Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

In Care Survivors Service (PE1596)

Thursday 5 September 2019 Public Petitions Committee About 09:30–10:15 Petitions 48 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

48 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The next item on our agenda is consideration of continued petitions, the first of which is PE1596 by Paul Anderson, on the In Care Survivors Service Scotland. The note by the clerk summarises our previous consideration of the petition in June 2019, at which we took evidence from Future Pathways, as well as recent written submissions received from Future Pathways and the petitioner.

This morning we will take evidence from representatives from Wellbeing Scotland. I welcome Janine Rennie and David Scott to the meeting. Thank you for attending. You have an opportunity to provide a brief opening statement of up to no more than five minutes, after which we will move to questions from the committee.

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

Thank you. I will start our statement and David Scott will follow on from me, but we should keep within five minutes.

Wellbeing Scotland has over 25 years of experience in supporting survivors of historical child abuse. We have a deep understanding of complex trauma and how it differs from conditions such as post-traumatic stress disorder and the challenges that it presents in respect of treatment and support for survivors of historical child abuse. We are recognised by the Confederation of Scottish Counselling Agencies as an organisation and we consistently have high scores from clients in terms of feedback.

We created and developed the In Care Survivors Service Scotland 11 years ago, and until the creation of Future Pathways, the ICSS was the bedrock upon which support services for survivors of historical abuse were based. We note that Future Pathways is only three years old as a service, with limited experience of working with abuse at all. There are today a large number of organisations offering a wide range of support services to survivors and we think that that is no bad thing, but no other service has been working in the field for anywhere near the time that Wellbeing Scotland has, in the interests of survivors. No service has our pedigree, experience or knowledge. The landscape of support for survivors is the same as it was when the ICSS started, and 2,500 survivors who chose the ICSS have reported that the current system is confusing and distressing.

An evaluation by Edinburgh Napier University in 2011 provided evidence that the ICSS model was preferred by survivors because we offer counselling, advocacy, informal support groups, a helpline and access to records all in one service. That was highly valued by survivors and recommended in the Tom Shaw report at that time. The main issue for the petitioner is that he is able to access those services all under one roof.

In many cases, clients do not wish to access NHS services due to the clinical approach and the lack of understanding of the needs of survivors of complex trauma. Survivors do not identify with mental health services and the approaches used by those services. The petitioner has highlighted that as a significant concern. Only 30 per cent of survivors have been diagnosed with mental illness.

With our vast experience, we perceive that there are several issues that the committee should explore.

Future Pathways is the only gatekeeper organisation and therefore there is a complete lack of flexibility within the system. Survivors have to register with Future Pathways to access the support fund. They are then being directed to a range of other providers to the exclusion of Wellbeing Scotland.

Those seeking counselling are required to attend an assessment with the Anchor centre, even those who are already attending the ICSS. All our workers have experienced that happening. There is an apparent lack of understanding of the academic research into the diagnosis and treatment of complex trauma and how that differs from complex PTSD and other conditions, and a continued refusal or unwillingness to refer to Wellbeing Scotland.

Future Pathways’ submission has many inaccuracies and I have provided evidence to the committee about that. The organisation is costing the Scottish purse over £1.4 million per annum in staff costs alone to broker other services. Survivors have proven that they are able to choose support without a support co-ordinator. The associated costs of that additional layer reduce the funds that are available directly to survivors. We feel that Wellbeing Scotland is a vital service for in-care survivors, particularly with the redress scheme approaching. However, by blocking referrals, Future Pathways will potentially shrink our service and we will lose key staff. We will have no confirmation of funding after March 2020. Wellbeing Scotland is a cost-effective service with a lower unit cost than all other providers, and with a reported service satisfaction level of highly satisfied by 97 per cent of survivors.

I will hand over to David Scott.

David Scott Wellbeing Scotland
link

Placing Future Pathways, a new and hitherto untried organisation with a new model of delivery—the broker model—in the lead role of co-ordinating funding for the majority of the existing infrastructure of support for survivors of in-care abuse has been a serious strategic error. Its decision-making in connection with Wellbeing Scotland and the valued and successful ICSS has been deficient and harmful, illustrating the short-sightedness of the choice to place so much authority in an organisation struggling to find its feet and its place in this most challenging field.

The dedicated staff at Wellbeing Scotland want to do their jobs and their jobs help people who have been let down by those they should have been able to trust. Those people who have survived abuse have made such personal strides forward with the help of Wellbeing Scotland that their stories, achievements and victories constitute an inspiration and an example of what can be achieved. Neither those survivors nor our staff can understand why Future Pathways is placing barriers in the way of this service and those personal victories.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you very much. I will open the meeting to questions.

We are interested in not a funding argument between Wellbeing Scotland and other organisations, but trying to understand whether what has been put in place means that the kinds of support that a lot of survivors would want and need is no longer available. You provide that kind of service and we could explore that with you to try to understand what the different model is—you highlighted quite a lot of that in your contribution.

It is clear from your written submissions and from the evidence that we have heard from Future Pathways that the relationship between Wellbeing Scotland and Future Pathways is not a positive one. You said that you have not had referrals and so on. I understand that a meeting between the two organisations took place on 5 August, and in its submission of 16 August Future Pathways stated that, as a result, it hopes that a stable contractual arrangement can be in place by mid-September to formalise future referrals. Can you comment on that? Is there a more positive working relationship with Future Pathways now?

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

That is for David Scott to answer.

David Scott Wellbeing Scotland
link

The meeting was very positive in that it developed improved communication between members of our board and organisation, and Future Pathways, but it did not really resolve the significant and weighty issues that we raised.

The specific issue of the contract has been discussed for some two years. The lack of referrals to Wellbeing Scotland was described by Future Pathways as a consequence of not having a contract in place and it was made quite clear to us that there would be no referrals until we had signed a contract. We have never seen a contract. We have had no draft; we have had no heads of agreement; nothing has been provided. We pushed very hard at the meeting to have something on paper that we could assess to move the thing forward. We were told that something would be provided in two weeks, but that deadline has unfortunately come and gone and we have still not seen anything by way of a contract. We have not really turned the corner on this and until we see what is in the contract—and we are completely in the dark on this—we will not know whether we are about to move into a new era of co-operation or not. It is quite mystifying to us as to why, after so long, we still do not know what we are being asked to sign up to.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do you have a sense of what it is about the contract that they think you might have a problem with?

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

One of our main issues with the original Future Pathways contract that was given out to providers was that it asked us to breach client confidentiality. It wanted individual agreements for each client, which would have identified the client and, not only that, the significant issues that the client brought. We were tense about that, so we sent out a document to the survivors who we worked with to see whether they were okay to give us permission to share that information. In particular, under the General Data Protection Regulation, clients have to give informed consent. About 80 per cent of the clients responded and said, “No, we absolutely do not want that information shared.”

Bear it in mind that the context is one in which a lot of the survivors of abuse in care who come to us do not want even to give us their real name when they initially come along. They are so distrusting of the state and so challenged by sharing any information at all, and they were being asked whether the intimate details of their care could be shared with another organisation that they did not know. Even when they did know them, they still did not want to share the information.

We were going by the views of our clients. We reported to Future Pathways at the board meeting that we were surprised that any providers signed up to the contract, because we are not sure that clients have in any way given informed consent. Providers are making that decision for their clients. I am not comfortable that we would make a decision for our clients and pass on highly sensitive information to an organisation that, as David Scott says, is only three years in operation and finding its feet, when our clients are at first very tense about providing any information to us, even as an established service.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is there an issue of trust? In the past, you presumably reported to your funders—the Scottish Government or whoever—on the level of support that you were offering. You would say, “We are dealing with X number of people”, and that was regarded as sufficient information. Is there a suggestion that Future Pathways lacks confidence in what you are delivering?

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

It was a big concern of ours, as to why they would lack confidence. For 10 years, we provided the Scottish Government with reports based on amalgamated core scores, which is a well-recognised clinical tool, and it was very happy with those reports. Our board’s concern was that Future Pathways was almost saying that we were untrustworthy and that it wanted more individual information, whereas the information that we provided before was fine. We were surprised to hear that the Anchor centre confirmed that it does not have to provide individualised information. Its information is compiled in the same way that we used to compile ours for the Scottish Government. We do not understand why that has presented a barrier or why there is an issue. We have gone over and over it, unfortunately.

09:45

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I want to try to get to the bottom of the Future Pathways waiting list. In your written submission of 21 June, you referred to the waiting list as “dangerously long”. The Future Pathways written submission of 16 August states that the organisation has now “eliminated” the waiting list. In your recent submission in the past couple of days, you mention that, of the 940 people who have received support from Future Pathways, 271 were referred by Wellbeing Scotland. You point out that the Future Pathways submission states that that figure is 95, which is incorrect. Will you go into that a bit more?

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

We are aware that the waiting list has been eradicated because Future Pathways doubled its staff. That is one of the issues that we raise in our submission—its staff salary costs have now doubled to £1.4 million. Future Pathways has recruited another group of co-ordinators to meet the demand from people coming forward. We said all along that we were willing to take referrals directly. We could have eradicated the waiting list with our low level of funding but, instead, the decision was taken to recruit more staff. When I examined the Future Pathways submission, I realised that some of the figures in it are up to 2018 whereas others are up to 2019, so there is inconsistency. The figures that I presented in my submission are up to March 2019.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

To your knowledge, has Future Pathways actually eradicated its waiting list?

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

To be honest, I do not know. That would be for Future Pathways to know. From our point of view, survivors are certainly being seen much more quickly than they were originally. Some can now access the support fund over the phone rather than having to wait to see a support co-ordinator. There certainly have been steps forward. Previously, people were waiting for about a year and a half, but they are now being seen much more quickly.

The system has changed a bit. Previously, somebody had to see a support co-ordinator and spend a substantial amount of time building a relationship, and they would then decide what personal outcome the person wanted to achieve. Now, our clients are reporting that they basically tell the personal outcome co-ordinator what they want to achieve and they get that, or it is turned down by committee. It seems to just go straight to committee. That is a missed opportunity. Our workers know our clients really well. We could have sat down with our clients to speak to them about what they want to achieve—they would have that idea in their heads. Future Pathways now seems to have accepted that survivors can make that decision for themselves, but that could have happened a long time ago and we would not have the situation that we are in now where some survivors have become quite unwell because of the waiting process after having disclosed what happened to them.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

So, instead of recruiting all those extra staff, Future Pathways could have provided the level of service that it is giving to survivors by using you.

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

Yes. We said all along that we had the capacity to take the survivors. I have made it clear to Flora Henderson that we are keen to work constructively with Future Pathways. We do not want Future Pathways to go as a service, because it offers practical support to survivors that we as a service do not want to provide—we think that that is a role for another organisation. However, rather than let us help, barriers have been put up. David Scott and I discussed the issue the other night, and we do not know what that is about. We cannot understand it, because we have existed for so long and we have built up a trusting relationship with the Scottish Government. The Scottish Government has been quite helpful in some of this process. We do not know why there are still blocks. We did not need to spend more of what is in effect the survivors’ money on salary costs when the result could have been achieved by the organisations that were already there.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

One of the issues that we have to explore is the disparity in the evidence that we have received from both sides. On referrals, you previously stated to the committee:

“Future Pathways have made less that ten referrals to Wellbeing Scotland since they started in September 2016.”

However, during our evidence session with Future Pathways in June, it confirmed to us that it has made 35 referrals for records searches and has funded the support of 192 people, in addition to 134 people who were supported to ensure that their support was not disrupted. Do you recognise those figures and can you confirm them?

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

Yes. Those figures are actually for on-going clients. When Future Pathways came into being, the Scottish Government made a commitment that we would continue to support our existing clients and that Future Pathways would pay for that. They were not new referrals; they were referrals that we already had who then moved over to be part of the Future Pathways umbrella.

Future pathways did not choose to make the 35 referrals for access to records. The Scottish Government gave a directive that those referrals would come to us, because we are specialists in access to records. The Scottish Government’s website said that we would receive the access-to-records referrals. We are now up to 50 such referrals, but we still have not received any referrals for counselling support.

On the access-to-records referrals, we are told that we are to offer support only for access to records and nothing else, which is a real concern because survivors who come along to access their records might access something that is quite disturbing to them. They might see something that is retraumatising, so it is important that people have counselling support as part of that process and that a counsellor is there to be with them.

Flora Henderson confirmed at the board meeting that we had recently that Future Pathways has not been making referrals, so she contradicted her own submission.

David Scott Wellbeing Scotland
link

The situation was clear: no contract, no referrals. There is no contract, because we have not seen one yet, and the issue there appears to be information flow and reporting back to Future Pathways. That was one of the strange aspects of the meeting. We were reaching agreement with the board of Future Pathways, but the chief executive kept bringing it back to there being a problem and to the need for more and much more specific information about our clients, and we feel that that breaches confidentiality.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Will you confirm that that information would not have been sought in the past when people were referred to Wellbeing Scotland? There was a way of recording the number of clients who you were dealing with that was acceptable to the Scottish Government.

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

It was acceptable to the Scottish Government, which was always happy with the information that we provided. We recently went through an audit by the Scottish Government. After all that has happened, and because I felt that we were not trusted as an organisation, we invited the Scottish Government to audit our files. The person from the Scottish Government signed a confidentiality agreement, carried out an audit of our files and found everything to be absolutely above board and fine. We have never had an issue with the Scottish Government in relation to our reporting mechanisms. That is why we find the situation so confusing.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

It occurs to me that, if you were already working with a client, that can hardly be classed as a referral. We will have to check that, if that is correct.

Future Pathways claims that the disparity in the figures is a result of a lack of sharing of information between the two organisations. Do you agree with that or accept it?

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

No, because, when we make a referral to Future Pathways, it then records that in its communication system. Generally, our worker will phone with the client to support them. One of the issues that we have had is that, when the first meeting has been set up with the client, unfortunately, the Future Pathways worker has tried to discourage the client from having their Wellbeing Scotland worker with them. Clients have found that to be really upsetting. Future Pathways workers have blatantly said, “Don’t have your Wellbeing Scotland worker here.” We certainly are being clear about the clients that we have referred. I submitted a report to Flora Henderson on our main spreadsheet, which highlighted in a column at the end the number of clients that had been referred, so she has that in writing.

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

Do you mean to Future Pathways?

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

To date, it is about 350. We want our clients to have the range of supports that were available to them. The only clients that we have not referred are those who have absolutely said that they do not want to be referred to Future Pathways and have no interest in the support fund. With any clients who have said that they want access to the support fund, we say that they have an absolute human right to that fund and should be able to access it.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

You acknowledge in your submission of April 2018 that

“many survivors have benefitted greatly from accessing the additional support offered by Future Pathways”.

However, in the petitioners’ experience, the new model has been significantly disruptive and unsettling. Can you give the committee an indication of how many survivors are in that situation?

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

The vast majority of survivors are in that situation. When we did our evaluation of the ICSS in 2011, one of the things that came across was that people did not want to keep telling their story to people over and over again. They wanted everything under one roof. That is what Tom Shaw’s report came up with: everything was to be a one-stop shop where people could come along and have their needs met. That is why we had people who could be counsellors and advocates and group workers.

Survivors are coming to us. We had one survivor who said that she had been referred to five different services by Future Pathways. She was getting really distressed and upset and losing track of when all her appointments were, who she had told what, and what she had not communicated. She said that it was incredibly distressing.

We have had a number of client meetings where about 80 survivors have attended and they are saying that one of the most confusing things is that their support co-ordinator tells them, “If you have to have advocacy, you have to go here”, but they think that they are getting advocacy from us. Also, they are being told that if they want counselling, they have to go to a private counsellor, but they see that we are already offering them counselling. Even new people who refer themselves to us say that the landscape for survivors is becoming incredibly confusing.

I am not saying it is a bad thing because there are now so many places for people to go, but my argument is that those places were always there. The reason that the Scottish Government and Tom Shaw’s report decided that there needed to be a specialist service that provided for survivors’ needs to be met under one umbrella was because they find it incredibly traumatising every time they have to tell somebody what happened to them.

We use that in our training. We say, “Would you go and tell somebody every intimate detail of your life? Would you even tell your general practitioner? Would you be comfortable with that?” So why is it okay for somebody who has suffered significant trauma to have to tell people every aspect of their life? Clients say that having to do that is incredibly humiliating and demeaning, particularly because it is to get some sort of financial reward. They find that extremely demeaning.

I raised my strong concerns before the model even came about. I said that clients will feel that they are going out with a begging bowl, and that is what they all report to us. They are deeply confused about where they need to go. They are being sent here, there and everywhere, then coming back to us extremely distressed. Some of the survivors who were told to disengage because they were going to another counsellor came back in a suicidal state, and they had been stable for years,

That is another issue. We offer lifelong support if people need it because the clients who we work with have suffered significant and severe complex trauma, and there still is not a really good understanding in Scotland and the UK about the impact of complex trauma and how it can affect every aspect of somebody’s life. Imagine how it would feel if you had to go to your GP with a very intimate issue and you felt that your GP was sending you here, there and everywhere and you had to tell that story over and over again. That is the situation that the survivors are being put into.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I want to explore the contract, data sharing and lack of information flow, where it looks as though Future Pathways needs more information. In its submission on 16 August, Future Pathways said:

“Wellbeing Scotland is the only Support Provider out of the 70 to not sign up to common quality standards and reporting requirements”

and that those standards and requirements

“were informed by typical NHS contract requirements”.

Other than the data-sharing issue, can you provide a little bit more information about why providing some of the information that the contract expects you to provide is problematic? Is that what is holding up the issuing of the contract?

10:00

David Scott Wellbeing Scotland
link

We do not really know. We had a strange subject discussion in the meeting with the board because we outlined all the problems around confidentiality and consent and we outlined what we could do. There was immediate agreement. The board of Future Pathways seemed quite comfortable with what we were saying, then a few minutes later the chief executive said that there was a problem with insufficient information again and the conversation went around another loop. We did that about four times. We thought that we walked away with an agreement on what we were going to provide, which is anonymised data so that Future Pathways can understand how many services we are providing and how many people we are providing services to in various categories, and also have management-level information so that it can understand what our capability, resource and availability is. There was no problem with any of that.

We were then told repeatedly by Flora Henderson that that was not enough. She required details so that Future Pathways could assess each individual person to make sure there was not some sort of duplication of effort. That breached the level of what we feel is appropriate and respects the confidentiality of our clients and their right to voluntary informed express consent.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I understand that Future Pathways also says that there is a lack of transparency and it is looking to establish that you are providing value for money. How is it that the other providers can meet those contract requirements, including the sharing of information, and in particular overcoming data protection and GDPR, in order to prove that they are providing a transparent service and value for money? What is the difference between Wellbeing Scotland and the other providers?

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

The other providers took the referral from Future Pathways, so that consent was already agreed between the Future Pathways co-ordinator, the survivor and the new support organisation. Essentially, because we have not had any referrals, we have not been in that process. If a survivor came to us tomorrow from Future Pathways and the Future Pathways co-ordinator had already gained that informed consent, of course there would be sharing of information because the survivor would have already known what information was going to be shared, who it was going to be shared with, and the limits of the information that would be shared, and they would have been able to make that decision.

Other providers are coming in in a completely different way. They are coming in with referrals from Future Pathways. The survivors who we are working with are already working with us; Future Pathways is the new organisation. As I said, a lot of them do not want to sign up to Future Pathways’ reporting requirements.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I understand that, so can there be an exemption? Have you discussed that particular aspect about data-sharing with the clients who you have been working with and those survivors who do not want to share their information?

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

The Scottish Government has agreed that there should be an exemption, but as David Scott said, Flora Henderson says no. The Scottish Government has been comfortable with what we have provided and we have a block grant from the Scottish Government. It has been happy with the information. It has given us an accessible and appropriate reporting requirement. We do not understand why the Scottish Government finds that appropriate for those survivors, but Future Pathways does not.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Given that Future Pathways has undertaken to ensure that continued support is available and in its evidence also said that support is not time limited, does Wellbeing Scotland have a long-term commitment from Future Pathways to provide support to people who are uncomfortable engaging with Future Pathways?

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

It does not. There have been lots of arguments back and forth about this. Future Pathways has said that survivors have to be signed up to it for it to continue to give support in the longer term. That is becoming a real barrier for the survivors who we work with who really do not want to sign up to Future Pathways, do not want to access the support fund and do not want any more intervention. That has been really challenging for them.

The block is that Future Pathways has said that it wants every one of those survivors to be signed up to Future Pathways in the longer term. Again, that seems to be taking choice away from the survivors who we are working with. They are not getting that choice. They are more or less being told, “If you want to carry on accessing services, you have to be signed up to Future Pathways.” I argued that point and said that people need to have a choice, and if they do not want to be registered with an organisation that many of them perceive to be a Government organisation, they should not be forced to do so. Years ago, when the reference group decided there was a need for a service for survivors, the agenda was to ensure that they could feel safe and confidential and that their information would not be shared in a number of different ways. A lot of the survivors we are working with are concerned that that stability is no longer there.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Do you consider that to be a barrier to a person-centred approach?

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

Absolutely. It is not a person-centred approach. That was my major concern. It is a service-led approach. It is not a person-centred approach.

Clients find the personal outcomes conversations incredibly demeaning. Again, I will put it back to you all: how would you feel if you went along to somebody and they had a debate with you about whether you needed a fridge or a carpet for your home? You are a human being. You have the capacity to decide whatever you need for your life. You do not need to have a personal outcomes conversation with somebody to decide what you need. In a lot of ways, we have gone backwards. It is a breach of human rights in terms of mental wellbeing and mental health that we think that somebody who has been a victim of complex trauma cannot make their own decisions.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Do you believe that the requirements for the contract do not constitute a person-centred approach?

Janine Rennie Wellbeing Scotland
link

They do not. If it was person centred, the clients would decide what would be an appropriate contract. When we put the contract out to the clients, we showed them the contract for each individual, and some of them were horrified.

I am not saying that they were all horrified Around 20 per cent of clients were quite happy for that information to be shared, but 80 per cent of clients got really upset with our service because they felt as if we were colluding with it by even asking that question.

That is another of our concerns. Survivors who have been stable and okay for a number of years are now starting to feel really chaotic. If you imagine someone coming to a level of stability, and then having all these different questions asked of them, it is confusing and retraumatising. Even the number of evaluations we are doing of everybody is retraumatising. It is as though we are seeing somebody as an object on a bit of paper rather than a human being.

Our core processes are part of the therapeutic work we do with clients because they like to see the distance travelled. They like to see how they said that, in session one, “My relationships were terrible or I felt suicidal” and then, in session 12, that they say “I am feeling a lot better now. I have reduced from most of the time to sometimes. I have made progress.” It is part of the therapeutic process. It is not just so that we can tick a box and have an evaluation. That is the data that I can amalgamate and show significant results that can be audited, if need be.

For the individual data, why does anybody need to know that somebody had a terrible relationship with their family, or that they were really struggling with the issues of their abuse in care? The personal outcomes that we put in place mean that we offer a session of counselling and then come back 12 sessions later and ask, “Does the person still have issues with their family?” How is it anybody’s human right to know what someone’s family is like unless they choose to share that or any of the other personal information that they might feel compelled to share?

I feel really quite distressed by this because they are human beings who we have worked with for 11 years, and they now feel that they are being forced into a system that some of them might not be ready for. I am not saying everybody. We have a client who had an excellent experience with Future Pathways from start to finish, so I am not saying it is everybody.

The model could work if we took away a lot of the things that are really demeaning and demoralising to clients, and if we trusted services such as Wellbeing Scotland, who understand complex trauma and client needs. Let us softly and gently take somebody through the process of being registered if they then want to access support, rather than firing them into a situation in which they have to be registered and they are asked to share information. One of our clients only gave a first name for two years, and that was not even his real first name. The state abused the individuals who we work with. That is the way they perceive it, so they find it demoralising to have to go through a situation of going cap in hand to the state. They need the support of services.

I have always said that if our service was not needed, I would be delighted, because it would mean that there had been recovery. It would be an achievement if our service was not needed any more. We would have walked away when Future Pathways came into being if we had felt that it was the right way forward for survivors, but we need to hang on in there and fight and campaign for our service to remain because people still need us. We will fight and campaign until they do not.

The Scottish Government has said that it does not know about our funding from 2020, yet it was able to confirm funding for Future Pathways to 2021, which admitted that it had significant difficulties in finding its feet. What you are doing is throwing out a service that has 11 years’ experience and bringing in a new, untested service that does not have that experience. Our chair raised with its chair that we are in a demeaning relationship with Future Pathways. It is being modelled on our service. Because they care about their clients, our workers have had to hang on in there for the past three years not knowing whether they will have a job.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We are coming to the end of the time that we have for PE1596. For confirmation, I note that you think that there is a role for Future Pathways, that you accept that the Scottish Government has seen your model as being one that was important in the past and that you are concerned that they should not be in competition with each other.

There are important and deep questions about how we support survivors and understand their needs, and about use of the non-medical model and so on. The Scottish Government is investing a lot of money: you are worried that it is investing in a new model and getting rid of a model that has proved to be effective. We can explore that with the Government. We do not want to personalise the response around an individual, so what does the board want specifically in respect of contracts and so on, from Future Pathways?

David Scott Wellbeing Scotland
link

The board wants the barriers to disappear: it feels the frustration that Janine Rennie described and that our workers report: the job that they want to do, at which they are excellent and which is working, is being hindered. We cannot see any satisfactory reason why. We think that the problems are entirely solvable and should have been solved years ago because it is obvious that they need to be solved. We cannot see what is driving the situation. We have skills and experience and we are a centre of excellence of national importance. We would, to be frank, expect any organisation with a co-ordinating role to work us to the very limit of our capacity, but the reverse is happening.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

In taking the petition forward, one thing that the committee wants—we will think about how it is to be done—is an opportunity to hear what the petitioner now feels. We understand the challenges and the courage that the petitioner has already displayed in lodging the petition, so we will continue to have a conversation about how we will get such a response. We obviously want to hear the petitioner’s response to this session. Can committee members think about what else we could be doing?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I find it very strange that the matter has ended up with the Public Petitions Committee. We have two organisations that cannot find common ground, and that are giving us disparate evidence and presenting it as fact. Both organisations are supposed to be working with some of the most vulnerable people in society. For me, the outcome will inevitably be that the losers will be the service users. As I said, I find it very strange that the matter has had to come to the Public Petitions Committee.

We should, given that the services are funded by the Scottish Government, take evidence from the Scottish Government: both organisations are suggesting that they have the support of the Scottish Government. We should bring the Scottish Government in as soon as we can to ask its opinion and for evidence on what it thinks is supposed to be happening.

10:15

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

At the heart of the matter is that there has been a change of model. The question is whether Future Pathways regards itself as a gatekeeper or a partner, and whether in changing the model the role that was already being done by Wellbeing Scotland—as the petitioner suggests—has now been reduced. I agree that we should take evidence from the Scottish Government in our consideration of the petition. Is there anything else that we could do?

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I completely agree with Brian Whittle. It is important to establish whether the contract requirements are suitable for a person-centred approach.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is there not a whole other matter—that of non-medical interventions? I think that there is, in the paperwork, a suggestion that one of the issues is a desire to medicalise problems when, in fact, people are not ill but are traumatised. Some will also be ill, but very often it is simply that a lack of trust is at the heart of the matter—in the sense that you are dealing with people who have already been betrayed. I am sure I am not the only person here who deals with folk who are survivors who do not give their names, and in whom there is a lot of anger, which is understandable. There is a quite lot that we can take forward.

I thank the witnesses very much for their very helpful attendance. As we make progress, you will get an opportunity to comment on future evidence that is presented.

I suspend the meeting briefly to allow the witnesses to leave.

10:16 Meeting suspended.

10:19 On resuming—

  1. 09:15 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 09:15 Deputy Convener Procedure · 2
  3. 09:15 New Petitions Petitions · 18
  4. 09:15 New Petitions Petitions · 4
  5. 09:15 New Petitions Petitions · 4
  6. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 48
  7. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 11
  8. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  9. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  10. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  11. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 14
  12. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  13. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 17
  15. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  16. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  17. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.