Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Healthcare Services (Skye, Lochalsh and South-west Ross) (PE1591)

Thursday 6 June 2019 Public Petitions Committee About 10:30–10:45 Petitions 7 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

7 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

For the next petition, I welcome Edward Mountain MSP.

PE1591, which was lodged by Catriona MacDonald on behalf of SOS-NHS, is on the major redesign of healthcare services in Skye, Lochalsh and south-west Ross. We previously considered the petition in June 2018, shortly after Sir Lewis Ritchie’s independent external view report was published. At that time, we agreed to keep the petition open for a minimum of six months to allow time for the recommendations in that report to be implemented. The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport welcomed the report and stated that she expected the recommendations in it to be delivered in full. To work towards that, she indicated that regular meetings and progress reviews would be carried out.

In a recent submission from the petitioners, which is included in our meeting pack, they state that they were concerned that Sir Lewis’s six-month review identified concerns that progress on implementing the recommendations in his report was being hindered due to factors including poor communication and slow activity. Encouragingly, however, they indicate that the one-year review, which was conducted a little over a week ago, was much more positive. They appear to be happy that community representatives have met the new chief executive and interim chairman of NHS Highland, and they are now of the belief that the priority recommendations will be implemented in the coming weeks.

Kate Forbes MSP is unable to attend today’s meeting, but has asked that the following statement be read out:

“I am sorry not to attend the Committee on behalf of my constituents as I have been at most of the other Committee hearings. This has been an incredibly long saga, and the tireless commitment of my constituents should be commended as well as the support of the Petitions Committee Members who have kept the petition open. This has given my constituents the comfort of scrutiny and accountability. The Cross Party work on this, with Edward Mountain and Rhoda Grant, has also proved invaluable.

Since the Ritchie Report, which was announced in October 2017 by me and Ian Blackford MP, there has been a thorough review, a series of recommendations and significant progress. Ultimately, last May it was agreed that Portree Hospital should, under no circumstances, be closed. A fortnight ago, Jeane Freeman came to Skye and Lochalsh to meet campaigners and healthcare professionals and it is safe to say that there is far more hope and confidence. I thank the Petitions Committee on behalf of my constituents.”

I ask Edward Mountain to make a contribution, and then we will discuss what to do with the petition.

10:45

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

It has been a great comfort to the people on Skye that the Public Petitions Committee has been considering the petition.

As members are aware, the problem concerns a redesign that was carried out by NHS Highland without consulting the people on Skye to any extent. I agree with Kate Forbes that there has been significant improvement. I remind the committee that, when we started the process, Sir Lewis Ritchie’s recommendations were accepted by the Government. Barely six months ago, five were classed as red, meaning active but with major concerns; 11 were classed as amber, meaning active but with some concerns; and only one was closed. Now, two are still classed as red, 14 are amber and none is green, which means that none is on track.

There is still a huge way to go on the redesign. I am sure that I do not need to point out the Public Petitions Committee that there has been a significant restructuring of the board of NHS Highland, which is still bedding in. We have a new chief executive and a new chairman of the board. I do not believe that the people of Skye believe that the new system is working.

Sir Lewis Ritchie’s latest report says:

“Although good progress has been made, it is important to note that the majority of recommendations are marked as amber, with several still marked as red and that there is, therefore, a clear need for ongoing intense focus on pushing forward with the delivery against the objectives in each work stream. We cannot be complacent.”

I know that the Public Petitions Committee is always under pressure to consider new petitions but the point is that, as you rightly said, convener, it is the job of your committee to shine a light on subjects. You have done so in this case, but I ask you to keep the light focused on it, perhaps for another six months, until we get the next update from Sir Lewis Ritchie. I therefore urge the committee to keep the petition open and review it in six months’ time, when we will have found out whether all his ambitions have been delivered by the Government and will know whether the people of Skye can feel confident that they are getting the health service that they demand.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I am a weekly subscriber to the West Highland Free Press. I know that you do not like us to use props, convener, but I was heartened to see a headline in last week’s edition, which I have brought in. The headline reads: “Round-the-clock urgent care to resume at Portree hospital”. Edward Mountain’s contribution notwithstanding, the campaigners certainly welcome that. Clearly, congratulations must go to the campaigners and to the local MSPs and the health board, as well as to Sir Lewis Ritchie, the chair of the health board and the current interim chief executive, who brought a wee bit more enlightenment to the views of the health board.

In many ways, I see this as a good-news story, but I take on board the fact that a lot of the recommendations are classed as amber. There is clearly still work to do.

I think that, given that there has been a significant rethink, the petition has done its job. I would therefore be minded to close the petition at this stage, while reminding the campaigners that they have an option to submit another petition to the committee, should there be continued problems in the future and they do not see all the changes that they are seeking. At the moment, however, I think that the petition has done its job.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Frankly, I do not think that it is possible for the committee to keep an intense focus on the specific issues in the petition. It is clear that the elected local representatives will continue to provide that focus, so it will still be there. The question is whether having the petition sit with us will enhance that focus. If we were to close the petition, we could write to the Scottish Government to highlight the specific areas that are classed as red and amber and to emphasise that there are still concerns. We could say to the petitioners that a new petition on the issue could be submitted in a year’s time. That would be a more transparent position to take, rather than having the petition simply sitting in the public petitions process without the job that has been suggested being done.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I see the petition as a success for the campaigners. Our job is to shine a light on particular issues and bring them to the attention of the Government and the powers that be. I get frustrated with lots of petitions, but the committee, the campaigners and the local MSPs have been very successful with this petition, and we have an outcome. The decision is whether the committee holding on to the petition is the right way to hold people’s feet to the fire. I agree with Angus MacDonald that, in this instance, we have probably taken the petition as far as we can, but I like the idea of writing to the Government to highlight the work that still needs to be done. A similar petition could be lodged, should things not reach the point that is needed, so I am minded to close the petition.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I broadly agree with Brian Whittle.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I do not think that we need to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. I say to Mr Mountain that a compelling case has been made, work has been done and commitments have been given. The test will be whether the commitments feed through. It would be a matter of some disappointment if a new petition needed to be lodged because the commitments were not matched by action on the ground and people continued to be disappointed. That, in itself, will perhaps concentrate some people’s minds.

We recognise the campaigners’ success and on-going interest. There will be an intense focus on the matter, and we will send a letter to the Scottish Government, along with a copy of the Official Report of this meeting, which will highlight the need for the Government to continue to respond to the local communities’ concerns about potential problems in the area. We very much thank the petitioners and their advocates in the Parliament for the work that they have done, and we remind the petitioners that they can return to the question. Do we agree to that approach and to close the petition?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 65
  3. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 13
  4. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  5. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  6. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  7. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  8. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  9. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.