This is the fifth time that I have presented a section 22 report to the committee on the annual audit of the Scottish Police Authority. This year, the auditor has given an unqualified opinion on the annual report and accounts, and there have been improvements in several key areas.
Many of the concerns that I have highlighted to the committee in the past have been addressed. In particular, I welcome progress in the SPA’s leadership, governance and financial management. Significant challenges remain, but the SPA is now better placed to address them than at any time in the past.
Although financial management has improved, there is still a major financial challenge in both the short and the long term. The SPA still operates with a deficit in its revenue expenditure. In 2017-18, the deficit was £37.9 million, which is money that had to be found from elsewhere in the Scottish Government’s budget. The SPA plans to return to a balanced budget by 2020-21, but its 10-year financial strategy suggests that it will return to a deficit position after that unless it changes its operating model.
Such a change is also central to achieving the ambitions in the policing 2026 strategy. The estates and workforce strategies will be critical in changing how the service operates in the future, but there has been insufficient progress in developing them so far.
Modernising the police service’s information technology system is also essential. The SPA has now agreed a data, digital and information and communication technology strategy, but it is not clear how the estimated £298 million cost will be funded.
My report details an increase in external support costs during 2017-18. That reflects the scale of transformation that the SPA and Police Scotland seek to achieve and the recognition that they do not yet have the required skills and experience. It is critical, however, that that expenditure on external support is closely monitored, the intended benefits realised and a transfer of knowledge achieved.
Finally, I note in my report the uncertainty about how railway policing will be devolved to Scotland. I am concerned that, unless that uncertainty is resolved, there is a risk that it will distract attention from the wider transformation agenda.
In summary, there has been considerable progress and there are still significant challenges to address. We will do our best to answer the committee’s questions.