Welcome to the 10th meeting in 2018 of the Public Petitions Committee. I remind members and others in the room to switch phones and other devices to silent. We have received apologies from Angus MacDonald.
The first petition for consideration is PE1545 by Ann Maxwell, on behalf of the Muir Maxwell Trust, on residential care provision for the severely learning disabled. We last considered the petition at our meeting on 15 March and agreed to invite the petitioner to make a written submission; we also agreed to write to the Scottish learning disabilities observatory to ask for information about its work to address the data visibility of people with learning disabilities in Scotland. The observatory’s submission provides a detailed outline of its work programme, which is included in our meeting papers.
The petitioner’s written submission expresses concern that there are limited references in the work programme to epilepsy, despite 60 per cent of people with profound learning disabilities having that condition. The petitioner is of the view that residential care would resolve many of the issues that the observatory is currently researching, and suggests that the financial consequence of inadequate care for the profoundly learning disabled should be a focus of the observatory’s work.
We should focus on the fact that the petitioner is saying that not enough emphasis is being put on the epilepsy question. We need to tease out some of the points that they raise about the work that is being undertaken by the observatory in order to find out in detail what is being done.
I was quite struck by the petitioner’s argument. Historically, someone with a learning disability was put into long-term care. That policy has quite rightly changed and I think that that has been a massive benefit to people who have been able to live and work in the community and achieve their potential. However, it almost feels as if, because of that policy, there is a view that it is not appropriate to have residential care in certain circumstances.
Although you would not want the general rule to be that people are put into residential care, the petitioner makes quite a strong case for there being a community where resources and support can be brought around about people. I agree that we should explore the issue further. Is the issue of epilepsy being considered sufficiently and, if not, why not?
I was going to say something similar on the question of whether the pendulum has swung too far the other way with the result that the option of residential care is now limited. That would be worth exploring. We should also explore the financial consequences of—I do not want to say inadequate care. We should explore both options, and compare the financial consequences of one with that of the other in relation to the willingness to give that care.
The petitioner makes the case that there are financial consequences of not making this provision available in certain circumstances, because further along the line there are consequences for the individual. That could be something that we could look at.
A point was made about the Scottish Government measuring the demand for long-term residential care based on the current number of children and young people in residential care. They make the point that it is a flawed way of measuring demand and fails to capture the true need that currently exists in Scotland. Is the methodology of calculating the number of people currently taking up residential care places affecting this issue as well?
If the facility is not available, in a sense you are ignoring demand; you are not seeking it out.
Do we agree to ask the Scottish learning disabilities observatory about its work in relation to links with profound learning disabilities and epilepsy and to look at the question of the financial consequences of what is seen as—if not inadequate—inappropriate care that is not totally supporting the person?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.