country. So the Government invested money in training them and then lost them to other countries. In Scotland, the rate was around double that, at 10.5 per cent.

I have had a look at the report for 2018—I do not know whether you have had a chance to look at it, as well. The figures have shot up again and are really quite stark. The percentage of foundation year 2 doctors who left Scotland after their training was 17.5 per cent. That is once the Government had paid fully for their training. They were qualified, and then they left the country. That is nearly one in five doctors. That is broken down per medical school. In Aberdeen, the figure shot up to 20 per cent from 10 per cent the year before. In Edinburgh, the figure was 13 per cent in 2017, and it shot up to 21 per cent—that is more than one in five. The figure for the University of Glasgow medical school went from 14 per cent to 18 per cent.

Can we get hold of similar data for GPs? As you know, I am extremely worried by those trends. The taxpayer is putting all that investment into training doctors, who, it seems to me from UK data that reflect Scotland, are leaving the country at an increasing rate. Can we get that data for GPs, or is the Scottish Government simply not collecting and publishing that because it is so shocking for Scotland?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The work that I referred to earlier that NHS Education for Scotland is doing to pull together all the information about medical training and the medical workforce on to a single platform should be able to provide that sort of data in future. We are not there yet, but NHS Education for Scotland should be able to break the information down between the different training specialties and the different destinations for people.

I agree that the numbers of doctors who leave after training are eyebrow raising. In the report, we refer to the Scottish graduate entry medicine programme, which is specifically intended to train doctors who already have a degree in another subject in primary care. It is associated with a bursary and a requirement for doctors to repay that bursary if they do not continue to work in Scotland for a period after they qualify.

There are questions for the Government about its thinking on training and support for medical students, and it would be appropriate for the committee to ask the Government and perhaps NHS Education for Scotland for their views on that, as well.

As far as I am aware, we do not have the figures for GP training in Scotland.

Dharshi Santhakumaran Audit Scotland
link

We do not currently, but the data platform has access to a new database called UKMED—the UK medical education database—which should provide a lot more detailed information to follow doctors through their training and on to whatever they go on to after that.

The foundation programme has some information about the percentage who are appointed to GP training following their FY2 year. I think that I am right in saying that there was a bit more variation in the percentage who were appointed to GP training in the UK compared with doctors as a whole.

11:00

On the Scottish medical schools, there was quite a wide variation in respect of people from Edinburgh, for example, who went on to be appointed to GP training as opposed to people from Aberdeen. I think that the message was not as clear or as stark for those who went on to GP training, but we will need to look at what comes out of the data platform to see that in more detail.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

The key thing that shocks me is the amount of investment that we are putting into training doctors who are leaving the country at an increasingly alarming rate.

I go back to the point about data. If the UK foundation programme and the UK NHS can collect that data, why on earth can we in Scotland not collect similar data that give us an impression of what is happening, how we spend public money, and the return that we get on our investment?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is the central question that is raised in the report and the previous report on workforce planning. That is a huge amount of the investment of public money and it is central to the NHS being able to meet the needs of Scotland’s people in future. We need to know what is happening to the doctors whom we train.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I have a final point on GPs. You heard the figures that I gave. From the evidence that your team has gathered and that you have seen, do you think that the attrition rate for GPs is as high as that for FY2s, or do you think that GPs are more likely to stay in Scotland, as they have chosen that career and that it is maybe a more home-based career, than hospital doctors, who can go over to Sydney, are?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We cannot give you a clear answer on that. My hunch is that it will be more extreme for acute doctors for exactly the reasons that you have just outlined. We know that many doctors are attracted to general practice because it is more flexible for their personal lives and because they are committed to serving a practice that is full of patients over a longer period of time. However, we do not have the numbers to give you that assurance either way at the moment.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Okay. Thank you. Do members have any further questions?

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

One thing has not really been touched on. I refer to exhibit 6, on page 22 of the report. It states:

“Responsibility for planning the primary care workforce is fragmented.”

How can that issue be addressed? Is the Scottish Government providing any leadership and co-ordination on that? It is clear that fragmentation is not good. How is that impacting?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We can finish on good news, which is always nice. In paragraph 45, we said:

“The Scottish Government intends to create a revised structure”

that brings those responsibilities together and that it expects to have that in place by November 2019. Up until now, I am sure that it has made pulling the planning together and doing it well more difficult. There is now a commitment to bring the responsibilities together.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

As there are no further questions for the Auditor General and her team, I thank them very much for their evidence. I now close the public session of the meeting.

11:03 Meeting continued in private until 11:24.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 130
  3. 09:45 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 113

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.