Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Reports

“The 2017/18 audit of NHS Highland”

Thursday 1 November 2018 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 09:00–10:00 Committee business 113 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

113 contributions
Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I welcome our witnesses today: Caroline Gardner, the Auditor General for Scotland; Leigh Johnston, senior manager, performance and best value, Audit Scotland; Joanne Brown, director at Grant Thornton UK LLP; and Pat Kenny, director at Deloitte LLP. I invite the Auditor General to make a short opening statement.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The first report this morning concerns financial pressures in NHS Ayrshire and Arran. The external auditor gave an unqualified opinion on the 2017-18 accounts for the board, but it is facing significant financial and performance challenges. In 2017-18, the board needed £23 million of brokerage from the Scottish Government to achieve financial balance. At the beginning of the year, the board’s potential deficit was £13.2 million, but that increased to £23 million during the year. The board faces an extremely challenging position in 2018-19 and beyond. It is projecting a deficit of £22.4 million in 2018-19, the current financial year, with an additional £13 million in 2019-20 before projecting a balanced budget in 2020-21.

An external review of the board’s approach to efficiency and transformation concluded that its current plans are not substantial enough to achieve long-term financial sustainability. NHS Ayrshire and Arran will find it difficult to address the financial and performance challenges that it faces and to implement the recommendations of the external review. That represents a significant leadership challenge.

The second report highlights financial pressures in NHS Highland. Again, the auditor gave an unqualified opinion on the 2017-18 accounts but reported on the scale of the challenges that the board faces in achieving financial balance. In 2017-18, the board delivered £35 million of savings, but it still required brokerage of £15 million. It faces an extremely challenging position in 2018-19 and beyond. It has identified that it needs to make £52 million savings in the current financial year. So far, savings of £30 million have been identified, leaving a funding gap of £22 million.

NHS Highland plans to produce a longer-term recovery plan, underpinned by a more detailed operational plan setting out new models of care in the Highlands. It has engaged the help of external consultants. Stable leadership will be needed to implement those plans, and I anticipate that the board’s financial position will deteriorate before the underlying issues are addressed and performance improves. The chief executive leaves the board at the end of December and the director of finance is acting on an interim basis. That obviously creates risks around the future leadership of the board.

I am joined by Pat Kenny from Deloitte, who is the appointed auditor for NHS Ayrshire and Arran; Joanne Brown from Grant Thornton, who is the appointed auditor for NHS Highland; and Leigh Johnston from Audit Scotland. Together, we will do our best to answer the committee’s questions.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you, Auditor General. I will ask Willie Coffey to open questioning.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I have a few questions about the Ayrshire and Arran report and situation. As you said, Auditor General—and it has been well covered—the brokerage amounts in the past couple of years have been pretty substantial. Your report preceded the cabinet secretary’s announcement that they would be written off, not just for Ayrshire and Arran but for all the health boards that have received brokerage in the past five years, which is welcome.

I want to explore some of the potential reasons behind that overspend. I do not doubt for a minute that that level of expenditure was required to deliver healthcare to the citizens of Ayrshire and Arran, but I would like to understand the main reasons behind that substantial overspend.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I will make a couple of points and then ask Pat Kenny to come in. First, Mr Coffey referred to the cabinet secretary’s announcement about writing off brokerage, which is obviously welcome for the boards that are affected. It is worth noting that the financial projections of both the boards that I am reporting on this morning do not include any provision for repayment, so it does not change the position that I have brought to the committee’s attention today.

Secondly, Mr Coffey is right that every board is trying to balance the need to manage its financial targets, its activity targets for things such as waiting times and the quality of patient care. That is why the challenges are so difficult to resolve. Pat Kenny will talk through the financial reasons for the overspend last year.

Pat Kenny Deloitte LLP
link

The board went into the financial year with an estimated deficit of around £13 million. That was due to underlying financial pressures—overspending in acute services, reliance on locum and agency bank personnel and that sort of thing. That underlying financial pressure of £13 million increased to £23 million during the year. The main reason for that was additional demand. The board was assuming that certain beds would be closed during the year, but that was not possible due to demand. The nursing costs associated with keeping those beds open resulted in another £6.2 million overspend. The balance of the overspend came from a failure to deliver assumed efficiency savings during the year, and that takes us to the £23 million brokerage figure.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

We know that Ayrshire and Arran’s health indicators are not as good as the rest of Scotland’s. Is there something unique about the overspend in Ayrshire and Arran that we are not seeing in the rest of Scotland, such as the demand?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

From our work across the national health service in Scotland, I would say that all boards are facing significant financial pressures for very understandable reasons to do with demographic change—there is an ageing population, which brings with it increasing demand. However, each board tends to have a different combination of factors that cause its specific local challenges.

As Pat Kenny said, Ayrshire and Arran NHS Board had made its budget dependent on assumptions about the ability to close some beds, but in practice those beds were needed to meet the demand for unscheduled care. The other savings proved difficult to achieve in practice. Every board will have its own set of circumstances.

There will be three section 22 reports this year on NHS boards in which these challenges have resulted in the need for brokerage. However, the report that I published last week on the NHS as a whole showed that all boards are struggling with balancing the three sides of the triangle—finances, waiting times and the quality of care.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

How much of the transformation agenda that we expect Ayrshire and Arran and other health boards to deliver can the boards control and deliver themselves? Three local councils make up the health board authority in Ayrshire and Arran—North Ayrshire, East Ayrshire and South Ayrshire—and, if we look at factors such as daily discharge, we will see a variable pattern across the authorities. How much can the boards effect change themselves and how much are they relying on their partners in the local authorities to make an effort to get performance up?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There is no doubt that, in every health board area, tackling that agenda depends on the whole health and social care system working well. The integration joint boards are increasingly important in doing that. Does Pat Kenny want to say anything about the specifics in Ayrshire and Arran?

Pat Kenny Deloitte LLP
link

A combination of both factors is needed to deliver the savings that are required. I am the auditor for the IJB and the councils in Ayrshire, and they are making good progress on moving some care from acute services to the community. There are some excellent examples in the health and social care space of improvements in things such as care at home, and end-of-life care is another good example of progress. However, there is still a long way to go in moving the services from the acute to the community side. There is a feeling—certainly from the health board perspective—that the community sector is not yet resilient enough to absorb the level of demand that will allow efficiencies to be made in the acute side.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Is it fair to say that no health board has complete control over the transformation agenda and that health boards rely on local authorities playing their part, too?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The health and social care system depends on health boards and local authorities working well together. In a few weeks’ time, we will publish a report on progress with the integration authorities, but the bigger challenge is the whole prevention agenda and the way in which we help people to remain healthy as they grow older, rather than needing support for long periods of their lives.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

You have mentioned that the staff agency and locum costs were quite substantial but were coming down. There has been a consistent problem in attracting NHS staff to work in Ayrshire and Arran. The price of that is the higher fees that are paid in agency and locum costs. I think that Alex Neil raised that issue in the committee previously. Are you aware of any national work that is going on to reduce that dependency and the high cost of that factor, which hits this health board and others?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That has been a big focus for the Scottish Government at the national level. The report that I published last week showed that agency costs, although there were still high, had reduced slightly in 2017-18.

Leigh Johnston will say something about the work that is going on at the national level.

Leigh Johnston Audit Scotland
link

Work is going on to try to attract people. I think that we will hear from NHS Highland that that is a big issue for it, too. The Scottish Government is undertaking a number of programmes of work to try to attract staff. Project lift, for example, is relatively new. It encourages people to take on more senior roles. Both reports allude to the fact that leadership is a challenge as well as the staff who deal with things. However, a lot of boards focus on reducing their staffing costs, as they are one of the things that they can try to reduce over a period of time.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I presume that they can do that only if they successfully recruit locally. The problems that there are in recruiting locally to deliver the service are an issue.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

They are. We know that, at the national level, the workforce is under pressure. We are seeing increasing difficulties in recruiting, some very long-term vacancies, rising turnover and risking sickness absence. That is another indicator of strain on the workforce. We are starting to see some improvements in national workforce planning to deal with that.

At the other end of the problem, there are short-term issues such as making better use of locum staff rather than agency staff, who tend to be more expensive and less familiar with local health services.

That is certainly an area that is a significant problem, and there is no quick fix. That will take time to resolve.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I want to pick up on a point that Mr Coffey made about workforce planning and training. One of my concerns about workforce planning in the NHS relates to the training of nurses. The concern relates to how many nurses are being trained, how many Scotland-domiciled nurses are being trained for the places that are available to them, and the places that are available to nursing students from overseas who are perhaps more likely to return to their home countries to nurse there. Did your audits look at whether the Scottish Government is training enough Scotland-domiciled nurses? Are there enough nurse training places for Scotland-domiciled students, who are more likely to work in our NHS hospitals?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have a programme of work that is looking at workforce planning because of its importance to the NHS and the health and social care system more widely. We do not have the details of that in front of us today, but we can certainly refer back to that after the meeting.

In broad terms, we have found that there is a need for improvement in the workforce planning that is required, particularly in looking at the demand side of the equation. Our first report on that found that the number of staff who were being trained tended to be the number needed to replace staff who were likely to retire and leave the service in other ways. However, we know that demand is increasing and that changing models of care mean that we need different types of staff in different places. We have reported on that, but that is not in the reports that we are discussing.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I have a specific question for Leigh Johnston. You talked about project lift, which is to encourage people. Surely the best form of encouragement by the Government is to make training places available for people who want to nurse in our NHS. In your analysis of the programmes to encourage more people to work in our NHS, did you do an analysis of the available places?

09:15

Leigh Johnston Audit Scotland
link

No, we did not. I think that the Royal College of Nursing is looking at that issue. In our recent “NHS in Scotland” report we recommend that more work needs to be done on workforce planning. The Scottish Government has recently published three workforce plans, but at a local level there needs to be more work on planning and on how the NHS will recruit people and, as you say, train people for the future. However, that is a long-term undertaking.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

How much is being spent on project lift?

Leigh Johnston Audit Scotland
link

I do not have those details.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

It seems to me that you can spend as much money as you want encouraging people, but if you do not make the training places available, it is a bit of a waste of money.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Paragraph 26 says:

“Following discussion with the Scottish Government in June 2017, NHS Ayrshire and Arran agreed to work with an external partner—”

PWC—

“to review the board’s approach to efficiency and transformation.”

Further discussions in early 2018 resulted in the appointment of an improvement director. However, in paragraph 23 you say:

“there is currently a lack of attention being given to detailed medium to long term financial planning by the board.”

That does not sound too good.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

What underlies those two paragraphs is, first, the board’s recognition, with support from the Scottish Government, that it needed to get to grips with the challenges that it faced, and secondly, the urgent nature of the short-term problems faced by the board was getting in the way of its ability to think about the longer-term picture and what was needed to deal with that. The latter is a theme that is common to my reporting on the NHS.

Pat Kenny will be able to talk you through the specifics that he is seeing in Ayrshire and Arran.

Pat Kenny Deloitte LLP
link

What we were looking for there was a linkage between the medium and long-term financial planning and the transformational planning. Obviously, for the transformation to be successful, or to deliver the targets that it needed to, the two would have to be compatible. Given the short-term pressures that the board was under, during the audit we found that there was a deficit in the board’s medium and long-term financial planning. Those plans were simply not available to the auditors at the time of the audit.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

From the bare bones of the report, it does not sound as if the board has had a grip of the situation.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The board recognises the scale of the situation and is very focused on the immediate actions that it needs to take to halt the decline that we are seeing in its performance and financial position. However, there is no doubt that it will be very challenging for the board to make the changes that are required at the same time as continuing to deliver services.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But this did not happen overnight.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

No. I have been reporting since 2012 about the danger that the focus on short-term targets is obscuring the underlying pressures that face all health boards, including NHS Ayrshire and Arran.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The board has got an improvement director in place. What is the improvement director’s remit?

Pat Kenny Deloitte LLP
link

It is basically to turn around the financial performance of the board and implement the transformational change that is required to enable the board to operate within its financial envelope. I believe that the director has significant experience of similar work in other parts of the health sector.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I am looking at some of the reasons that have been given for the overspend—this touches on something that Willie Coffey was talking about. Paragraph 19 says:

“A key factor is the older age profile and high levels of deprivation in the Ayrshire and Arran population.”

That will not go away, so how will the board effect the changes that are referred to in paragraph 17?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I think that the underlying solution to the challenges at NHS Ayrshire and Arran, and right across the NHS, is about changing the way in which services are provided. That is absolutely in line with the Government’s 2020 vision for providing much more health and social care in people’s homes, or close to their homes, and avoiding unnecessary admissions, making it easier for people to be discharged quickly if they do need to be admitted to hospital.

The problem is that we are not seeing progress happening quickly enough on that, partly because of the continuing focus on short-term financial targets and on the local development plan targets, which tend to be for aspects of the acute services, such as waiting times for elective treatment or accident and emergency waiting times. I have been recommending for some time that boards need to find space to pull back to look at how the overall system works, to understand what services are being provided in the community and the impact that they are having, and to rebalance the system to meet the needs of the ageing population—and, as you said, that is a factor that is not going to go away.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

It seems to me from looking at the report that the problem has been there for some years but, according to what you say in paragraph 23, the board has not been addressing it. The Government seems to have stepped in and put a bit of pressure on and has put someone in place to help the board along. That is not wrong, but it seems that this has been allowed to go on for quite some time, and the board has not been addressing the problems. Is there not a better mechanism for picking this up and for ensuring that boards get the support that they should have?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I do not think that the board is alone in the challenges that it faces. Two boards are being reported on today that face similar problems. The committee is well aware of the challenges that NHS Tayside has faced in achieving financial balance, and my report last week on the NHS as a whole shows that the whole system is facing similar pressures with both financial performance and performance on such things as waiting times declining. The underlying reason for that is the ageing population that we have in Scotland and the changing types of care that we all need as we get older.

The signs of that pressure have been visible during the time that I have been in the job. I welcome the fact that the Government is now trying to make space for that longer-term view. We have seen some announcements from the cabinet secretary over the past few weeks that demonstrate the commitment to making a bit of breathing space to tackle the underlying challenges, but you are right to say that they are not new issues. I have been reporting on them for some time now.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

You mentioned that there are pressures right across the system in every board, although we are focusing this morning on Ayrshire and Arran and on Highland. If you add up the number of partnership boards and the number of NHS boards, plus the three regional structures that have been created, that is a total of 56 different organisations, each with its own board, its own chief executive—many of whom are on film-star salaries—its own structural finance director and all that kind of stuff. Given the financial pressures, has the time not come to look at the massive overhead that is involved in having 56 different organisations—not including the 32 councils—delivering health and social care in Scotland?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I do not want to veer into the territory that is covered by my report on the NHS, which was published last week and which I know the committee will consider soon. However, that report talks about the growing complexity of the governance of the health and social care system in Scotland and the risk that that poses to people’s ability, first, to get the right leaders in place to do what is needed across Scotland and, secondly, to be clear about who is accountable for what and therefore what progress we are making.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

We can discuss those issues when we consider your latest report. It is quite interesting that Highland is the only part of Scotland where there is only one board delivering the single agency model for health and social care, although there are 31 partnerships in total. Although Highland clearly has financial pressures, is there any evidence so far that the single agency model is better or worse at delivering health and social care according to plan?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is a very good question and one that we are considering as we finalise our report on health and social care integration, which is due for publication in the next few weeks.

At this stage, I can say that it is clear from the report on NHS Highland that the lead agency model is not a panacea and that there are still financial pressures in the health board and the council. The different accountabilities that those bodies have and the financial pressures that they face more widely constrain how matters are dealt with. We are watching the situation closely to see how it develops.

Joanne Brown Grant Thornton UK LLP
link

That is fair. The NHS Highland report outlines that the board faces challenges in adult social care, including in relation to the financial sustainability of that service, and in its working relationship with the council through the lead agency model. Although the board can demonstrate good outcomes from the model, there are underlying challenges in it, including in relation to how governance operates for the board.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I return to an issue that the Auditor General specifically mentioned in relation to Ayrshire but which also affects NHS Highland and, indeed other boards. One cause of the problems is an underestimation of the demand for services, particularly acute services. That is one of the reasons why the 100 beds were not closed down. In this day and age, we know the size of the population in every area, the complexities that are likely to be faced—they are changing, but we have a good idea of what they are—the age structure of the population and historical demand. We can predict accurately the number of people who are likely to be seen at an A&E department day by day. Is the starting point not to get a far better handle on and a more professional, systematic approach to demand forecasting?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We are seeing progress on that issue—I will ask Leigh Johnston to talk about what we understand about the Government work that is under way—but there is another dimension to it. The committee has heard a lot about optimism bias, particularly in relation to information technology projects. The focus on financial and waiting time targets means that there is a degree of optimism bias in boards’ financial planning, too—they tend to make assumptions that they will achieve savings that are, in practice, very difficult to achieve. Both sides of the equation need to be tackled.

I ask Leigh Johnston to say a bit about demand planning.

Leigh Johnston Audit Scotland
link

Work is being undertaken to plan better. We must also think about the issue in the context of integration and how more care is being moved into the community. The hope is that, in future, there will be less unscheduled care.

Winter pressure is the other issue to which the Government would point. That occurs yearly, but the winter this year was particularly bad, which had an impact on NHS Ayrshire and Arran.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Are we sure that we are talking about overspending? Were the boards allocated budgets that were too low in the first place? For example, reference has been made to the economic and social profile of Ayrshire. It is one of the poorest parts of Scotland, and we know that, to a large extent, demand for health and social care is driven by levels of poverty and deprivation. Is there overspending, or are we really talking about underfunding?

The chief executive of NHS Ayrshire and Arran doubles up as the chief executive of the west of Scotland regional planning group. The chief executive of NHS Lothian, which is another health board that is in trouble, also doubles up in a similar role. Does that not send out the wrong message? Given the situation in Ayrshire, should the chief executive not be working full time on NHS Ayrshire and Arran?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I will start, but Pat Kenny may want to add to my response.

On whether the budget as a whole is sufficient, health boards are funded—Alex Neil will know this better than anybody else in the room—on the basis of a national formula, which aims to take account of a number of factors, including the make-up of the population, its age profile, levels of deprivation and so on. The Government has been making more rapid progress towards ensuring that everybody achieves their funding under the national resource allocation committee formula.

As I say in the report on the NHS that was published last week, across a period of time, the Government has succeeded in keeping health service funding slightly ahead of inflation. However, funding on a per capita basis tends to lag behind inflation, and we know that healthcare costs increase more quickly than inflation as a whole and that the population is ageing. Therefore, there is no doubt that the health service budget as a whole is under pressure. In my view, it is probably not possible simply to buy our way out of the challenges that we face. The answer is in reshaping how care is provided in order to meet the needs of an ageing population.

09:30

The leadership examples that Alex Neil touched on are another feature of the complexity of the structures that we now see in the health service and the number of bodies that are involved. That is compounded by the difficulties that the health service is having in attracting the number and quality of chief executives needed to do the work. My report on NHS Highland highlights that the chief executive there will leave by the end of the year, and we know that a number of other very experienced and senior chief executives have indicated their intention to leave or retire, so the pressure on leadership will only get worse. For me, that is one reason for looking at the way in which the NHS is governed and structured to ensure that we make the best use of the leadership that is there.

Does Pat Kenny want to add to that?

Pat Kenny Deloitte LLP
link

I would add only that, in Ayrshire and Arran, as in most other boards in Scotland, there has been limited progress in moving the set-aside budget for acute services into the community sector. That is where the biggest bang for the buck would be in terms of improvement overall. More progress in moving the set-aside budget could have an impact on the ground.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It might be useful if you explained what the set-aside budget is.

Pat Kenny Deloitte LLP
link

Basically, it is the provision that was set aside for acute services when the health and social care partnerships were formed, with the objective of moving it to the community sector over a period.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

Auditor General, I want to follow on from the answer that you just gave Alex Neil on the difficulty of finding leadership with the capacity to address some of the problems. As you pointed out, in Ayrshire and Arran, the chief executive and the finance director are leaving, and we have seen similar issues in Tayside, for example. In your answer to Mr Neil, you said that we cannot buy our way out of the problems and that we have to change how we deliver health and social care. However, you have also said on a number of occasions that the difficulty facing those two boards, and other boards, is in balancing the level of activity and performance needed to deal with demand with the need to balance the books and the finances. Is it not the case that there just simply is not enough money in the health service to do the things that we want it to do?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I point out for the record that it is the chief executive of NHS Highland, not NHS Ayrshire and Arran, who is due to retire, but your point holds.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I need to be careful here, because it is clearly a question of significant Government policy. However, I can say that 42 per cent of the Scottish Government’s overall budget is already spent on the NHS, and that has risen as a proportion over recent years. The challenge of meeting the immediate demand for health services means that there has probably been no alternative to that. However, if we keep on doing it, it will squeeze out the ability to spend on other public services, including equally important ones such as education and other things that will set up Scotland as a country that can thrive in the future, whatever the constitutional arrangements might be.

There is good evidence that continuing to meet demand as it ships up at the hospital door is not the best way of providing care for older people. There is good evidence that we will treat the people of Scotland much better if we provide much more care in the community and in people’s homes or close to home, if we keep them well for as long as possible and if we support them at home for as long as possible. If people are admitted to hospital only when that is best for them and go home as quickly as possible, access for younger people who have more acute needs that can be treated and cured will not be slowed down by the number of older people who have no alternative but to be admitted to hospital. For me, it is not just a matter of whether we should shovel more money into the health service. Of course, the health service is a vital part of society but, if we do not change the way that we provide services, the demands will swamp other equally important public services. On top of that, the current approach is not the best way of looking after people.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

In some of your previous comments about transforming the delivery of services, you talked about the need to create space in which to make that change. My question is more about leadership than finances. In Highland, two of the senior managers have left, while in Tayside, the whole senior management team has moved. Problems have also arisen in boards; as the Highland report points out, there has been a significant turnover of non-executive directors on that board. Are we asking those in leadership positions in our health service to do something that is simply impossible? Is that why they are leaving and why we cannot find replacements?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The very narrow focus that there has been in the past on short-term targets such as achieving in-year financial balance and local development plan standards has tended to mean that people have focused on the short term in certain ways and, as a result, they have had to run faster and faster to try to keep up. Clearly, that is becoming impossible, so there is a link in that respect.

I welcome the cabinet secretary’s announcement of a medium-term financial framework for the NHS, which will help people think about where the local development plan standards fit into that context and will buy them some breathing space to make the sorts of changes that will genuinely address the underlying challenges. The committee might want to explore with the Government how it intends to use that space to build leadership capacity and how it will ensure that that capacity is going into the right things and that the governance is clear and strong enough to deliver what is needed in practice.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

Again, on the issue of leadership, Mr Neil talked about the number of chief executives required under the current system—indeed, I think that he also used the phrase “film-star salaries”. However, in the Highland report, you point out that the number of clinicians who earn more than £200,000 has doubled and that two clinicians now earn £400,000 each per annum. Is there a problem with the salary structure not just on the governance side but on the clinical side of the NHS?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is important to point out that although chief executives are highly paid members of staff, they do, as you said, a very demanding job. Personally, I do not recognise the phrase “film-star salaries”.

As for clinical salaries, clinicians are obviously vital to running the health service, and what we see in Highland is very much an effect of the difficulties in recruiting and retaining people to provide services in remote and rural areas. I ask Joanne Brown and Leigh Johnston to give you a bit more detail about what is happening in Highland.

Joanne Brown Grant Thornton UK LLP
link

With regard to the two individuals highlighted in paragraph 21 of the Highland report, the issue links to wider challenges that NHS Highland faces with regard to agency and locum costs. This is about providing suitable, safe and effective clinical care in the Caithness general hospital and Belford hospital areas—in other words, the areas outwith Inverness—and a challenge for NHS Highland has been to look at service provision across those remote and rural areas, recognising that acute services are based at Raigmore. The question is how locum and agency staff can be used to provide the care that is required at those outlying hospital sites.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

I am sorry—I am not sure that I understand. Are you saying that those two clinicians are earning more £400,000 a year because they are temporary staff on inflated remuneration rather than permanent staff employed by the board?

Joanne Brown Grant Thornton UK LLP
link

In those two instances, the people involved are agency locum staff, and the salaries reflect the nature of the clinical specialisms and skills that are required as well as where they are based. In some of NHS Highland’s outlying hospital sites, there is a requirement for 24-hour care and access to a clinical specialist on that basis. The issue relates to the need to provide that service.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

I am still not sure that I quite understand why somebody is paid £400,000 just because they work in Caithness.

Joanne Brown Grant Thornton UK LLP
link

It is about the specialisms that they provide under their contract, the nature of the clinical services and the nature of the pay arrangements that are in place. It is an on-going and increasing cost for NHS Highland.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

Okay—so are the nurses who work in Caithness, who also work in a rural area, paid twice as much as the nurses at Raigmore hospital?

Joanne Brown Grant Thornton UK LLP
link

I do not have that information to hand. It depends on whether they are agency or locum, the nature of the clinical specialism and where that nurse is based as part of their employment contract.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Auditor General, you talked about measures that have been taken in the past few weeks, including the decision to write off all outstanding brokerage by the end of the 2018-19 financial year. That sounds very welcome, but what is the practical impact of that if, as you said in your opening statement, no provision had been made to pay back that brokerage?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

For the two boards that the committee is looking at today, the financial projections that I have reported to you do not include any plans to repay the brokerage that they have received so far, so their financial position, as they are forecasting it at this stage, remains as challenging up to 2020-21 as it did before the Government announcement on brokerage.

A small number of boards have financial plans that include provision to repay brokerage over a period. Of those, I think that NHS 24 is the most significant. For those boards, having the outstanding brokerage written off will provide them with welcome breathing space to look at their financial forecasting more generally and at how they can use the resources available to them. However, it will make no difference to the financial forecasts for the two boards that are being looked at today.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I will come back to that last point in a second. Although all the brokerage has been written off, it looks as though NHS Ayrshire and Arran will rack it all up again. Your report indicates that the board anticipates that it will require a further £22.4 million of brokerage in 2018-19, but that hinges on high-risk savings being achieved. Therefore, there is the potential for a further write-off. Is it your understanding that, irrespective of how much brokerage is on the books by the end of 2018-19, it will all be written off?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I think that it is fair to say that we are not yet sure. Leigh Johnston may want to say a little bit more about the range of announcements that we have heard recently.

Leigh Johnston Audit Scotland
link

The financial framework was published recently, which will require boards to plan over and break even after a three-year period. They also have a 1 per cent flexibility in their budgets. Other than that, we do not have much detail. We are in the process of working through the framework and understanding what it will mean for the boards. I am sure that the boards will be looking at their forward planning and trying to understand what it will mean for them, but we really do not have details about what it means in practice.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

On the issue of forward planning, paragraph 21 of the Ayrshire and Arran report says that the projected figures are based on the board achieving £26.1 million-worth of savings, of which £9.7 million has either not yet been identified or is identified as “high risk” so may well not happen. I accept that the Government announcement looks very welcome on paper, but is there a risk that the board will not strive in quite the same way to achieve those £26.1 million-worth of savings because it knows that the brokerage will be written off anyway?

Leigh Johnston Audit Scotland
link

The brokerage will be written off in 2019, but the announcements do not address the underlying issue. As I said, we are trying to understand what the three-year break-even requirement and the 1 per cent flexibility mean in practice. Until we have a better understanding of that, we will not know what that means in relation to what the board has said to date about what it is trying to achieve.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I have a question about something that the Auditor General said. Some boards have plans to repay their brokerage, which is a point that was raised when the committee looked at financial planning in education and the college sector. I hesitate to use the word fairness, but is there a concern that boards that have made significant sacrifices and have made significant plans to repay their brokerage will look at this situation and say, “We have cut our cloth very carefully and now we are being penalised for that.”

09:45

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I am sure that those boards will feel slightly hard done by, in the way that you have described. My concern is twofold. First, steps are being taken towards the longer-term financial planning that I have recommended since I have been in this job, which I welcome. However, it is important that long-term planning is done in a way that does not undermine incentives for good financial management and that the space it creates is used to address the underlying challenges that Leigh Johnston described. The demand pressures will only keep increasing and healthcare costs will keep increasing faster than the Scottish Government’s resources are likely to increase. The measures are useful only if they build a bit of breathing space for people to tackle the underlying changes that are required. As I said in my report last week, we need to work with local people and involve them in planning better health services that are more sustainable for an ageing population.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I have a final question on NHS Ayrshire and Arran. Your report says:

“In 2017/18 ... 60 per cent ... of savings were achieved on a recurring basis”.

How does that compare with recurring savings that have been achieved by other boards throughout Scotland? Is 60 per cent a sustainable figure? Ideally, what percentage would you be looking for the board to achieve?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I am racking my brains—I am not sure whether Leigh Johnston can help me. The report that we published last week contained that information for all health boards throughout Scotland. I think that the 60 per cent figure is probably higher than the average. Pat Kenny is nodding, so I will ask him to say something in a moment.

The challenge is that, the higher the level of non-recurring savings, the more the board will be back to square 1 at the beginning of the next financial year, in needing to look at ways of reducing cuts—potentially, by cutting services—in order to balance its budget. We know that that is getting harder for all boards to do each year, and having a high level of non-recurring savings is simply not a sustainable way of delivering health services in the long term. Do you want to comment on NHS Ayrshire and Arran, Pat?

Pat Kenny Deloitte LLP
link

Yes. I confirm that, based on the boards that I audit, the 60 per cent figure is probably above average. Generally, the overreliance on non-recurring savings is a problem throughout the sector. I certainly find that with the boards that I audit.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

Paragraph 3 of the Auditor General’s report on NHS Ayrshire and Arran has a little bit of explanation about brokerage:

“This is a form of loan funding known as brokerage. It is arranged based on assurance from the board that it can repay the brokerage over an agreed period.”

Today we have heard that the board cannot repay the brokerage. What is the value of an assurance from it?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Before the cabinet secretary’s recent announcement, there was an agreement between the Scottish Government and the health board based on that assurance; that was the arrangement that was in place. For a number of years, I have reported that health boards in general are not doing enough long-term financial planning. That places such assurances in question, as you have highlighted.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

When you take representations from the board, how does that affect the rest of your audit?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Jo Brown and Pat Kenny—and every health board auditor—will be looking at the going-concern question in the specific circumstances of their boards. They are considering the assurance around the narrow question of brokerage and the wider quality of financial management and planning, and the assurances that the Government is providing about its commitment to continue to fund health services in that regard. Clearly, however, that judgment is more difficult to make in boards where brokerage is involved than it is in other boards.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

It is more than just the going-concern question—it involves assurances being given that are blatantly not correct. What is your view about the Scottish Government’s part in this? It is providing money without testing that assurance.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is testing the assurance and, in both the boards that are being reported on today, you can see the measures that they are putting in place to make the assurances more robust by providing support for the changes that are needed.

In general terms, I have been reporting for a number of years that the focus has been too much on achieving in-year financial balance and not enough on making sure that the longer-term plans are robust and tested. The two boards that you are looking at today are a symptom of that.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

We come back to the governance issues that we have raised before.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Auditor General, I want to explore workforce planning a wee bit more. It comes up in both reports and we touched on it earlier.

Are we training enough doctors and nurses who are likely to stay and work in our NHS hospitals in Scotland? I recently heard of a young doctor who qualified in Scotland—with the Scottish taxpayer paying for her to train right through university and in our NHS hospitals—and went off to take a job in New Zealand. Is she likely to come back? That is anyone’s guess. I have heard—although I cannot substantiate this figure—that up to 40 per cent of doctors, who we pay to train here in Scotland, leave for Australia and New Zealand. Is that a good use of public money?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

You are absolutely right to identify the problem. About a year ago, we published a report for the committee that looked at workforce planning in the acute sector of the health service. It identified a number of problems with planning for the workforce that we need and the training that is under way, particularly given the length of time that it takes to train professionals to the quality and the standard that we need, as well as the other demands that are making it harder to retain them. I do not have the detail of that in front of me, but I am happy to write to the committee to follow up on your questions.

That significant issue is one of the things that is increasing the pressures on services, which we experience as patients, and on the staff who work in the health service. It adds to the capacity challenges that we refer to in all our reports on the NHS.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Did you say that you are preparing a report on that specific issue?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

No. We published a report on workforce planning in the acute sector about 12 months ago.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Okay, we can refer to that.

My second question is on prescribing. You identified prescribing as an issue in the two section 22 reports that are in front of us this morning, as well as in previous NHS Tayside reports. In NHS Ayrshire and Arran, you identified general practitioner prescribing costs as an issue, and in NHS Highland, you said that brokerage is required for prescribing costs of £2.8 million. Will you tell us a wee bit more about why there is pressure on prescribing costs?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Again, that issue affects the NHS around Scotland; it is not just those two boards. There are at least two factors. First, we have an ageing population. As people get older, they tend to have a range of conditions that can all be treated with medication, so we end up with people taking a number of different medications that are prescribed to them on a recurring basis, which increases costs.

Secondly, new drugs are becoming available to treat conditions that were not treatable before or that treat conditions more effectively. Those drugs are often more expensive than the previous approaches to treatment. The combination of the volume and the cost of the medications means that the increases in prescribing costs and drug costs are much higher than the increases in the funding that is available for the health service as a whole. That does not affect just Scotland; it is prevalent around the developed world.

There are factors in some boards that mean that their prescribing rates tend to be higher than those of other boards. As you say, convener, that is the case in NHS Tayside, but it is an overarching problem for the NHS as a whole. Pat Kenny or Joanne Brown may want to add something on that.

Joanne Brown Grant Thornton UK LLP
link

Similarly to NHS Tayside, prescribing rates in NHS Highland are slightly higher than they are in the rest of the NHS in Scotland. The board is looking at that issue as part of its financial sustainability plans and at how those costs can be contained. It is working very closely with GPs and clinicians to understand the nature of the prescribing, which it will consider and factor into its financial plans.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

What you said at the end really intrigues me, Ms Brown. We are getting to a situation in which we are asking GPs to think twice before prescribing basic drugs. Auditor General, does that not undermine the Government’s policy of free prescriptions?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is very difficult to comment on specific circumstances. We are auditors, not clinicians. In the past, we have done work on prescribing costs, which shows that there are significant variations across Scotland in the patterns of prescribing for some common drugs, and it is not always clear that that is accounted for by the make-up of the population in terms of age and sex, or by deprivation levels. The Government and health boards have done a lot of work to address that. For example, we know that the rate of prescription of generic drugs has increased significantly, which generally means that patients get the drugs that they need at a lower cost to the health service. However, because of the scale of the cost of drugs to the NHS and the rate at which it is increasing, that is not an area in which the Government or health boards should be complacent.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

In paragraph 22 of your report on NHS Ayrshire and Arran, you talk about areas in which the board will have to make savings, which include the need to close unfunded beds and the need to reduce workforce costs. The question that is begged is, if the board does those things, what will the impact be on the quality of care? What will the attendant impact be on the board’s ability to meet national targets and standards?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I want to make it clear that the areas that are referred to in paragraph 22 are not areas in which I think the board should be targeting savings; those are areas in which savings are planned. I will ask Pat Kenny to talk about the process that has been gone through in identifying those savings.

Pat Kenny Deloitte LLP
link

The savings that are identified in paragraph 22 are the savings that NHS Ayrshire and Arran is working towards. The closing of unfunded beds is reliant on the resilience of the health and social care or community sector, so there is a risk factor attached to it. In seeking to drive down workforce costs, the board is homing in on the agency and locum elements of the costs. Paragraph 22 identifies the actions that the board is taking in an effort to reduce costs in certain areas.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

What impact will that have? When the board does the analysis, it will say, “That will strip cost out of the system,” but I presume that it must also factor in the practical impact on patient care. Has that been done?

Pat Kenny Deloitte LLP
link

I go back to the £6.2 million that I referred to in the report. The community sector was not ready to absorb the demand and the board was not able to close the beds that it had anticipated closing because of that excess demand. I think that the board looks at the impact carefully, and it will close the beds only when it feels that it is safe to do so.

I have had several conversations with the board’s chief executive. As I said earlier, he does not feel that the community sector is ready or resilient enough to absorb that demand. That is why he thinks that the board cannot safely close those beds.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I understand the point that you make, but I want to press you a bit further. You said that the chief executive cannot close the beds at this time, because the social care sector is not ready to pick up what it needs to. However, the report suggests that the board seems to have identified that those beds must be closed in order to make the savings. It sounds as though the board is going to do that in the full knowledge that the social care sector is not ready to pick up the slack. Am I hearing you correctly?

Pat Kenny Deloitte LLP
link

No. I think that the board is making that assumption on the basis that, in targeted areas, it can close the beds safely. What the board was expecting to happen is not happening on the ground and the demand is still there, so it cannot safely close the beds. That consideration is made, and the board will close the beds only when it feels that it is absolutely safe to do so, which is the right approach to take.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Do members have any further questions for our witnesses on the reports?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Mr Kenny, you mentioned the set-aside moneys, which are an issue in not just NHS Ayrshire and Arran but many other boards. When we were emptying the Victorian so-called asylums many years ago, the health boards were provided with bridge funding, because there was a transition period during which boards must run down existing services in parallel with providing new services in the community. That bridge funding was regarded as a major part of the infrastructure in making the transformation in mental health care from those Victorian institutions to care in the community. The fact is that the set-aside money is not being set aside. Is that not indicative of the need for some kind of bridge funding as we transfer people from treatment in the acute sector to treatment in the community?

10:00

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is a very good question. It is one of the questions that the Government should be considering as it develops its medium-term financial framework for the health service, particularly given the financial and service pressures that we are seeing on health boards right across Scotland, not just on these two boards.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I have a couple of questions on NHS Highland. Paragraph 25 of your report says:

“the board commissioned an external independent review of governance arrangements”.

It seems that the hiring of consultants and so on is almost a reflex when boards get into difficulties. NHS Tayside did it, NHS Ayrshire and Arran did it and NHS Highland did it. How much is that costing?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The review of governance had no financial cost attached to it. It was an initiative that was started off by the health board chief executives, working with the Government to commission what was almost a peer-review of governance. The review was led by the chair of NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde. Both NHS Highland and NHS Ayrshire and Arran have, at the same time, received some consultancy support for their transformation plans, which is referenced in the two reports. However, that does not apply to the governance review that you highlighted in your question.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Is there a pattern of consultant costs arising from these situations where, almost by reflex, boards reach out and bring in an external consultant?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I would say that it is not by reflex. Our sense is that the Scottish Government has been increasingly aware of the pressures that health boards are under and, as they have demonstrated that they are unable to deliver their plans, the Government has worked with them to bring in support for transformation. As long as that is done well, I welcome it. Often, people think that the hard work is done when a plan has been produced, but of course its success depends on the quality of the plan and the quality of the implementation. I am not against the use of consultants per se, but that needs to be managed well and to demonstrate good value for money.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Exhibit 2 on page 7 of your NHS Highland report details the reasons why brokerage was needed. They seem to be exactly the same reasons that this committee looked at when we went up to Inverness and met the board. Raigmore hospital is mentioned; it was a problem then and it seems to be a problem now. The board does not seem to have got a grip of that.

In terms of the point that the board

“has struggled to recruit sufficiently skilled staff”,

there seemed to be evidence last time around that the board was managing the vacancies to try to create cost savings. Is there evidence of that happening again?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Your first point is right. I produced a report back in 2013-14 on NHS Highland and some of the cost pressures then were very similar to those that we are seeing now.

NHS Highland is interesting in that it appeared to be making progress in dealing with those cost pressures—it was able to deliver financial balance for a couple of years—and then the position worsened again. That reinforces the point that these are underlying pressures rather than simply poor financial management.

As Joanne Brown said, the particular workforce challenges in NHS Highland are definitely exacerbated by the fact that it is remote and rural and the normal ways of providing services that we are used to in more urban areas simply do not work well in NHS Highland.

The progress that it has been able to make in finding sustainable ways of providing those services that reduce the need to rely on locum staff, whether from agencies or banks, is getting more difficult, given its workforce challenges: the number of vacancies is going up and, in order to continue to deliver services, it is having to rely on agency staff in some areas.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Lastly, just to put my mind at rest, may I presume that there are no governance issues in relation to the board? Last time, there were governance problems in how the board operated. Is it now transparent and above board?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I say in my report that the financial reporting to the board is much better. The problems were being signalled to the board and the discussions about the need for brokerage were held properly and in good time, which is in contrast to the previous report that I made.

That is not to say that there are not some governance challenges. You referred to the review of governance, which identified some areas for improvement. As my report says, the chief executive will leave at the end of the year and the director of finance is acting on an interim basis, so there are challenges to the governance of the board.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

As there are no further questions from members on these health reports, I thank the witnesses very much for their evidence. We will suspend for two minutes to allow a changeover of witnesses. Thank you.

10:05 Meeting suspended.

10:07 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 113
  3. 10:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 76

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.