Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Reports

“The 2017/18 audit of Community Justice Scotland”

Thursday 6 December 2018 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 09:45–10:15 Committee business 67 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

67 contributions
Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Item 3 is on the section 22 report “The 2017/18 audit of Community Justice Scotland”. I welcome our witnesses: Caroline Gardner, who is the Auditor General for Scotland; Mark Roberts, who is a senior manager at Audit Scotland; and, Jo Brown, who is a director of Grant Thornton.

I invite the Auditor General to make a short opening statement.

Caroline Gardner
link

Our brief report results from the first annual audit of Community Justice Scotland, which is a small central Government body that began work on 1 April 2017. Community Justice Scotland is critical to the Scottish Government’s justice strategy and its ambition to shift the balance away from custodial sentences towards more community-based sentences. It spent £1.2 million in its first year, and the auditor gave an unqualified opinion on the annual report and accounts.

Community Justice Scotland started work with a board consisting of a chair and four members, appointed by the Scottish ministers. That make-up did not comply with the Community Justice (Scotland) Act 2016, which specifies a minimum of five board members in addition to the chair. Between October 2017 and October 2018, the chair of the board was absent. Three of the remaining four non-executive directors agreed to take turns at chairing board meetings until April 2018, when the board agreed to appoint one of its members to be interim chair. The Scottish Government subsequently approved that arrangement. During 2017-18, the board’s audit and risk committee met just twice and its human resources and remuneration committee did not meet at all. The chair resigned in November, and the Scottish Government plans to recruit a new chair. In addition, the Government appointed four new members to the board in October, bringing the total number to eight, one of whom is acting as interim chair.

Effective governance is critical to the work of all public bodies, irrespective of their size. We will monitor Community Justice Scotland’s progress through the 2018-19 audit, and my performance audit programme contains a proposal to look at community justice in 2020-21.

I am accompanied by Joanne Brown, who is the appointed auditor for Community Justice Scotland, and Mark Roberts from Audit Scotland. We will do our best to answer the committee’s questions.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you very much.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

Good morning, again. A key part of the report concerns the number of board members. Has the Government explained why it did not appoint the appropriate number of people at the start of the process and what the barriers and challenges to doing so were? Has there been any explanation?

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

Our understanding is that, in the very early stages of Community Justice Scotland, discussions were had between the organisation and the Scottish Government about how many board members it needed. I am still not clear why it was decided that there would be a chair and four non-executive members as opposed to what was specified in the 2016 act. There was discussion about whether a small number of board members would be appropriate during the organisation’s early stages, but why that number was chosen is a question that would be better directed to the Government.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

What are the sanctions on the Government, or the challenges that it faces if it does not comply with an act of Parliament?

Caroline Gardner
link

It is part of the role of Parliament and its committees to think what is appropriate in individual circumstances. It is my role to bring matters to your attention. In this case, the size of the board did not comply with the legislation that was approved by Parliament.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

A much bigger consideration than whether we have the right number of people on the board is whether we have the right skills on the board. Did we have the right skills on the board at the outset when we had the one-plus-four model, and do we have the right set of skills on the board now?

Caroline Gardner
link

The appointment of the new members is a very important opportunity to broaden the skills and make sure that they are what the organisation needs. Jo Brown might want to comment on that.

Jo Brown Grant Thornton
link

Now that the board has an additional four non-executive members, it is undertaking a skills matrix, to look at the skills of the people on the board and identify where there may be potential gaps or where training might be required.

From speaking to the accountable officer, I know that plans are in place to train members of the audit and risk committee, to strengthen their understanding of how they discharge their role. We will look at that as part of the 2018-19 external audit.

Caroline Gardner
link

Currently, there is not a chair. The chair resigned in October 2018 and the Government has not yet advertised for a new one. The chair for the first period of the organisation’s existence was Jean Cooper.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

How often does the board now meet, and do the board members draw lots over who chairs the meeting?

Caroline Gardner
link

Jo Brown will pick up the point on frequency.

Jo Brown Grant Thornton
link

To clarify, in the transition period when the chair was absent, three of the non-executive members rotated the chairing of meetings. A decision was taken in April 2018, when the position on the chair became clearer, to appoint an interim chair, Glynis Watt, who continues to act as interim chair.

As a relatively new organisation, the board made the decision to meet monthly and at present it meets 10 times over the 12 months of the year. The board continues to look at the frequency of its meetings in the light of the business that is going to the board and the number of decisions that it needs to take, to make sure that that is appropriate.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

Can you say a bit about the make-up of the current board, in terms of its diversity and skills? Is it an accurate reflection of the skills that such a board requires and of the diverse make-up of Scotland?

Jo Brown Grant Thornton
link

On skills, what we see as external auditors is that there is a strong focus on experience in community justice. The four new appointments made in October 2018 strengthen that community justice knowledge and experience. Members have differing and diverse experience of working across public sector organisations, not-for-profits and third sector organisations.

In 2018-19, we will continue to look at the board’s financial understanding, how financial management is taken into account in the skill set of the board and the board’s wider governance experience. Those aspects should come through the skills matrix and be picked up as part of the training.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

I have two final questions. Is there a gender balance on the board? Is there any ethnic minority representation among the eight members?

Jo Brown Grant Thornton
link

On gender balance, the four new appointments were male, but a number of the previous non-executive directors were female. I think that the gender balance is just shy of 50:50. I could not comment on wider diversity, but I am sure that we can get that information.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

That would be great.

Finally, given that the board had one chair and four board members, did not comply with the 2016 act for almost all its existence and does not currently have a chair, it does not seem to have had a great deal of Government oversight or interest. Was this body created just because it seemed the right thing to do? Do you get a sense that it is a strategic priority for the Government and that it is investing the time and energy needed to make it a success?

Caroline Gardner
link

Community Justice Scotland is a priority. The board needs to play an important role as it moves into the second year of its life in making that change happen. Mark Roberts can give a better sense of the oversight that the Government exercised during this period.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

Government officials were at a number of the board meetings in the course of the year. They were aware of the process of establishing the organisation prior to April 2017 and how it operated subsequently. There was a reasonable level of Government awareness as to how the board operated during the year.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

I will pick up that question and come at it from a slightly different angle. The board is appointed by the Scottish ministers, there is no chair and no deputy, and for at least some of its existence it has been a very small board. Some people may wonder whether it is understandable that the Scottish Government is not in a tearing hurry to find more people to be on the board, on the basis that it has greater control over it in this way.

Caroline Gardner
link

That was not our conclusion at all. It is important to remind ourselves that, when the chair was first absent, nobody on the board or in the Government knew how long that absence would last. With hindsight, we know that it lasted for 12 months, from October 2017 to October 2018, but when she was first absent, the process was open ended with no end point in sight. As Jo Brown said, for the first period the board rotated the chair between the members, and after six months, they agreed to appoint a member as the interim chair. By the end of the 12 months, it was appropriate to ask whether the arrangements in place were operating as effectively as was needed, and the Government has now appointed an additional four members. The chair has resigned and the Government is planning to appoint a new chair.

My concerns are the effect on the basic governance arrangements for the new body; more broadly, the extent to which there is a consistent approach to setting up new bodies, which is not a trivial task, even for small bodies; and the opportunity cost of making sure that the body can play its important role of delivering more community justice services and more effective services across Scotland.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you. Alex Neil has a supplementary on that issue.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

If this body and its board were abolished at 5 o’clock this afternoon, would anybody in Scotland notice?

Caroline Gardner
link

That question is not entirely fair for a brand new body. It has not yet been able to establish itself to carry out its important function. I hope that when it is up and running and carrying out that function, it will be a key part of community justice, as the Government and Parliament envisaged when they established it. There is an opportunity cost to its not being there yet.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

However, it has now been up and running for a year and three quarters. What has it achieved in that period?

Caroline Gardner
link

Its achievements have been focused on getting itself established. As I have reported to the committee today, that has taken longer than it should have done.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It has not been entirely successful in doing that, has it?

Caroline Gardner
link

That is why my report is in front of the committee today.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Are there not lessons in here? I would have thought that an obvious one is that boards should appoint a deputy chair so that, if through illness or whatever a chair has to be absent for whatever length of time, a deputy chair can step in. To allow members to rotate the chair is not good governance, apart from the lack of consistency and the question of whether there are the right people with the skills to chair a board meeting.

The other thing that strikes me is that the matrix of skills is being done now. Surely the skills are looked at before people are appointed to the board, not after they are appointed? Once they are appointed, the board is landed with the set of skills that it has, whether it is the right set of skills or not.

Caroline Gardner
link

You are absolutely right. There are lessons to be learned, and that is a reason why I report to this committee. The first lesson is that appointments need to comply with the legislation that sets up the body, which did not happen in this case. As the committee has discussed before, there is merit in having a deputy chair who can step in when required and who can play an important role when, for example, there are differences within the board by helping to resolve them and move forward. Being clear about the make-up of the board with regard to the skills that are required and compliance with such things as the Government’s diversity legislation and its policies are also important.

This is a small body that potentially plays an important part in the justice system in Scotland, and I have reported to the committee because I think that it is important that those lessons are learned.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

There are lots of lessons in here and this is something that we will need to discuss later. We need to follow up, as this is shambolic.

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

This is a very important public body—I speak as a former prison social worker—and we spoke in our earlier session about the importance of public sector reform. The raison d’être of the organisation is to shift the balance from short-term custodial sentences that are costly and ineffective to robust community disposals that will rehabilitate offenders and make our communities safer, so it is an important organisation.

We also know from experience that the early years of any organisation are crucial in getting the right start and the best start and laying strong foundations. Therefore, if I have picked up correctly what the panel said, it is deeply concerning and regrettable that the organisation has been without a chair for a year, which is a long time even for a well-established organisation, never mind a new one.

10:15

I do not expect you to breach any rules by giving personal information about any of the individuals who are involved, but I would be interested to know the impact of people taking turns to chair meetings, given the issue of consistency that Alex Neil raised. Could anything have been done earlier to resolve the situation? How actively involved is the sponsoring team?

Caroline Gardner
link

There were lots of questions in there, which I will ask Mark Roberts to pick up.

I agree with the broader point that you are making, which is that it is important that a public body that is set up to fulfil a major policy priority for the Government has fair wind and support behind it. It is not a trivial matter to set up a new public body, and it needs to be done in a way that gives it the best chance of fulfilling its objectives.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

I will pick up on the situation with regard to the deputy chair. As we said in the report, the act makes explicit provision for a deputy chair to be appointed, but the board decided not to do that during the early stages of its work.

As I said in my answer to Mr Sarwar, the sponsoring team in the Scottish Government was fairly actively involved in seeing how work was going by attending board meetings and so forth. There was understanding and oversight of what was going on. In recent months, with the expansion in the number of board members, there has certainly been a large amount of engagement between CJS and the sponsoring part of the Scottish Government. There is engagement and it is seen as a priority for Scottish Government policy.

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

I suspect that there are probably questions that the committee will want to follow up with the accountable officers of the organisation and the sponsoring team.

I want to pick up on Anas Sarwar’s point that diversity is strength. There is oodles of evidence that gender balance and diversity more widely are not just the right thing but the smart thing to do, so that we tap into all the talents that are available. Given that the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Act 2018 was passed by the Parliament and has to be fully implemented by the early 2020s, what assurance can the committee get that, in this instance, the law will be complied with? If the four new appointees are all men, does that mean that all the existing appointees are women?

Caroline Gardner
link

I think that Jo Brown said that a number of the previous board members were women. The chair who resigned was a woman. We do not know yet who the new chair will be, so the balance is not yet fixed.

Your wider point is an important one. It is about how the Government makes sure that the intentions that are enshrined in the legislation are being given effect to as appointments are made, so that we get the right people on boards and so that, by the target date in the legislation, 50 per cent of those board members are women.

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

I have a final question. Given that women are underrepresented as chairs of our public bodies, does the panel have any insight into, or assurance to offer about, the efforts that are being made to engage our community in the widest sense and to encourage applications from women, people from a black and minority ethnic background or people with a disability?

More broadly, will you give the committee a sense of the top three priorities for the organisation over the next 12 months?

Caroline Gardner
link

On the first question, we have not yet looked directly at the measures that the Government is taking, in general, to encourage more diverse applicants for board member and board chair positions. This is an example of where there is an opportunity to do that, but we have not looked at it, so I cannot give you that assurance. The committee might want to explore the issue with the Government.

On the priorities for the board, the starting point is to establish the basics of good governance, to have a board that complies with the legislation, to have a chair in place and to have a board that comes together around its priorities. The board must then start the important work of working with its partners around the justice system and with wider stakeholders to make a reality of the policy commitment that Angela Constance highlighted at the start of her questioning. The policy is a really important part of public service reform, and all the evidence suggests that it is both better for Scotland and better value for money. That is why the board is such an important part of the process.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Before we move on, I have a brief question. As far as you are aware, has the way in which the board has been constituted impacted on its services over the past year or 18 months?

Caroline Gardner
link

There is no doubt that 2017-18 was always going to be the year of the organisation starting operations. In my view, there is probably an opportunity cost in slowing down the board’s ability to move on to the next stage, which is that of starting to have an impact on justice services. It is hard to quantify, but it is also hard to see how the problems could not have had that effect.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Before I move on to financial capacity, which is the main thrust of my next question, I note that we are all absolutely signed up to the objective—there is no doubt about that. However, that is what makes this a greater tragedy. By now, we would have expected the board to be racing ahead because of the urgency and the priority that the policy has been given. That worries me, although it is sensible to suggest that we slow down a bit and get the organisation into shape before we move to the next phase.

I also want to confirm that the chair resigned three months ago.

Caroline Gardner
link

It was in October this year.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Has the job still not been advertised?

Caroline Gardner
link

Mark Roberts checked in with the Government on that very recently.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

The post has certainly not been placed on the Scottish Government’s appointed for Scotland website, where details of most public appointments are placed.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Alongside Angela Constance’s point about deliberately trying to use the appointment of a chair to improve the diversity of the board, I think that we will want to raise directly with the Government the point about treating this a bit more urgently, given the importance of what we are trying to achieve.

On financial capacity, which is another internal issue, are you satisfied that the board now has the internal capacity that it will require to do the job once it is fully up and running?

Caroline Gardner
link

I ask Jo Brown to pick up that question.

Jo Brown Grant Thornton
link

The organisation is very small—as the report sets out, it has only 26 employees. We will look very closely at financial capacity as part of our 2018-19 audit. I know that the accountable officer continues to have conversations with the Scottish Government and the sponsor department. The organisation makes use of Scottish Government finance systems such as payroll and financial ledger. However, she recognises that, at the moment, the financial capacity and capability in her team are limited outwith that Scottish Government arrangement, and she is looking to recruit to a post to strengthen her financial team. Again, we will look at that as part of the 2018-19 work.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Last week, we heard that some integration joint boards do not have full-time financial officers. They deal with hundreds of thousands of pounds—potentially, in some cases, more than a billion pounds—per year. There might be a lesson here about small organisations sharing a central financial resource, for example, so that they can get the level of expertise that they require without having to build in a huge overhead that might not be justifiable for organisations of that size. Do we need to be a bit more imaginative about how we address such issues?

Caroline Gardner
link

Jo Brown may want to comment in a moment, but my sense is that it is a case of horses for courses. The body has a service-level agreement with the Scottish Government to prepare its financial accounts. It uses the Scottish Government’s central finance systems such as the Scottish Executive accounting system, and that is entirely appropriate at this stage. However, you are right. Perhaps like the IJBs, as it develops and plays more of a role in working with the Scottish Prison Service, local authority community justice services and others to change the way in which sentencing works, its scale and the complexity of what it needs to manage will also change. It would then be appropriate to review what capacity it needs—not to do the transactions processing but to carry out the strategic financial management of how funds need to flow through the system and how they may need to move from one place to another to make that change happen.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

More generally, has the board agreed a business plan or a strategy of its own? It knows its general outcomes, but has it agreed a performance monitoring system for its own added value in the system?

Jo Brown Grant Thornton
link

The board’s strategic priorities and strategy are set out in a document and have been agreed. There is a one-year financial plan that supports a business plan. The board recognises that, from 2018-19, Community Justice Scotland will have a larger budget and that it will start to do more commissioning. The board is looking to create a wider three-year financial plan.

Jo Brown Grant Thornton
link

The board is looking at that just now. It has committed to having it in place when it looks at the budget for 2019-20; February 2019 is therefore the timescale that it is working to. As part of its strategy, it has a broad outline around the outcomes that it wants to achieve and it is starting to look at the performance management framework and how it reports against those outcomes. However, as you would expect for a relatively new organisation, a number of those areas are still under development.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

When you say that the organisation uses Scottish Government systems, does it just input into a computer system or is there someone in the Scottish Government who is responsible and who prepares the accounts, understands what Community Justice Scotland does and understands the business when putting together the financials?

Jo Brown Grant Thornton
link

It is probably a combination of both. There is a team in Community Justice Scotland that can input directly into the financial ledger and process transactions. On financial statement support, for the 2017-18 audit, the statements were prepared by somebody in the Scottish Government’s finance team who understood CJS’s accounting transactions. They prepared the set of accounts and liaised with us from an audit perspective around the underlying supporting information for those transactions.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

In the process of signing off the accounts, did you deal with somebody at Community Justice Scotland or somebody at the Scottish Government? Who took responsibility for the financials?

Jo Brown Grant Thornton
link

Our facilitation was with somebody in Community Justice Scotland. However, when we were doing our audit work, there were wider questions around the financial statements, such as how they were prepared and how the accounting treatment of certain aspects was picked up. We liaised with Community Justice Scotland but ultimately spoke to somebody in the Scottish Government’s finance team around the accounting and preparation of the financial statements.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

There is therefore a gap in Community Justice Scotland at the moment in understanding the financials.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

The annual audit report says:

“There was lack of clarity at the Audit and Risk Committee at the end of July”,

because nobody from the Scottish Government—which I think prepared the accounts—turned up to talk about the accounts. Why did the Scottish Government not show up?

Jo Brown Grant Thornton
link

There was a misunderstanding between Community Justice Scotland and the individual in the finance team at the Scottish Government around the preparation of the accounts. One of the challenges that the organisation has had is understanding the role and remit not only of the audit and risk committee but of the individuals who attend it. There was a misunderstanding that I—as the external auditor—was preparing and presenting, rather than auditing, the financial statements. As part of that misunderstanding, there was nobody at that meeting to present the accounts. The organisation was not aware of that and has learned from it. I would expect to see that much improved in 2018-19.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

On the same area, you said that the audit and risk committee met twice in 2017-18. Is it continuing to meet? Does it have an internal audit programme and plan in place, and are those being carried through?

Jo Brown Grant Thornton
link

It has an internal audit programme—the internal audit is provided by the Scottish Government internal audit service—and an annual plan for 2018-19. The audit and risk committee met in July and, more recently, at the start of November. The next meeting is scheduled for early January. It has started to do a forward schedule of business and it needs to continue to project that through and agree it.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

As members have no further questions, I thank the Auditor General and her colleagues for their evidence this morning.

10:29 Meeting continued in private until 10:47.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 101
  3. 09:45 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 67

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.