As the committee knows, the Scottish Parliament has new responsibilities for taxes, borrowing and social security. The changes enhance the Scottish Government’s ability to manage its spending but they also introduce more complexity and risk. That increases the importance of comprehensive, clear and consistent financial reporting to support this committee and the wider Parliament in your vital scrutiny role.
The annual consolidated accounts are a critical component of the Government’s accountability to Parliament and the public. They cover around 90 per cent of the spending approved by Parliament in 2017-18. My independent opinion on the consolidated accounts is unqualified; I am content that they provide a true and fair view of the Government’s finances and that they meet the legal and accounting requirements.
I would like to highlight three areas from my report for the committee. First, on financial management, the Government managed its budget for 2017-18 within the overall limit set by Parliament, and budget management was effective. The Government borrowed its full annual capital limit of £450 million, in line with plans outlined by ministers as part of the 2017-18 budget. At the end of the financial year, the Government had net capital borrowings of £1.036 billion, which is around 35 per cent of the overall £3 billion cap. The Government still needs to finalise the policies and principles within which it will manage its new borrowing powers; that is important to support decision making about the level, type and timing of borrowing, and to avoid excess borrowing and associated interest costs.
The Government has taken policy decisions to provide significant financial support to private companies, which inevitably increases its exposure to risk. My report highlights the need for more transparency on the Government’s approach to supporting private companies. Although business cases were clear for the loans that were provided to two companies during 2017-18, there is no framework to guide support of that kind. That should cover issues such as financial capacity, risk tolerance and the expected outcomes, and it would provide Parliament with better information and greater assurance.
Secondly, on financial reporting, the Government has improved its financial reporting this year through its first medium-term financial strategy and its “Fiscal Framework Outturn Report”, both of which play important roles in the Parliament’s new budget process. They will develop further over time. However, the use of capital borrowing powers for the first time in 2017-18 reinforces the need for the Government to improve the reporting of its overall financial position, as I have recommended before. Currently, there is no appropriate audited account that sets out all the Government’s assets and liabilities, including borrowing by the Scottish ministers. That would provide important information about the impact of past decisions on future budgets and potential risks to financial sustainability. The Government has committed to producing a consolidated account that covers the whole public sector in Scotland, but that is now overdue.
Thirdly, on performance reporting, the performance report that is included in the consolidated accounts complies with reporting requirements and the accounts direction. However, the accounts still do not report on the performance of individual portfolios or the Scottish Government as a whole, on the outcomes that it seeks to achieve. There is a need for more detailed and transparent performance reporting that links spending with outcomes, in line with the Parliament’s new budget process.
My report on the 2017-18 consolidated accounts is intended to support parliamentary scrutiny of the Government’s finances. It provides assurance and identifies a number of areas for further improvement.
As always, we will do our best to answer the committee’s questions.