Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Access to Justice (PE1695)

Thursday 5 September 2019 Public Petitions Committee About 10:45–11:00 Petitions 17 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

17 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The next petition for consideration is PE1695, by Ben and Evelyn Mundell, on access to justice in Scotland. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to take action to ensure that access to justice, including access to legal advice from appropriately trained lawyers and financial support through legal aid, is available to enable people in Scotland to pursue cases where they consider a human rights breach has occurred. I welcome to the committee David Stewart MSP; I understand that Edward Mountain MSP also has an interest in the petition.

The petition was last considered on 8 November 2018, when the committee agreed to write to the Scottish Government. A response has been received, as well as a written submission from the petitioners. The Scottish Government’s submission, which is dated 5 February 2019, confirms that, in its response to the 2018 independent strategic review of legal aid in Scotland, “Rethinking Legal Aid”, it said:

“a new legal aid system in Scotland will be developed that is user focused and has the flexibility to adapt according to emerging situations and developments.”

As part of that work, on 27 June 2019, the Scottish Government launched its legal aid reform consultation, which looks at areas concerning the user’s voice, the flexibility of the system and whether legal aid should be regarded as a public service.

In their submission, the petitioners are critical of the Scottish Government’s response, and they are of the view that the Government has ignored the human rights aspect of their petition.

I ask David Stewart to come in at this point.

11:00

David Stewart Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I thank the committee for allowing me to come along to give some background information about the petition. Members will know that I have given evidence twice before on the Mundell petition. I thank the other MSPs, such as Edward Mountain, who have been very helpful in supporting the petition.

As I said when I spoke previously about the petition, on the surface, this is a highly complicated case, but I think that it is well summarised in the papers that the committee has received. On the surface, it is about the ring fencing of dairy farmers’ milk quotas within the southern isles ring-fenced area. However, to me, the fundamental question is how ordinary Scottish families on a modest income can seek redress and remedy for potential breaches of the European convention on human rights and for injustice in general.

I want to answer that one question, convener. The simple answer is that they should seek legal representation through the civil legal aid scheme. You will know from my presentation in November that the family have been in touch with more than 50 law firms in person or by phone, but the vast majority will not deal with human rights cases, and many of the firms that deal with such cases have said that they will deal only with cases involving prisoners or immigration issues. One lawyer who agreed to take up the case wanted an upfront payment of £25,000 before proceeding. At the time, that represented double the family’s yearly disposable income.

The Mundells have told me that many farmers in the ring-fenced area were placed in an impossible situation with a milk price that was below the cost of production, leading, effectively, to the forfeit of property—at the time, the quota was worth probably around £450,000. As identified in the committee’s papers for the meeting in November, that could be a potential breach of article 1 of protocol 1 of the ECHR.

I am conscious that time is very tight, convener, so I conclude by quoting from the report of the First Minister’s advisory group on human rights leadership, which said:

“Progress then has evidently been made on Scotland’s journey. However, it is critical to acknowledge that there are gaps and shortcomings too ... too many people are not enjoying their rights in everyday life ... All of this leads to a denial of access to justice ... It is a matter of political choice and priorities. What is needed is the political will to implement the solutions.”

There is unfinished business here for Scottish human rights. That is illustrated by the Mundell petition, but it is a wider issue. I know that the petition has been before the committee for some time, so I urge the committee to refer it to the Equalities and Human Rights Committee.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I had a chat with Edward Mountain yesterday and I said that I would raise this issue. The Mundells have certainly raised issues around the gaps and imbalances in the current system. I know that they feel that they have been sidelined and marginalised and that there is legislation that is being hidden behind, which is benefiting a private company at their expense.

If the Government believes that its actions are in the national interest, surely it is in the national interest that the Mundells should be able to access the system and helped. Edward Mountain says—and I agree—that there needs to be a commitment from the Scottish Government that it will investigate the issue that the Mundells have raised on its own merits, not as something that affects a farmers’ collective. That would allow Mr and Mrs Mundell to move a bit closer towards a resolution.

I like David Stewart’s suggestion; that the Mundells do not seem able to access the services that would help them to reach a resolution certainly seems to me to be a human rights issue. I think that the Scottish Government is being a little bit stubborn when it comes to looking at the case on its own merits.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I do not think that it is our job to get the Scottish Government to address an individual case. The question is whether that case has consequences that need to be addressed through the legal aid system. David Stewart’s point is that the Mundells have a right to appeal, but no lawyer will take up their case, but that is quite different from saying that there is no funding. I heard David Stewart’s comment that human rights lawyers only take up cases around immigration and prisoners. I am not sure that that is true, but it might be the Mundells’ experience that they could not get a lawyer. I suppose that that is an interesting question.

The Scottish Government is running a consultation on legal aid reform; if the outcome from that is unsatisfactory, the petitioners could come back. However, there is a sense that we do not want the petition to be completely lost and that we want to refer it somewhere. I think the question is which is the best committee for it go to, and the suggestion is that it should go to the Equalities and Human Rights Committee.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

We must not overlook the Justice Committee. The Scottish Government is reforming the legal aid system, and I think that we should be careful about which committee we refer the petition to, because there are two angles here.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Without speaking for the petitioners, my sense is that they have found themselves in a set of circumstances and they want that resolved. There is a number of ways in which they are trying to resolve it, and the final iteration is that their human rights have been denied because they cannot get access to legal aid to address the injustice that they perceive they have experienced. If the petition goes to the Justice Committee, the question will be whether that committee will look at the information in connection with the reform of legal aid; if it goes to the Equalities and Human Rights Committee, the question will be whether that committee will look at the denial of rights because a lawyer will not take up the case.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

For clarity, convener, my point is that I think that the Mundells are highlighting a gap in the system and their inability to access their right to legal aid, which we would perceive as an indelible right. For me, that gap is the big issue here.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I have been looking through the papers. I have a question for David Stewart. Have the petitioners contacted the Equalities and Human Rights Commission about the situation, and, if so, what was the outcome?

David Stewart Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I raised that point in my more detailed November submission, which was before Gail Ross was on the committee. I quoted the Scottish Human Rights Commission, which said that it was denied the ability to raise specific cases such as the Mundells’ case, unlike what happens in Northern Ireland. That was certainly the case in November. I am happy to pursue the Scottish Human Rights Commission separately about that, but we explored that option last time.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I am not talking about the Scottish Human Rights Commission; I am talking about the Equality and Human Rights Commission. There are two different organisations.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

One has the ability to take up cases and the other does not. I wondered whether that was—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

If you go to the Equality and Human Rights Commission, it will refer you to the Scottish Human Rights Commission, so there is a gap in the system. I wonder whether the most useful thing to do, given that the most recent submission from the petitioners is firmly focused on human rights, is to refer the petition to the Parliament’s Equalities and Human Rights Committee so that it can address these questions. Do members agree to do that?

Members indicated agreement.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We are not closing the petition; we are referring it to the Equalities and Human Rights Committee. We hope that that committee will look at these questions, particularly around the ability to enforce rights if a lawyer will not take up a case. That seems to be at the heart of the petition.

David Stewart Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I appreciate the option that has come out. Thank you.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I thank David Stewart for his attendance and the petitioners for raising the issues with us.

  1. 09:15 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 09:15 Deputy Convener Procedure · 2
  3. 09:15 New Petitions Petitions · 18
  4. 09:15 New Petitions Petitions · 4
  5. 09:15 New Petitions Petitions · 4
  6. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 48
  7. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 11
  8. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  9. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  10. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  11. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 14
  12. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  13. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 17
  15. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  16. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  17. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.