Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Reports

“The 2017/18 audit of the Scottish Government Consolidated Accounts”

Thursday 1 November 2018 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 10:00–10:30 Committee business 76 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

76 contributions
Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Item 3 is on the section 22 report, “The 2017/18 audit of the Scottish Government Consolidated Accounts”. I welcome Caroline Gardner, Auditor General for Scotland, Stephen Boyle, assistant director, and Michael Oliphant, senior audit manager at Audit Scotland.

I ask the Auditor General to make an opening statement.

Caroline Gardner
link

As the committee knows, the Scottish Parliament has new responsibilities for taxes, borrowing and social security. The changes enhance the Scottish Government’s ability to manage its spending but they also introduce more complexity and risk. That increases the importance of comprehensive, clear and consistent financial reporting to support this committee and the wider Parliament in your vital scrutiny role.

The annual consolidated accounts are a critical component of the Government’s accountability to Parliament and the public. They cover around 90 per cent of the spending approved by Parliament in 2017-18. My independent opinion on the consolidated accounts is unqualified; I am content that they provide a true and fair view of the Government’s finances and that they meet the legal and accounting requirements.

I would like to highlight three areas from my report for the committee. First, on financial management, the Government managed its budget for 2017-18 within the overall limit set by Parliament, and budget management was effective. The Government borrowed its full annual capital limit of £450 million, in line with plans outlined by ministers as part of the 2017-18 budget. At the end of the financial year, the Government had net capital borrowings of £1.036 billion, which is around 35 per cent of the overall £3 billion cap. The Government still needs to finalise the policies and principles within which it will manage its new borrowing powers; that is important to support decision making about the level, type and timing of borrowing, and to avoid excess borrowing and associated interest costs.

The Government has taken policy decisions to provide significant financial support to private companies, which inevitably increases its exposure to risk. My report highlights the need for more transparency on the Government’s approach to supporting private companies. Although business cases were clear for the loans that were provided to two companies during 2017-18, there is no framework to guide support of that kind. That should cover issues such as financial capacity, risk tolerance and the expected outcomes, and it would provide Parliament with better information and greater assurance.

Secondly, on financial reporting, the Government has improved its financial reporting this year through its first medium-term financial strategy and its “Fiscal Framework Outturn Report”, both of which play important roles in the Parliament’s new budget process. They will develop further over time. However, the use of capital borrowing powers for the first time in 2017-18 reinforces the need for the Government to improve the reporting of its overall financial position, as I have recommended before. Currently, there is no appropriate audited account that sets out all the Government’s assets and liabilities, including borrowing by the Scottish ministers. That would provide important information about the impact of past decisions on future budgets and potential risks to financial sustainability. The Government has committed to producing a consolidated account that covers the whole public sector in Scotland, but that is now overdue.

Thirdly, on performance reporting, the performance report that is included in the consolidated accounts complies with reporting requirements and the accounts direction. However, the accounts still do not report on the performance of individual portfolios or the Scottish Government as a whole, on the outcomes that it seeks to achieve. There is a need for more detailed and transparent performance reporting that links spending with outcomes, in line with the Parliament’s new budget process.

My report on the 2017-18 consolidated accounts is intended to support parliamentary scrutiny of the Government’s finances. It provides assurance and identifies a number of areas for further improvement.

As always, we will do our best to answer the committee’s questions.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you very much, Auditor General. I invite Iain Gray to ask the first question.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

I want to ask about the support to private companies through the provision of loan finance, which is the second of the newer elements of the consolidated accounts to which the Auditor General referred. The report says:

“Publicly available information about the extent of the loans is limited.”

You reiterated that in your opening remarks. Commercial confidentiality is one of the reasons why the Scottish Government has argued that it has to limit what information is available. Is it reasonable to withhold information for that reason, or is the Scottish Government being overcautious in doing so?

Caroline Gardner
link

I will answer that question on two levels. First, the consolidated accounts do not contain very much information about any of the support to private companies. That is contained in notes to the accounts. However, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Economy and Fair Work has provided information in more detail to the Finance and Constitution Committee compared with what is included in the accounts in most circumstances. I think that there is a case for more transparency not just on the loan support and other guarantees that are provided, but on the principles that the Government intends to use in making decisions about that support—on the overall amount available, what factors it takes into account, and what risk it is prepared to bear. There is a case for greater transparency in general.

Secondly, on commercial sensitivity, I accept that there are circumstances in which there may be a good argument for keeping information confidential for a short period of time—for example, while a significant negotiation is under way or while a significant contract is under procurement—but the commercial sensitivity test should be applied sparingly and should be time limited. The Government should cover that as part of its framework. Given the inevitable risks that are associated with such support and the fact that the Government’s appetite for providing it appears to be increasing over time, it is important that Parliament has that framework to let it understand better what is happening in practice.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

On transparency on the principles and the framework, is it correct to say that you are specifically recommending to the Scottish Government that it produce a framework that outlines the criteria that it will apply and the potential scale of support for private companies?

Caroline Gardner
link

Exactly.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

That is a specific recommendation.

Caroline Gardner
link

Yes. I have recommended that the framework should be public and that it should cover things such as the capacity for providing support, the risk appetite and the criteria that will be used in assessing individual cases.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

I presume that you have not had a response to that recommendation yet, because the accounts are new.

Caroline Gardner
link

I do not think that we have yet had a response in the annual audit report process. I ask Stephen Boyle to pick that up.

10:15

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

We have had no confirmation that that forms part of the Government’s planned response to the report. We will continue to follow that through in the course of our audit work over the next few months.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I confess my ignorance. What is the remit of the internal audit directorate?

Caroline Gardner
link

It provides the internal audit service to the Scottish Government and to a number of other public bodies that opt in to receiving their internal audit service in that way.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Out of curiosity, what are those other public bodies?

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

We are talking about a range of public bodies. Some that come to mind are the Scottish Public Pensions Agency, Transport Scotland and Registers of Scotland. The financial results of many of the bodies involved are captured in the consolidated accounts for the Government.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

NHS boards are not among those bodies.

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

No—you are right. The internal audit directorate does not provide internal audit services to NHS boards, although its work would cover the Scottish Government health and social care directorate.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I am a bit alarmed that paragraph 46 says that

“the Internal Audit Directorate ... does not comply with significant aspects of the standards.”

In the next paragraph, the report says that

“significant improvements are required in audit planning, audit documentation, audit reporting and management review.”

That is all pretty basic stuff, in which you are saying that there are deficiencies.

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

Those are important matters, which we have reported to the Government under its governance arrangements, as well as capturing them in the report.

The scope of our work is under auditing standards. That requires us to look at the work of internal audit as something that external auditors would do routinely on an annual basis. We identified deficiencies against some of the public sector internal audit standards, but certainly not all of them. We thought that the deficiencies that we identified were material and that improvement was required.

I am pleased to say that the Scottish Government’s internal audit directorate has taken the matter very seriously and has invested in what it is describing as a “back to basics” approach to ensure that there is on-going work to improvement its arrangements.

It is probably worth mentioning that a host of improvements and changes have been made in the internal audit directorate over a number of years in an effort to transform the service. We have regular dialogue with the directorate, and we are confident that the work that it is doing will improve the standard of provision.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Is there a timescale for that?

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

The internal audit directorate gave an update to the Scottish Government’s audit committee in September, and it is content to track that progress. We will pick that up through a review of the directorate’s work early in 2019.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Our of interest, what is the line of reporting for the internal audit directorate?

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

The director of internal audit reports to the Scottish Government’s director general for the Scottish exchequer. In addition, the directorate reports the outcomes of its work to the audit committees of the organisations to which it provides services. For the Scottish Government, it reports to the Scottish Government’s audit and assurance committee. For the other public bodies to which it provides services, it reports to their audit committees.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Could you say a wee bit about the forecasting that has to be used, which you mention in paragraph 28? For my sins, I also serve on the Finance and Constitution Committee, which sees huge variations between the forecasts from the Scottish Fiscal Commission and those from the relevant United Kingdom Government agency—the Office for Budget Responsibility. As I understand it, the Scottish Government is tied to using the forecasts from the Fiscal Commission, but there are big differences between its forecasts and those of the OBR. Does that present us with difficulties in getting more accurate forecasts for the budget in years to come?

Caroline Gardner
link

One of the starting points for my report to you this time is that the Scottish Government’s finances are becoming more complex and volatile—more risky, to put it crudely—because of the new financial powers. That would be the case anyway, because we are now reliant on taxes that are raised in Scotland, which reflect the performance of the Scottish economy relative to the UK economy. However, the fiscal framework means that volatility is even greater, because of the interaction between the Fiscal Commission’s forecasts about what is happening to the Scottish economy and Scottish taxes and the OBR’s forecasts for the UK economy, which affect the block-grant adjustment. The way in which those two factors move can either reduce the impact on the Scottish budget or amplify it.

A couple of weeks ago, I produced a briefing on the risk in the Scottish budget, which I sent to the Finance and Constitution Committee for its interest and information. The issue is one of the factors that mean that financial management is more difficult for the Government, which reinforces the importance of the recommendations that I am making in this report for things such as a consolidated public sector account and clarity about the principles that will be used for the new borrowing powers, as well as support for private companies.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

The fact that there is such great variation between the estimates and forecasting of the two bodies certainly challenges the Finance and Constitution Committee.

VAT assignment is coming soon. We understand that that will be based on surveys and estimates rather than on any actual outturn data, which we understand is difficult to gather and is not recorded as Scottish in that sense. Does the fact that we are constantly dealing with survey data when estimating VAT assignment present any difficulty?

Caroline Gardner
link

I do not know any more than the Finance and Constitution Committee does about the basis that will finally be agreed for apportioning VAT receipts to Scotland, but I understand that you are correct that it will be based on survey data, which, clearly, brings with it risks that will need to be managed. We will be watching closely to see what the agreement says and the way in which it is implemented in practice by the two Governments.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

In paragraph 24 of your report, you say that the value of the common agricultural policy to Scotland is about £500 million. I do not want to make any political points about that but when do we need to know that that money will continue to come to Scotland, so that we can work it into the Scottish budget?

Caroline Gardner
link

Anyone who is making firm predictions about the impact of EU withdrawal is on dodgy ground at the moment. Stephen Boyle can tell you where we are in terms of the current position.

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

There is probably not much more to add. We conduct an annual audit of Scotland’s share of the UK agricultural policy money. This year’s audit is scheduled to conclude in February. Thereafter, as the Auditor General suggested, there is uncertainty about what will happen after Brexit day and whether there will be any transitional period. Those issues will inevitably play into the duration of that funding as it relates to Europe and the question of whether the funding comes from the UK Government or the Scottish Government thereafter.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I was just asking whether the amount of money has to be announced by a certain point—for example, February every year—so that it can start to work its way through the budget. Is that the case, or are things a bit more flexible?

Caroline Gardner
link

I think that, in line with the assurances from the UK Government, the budget will be based on an assumption that the current EU funding period will continue. However, none of us knows what will happen if there is a no-deal outcome or if there is a change in the UK policy for the way in which that funding is allocated across the UK. That is another element of uncertainty in the budget that will need to be managed.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

There are a few more questions, so I ask everyone to keep the questions and answers as tight as possible.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

I have a couple of questions on the financial statements. On page 88 of the consolidated accounts document, note 8 says that the figure for “Inventories” was £106 million in 2017-18 and also £106 million in 2016-17. Is that a coincidence?

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

I think that it is exactly that—a coincidence. I will give a little bit of context. If my memory serves me, it predominately relates to the stock of theatre supplies that individual hospitals hold. It is subject to audit each year and it is just—

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

Is it not just the same stuff getting older?

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

We are confident that it has been appropriately covered.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

On page 89, you mention that some of the comparative numbers have had to be “restated”, which, as I understand it, happens either to make the statement consistent because the accounting methodology has been changed, or because there is an error that needs to be corrected. Are there any other restatements in the financial statements?

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

I will do my best to start with that point. Note 9a gives an analysis of the loans or non-current financial assets that the Scottish Government has across a range of categories, from loans to Scottish Water to housing loans to the very specific one that the Government has sought to include in this year’s note. A consequence is that it has needed to restate it to provide more detail and transparency on the loans to farmers that were a consequence of some of the challenges with the IT system. We think that it is welcome and appropriate to provide additional transparency in the financial statements.

I am not sure about other restatements. I will just check.

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

Off the top of my head, I am not aware of any restatements with regard to the core financial statements. We can double-check that for you.

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

It is not in the core financial statements but, in relation to the First Minister’s benefit in kind of Bute house, a restatement was required to the 2016-17 figure. That was as a result of an error that was identified by the Scottish Government in the calculation of the benefit in kind that is provided by the accommodation at Bute house in Edinburgh. The restatement was required because of an error over a number of years, which the Scottish Government picked up in August last year. It held discussions with Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs to arrange a back payment of £16,765 to cover it. As part of our discussions with the Scottish Government, we asked that the prior-year figure should be restated to bring it into line with the current-year figure in 2017-18.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

Was the settlement figure borne by the public purse or by the First Minister?

Caroline Gardner
link

The Scottish Government took the decision to meet it because it was the result of an error in a civil servant’s calculation.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

That does not change the fact that it is the personal liability of the First Minister, so her tax has been paid by the Government.

Caroline Gardner
link

Given the period over which it occurred and the relatively small amount of the money involved, the Government took the decision to directly fund the adjustment of the benefit in kind for the use of Bute house.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

I think that we need to think further about that.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Auditor General, in your opening statement, you told us that the Scottish Government borrowed £450 million this year for capital funds, which is up to its limit. Overall, the net borrowings are £1.036 billion.

You said that there is no borrowing policy in place; I have written down the words “needs to have one”. Can you clarify whether a borrowing policy should be put in place? Do other jurisdictions have one, and how imperative is it that we have one?

Caroline Gardner
link

The new borrowing powers are a significant element of the financial powers that were devolved under the Scotland Act 2016. There is an overall £3 billion cap for borrowing, there is a £450 million a year annual limit and the Government has net borrowing of £1.036 billion. Those are significant amounts of money. I have made a couple of recommendations that relate to the new borrowing powers. The first, as you quite rightly said, is that there should be a statement of the policies and principles that the Government will apply in using those borrowing powers to guide its decision making and to support parliamentary scrutiny of the budget and the Government’s financial statements.

The overall total of £3 billion is a relatively small amount of money, and it is important that the Government thinks over the long term about how it wants to use that to support its investment in the assets and infrastructure of Scotland as a whole. It is also important that it makes sure that it draws that down at the right time, rather than borrowing before it needs to and incurring the associated interest costs.

Other jurisdictions and Governments have that approach, which is part of good financial management. In many ways, it is close to the prudential approach that applies to local government borrowing, through which councils are required to have a policy and a long-term plan for the way in which they will use their ability to borrow. It is entirely consistent with good financial management.

10:30

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Have you recommended the approach previously and, if so, when and what has happened as a result?

Caroline Gardner
link

From memory, it was one of the recommendations in my report on the consolidated accounts last year, as we knew that the borrowing powers were coming. The Government has not yet published a policy and principles, which is something that the committee may want to follow up with the Government.

It is worth noting that that borrowing does not appear on an audited account anywhere. It comes in and out through the consolidated fund, which is a cash account and which does not have a statement of financial position—a balance sheet, as it is more commonly known. The borrowing is not recognised on the balance sheet within the consolidated accounts. For transparency, it would be good for the Government to fulfil its commitment to having consolidated public sector accounts including a balance sheet with all its assets and liabilities.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

That is useful. Do you have any sense of when the borrowing policy will be in place?

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

The Government is considering how and when that will be developed. We expect that much of that work will fall to the new directorate for the Scottish exchequer as part of its core responsibilities. As I said earlier, we will continue to engage closely with the Government on that over the next few months.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I have two questions. First, before the new borrowing powers were introduced, there was a limit in that no more than 5 per cent of the Government’s revenue could be used to fund repayments for borrowing, private finance initiative deals and all the rest of it. Is that still the case and, if so, is there now a case for reviewing that 5 per cent limit? For example, if it was allowed to go up to 6 per cent, that would in principle allow a 20 per cent increase in capital spend. Is that still happening?

Caroline Gardner
link

The 5 per cent limit is still in place. The Government has set that limit for itself, so it is not like the £450 million annual cap, which is within the fiscal framework. The issue is closely linked to the questions that Mr Kerr asked about a framework for borrowing. It is part of the Government’s overall capacity for investment.

I ask Michael Oliphant to update you on where we are with that.

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

The limit is still in place. The medium-term financial strategy, or “Scotland’s Fiscal Outlook: The Scottish Government’s Five Year Financial Strategy”, as it was called, which was published during the summer, outlines the projections and where the Government is at and plans to be against the 5 per cent limit. If memory serves me right, it is close to 4 per cent at the moment. As the Scottish Government borrows more through capital borrowing such as the £450 million that it borrowed in 2017-18, the figure will increase towards 5 per cent. Obviously, the repayments that are made on previous borrowing will have the opposite effect. As members will be aware from the 2018-19 budget, the Scottish Government plans to borrow a further £450 million, which again will increase the pressure. There are some changes to the status of regulatory asset base funding for rail projects, and we still have to find out from the Government how those will affect the 5 per cent affordability cap.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Obviously, as the Government increases its revenue—last year, it increased income tax, so we would expect revenue to go up—the limit will be 5 per cent of a higher figure. If we increase revenue sufficiently, that will perhaps give the ability to fund more than 5 per cent. Would it be prudent to look at that 5 per cent figure as part of the review and in designing a new policy for the new circumstances?

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

As the Scottish Government is outlining a policy on borrowing, I think that it will look at the 5 per cent affordability cap. It is a self-imposed cap, so it is within the Government’s gift to raise or lower it. As you say, as the total budget increases or perhaps decreases, that obviously affects the underlying amount behind the 5 per cent.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I want to go back and follow up on Mr Coffey’s questioning.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Briefly, please.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Yes. We have seen the issues in getting our share of the EU agricultural money, but there is a wider question about when we will stop paying our annual EU contribution at the current levels, whether that is next year or at the start of 2020-21. Obviously, that contribution will be substantially lower. The Scottish Parliament information centre has indicated that the existing gross figure for Scotland’s share of EU contributions from the UK annually is around £1.6 billion. If we got that money and funded every single EU programme that exists in Scotland right across the board, we would have £800 million a year left to spend on other things.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Briefly, please. You should ask a question.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Is any work being done to look at the impact of Scotland getting its share of the EU UK funding two or three years ahead?

Caroline Gardner
link

You would have to ask the Government that question. I imagine that it will be undertaking work on that. We have not done any work on that at this stage.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Exhibit 1 on page 6 of your report shows “Total expenditure (resource and capital)”. Will you clarify where the local government spending is? Is it under each portfolio headline?

Caroline Gardner
link

No. The main local government settlement is under the “Communities, Social Security and Equalities” line in the table.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Is the money that is given to local authorities and is then spent on education under “Communities, Social Security and Equalities” or under “Education and Skills”?

Caroline Gardner
link

Most of it is within the settlement and is therefore under “Communities” in the line that I have just referred the committee to.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Okay. The “Education and Skills” budget line shows the largest underspend of any Government department. However, we understand from the First Minister that that is her number 1 priority, so that seems to me to be a little strange. Do you have any explanation for such a large underspend?

Caroline Gardner
link

Yes. Pages 53 to 63 of the accounts include some information about those. I ask Stephen Boyle to talk members through the specifics of that line.

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

I refer to page 55 of the consolidated accounts. The accounts follow a similar format whereby all the individual Scottish Government departments analyse their revenue and expenditure over the year. The set format is that any variance against budget that is over £3 million comes is accompanied by an explanation. Specifically, there are a couple of explanations that relate to the education department, one of which relates to the calculation of student loans, which is captured under that budget heading.

Another variance is the lower than anticipated funding that was required by the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council during the year. We will probably need to come back to the committee in writing on the detail of that and what lies underneath it, or the committee could explore that directly with the Scottish Government.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I think that I would like both to happen. Will you come back with more information in writing, Mr Boyle?

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

Of course.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Members have no further questions about the consolidated accounts for the Auditor General and her team.

I put on record my thanks to Iain Gray MSP for his service on the committee. This is his last meeting with us, and I am very sorry to see him go. I thank him for all his scrutiny.

10:38 Meeting continued in private until 11:13.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 113
  3. 10:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 76

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.