Item 2 is on the section 23 report, “Scotland’s colleges 2019”. I welcome our witnesses from the Scottish Funding Council to the meeting: Karen Watt, chief executive; Martin Fairbairn, chief operating officer and secretary to the council; and Lorna MacDonald, director of finance. I invite Karen Watt to make a brief opening statement.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Scotland’s colleges 2019”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Karen Watt Scottish Funding Council 40
- Jenny Marra Lab 17
- Colin Beattie SNP 15
- Lorna MacDonald Scottish Funding Council 14
- Martin Fairbairn Scottish Funding Council 12
- Anas Sarwar Lab 10
- Bill Bowman Con 8
- Willie Coffey SNP 6
- Liam Kerr Con 5
- Alex Neil SNP 3
The record
130 contributionsThank you for the opportunity to discuss the Auditor General for Scotland’s report, “Scotland’s colleges 2019”. I know that time is tight, so I will just make three opening comments.
First, as you will see from my letter to the committee, the Scottish Funding Council has accepted all the recommendations in the report and we have already acted on many of them. We are working closely with the college sector and the Scottish Government to deliver the recommendations in a way that enables us to keep an eye on students and learning outcomes as well as financial viability.
Secondly, overall, the report shows that there has been a small improvement in the underlying financial position of Scotland’s 20 incorporated colleges. However, the report also shows that colleges are facing a fairly tight financial environment. Below that sector-wide picture, there is a lot of variation in how individual colleges are performing; some are more challenged than others. Our focus is very firmly on the question of how colleges plan for their activities and make their cost base as viable and sustainable as possible.
Thirdly, despite all the pressures that colleges are facing, they are generally performing well and continuing to deliver against our shared targets and outcomes. Not only has the college sector exceeded the learning activity targets that we have set but 95 per cent of the students coming out of the colleges are going on to work, training and further study within three to six months of qualifying. Undoubtedly, there are challenges; there is also much to celebrate.
Thank you very much indeed. Colin Beattie will open questioning for the committee.
link
When arm’s-length foundations were originally set up, it was accepted that a fair proportion of the money that went to them was already allocated to projects and would be disbursed in that way. However, for some colleges at least, a reasonable proportion of the funding that came from external sources came in through those foundations. It seems that that income has reduced substantially for most if not all colleges. What is the reason for that? Are you aware of the background to that?
It might be easier to start with a general outline of the other income that colleges have access to and how they can deal with it. The report clearly sets out that there has been an increased dependency on Scottish Funding Council money. The other main sources of funding, along with ALFs, are tuition fees, education contracts, catering and other operations. There are European funds as well.
The issue of where colleges get additional income from is not just about the additional income; it is about how much surplus is generated for the college over time.
link
Not all the income that colleges make goes into ALFs.
No, that is absolutely right. If colleges generate a significant surplus, we would expect that to go into ALFs. However, we expect colleges to make enough to break even and they can use the surplus they generate for other activities.
In general, colleges are under pressure and, in some regional economies, there are slightly fewer opportunities for colleges to open up other activities that can generate income. Some of the things that we are doing, such as the flexible workforce development fund, will enable them to engage with employers, which may generate additional income because they will get more contracts for work.
However, ALFs are independent—they are arm’s length. A college needs to apply to an ALF to receive any funds. By and large, those have been for longer-term capital projects. The amount of money in ALFs is reducing as that money is being spent on the kind of things that colleges are applying to them for.
link
But we are talking about colleges being able to generate external income, which, by the nature of that income, would go into an ALF and be disbursed later to the college at an appropriate time, which means that they are generating a commercial profit. That aspect of their business seems to be reducing—it seems to be going away. What is the reason for that? Are the colleges no longer competitive? Are they no longer focused on that aspect?
It is a general range of other pressures. By and large—I think that this is partly what the Audit Scotland report recommendations are saying—the underlying operating position is still fairly healthy. We have seen that position improve over time. However, the ability to generate significant surplus from those other activities has been reduced, for a range of reasons. Increasingly, it is about the opportunities in regional areas and how long it takes to generate some of that additional income from contracts with employers. Lorna MacDonald may want to add to that.
The surplus that is generated from such activity would be used to address some of the pressures that colleges are facing. If there was any surplus from commercial activity at the end of the financial year, that is when it would be transferred into the ALF. Otherwise, it would be used for the operations of the college.
link
Am I interpreting this correctly? You are saying that because of the financial pressures on colleges, money that would normally be parked in an ALF until there is a particular project or purpose to spend it on is going straight into meeting operational needs, so it is not going to the ALF at all.
Yes.
link
Is there a reduced ability to generate income, or is it simply that the income is no longer visible to us because it is going straight into the operation of the college?
It is much more about generating income and sending it back into the business, rather than into an ALF.
We are looking at this territory. The intelligence is that the market for surplus-generating activity, which is in the consultancy-type field, is increasingly competitive. The margins on that activity are also reducing, so it is a combination of these things. The margin on such activity is much less than it was—it was always narrow anyway—and there are the other aspects that Karen Watt and Lorna MacDonald touched on.
link
So when you talk about the market being more competitive, you are talking about it being competitive on pricing.
Yes.
link
It is not about the product that colleges are offering.
No, it is about the price.
link
The Auditor General has told the committee that she wants the SFC to take clear account of the income-generation issue
“as it looks at the long-term forecast for individual colleges and the sector as a whole.”—Official Report, Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee, 13 June 2019; c 7.
What steps are you taking to follow that suggestion?
When we look at the financial situation, we quickly home in on two particular indicators. One is on underlying sustainability and financial health and the cash position. We have also put out strengthened guidance on the quality of not just the colleges’ financial projections but their mitigating plans. We have taken Audit Scotland’s recommendation very seriously in terms of strengthening that guidance.
We are also doing more checking and following up. We are doing much more testing of the assumptions underpinning those future plans and we are working alongside colleges to get greater assurance that their plans will bear fruit and bring colleges into a sustainable position. We are doing a lot more checking, we are giving much stronger guidance about the assumptions that we expect them to make, and we are doing more testing. We are working alongside boards and senior teams to make sure that they understand the financial position and that they are able to keep an eye on this situation in the way that you would expect.
We are doing a lot of work with a range of bodies in the sector such as the College Development Network to help governing bodies to ask the right questions and to make sure that the assumptions underpinning those future plans work, because this is also about leadership and governance in the college sector.
link
On a different point, capital investment featured strongly in the Auditor General’s report. Has the £27 million of capital funding that was allocated to address the high-priority repairs been spent? Has all the work been done?
That figure is the amount that was set aside. I think that about £125,000 had not been spent by the end of July but it had either been spent or was committed by the end of July.
link
Okay. There is a risk related to the reduction in capital expenditure. How will that impact on colleges, given that a fairly high proportion are still high risk? How is it impacting on how colleges can efficiently deliver their services?
Martin Fairbairn can answer that question.
There is no doubt that the level of backlog maintenance represents financial and operational challenges. We have been particularly interested in how colleges are using the money that has been provided so far specifically in relation to backlog, but also on any other resources and how they have prioritised that.
Colleges have definitely been prioritising spending on those areas where there might otherwise have been an impact on curriculum delivery. The challenge is that, as a result of that backlog and the conditions that the survey identified, there has not been a material impact on learner delivery in classrooms. We have not seen to any huge extent activities having to be mothballed followed by provision not being delivered. That does not take away from the fact that some of the most intense areas need to be addressed, as has been identified in the Auditor General’s report.
link
You talk about receiving intelligence. How up to date is your intelligence on what the status is?
Most recently, it has been on the back of the returns that we have received from colleges over the past six months on how the colleges have used the £28 million or thereabouts that was allocated for the first tranche of backlog maintenance, so the intelligence is very up to date.
link
So, based on your intelligence at this point, you are satisfied that the college estate is a safe learning environment.
We have nothing to indicate that it is not—that is correct.
link
What timescale has the SFC, along with the Scottish Government and the Scottish Futures Trust, set for the introduction of the new revenue funding model for future investment in the college estate?
Are you referring to what is called the mutual investment model?
link
Yes.
That model was recently announced in the programme for government. I do not have intelligence on the timeframe for its introduction. I know that in a recent announcement about the combination of the schools for the future programme and the investment in Halbeath campus at Dunfermline, the Scottish Government announced that, for Halbeath campus, which is one of the most critical campuses, a traditional capital grant approach will be used. That is very welcome because it allows us at least to make a start in one of the most critical areas.
It will probably take some months yet for the full detail of the mutual investment model to be worked out and that development will play a key part in influencing the infrastructure commission’s work. I understand that the commission is producing a report around the end of this calendar year, so I would expect there to be more information then. If you want more detail on the model, I suggest asking the Scottish Futures Trust, because we are not the experts in how the MIM is being developed.
09:15
link
So, at this point, you are not heavily engaged in that development and you do not know a lot more than what has been made public.
We have been informed by the Scottish Futures Trust through discussion as the MIM idea has been developed, but either the Scottish Futures Trust or the Scottish Government would probably be a better source for how it will be rolled out.
I want to ask about something that I hope is a positive action. In the past, we took evidence and commented on the fact that certain colleges were interpreting your accounting direction in their own way, shall we say, and that not always the same assumptions were put into the financial forecasts. You say in your submission that you are now asking colleges to submit their draft accounts and forecast calculations for you to review. How many sets of financials and calculations do you have to look at? Do you have the resources to do that? How is it going?
We have made that commitment, and we will be looking at that very strongly. We do have the resources. We have a team of financial experts who look at that on a regular basis, but in this particular situation we will be looking forensically at the way those are put together.
Lorna MacDonald may want to say something about our current approach and the amount of resource that we are putting into that.
We are geared up for that, and we are very committed to getting consistent reporting across the sector. It is such an important indicator that consistency is required—indeed, it is absolutely essential that the colleges understand their own underlying positions. We will be engaged in that activity over the coming months, and the accounts will be finalised or at least signed off normally in December. We are ready for that.
How many sets of financials do you have to look at?
Across the sector and the incorporated colleges, we will be looking at 20 sets of accounts.
Plus the forecasts?
Plus the forecasts, yes, but the underlying position is that we look at the statutory accounts.
But you have not started that with the colleges yet.
They will be working on their statutory accounts at the moment. We will take forward that activity when they have their final drafts.
Do you have any—I will not say “informal”—on-going discussion with them to ensure that they are going in the right direction, rather than finding things—
Yes. That work goes on throughout the year, using the returns that they submit. There should not be any real surprises when we get to this stage.
Did you meet any resistance from the colleges to the request that they submit their draft accounts?
No—no resistance at all. I think that we are all collectively working on this because we all collectively understand the high priority of understanding the position.
Are there any particular colleges that you expect you may have to direct to change something?
That is always possible, and that is the purpose of our checking the drafts. If that is the case, we will do that at that time, and we will work with the external auditors in that process.
You have not dealt with any troublesome colleges.
No.
We have not come to that point. It is a fair challenge, because the relationship with each of the colleges has been very positive. They have responded well, and we have put out more guidance. It is slightly disappointing that some of the calculations that we were getting were still wrong. It is relatively complex to make all the various adjustments, but we will be spending a lot of time on making sure that the underlying assumptions are calculated correctly and in advance of sign-off.
Rather than talk about inputs, I am keen to talk about outputs. In Scotland we face a number of critical skills shortages. The construction industry is short of about 12,000 people with the right skills, the information technology sector is constantly grossly short of the skills that we require, and many other sectors are as well. How focused are the Funding Council and the colleges on playing their part in dealing with those critical skills shortages, which are holding back growth in the Scottish economy?
The first thing that I have done, since taking up my position, has been to work very closely with Skills Development Scotland on how we can work together to look at regional skills needs. We can look at the national picture but, increasingly, we need to look at how the colleges play into regional economics.
The colleges are becoming much more involved in regional skills planning. They are around more tables in terms of that sort of planning. However, by and large, employers’ ability to understand what they need and to work closely with the colleges on how their curriculums develop and how they anticipate things is still work in progress. Colleges are incredibly well placed to respond very quickly to particular needs, particularly from small and medium-sized enterprises—they are plugged in—and we are helping them by enabling funds such as the flexible workforce development funds to meet the needs that are coming from the local economies.
In places such as Dundee, where Dundee and Angus College is working with Michelin, we see those connections already being made, through the plans that are developing and the engagement with the college on the upskilling and reskilling needs of the local economy. We are seeing more of that.
With all due respect, that is the kind of answer that we were getting 10 years ago, when I was convening the Enterprise and Culture Committee. We have still not cracked the issue of the skills shortages.
It seems to me that a much more urgent approach needs to be taken, because these skills shortages exist now. I accept that you need always to be looking for ways to improve co-ordination between Government agencies and all that sort of stuff, but we have been doing that as long as the Parliament has been here and the fact is that skills shortages are worse than they were 20 years ago. What more needs to be done?
A number of years ago, long before this place was established, there was a dire shortage of school teachers. The then Government announced a crash programme of teacher training and took in substantially more people, and, over a three or four-year period, we broke the back of the teacher shortage. Do we not need to do something much more urgent about the dire skills shortages that we are facing?
We are short of 5,000 long-distance lorry drivers. Those jobs are well paid—the starting rate for a long-distance lorry driver is about £38,000 a year. We also have a dire shortage of train drivers. Those jobs require fairly basic skills and are well paid, yet all the agencies are not delivering.
To be fair, there are a lot of examples of colleges having responded immediately to the shortages that are obvious in some areas. I see colleges increasingly getting involved in courses—for example, apprenticeship schemes—that are quite specific to the needs that are emerging. Apprenticeship programmes are being directed at particular skills areas. Colleges, are well placed to do that quite quickly.
You are asking us to solve something that, as you rightly say, has taken a long time to solve and for which the plans have been in place for a number of years. The Government’s development of a skills action plan and the way in which apprenticeships are developing, which enables colleges to respond to things quickly, should reduce the gap between what is needed and the provision.
I can say no more than that. You are right. It is for the Funding Council to get into a different relationship with Skills Development Scotland, which will enable us to have better conversations about what is needed in a particular region. In the south of Scotland, for example, where a new enterprise agency is in play, the colleges are not only closely involved in planning what is needed for the south of Scotland but are starting to develop curricula and schemes that will change the nature of the provision.
None of this happens quickly, but, when all of those things come together, we can close some of the gaps.
I agree with that. It is all good stuff, but I think we have an emergency. If we are really going to grow the economy in the period ahead, we need to be doing something at a national level and we need to be doing it urgently, in a way that is much more focused on the dire skills shortages that are holding back growth, but I do not see that. I realise that the colleges have a part to play, but somebody has to drive that change across the board.
I will continue Alex Neil’s vein of questioning. Last week, the committee took evidence from the Scottish Government, which is planning the new social security delivery programme for Scotland. A lot of that is heavily based on IT, and the head of digital for the Government or the head of IT for the project said that, in Scotland, in particular, we have a worse problem with IT skills than there is in the rest of the United Kingdom. You addressed Alex Neil’s point on a regional basis, but I think that we have a specific shortage in Scotland, not just in the public sector but in the private sector as well.
I want to drill down specifically. You mentioned the example of Dundee and the Michelin workforce, but do colleges across Scotland have the capacity to take workers who have been made redundant or who are seeking to upskill and move into other areas when the target for full-time equivalent students remains so high? It is currently 116,000. We can argue the merits of that and of young people being in full-time education, but, on a practical level, because of that target, do colleges have the capacity to take the kind of people you are talking about and upskill them?
There is a clear tension between such targets and the flexibility that colleges may need in the long term. Some of that flexibility has been enabled by, for example, the policy shift away from the priority being 16 to 24-year-olds. The ability to move and shift below the surface of such targets has made a difference in enabling more mature and adult learners to come back to college. There is some flex in that.
I go back to apprenticeships. There are opportunities for colleges to bring a broader sweep of people in through the apprenticeship family, for which colleges currently have access to funding through Skills Development Scotland. You are right. The challenge is to change the nature of some of the provision from investment in 16 to 24-year-olds into the ability to flex into more upskilling and reskilling. I would say that that is still a challenge. It is about balance, but that is where I think the Funding Council will need to go over time. How do we get a funding model that enables colleges to shift their provision as required, depending on how the economy is shifting and changing? Embedding digital skills in every curriculum—not just having information and communications technology as a particular course, but bedding that into the suite of provisions so that we enable people to come back to college and have those lifelong skills—is part of the curriculum development.
You are right to say that there is a definite tension between the targets and the ability to flex. However, I think that the position is already shifting.
Do you think the targets will shift?
Below the targets, there is already some shift in how we have talked about 16 to 24-year-olds and the ability to bring in adult learners. We will see—
What do you mean by a shift below the targets? If the Government’s target remains static at, I believe, 116,000, how can there be any shift below it?
I simply meant that the category of people that we can target within that number has shifted. You are right. I am saying that there is a challenge in having volume targets of that nature. The issue is how we can quickly shift into that sort of upskilling and reskilling. It is about course design as well.
For how many years has the target been 116,000?
Since—I am looking to my colleagues—2012.
Since 2012-ish.
That rings true to me. I remember having a debate about it with Mike Russell in the chamber. That would have been seven years ago.
There has been quite a lot of demographic change since then. What I hear from the colleges is they are putting a lot of resource into desperately chasing 16 to 24-year-old full-time students. Schools are keeping them on at an increasing rate, and I am told that the universities are lowering the entry requirements for many university courses that those students might be eligible for. Some of them are staying at school and some are going off to university, and the colleges are using all their resource to get them in their doors when there are all these firms that need upskilling.
Is it time for the Government to look at the target? It is a seven-year-old target that has not shifted at all.
09:30
It may be helpful for the committee to know that there is the 116,000 FTE target but no target for full-time students. At the time of the recession, in 2012-ish, the policy focus was correctly on younger and full-time students, but a target was never set for full-time students. Within that 116,000 full-time equivalent target, as a system—including as individual colleges—we can look to increase the amount of provision that is for older learners and for learners who are in work. That could include working with companies’ workforces.
Excuse me, Mr Fairbairn. My direct question is whether we can have a static target such as that, without revision, when we are seeing such demographic change in our communities. Is that realistic, and is it fair to the colleges?
It is the right question at this point in time. The conversations that we are having with the Government are about the nature of those shifts and changes. For example, on widening access, it is absolutely the case that there is a demographic shift towards fewer young people going to college, and we know that, even by 2023, that population of 16 to 24-year-olds will have declined by about 10 per cent.
When some of the targets were set, we would not have known—particularly in the context of widening access—that universities were going to be relatively successful in widening their offer to students, who now have broader pathways and different choices. You are quite right, convener: colleges are now just one of a number of choices that people are making. It is a tension in the system, undoubtedly.
That is partly why the Funding Council is now thinking quite a lot about whether it is wise to have targets for each sector in our tertiary education system or whether we need to look at the system as a whole. On the issue of widening access, for example, colleges are being challenged much more around how they get footfall when we have universities in that same space.
I think there is a need to step back and look at the whole system rather than have specific targets that pick up particular things for particular parts of it. We would encourage a look at those targets in the round, now that each bit of the system is shifting and changing.
That is very useful. Thank you very much.
Thank you very much, convener, and good morning to the panel.
I will ask about Ayrshire College. The Auditor General’s report shows us that one of the significant risks that the college still faces is the private finance initiative millstone around its neck, of about £1.4 million a year. Can you explain to me why Ayrshire College is unique among the colleges in still having a PFI obligation? Other colleges’ PFIs—West Lothian College’s was one—were paid off by the Funding Council in previous years.
As you know, every college made decisions about how to balance the cost of provision with the quality that they want for the student learning environment.
Specifically on Ayrshire College, the £1.4 million represents about 3 per cent of its total income. When we have talked to the college, in particular in recent years, it has not asked us to buy out its PFI contract, although it has sought some support in its sustainability plan, so we have helped it with its annual payments.
Other elements of income have come in to offset those payments The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills enabled the college to retain some of the net proceeds from disposal of the former Kilmarnock College campus.
At this point in time, our judgment is that the PFI is affordable. That is not a value judgment on PFI. It is simply the case, when we look at the whole financial position of Ayrshire College, that some of the other increased costs that have come through have been similar to what has happened in other colleges. That has been part of the discussion with Ayrshire College about its sustainability plan. How will it bring those other costs into scope? We discussed financial planning and mitigation. Our judgment, given that the £1.4 million is 3 per cent of its total income and the college is managing that within its current envelope, is that other costs in its business, when we strip out everything else, are the issue. We are talking to the college about that.
I will pick up very briefly on the West Lothian College issue—which was long before my time. I understand that the amount of its income that was going towards PFI costs was very much more significant—about 20 per cent. The judgment that was made at that time, given all the other factors, was that that cost was a significant burden and could, therefore, be addressed. Also, there was a willing contractor in that situation. The situation with Ayrshire College is different—we have had assurances from the college that it is managing the costs.
Okay. You said the amount is “affordable”, but we know that the college had to introduce a voluntary severance scheme, which has saved an almost equivalent amount to the recurring annual amount that is needed to pay the PFI costs. It is hard to escape the conclusion that the college brought in the voluntary redundancy scheme to pay off their staff for that reason. If that is what you mean by “affordable”, I think that it would particularly upset a number of staff and former employees of Ayrshire College. The affordability exists only because the college has saved pay through the VR scheme. How can that be a sustainable and sensible policy for the SFC to introduce?
I would separate affordability and sustainability. In most colleges the average staff base represents about 65 per cent of costs. Our sense is that other costs and aspects of income and expenditure are issues for Ayrshire College, and that they are similar to trends and patterns around staff and other costs that other colleges are facing. Our judgment is that the PFI cost is not the significant issue that it faces.
Okay. The Funding Council has provided, I think, £700,000 a year for two years to help out, but the remaining PFI obligation after that will still be more than £4 million, which the college will have to find. Is there any commitment from the Funding Council to assist the college in meeting that obligation in the remaining four years of that PFI? If not, the college might face another VR scheme.
We are working very closely with Ayrshire College. Let us see how its new plan comes in to us. We will always run alongside colleges to look at their overall situation. At this point in time, we are running very closely alongside the college, as we are with others. We will keep the matter under constant review.
Okay. My last question is about harmonisation costs in the mergers of several years ago. My understanding from previous discussions in the committee is that some colleges received harmonisation funding from the Funding Council and some did not. Ayrshire College did not. Do the colleges that received harmonisation assistance at that time no longer receive it, or is it built into their year-on-year settlements? I think that we were told that the payments were a one-off. Can you therefore clarify for the committee—finally, I hope—that the harmonisation assistance that was provided by the Funding Council to some colleges was a one-off and it is not recurring?
My understanding is that there are two distinct matters. There was the merger programme, and there was a range of different salaries and pay conditions that had to be harmonised, so colleges did that. They came together and looked at how best they could merge.
Some did, but others received funding from the Funding Council.
At the time, decisions were made about the best way to make the mergers happen. Clearly, now we have harmonisation at national level through national bargaining. That has been a separate three-year programme costing £99 million. My understanding is that the merger programme has been done and we are not funding any element of it. I am looking to both my colleagues on that.
At the time of the mergers, of the nine that took place in 2013 and 2014, only one merger—that for Scotland’s Rural College—was given funding for harmonisation. That was a very special thing that was to do with pensions, and was a one-off transitional arrangement. That was the only piece of additional funding in terms of costs of harmonisation. Additional funding was provided in merger situations in which there was associated restructuring, but not for harmonisation. When colleges harmonised, the cost of that was met from within the new merged entity, apart from in the case of SRUC.
Okay. Thank you for that.
I will pick up on that matter. My understanding is that some colleges had the foresight during the merger process to harmonise at that point. When harmonisation was required across the country, other colleges that had not had such foresight in planning at the time of the merger process were given money. Mr Coffey and I understand that Ayrshire College and Dundee and Angus College had done the harmonisation as part of the merger process, so they were financially penalised because they did not receive harmonisation money when it was required elsewhere in the country. I know that Karen Watt is new in post. Would you be willing to meet both colleges to discuss that specific issue specifically? Willie Coffey and I feel that our colleges and constituents have been penalised by the process.
I would be very happy to do that; let us have that conversation.
I make the point that for our funding model, we are, at the minute, looking at national bargaining and will take it into account. When national bargaining is completed, we will decide what funding model we need in order to deliver the volume of activity that is needed in particular colleges. Regional skills needs will also be part of that conversation—it is not just about harmonisation. We would also like to have a conversation about how our funding model will develop over the next few years.
Okay. Thank you for that commitment.
I have a couple of questions about the diversity of the boards and leadership of colleges. The Auditor General’s report indicates that 43 per cent of college board members are women. What work has been done by the SFC to achieve gender balance on boards? I will ask about principals separately.
We take gender issues and the gender balance on boards very seriously. As Anas Sarwar knows, there are a range of challenges in broader society in ensuring that we get women involved in public life and on boards. On gender, we are doing a lot, particularly through funding to help to generate a broader range of people coming forward. Funding from Advance HE is helping boards to reach out in various ways to make sure that they include proper representation.
09:45
College boards also include a number of staff and student representatives who are elected members. That means that the boards’ ability to manage the balance on them is, in a way, slightly challenging, because who those people are is outside boards’ control. A lot is being done to balance gender as well as possible, but there is always more that can be done in that regard.
Do you want to add something, Lorna?
I do not want to add anything on that, but in terms of senior management teams and principals in the sector, the position at the end of October was relatively balanced, at 46 per cent male and 54 per cent female.
Is that figure for principals of the colleges?
Yes.
What proportion of boards are from ethnic minority backgrounds?
I do not have that figure to hand. Could I write to you with that figure and the plan?
Is that something that you monitor and record?
It is. I have the figure and can get it, and I can write to you about the actions that are in train on that.
What proportion of principals are from ethnic minority backgrounds?
Again, I apologise because I do not have that figure to hand.
I had analysis done by the Scottish Parliament information centre that showed that not a single college or university principal in Scotland is from a diverse ethnic minority background. We are, rightly, prioritising gender-balanced boards: surely a similar amount of interaction and interest should apply at leadership level in terms of ethnic minority representation. I had thought that that would be at the front of your mind, rather than your needing to look into the matter and come back to us. If you can do that, that would be great.
That is a very fair challenge. In the past fortnight we met the Scottish Human Rights Commission. We looked across the piece at what the Funding Council could do in respect of closer alignment on public duties. We are exploring with the commission whether there could be a memorandum on closer working. We are very clear that we have responsibilities and duties, and we want to make sure that we work as closely as possible. A good and fruitful set of conversations has opened up on ensuring that we are absolutely on top of public duties, as we should be.
Can you tell us a bit about the gender balance and ethnic minority balance among the senior leadership and staff of the SFC?
I think that I might have brought greater gender balance to the senior team in the Funding Council.
Which is very welcome.
The point is well made. The Funding Council does not, I find, have a huge amount of turnover. When we recruit, the challenge is to ask whether we are reaching out and doing the right things through advertising and using networks. We have appointed a person to help us to make sure in-house that we are doing as much as we can when we have such opportunities—when there is turnover and we need to advertise. It is a very good challenge.
Can you tell us about ethnic minority representation within the SFC?
Ethnic minority representation at this point in time is under 2 per cent of our workforce. We are not meeting our national targets on that at the moment.
Thank you.
link
I have several wrap-up questions based on what we heard earlier. First, I want to go back to the start and to Colin Beattie’s questions about finances. I think that Karen Watt said that there was an increasing dependence on Scottish Government finances.
Last year, income in the sector was £711 million, which was a reduction on the previous year. Expenditure was £741 million, which was an increase on the previous year. I think that the revenue funding increased in real terms, but that was allocated to the staff harmonisation. Given all those premises, are college finances sustainable?
I would say yes, but I think that we need to see the plans that will come in at the end of this month and how our strengthened guidance has helped colleges not just to give us their plans but to have a very detailed set that elevates the assumptions that they are working on and their mitigating strategies. At this point in time my answer is yes, but I would like to see what those plans are telling us.
When the things that are beyond a college’s immediate control are stripped out and we look at the underlying operating position—so looking at net depreciation and other things and adjusting for technical accounting factors—I think that the underlying surplus position has improved. We have seen it go from £300,000 up to £3.1 million. I would still like to see how those calculations are being made, and I would still like us to be running very closely to some of that planning.
The answer is yes, but the situation is not without challenge. The next suite of strengthened plans will help us to give a much better picture not just for the immediate period, but into that critical three to five-year period.
link
Forgive me if I have missed something in what you have been saying. Bill Bowman asked about financial forecasting, and I think that I am right in saying that 17 of the colleges are projecting deficits over the next five years. I think that I am also right in saying that only two colleges have identified specific actions that will address those deficits. If that is right, why have the colleges not all done it? Is that acceptable?
We would like to see colleges doing a lot better on financial planning. As you know, we operate a system that looks at the level of engagement that we need to have with each individual college. We are actively engaged with colleges that are in particular difficulties, but by and large we need to very strongly keep an eye on that picture.
Lorna, do you want to come in on this?
Mr Kerr is absolutely right. The audit report mentioned 12 colleges that were projecting deficits at the time of the audit field work being carried out; that is very much the picture that is reflected in the Audit Scotland report. The Funding Council engaged with the colleges that were projecting immediate deficits to make sure that they had mitigating actions in place. The situation has moved on from the picture that is presented in the Audit Scotland report, but that is just a matter of timing.
link
I understand.
Finally, both Alex Neil and the convener asked about the outputs and the ability to deliver the various targets in relation to the workforce. You said that you were looking at the funding model, and that is a process that will take place in the future. Do the financial pressures that face the colleges present a risk to their ability to deliver the objectives of the Scottish Government and the Funding Council, and indeed the objectives that were identified by Alex Neil and the convener?
No—there will always be challenges, but I simply meant the end of national bargaining and how we have funded that over the past two or three years. We need to look at the model going forward. By and large, colleges are performing well and they are meeting their activity targets. Those targets are not without pressures, as we have discussed, but we are not changing the funding model because we think that the colleges will not meet the targets. It is more about taking a more rational approach to how we fund activity in particular areas.
We will always keep our eye on those targets and the outcomes that we are seeking to achieve—the attainment levels and the success rates. That, along with the work that we are doing on a range of fronts on quality assessment with Education Scotland, is utterly in the vein of making sure that the targets are met and that the levels of success and attainment are not just maintained but raised in some areas. The issue about the funding model is much more about taking a more rational approach to how we fund activity in future.
link
Perhaps I can put the question slightly differently. Do the current financial pressures present a risk to the outcomes that we all want to see?
The colleges are managing well. Through all the work on how they project forward, we are aiming to get a better sense of where the pressures lie and, where there is any risk to a target or to attainment levels, to work alongside the college to ensure that it is paying attention to that. At this point, I would say that the colleges are on track to meet the targets as we expect them to, but that is not without challenge or pressure.
link
I understand.
The European social fund projects will come to an end in 2022. My understanding is that that is nothing to do with Brexit; the money was coming to an end anyway. Is that correct?
With regard to some of the social funds, yes, that is absolutely right. On Scotland’s workforce planning funds, that is right.
Is that money allocated directly from the European social fund or from the Scottish Government?
We pay out programmes from the European social fund. Lorna, can you pick up on how the social fund works?
Yes. It is match, or contribution, funding, so there is an element from the Funding Council budget as well as European funds.
My understanding is that the funding will end in 2022, which will have quite a big impact on colleges. In Dundee and Angus College, that will be the equivalent of the loss of 250 full-time places. Do you have plans to replace that funding for colleges?
You are right. There is a risk around whether there will be replacement funding and what kind of programmes will be put in place. There is a commitment to work on the funding on developing Scotland’s workforce until 2022-23.
There will be different impacts in different areas. For example, we are looking at how the UK Government’s commitment around the UK shared prosperity fund would work. At this point in time, I do not know more than you about how that fund will work, but we are working closely with the Scottish Government to make sure that the case is made and that there is an understanding about the impact on each of the colleges about any loss of funding.
The issue is not just the direct funding streams such as developing Scotland’s workforce. The Funding Council is also tracking closely the indirect funding that colleges get. For example, the apprenticeship family, particularly foundation and graduate apprenticeships, is funded through European funds, and again that is a source of additional income to the colleges. We are working very closely not just with the Government on how the shared prosperity fund might work, but with Skills Development Scotland on the nature of funding for the apprenticeship family’s programmes.
May I go back to my first question on this? I do not have the knowledge on how the European social fund works. Do those funds come directly from Europe for allocation to the sectors by the Scottish Government, or do they come directly from Europe to the Scottish Funding Council? Is the money drying up from the European source, or is it being reallocated at a Scottish level away from the college sector?
It is planned funding that is coming through. At one level, some of the decline in funding was already planned; as you said, it is not about Brexit and it is not about a reallocation or redistribution. These moneys had been planned and they are match funded. The colleges know what they are due to receive at some level until 2022-23. It is a planned programme, and the money is not being reallocated anywhere else.
The issue is what happens next. Will there be replacement funds? With the funding that is available, how can we look at how sustainable some of the programmes are over time? The issue is particularly resonant in some areas—for example, in Dundee and Angus College, and in the Highlands and Islands—where we are looking not just at the developing Scotland’s workforce funding but at particular structural funds, Interreg and other programmes that have come directly into the Highlands and Islands region and which we are anxious to maintain at some level. That is why we are liaising with the Government.
Can I take an assurance from you today that you are doing a strong piece of work that is looking to find money so we do not lose those 250 places in Dundee and Angus College?
We can absolutely give the assurance that we are tracking this. We are on it and we are making the case for how those funds might impact and be replaced over time.
Great—thank you very much.
We have no further questions, so thank you very much for your evidence.
10:00 Meeting suspended.
10:05 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 12 Sep 2019 →- 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 130
- 09:45 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 113
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.