Our brief report results from the first annual audit of Community Justice Scotland, which is a small central Government body that began work on 1 April 2017. Community Justice Scotland is critical to the Scottish Government’s justice strategy and its ambition to shift the balance away from custodial sentences towards more community-based sentences. It spent £1.2 million in its first year, and the auditor gave an unqualified opinion on the annual report and accounts.
Community Justice Scotland started work with a board consisting of a chair and four members, appointed by the Scottish ministers. That make-up did not comply with the Community Justice (Scotland) Act 2016, which specifies a minimum of five board members in addition to the chair. Between October 2017 and October 2018, the chair of the board was absent. Three of the remaining four non-executive directors agreed to take turns at chairing board meetings until April 2018, when the board agreed to appoint one of its members to be interim chair. The Scottish Government subsequently approved that arrangement. During 2017-18, the board’s audit and risk committee met just twice and its human resources and remuneration committee did not meet at all. The chair resigned in November, and the Scottish Government plans to recruit a new chair. In addition, the Government appointed four new members to the board in October, bringing the total number to eight, one of whom is acting as interim chair.
Effective governance is critical to the work of all public bodies, irrespective of their size. We will monitor Community Justice Scotland’s progress through the 2018-19 audit, and my performance audit programme contains a proposal to look at community justice in 2020-21.
I am accompanied by Joanne Brown, who is the appointed auditor for Community Justice Scotland, and Mark Roberts from Audit Scotland. We will do our best to answer the committee’s questions.