The next petition is PE1631, by Maureen McVey, on child welfare hearings. At our last consideration of this petition, in March, we considered a suggestion that was made by the petitioner to use fixed specialised family law courts for child welfare hearings and we sought the Scottish Government’s view on that suggestion.
The Government highlights that the Lord President has the powers to determine that family cases be heard by specialist family sheriffs, but advises that a number of matters would need to be considered before making that decision, as outlined in our meeting papers. In her written submission, the petitioner asks whether there are criteria for the Lord President to determine when and in what child contact cases that happens.
Members will recall that, at our last consideration of the petition, we also considered a recommendation that was made to the Scottish Civil Justice Council, based on independent research that it had commissioned, to use note sheets to ensure that information flowed between sheriffs in situations in situations where scheduling meant that the same sheriff was not able to remain with the case. We therefore agreed to write to charities providing advocacy and support to children for their views on the current practice of recording discussions at child welfare hearings.
The Scottish Child Law Centre is supportive of the idea of note sheets, stating that they would improve the quality of decision making and promote and safeguard the best interests of the child. However, it also highlights that note sheets should be used only to facilitate information flow between sheriffs and should not compromise judicial impartiality.
With regard to striking an appropriate balance that ensures that the recording of discussions at child welfare hearings does not make the process overly burdensome, the Scottish Child Law Centre suggests that it would improve the child welfare hearing process if sheriffs provided a written account of the basis on which they made their decision in the child welfare hearing in the form of a child welfare hearing decision note. The petitioner is supportive of this suggestion.
Members may also wish to note that there are currently two consultations underway relevant to this petition. The first is a consultation by the Scottish Civil Justice Council on a report by a subcommittee on case management of family actions. The second is a consultation by the Scottish Government on a review of part 1 of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995. Both consultations close in August 2018.
Do members have any comments on what we should now do with this petition?
