Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Independent Water Ombudsman (PE1693)

Thursday 6 June 2019 Public Petitions Committee About 09:30–10:15 Petitions 65 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

65 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Agenda item 2 is the consideration of continued petitions, the first of which is PE1693, on the establishment of an independent water ombudsman, which was lodged by Graeme Harvey on behalf of the Lowland Canals Association. Members might wish to note that, since the petition was lodged, the lead petitioner, Graeme Harvey, has stepped down from his role as chair of the Lowland Canals Association. We recently received a written submission from Mr Harvey, which the clerks have provided us with to form part of our consideration.

At our most recent consideration of the petition, on 20 December 2018, we discussed the role of the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman, the implications of creating a new ombudsman and the current repair backlog as set out by Scottish Canals. In order to explore those and other issues further, members agreed to invite Scottish Canals to give evidence. I welcome to the meeting representatives from Scottish Canals: Catherine Topley, the chief executive; Richard Millar, the director of infrastructure; Claire Lithgow, the director of finance; and Josie Saunders, the head of corporate affairs.

I invite you to provide a brief opening statement of no more than five minutes in total, after which we will move to questions from the committee.

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

Since I took on the role at Scottish Canals, last year, our aspiration has been—this is one of the tasks that the Scottish Government provided me with—to work closely with the boating community as well as with many of the other communities that we serve. We are here today to talk about the boating community, so I will keep my evidence within that sphere.

It is clear that the boating community has felt that it has not had a good, close working relationship with Scottish Canals for some time. As a consequence, we have worked very hard, over the past year, to improve that relationship with regard to not only how we look at the canals but how we live on and utilise them.

The canals have a £70 million repairs backlog, as we have stated previously. If we had the finances to implement those repairs, the canals’ state of repair would be as good as new. We must be realistic and recognise that a proportion of that £70 million relates to immediate and ready repairs. Richard Millar has always maintained good working relationships, as have Josie Saunders, Katie Hughes and Claire Lithgow, although those can vary at times, depending on what is happening within the business. It is fair to recognise the management team’s willingness to continue those working relationships in the future.

On the asset as a working heritage asset, we have to recognise that, given its age, on-going repairs and maintenance will be required. Working with the boaters, explaining the asset management strategy, incorporating their views and the issues associated with the canals, and the transparency on the state of the canals have certainly helped the relationship with the boaters. I cannot guarantee that the canals will always be open and that we will always be able to fix and maintain them, but we work to ensure that they are safe and comply with what is required of them. By speaking and working with the boaters, we can ensure that that approach extends throughout Scotland.

Today, we are looking specifically at a petition from the LCA on a water ombudsman, which focuses particularly on the central belt of Scotland. There are 240 miles of canals across Scotland, and we must keep in mind the Crinan canal and the Caledonian canal, which also bring a significant amount of tourism, transit and activity across the breadth of Scotland’s geography.

We are happy to answer any questions that the committee has for us and to be objective about the issues that are presented to us and honest about the journey that has led us to this position.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you. You will be aware that the focus of the petition is on what can be done if people are not satisfied with what you are doing. You have outlined a problem and a challenge, but the question is what recourse people have if they are not satisfied with what you are doing.

The committee understands that the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman has no powers to assess the overall quality of the service that Scottish Canals provides and that it is unable to investigate matters relating to rent and service charges, as they are an excluded category. Who deals with those issues, including any disputes with Scottish Canals, if the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman does not?

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

As I said in our submission, we follow an internal complaints process, and complaints are processed and managed through it. The particular issue of pricing is clearly an emotive one—I completely understand that. The context is that, at the time that the discussions were under way, there was such inconsistency in the pricing along the canals that two berths sitting right next to each other were on entirely different pricing structures. From that perspective, it was appropriate, fair and transparent that we implemented something for wider usage across Scotland. As the committee will know, we did that in an open and transparent way.

Your main question was about the process, which is a two-stage process. We use our internal process to allow individuals to raise a complaint that will be formally investigated, and the complaint is then escalated to the SPSO. I understand that, as the SPSO has underlined, there is not specifically a space in which individuals can complain about pricing, but there is an open and fair dialogue about how we have got to that pricing. We should bear in mind the fact that the boaters and the community will have been involved in the consultation on that. With that in mind, I would question whether the numbers associated with the complaint reflected the overall process and the individuals involved in it.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

But there is no recourse. If you decide that that is the cost, that is the cost. There is a monopoly. You may say that the process is transparent, reasonable and necessary, but there is nowhere else for the complainant to go.

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

As things currently stand, there is nothing to prevent Scottish Canals from significantly hiking the pricing other than the fact that we have already agreed a pricing strategy with the boaters, which will not change in the forthcoming period, and the fact that we are a non-departmental public body and would, therefore, not look to act in such a commercial way, which would put individuals in hardship. We want the boaters on the water, so we would not want the prices to be such that they would exclude individuals from being on the water.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

There may be good intentions, but, at the heart of it, there is nothing that compels Scottish Canals. It could hike prices further if it wished to.

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

At the end of the day, part of the remit of Scottish Canals is to act as a commercial operation, so the commercial aspect of boating and the pricing associated with it are, of course, relevant. There is an opportunity to increase prices in line with the market in the future, but that is all that it would ever be.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So, the commercial operation, which is necessary because there is a shortfall in moneys to sustain the canals, means that you may make decisions that people who use the canals would be unhappy with.

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

Yes, that may be the case.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Some of the submissions that we have received raise significant concerns that on-going canal maintenance is suffering as a result of Scottish Canals’s focus on asset investments. Has the right balance been struck between asset investment and canal maintenance? How do you respond to concerns that Scottish Canals is diverging from its statutory obligation to maintain the canals?

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

On your second point, as you know from the submissions that we have presented, under the framework agreement, Scottish Canals is asked to act in a manner that allows us to regenerate the canals and make the best use of them, which includes commercial operations. Canals cannot stand alone or in isolation, with just boats on them, and I think that the boaters would absolutely agree with that. The reality is that canals are so vibrant because of the other activity that runs alongside the boating, which makes for a much more pleasurable and enjoyable experience not just for the boaters but for walkers, cyclists, dog walkers and so on. From that perspective, we need to look at the expanse of issues—we cannot focus solely on one area.

As you know, 15 or 20 years ago, canals were places where we kept our shopping trolleys and couches, and they were in a dire state. The state that they had got into was an embarrassment to Scotland. To maintain a positive and flourishing environment, we need activities along the canals. Those activities have to draw in the community and the community has to want to be part of them, which is why the commercial and regeneration arms go hand in hand for us. We do not want to lose that vibrancy.

I will ask Richard Miller to comment on the first part of your question, regarding the balance of commercial activities and activities relating to assets, in a moment. Those activities go hand in hand because we can never be fully financially sustainable with £10 million. I absolutely agree that it is a lot of money for anybody, but, in investment terms, £10 million can be recycled through only so many activities at any given time. Consequently, we must have a balance between the commercial activity—revenue-generating activity—and sustaining and delivering on our core business.

I underline that the Government grant in aid that is given, which is £8.5 million this year, is for our statutory responsibility of looking after the canals and cannot be used for anything other than that. To give some context, the accounts that will be published soon show that the staffing cost alone for Scottish Canals is £9.5 million. Any money that we generate has to go towards not only maintaining the canals but running them, and that money goes towards ensuring that that wider work is done. Therefore, we already contribute to the running of canals through our commercial model.

I ask Richard Millar to comment a little more on that, and then I will be happy to take further questions.

Richard Millar Scottish Canals
link

We have been working on that issue for some time through the asset management strategy. As a public organisation that looks after 140 miles of historic waterways that are between 200 and 250 years old and that have inherent risk because they are engineered channels that hold back water, we are always required to find a balance between investing in the core infrastructure—the locks, lock gates, reservoirs and aqueducts—and investing in maintenance and the operation that we deliver on the canals. The asset management strategy has been totally aligned with international best practice and is very much a forward-looking plan. People have seen that it represents best practice.

09:45

We have considered the questions that you raise. There have been some really challenging questions for Scottish Canals around the amount of money that we have, how we spend it and how, if we do not see the increase in funding that is required, we make decisions that are sensible and rational and ensure that we keep the best of the canals operational. We are absolutely determined to keep all of these canals operational and in navigation, because we know the massive value that the towpath and the water space brings to Scotland. There is no doubt that that is at the very core of what we are doing. I know that the asset management strategy has been contentious among some of the boaters, but it has helped us to understand what our liabilities are, what level of investment we require and how we should invest.

We have worked closely with the Scottish Government, and we have been lucky enough to experience a significant increase in our capital investment. However, there is still a requirement for revenue. That is important when you are running 250-year-old structures, because there is a lot of patching and repair work to do, and that can be funded only out of revenue. We have had to develop—in a balanced way—the commercial side of the business and new revenue streams so that we can do those repairs. Our revenue funding has remained static throughout the recession. In 2009 or so, it was up at £11.5 million, moving to £12.5 million. However, since 2011, it has been static at around £8 million, although there has been a slight uplift this year. Revenue is important to us for the task that we need to do, and we are striving to deliver that balance in the business.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Your staffing costs are £9.5 million. Given the challenges that you face, have you ever considered making efficiency savings in your administration? I am thinking of the salaries of the directors and other highly paid members of staff. A cost of £9.5 million for staffing is quite high.

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

I will address that point and then ask Claire Lithgow, our finance director, to comment further.

In short, yes, we have done that. We continually consider efficiencies. The staff numbers of the organisation have not varied significantly in the past eight years. I am confident that the organisation has not lost control of its staffing costs. What we have seen is a combination of increases involving issues such as the Scottish living wage and the uplift in terms of pension costs and corporate costs. Of course, with static grant in aid of £8 million, we have incurred those costs internally, which eats away at our profit.

On the directors’ salaries, the previous chief executive was on a different salary and, through the movement of his role, there was an opportunity to review that. In line with Scottish Government policy, there was an aspiration to reduce that salary by 10 per cent, which has currently been achieved.

Claire Lithgow Scottish Canals
link

We should also bear in mind the cost of public sector pensions. Scottish Canals has moved from its defined benefit pension scheme to a defined contribution pension scheme, which will have an impact as the members on our old DB scheme, which is now closed, move on from the organisation in one way or another. The DC pension scheme gives us more certainty around our future pension costs and liabilities. We are part of the Scottish Government’s public pay policy, so we have taken year-on-year increases in line with pay policy. We have no incremental pay increases, so we have capped any movement in the overall wage bill from an annual increase perspective, in line with Scottish Government pay policy. Those moves have been made in an effort to decrease the overall wage bill.

Over the past 18 months or so, we have done a lot of work around productivity, to ensure that we are getting the biggest value from our workforce and that we are maximising their productivity. As Catherine Topley said, we have not increased our overall headcount.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

To clarify, did you say that the directors’ salaries have been cut by 10 per cent?

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

I said that the chief executive’s salary has been cut by 10 per cent.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Has there been a change in the tier below that?

Claire Lithgow Scottish Canals
link

There has been no change in the people in post at that level.

Richard Millar Scottish Canals
link

The number of directors has recently reduced by one.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Does that indicate that, previously, things were top heavy and the number of directors was too high?

Claire Lithgow Scottish Canals
link

We have aligned our operations to build in greater productivity and efficiency. We have streamlined what we do, so we felt that it would be more appropriate to the organisation’s directorship structure for there to be one fewer person.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I have a question for Richard Millar on the work that is being done through the asset management strategy. Will you illustrate how returns on investments contribute to the operation and maintenance of the core canal network?

Richard Millar Scottish Canals
link

We can prove that we are tirelessly developing. As you will have seen from the papers, when we split from British Waterways to become Scottish Canals, we received a £10 million dowry as a result of moneys that had flowed south of the border when we were one United Kingdom organisation. We were able to prove that moneys had flowed in that direction and that, when we split away to become Scottish Canals, we required that money back. We were successful in securing £10 million of investment, which we have used as a commercial investment pot.

Some of the money has been invested in capital growth and opportunities to develop sites that are close to the canals in order to add value to communities. We should remember that a million people live within 3km of Scotland’s canals, and that 20 per cent of Scotland’s most challenged communities are on the banks of our canals. We have worked with the board to focus the investment on providing a double whammy, so that we deliver improvements beside the canals and deliver for some of the challenged communities. Our capital returns will be reinvested to help us to grow. We have put half the money into developing revenue opportunities that have increased our income. The statutory accounts shows that the income that is coming into Scottish Canals has increased tremendously over the past few years.

As Claire Lithgow said, the business has challenges in relation to corporate overheads and the growth in pension, and following Government policy—for example, by paying the living wage—has had implications. Changes take time, and £5 million is not a lot of money to develop income streams. However, there is no doubt that things are moving in the right direction, and the business is starting to see those returns. We need to work on and develop the income streams over time, so that they tip into adding value to the canals in the future.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Is sufficient resource being directed to canal maintenance as opposed to asset development?

Richard Millar Scottish Canals
link

For me, canal maintenance and asset development are the same. The asset management plan looks at the foundational structures. We have 4,100 major structures and 140 miles of canal banks, embankments and towpaths. Through the asset management strategy, we look at what is required to maintain those structures in good condition.

Recently, we have done a lot of work on improving the embankments around Linlithgow, because the canal holds back 31.5 miles of water. We have done works at the Ness weir, which holds back almost 2m of depth of Loch Ness from Inverness. We have been identifying the public safety pieces of work that are needed to ensure that the canals are here for the next 250 years. We have also been addressing defects and ensuring that we tackle and manage problems on the canals when we see them, so that the assets do not slip into decline.

It is about finding a balance. Have we got enough money to maintain the canals? The answer is that we are challenged. Our grant-in-aid funding has increased, and there have been improvements from the income that is being generated from commercial developments, but the asset management strategy clearly shows that we are somewhere between £2.5 million and £6 million short of getting to what we would call a steady state, which is a situation in which the canals are sustainable, maintained and fully operational. At the moment, we are operating with risk, which means that we are challenged when major failures happen. Every month, every metre of canal is monitored and inspected but, as we saw last year at Twechar and Bonnybridge, sometimes work is needed of a scale that we cannot afford to fund, given the moneys that we have at the moment.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The submission that we have received from the petitioner mentions the Scottish Canals asset management strategy, and it says that,

“On Page 8 under Canal Strategies, the comment”

is made

“that ‘budget prioritisation may not necessarily include navigation although it is an important consideration’”.

Does that mean that using the canals is not a priority for Scottish Canals?

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

That line does not sit well on its own, but it needs to be considered in the context of the entire report. What we are saying is that, as Richard Millar has emphasised, we have to take safety before navigation because of the funding scenario. Our priority is absolutely navigation and maintaining the canals, but in the context of the asset management strategy, which sets out the challenge, what we are saying is that we have to look at safety and risk before navigation.

Richard Millar Scottish Canals
link

When people walk along them, canals look like sleepy backwaters that would not worry anyone, but there are inherent risks. There are reservoirs and embankments, and there are structures that, if they failed would—as we have seen in England and Wales, where there have been significant failures in recent years—would cause local flooding and cost the public purse and insurance companies a lot of money to fix. We must ensure that we look after and maintain the canals and keep the villages, towns and people in communities that are close to them safe. That has to be the number 1 priority. We then have to consider staff and visitor safety, because we have 22 million visits to the canals every year. A lot of people out there are using them, as we have very successful towpaths, and we have to ensure that they are safe.

We are absolutely determined to keep the vibrancy on the water as well. That is critical, but it comes at a cost, not least for locks and lock gates, as we saw recently, when we fixed lock 6 in Falkirk. Significant investment of £350,000 was required to fix a lock chamber there. When we extend that and look across 90 locks, many of which are much bigger, it is a challenge.

What we have done in the asset management strategy is to create a blueprint. Our hearts and souls say that we want to keep everything open and keep all the plates spinning. However, we are in times when money is difficult. If we have to, we will deploy the asset management strategy, which is a blueprint for how we will act that is balanced against the public value from the canals.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I understand the safety issue, but the danger is that the logic of your position will be that we should stop using the canals. They would become something that people can go and see but not expect to use. That is what I read from your position. Navigation appears to be a bonus, and rather than being a working heritage asset, the canals will be something historic that people can go and look at. Do you understand why people have those anxieties?

Richard Millar Scottish Canals
link

I absolutely understand the anxieties. We constantly have conversations with the boaters on the subject in order to understand their views. However, we come back to the fact that, with limited money, we can only do so much. We cannot do everything that we need to do. That is clear from the model in the asset management strategy. We are challenged.

We are in a much better position today than we were in a year ago, when the petition was lodged, and that is thanks to significant investment from the Scottish Government. However, the canals are 250-year-old structures that do not come with any plans, any design code or any consistent construction, and they have hidden challenges. We are determined to keep them safe, to keep our visitors safe and to keep navigation on board. However, as I said, we cannot do everything. If we do not have the resources, we need to have a blueprint to allow us to prioritise.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, does it not? You do not have enough money and you have to think about safety, so you cannot prioritise navigation. You end up in a position where there is not enough money to do the thing that you would really like to do. Do you not see that it feels like you are not challenging the level of budget that you have? You are using the budget that you have to develop the area round about, perhaps, because you are not prioritising navigation.

10:00

Richard Millar Scottish Canals
link

We are challenging the—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

You are not prioritising navigation.

Richard Millar Scottish Canals
link

Navigation is a statutory part of what we deliver; it is at the heart of what Scottish Canals is all about. However, we have limited moneys to manage and maintain the infrastructure, as with any public sector organisation, so we must make hard decisions. Over the past year, we have had conversations with the Scottish Government on the back of the model that we have created and the engineering science that is the basis of the asset management strategy, which have given us a clear agenda.

When problems happen, we can deploy a small contingency of our own. However, if we identify a large problem, we have no choice but to have a conversation with the Government. We had such conversations in relation to Ardishaig pier, Twechar and Bonnybridge, and in relation to Cullochy, which was a major failure on the Caledonian canal in 2015. The agreement between us and the Government is that, if significant problems arise that go beyond what we can afford, we can have such conversations and use the methodology that is in the asset management strategy to ask how the Government can help us with the challenge.

Working with volunteers has also been critical. We are changing how we operate the canals, and working with volunteers to tackle inherent problems with the canal infrastructure is definitely an approach for the future.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I will not labour the point but, if you say that your budget priority is not navigation, any conversation that you have with the Scottish Government will not be about prioritising funding for that.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Investment is a key issue. A number of submissions have suggested that a lack of Scottish Government investment has contributed to the lack of maintenance. The submissions referred to a £70 million backlog, which you have mentioned. Have other factors led to that backlog?

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

We must be clear that, although our funding model has not changed, we are similar to any other public body, so I would be cautious about referring to a lack of investment. The Scottish Government has reviewed the funding model as best it can, and we have fallen under that process. To address the point that the convener made, we have genuinely presented business cases year on year for additional funding but, as is the case for the public sector generally, there is not enough money to go round. We sit in that bracket.

You are right that the backlog did not occur overnight; it did not suddenly develop because the Scottish Government did not have enough money to give us in the past three years. We must remember that the canals have been around for 250 years. Before Scottish Canals was established separately from British Waterways in 2012, there was a UK canal network. It is fair to say that the assessment of the state of the canals at that time might not have reflected the investment that was required. The backlog has not arisen over the past five years or as a result of a lack of investment in that period.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Our canal system is an asset to Scotland. You have talked about developing that asset and its potential, which is not just for navigation. Are you moving towards self-sufficiency? Is the Scottish Government pushing you in that direction of travel?

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

We aspire to head in that direction, but I reiterate that £10 million and a commercial investment cycle go only so far. All things being equal, if our costs stood still, the amount that we could generate from revenue and commercial capital would be more significant, so we would be much more self-sustaining, but those things do not stand still, so year on year we must balance what we can bring into the organisation versus what goes out.

We certainly contribute significantly to the cost of running the canals, not least their infrastructure, from the income that has been generated from the commercial and revenue activities. I underline again that it is the commercial capital, not the grant in aid, that has generated that. I also underline that that commercial capital is a long-term thing. The money that we generate from the Falkirk wheel makes a significant contribution to the running of the canals.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Do you have a blueprint or timescale for when the backlog can be cleared and you will be self-sufficient in that regard?

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

We have several models for when the backlog could be cleared, which depend on several investments during the period. As you can imagine, the situation is pretty fluid, depending on what money is available and how it comes in over the period.

I am realistic about what is achievable in the next 10 to 15 years around the commercial modelling and the maturity of that. We work on various models, none of which will get us to a position in which we will be self-sustaining in the next 10 to 15 years, but we look to continue to grow the income, because growing the income will allow us to invest further in the canals. I am talking about using that revenue for asset management—dealing with the repair backlog—rather than recycling it and putting it back into commercial capital. We must make it clear that we are using the money to do that.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I want to return to the subject of mooring prices. One of the towns in my constituency is Kirkintilloch, which is a canal town. A year or two ago—I cannot remember exactly when—constituents came to me because they were horrified about the exorbitant price rises, as a result of which some people were made homeless, and they felt that they had no recourse to anyone. I appreciate that that situation predated your appointment.

What has changed? What reassurance can you give that that will not happen again?

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

I will give you some context, after which Josie Saunders will be able to say more about that period, as she supported the consultation and its development, along with Katie Hughes.

We have agreed the price in consultation, and we have put in a timeframe. Is it 20 years?

Josie Saunders Scottish Canals
link

It is an on-going process.

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

I am sorry—I was referring to the period in which the increases would develop.

Richard Millar Scottish Canals
link

When we consulted as part of the pricing consultation, we agreed on an uplift of no more than £100 every year to get to the market rate that was established. That could take up to 20 years to get to.

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

I give the reassurance that, within that process, we have already identified a way to limit the increase—this addresses Ms Lamont’s point—in the costs. I think that the maximum that we will look to implement is about £8.80 a month, but Josie Saunders will be able to say more.

Josie Saunders Scottish Canals
link

The process of the pricing consultation was challenging. It is probably worth saying that no other canal authority has managed to find a methodology for setting fair and transparent prices. It is an issue that every canal authority is grappling with and is looking to Scotland to learn from.

Dealing with price increases—especially increases that relate to residential accommodation—will always be a challenge. We did not enter into the process lightly. We embarked upon it publicly and knew that it had to be independent of Scottish Canals. We knew that we would need to bring in independent consultants who would be independent of our boating customers and who would be able to understand what was out there in the marketplace and what the market demands were. We knew that they would have to be able to look at the various facilities and opportunities that were available to our boating customers at each of the locations along the mooring sites that we operate and to come up with a sensible methodology for setting the prices.

That is what Gerald Eve and Bilfinger GVA were brought in to do. As part of that process, they met boaters and held public meetings at each of the canals. The feedback from those sessions was that boating customers told them—and they subsequently told us—that they needed to extend the brief so that they could go and visit each of the mooring sites. That is exactly what they did, and they did that without Scottish Canals. They went along and met boaters and saw what made each of the mooring sites attractive and what facilities were available. They took away that information and the feedback from the boating customers, carried out desk-based research and came up with the methodology. I do not know whether that methodology is perfect, but it is probably the only one out there.

That process led to a set of prices that formed the recommendations that we then took out to consultation. Right at the beginning, we said that, because the process was independent and was carried out not by us but by a third party, with all parties’ input, the recommended prices and the methodology behind them would not be challenged and we would all have to accept them. However, Scottish Canals committed to implementing the charges fairly where we could. Therefore, the consultation was not on the recommendations and the methodology behind them; it was about how they would be implemented. As Catherine Topley said, the feedback from customers in the consultation was that they were concerned that some boaters might face financial hardship. Hence, we took the decision to cap the price increases in any financial year at £100.

Another thing that came out of the consultation was that most of our boating customers want on average a year’s agreement with Scottish Canals. However, we made it clear that a year’s agreement could be extended to three or five years if, for example, someone had a child at a local school, if they had parents in an area or if, for whatever personal reasons, they needed security of tenure. That still stands. Therefore, I am sad to hear that some of your constituents have been forced off the water as a result of the prices, and I would be keen to pick that up with you.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I should say that many of them were not happy with the independent review, either.

Putting that aside, I return to the convener’s opening remarks and question. Boaters have no recourse. You say that you are engaging with them openly and transparently, but how does that happen? Is it through public meetings?

Josie Saunders Scottish Canals
link

Yes. We have public meetings for each of the canals, either every six months or every year, depending on the location. I attend those meetings along with Catherine Topley, Richard Millar and a number of other senior managers from Scottish Canals. We have a volunteer group that meets regularly; some of the members of that group are with us today. We are in the process of establishing with some of our boating customers and representatives of boating groups a kind of advisory group to help to identify how we can spend some of the resources that we have available and where they should be prioritised. For example, it will consider whether we should prioritise weed management, encouraging volunteering or other areas.

We also have individual meetings. Catherine Topley and I and a number of the other people round the table meet regularly with individual boaters and groups. Being accessible in that way is an important part of what we do.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

One of our submissions alleges that many boaters are frightened to speak out at those meetings because they do not want to be penalised or not have their licence or annual mooring renewed. One boater was allegedly threatened with possible legal action for expressing an opinion. Is that satisfactory?

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

I would fundamentally disagree with any such behaviour happening in any of the meetings, and I have never experienced it in my tenure. I do not know when that happened, but I know that, when I joined Scottish Canals, I sat with the boating community and we agreed the matrix of the meetings. As a matter of fact, Ronnie Rusack chairs the meetings to ensure that there is a balanced approach and that the meetings are open and a safe space. I do not know when that experience happened but, hand on heart, I can say that it certainly has not occurred during my tenure.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Has there been a culture change in the dealings with boaters? Should boaters, whether they live on the canal or pay for the facility as a leisure facility, have more rights?

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

There has certainly been a shift in our relationship with the boating community. Again, I underline the point that there are good relationships between individuals at operative and management level but, corporately, there has been an absolute shift, and we have all benefited from that. The shift has allowed rights that already exist to be expressed and utilised.

As a result, we have seen significant changes with people’s expression of what they would like to see or where they have challenged particular issues. We have progressed on that using the boating meetings to implement changes that have been requested. Those meetings are minuted and there is an action log that identifies what people have asked for and what we have been able to deliver.

There are rights that were not used to the best effect in the earlier relationship.

10:15

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am very conscious of the time. You mentioned an advisory group. Would it be possible for you to send us details of its terms of reference, whether it has been established, when it has met, who the members are and how often it will meet? You also talked about a £70 million repair backlog. It would be interesting to know how much of that is regarded as critical and how much of it would be helpful but not absolutely disastrous if it was not done.

This is my final question. Do you accept that there are fewer protections or rights to complain for users of canals in Scotland than there are in England?

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

I hold my hands up and say that I am not an expert, but based on my conversations with the chief executive of the Canal & River Trust, I would say probably not. When I discussed the matter with him and took counsel from him, his view was that the ombudsman in England and Wales reviews only the processes that have been used and does not really provide what the boaters seek to achieve in Scotland. Based on the advice that I have been given, we would be looking at an entirely different set-up but the ombudsman is not my area of expertise. We would have to look at its remit and how far it can go under that remit.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Ms Topley, I believe that your secondment finishes in December. It appears that communication between Scottish Canals and the user groups has improved; that will clearly be your legacy. What will happen when you are not there?

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

The boaters have been concerned about that. As part of my engagement with the Government, we have been looking at ensuring that the individual who comes into the post is clear on the priorities.

One of the first things that the Scottish Government asked me to do was to look at how the relationships had broken down and how we could develop them going forward. That is a fundamental part of the recruitment process for the new chief executive.

We have a new board and we are clearly experiencing the benefit of that knowledge coming through. There are therefore two parts to the answer. First, improved communications should be inherent in the new chief executive recruitment process, and secondly, the cultural experience of the way in which we have engaged has changed; as a result, it has been embedded as a legacy and will continue at the senior level with the board and the executive team.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The final issue that was flagged up was the question of the chair of Scottish Canals. I understand that someone is serving a second three-year term and it has been confirmed that they have been awarded a third term. The petitioner regards that as unheard of. You might want to come back to us on governance and satisfying the petitioner and others of transparency.

Catherine Topley Scottish Canals
link

I am not aware of the discussions that are on-going between the chair and the Scottish Government. As you can imagine, that is a matter for ministers. I am confident that ministers will not act outwith the normal governance process, so I would be happy to explore what that consists of and report back to the committee on that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I thank you and the panel for your time today. We have taken slightly longer than we expected to, but, as with many of these things, we discover an interest in an area where people have a lot of focus and about which people care passionately but we do not really understand the inner workings of the issue.

We have asked you for some further information, which I hope you will be able to provide. Equally, if there are things that you feel we have missed during our consideration, we would be more than happy to hear from you.

We must decide what to do next. We will want to take the opportunity to reflect on what we have heard and to ask others to respond to what we have heard

One area on which we need to satisfy ourselves is where to go with complaints on the ombudsman. Is it the same as elsewhere in the United Kingdom and, if not, is that something that we could look at? We should not forget that that is the focus of the petition.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

The evidence that we have heard from both sides points to a cultural change and an improvement in the relationship between the parties. I am still concerned about the fact that there is no recourse and the relationship is totally reliant on the attitude and culture of Scottish Canals and the board. It will always revolve around that and we need to consider that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Rona Mackay made the point that there is a direct impact on those who are not just using the water for leisure but living on it. We will also want to reflect on that.

With the committee’s agreement, we will reflect on the evidence and come back to a later meeting with some conclusions. There will be an opportunity for people, having heard what we have discussed today, to make further comments; that would be useful.

I thank the witnesses for their attendance.

10:20 Meeting suspended.

10:23 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 65
  3. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 13
  4. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  5. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  6. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  7. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  8. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  9. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.