The secondary legislation that we are discussing will bring into force part 3A of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003, on the community right to buy abandoned, neglected or detrimental land. That is land that is wholly or mainly neglected or abandoned, or the management or use of which is causing harm to the environmental wellbeing of the relevant community.
It is very important to emphasise that part 3A of the 2003 act is not intended to be the first step that a community should take when trying to buy land in order to deal with any problems that the land might be causing. The 2003 act requires that the community should already have tried to buy the land through some other means and that, if the community claims that harm is being caused to its environmental wellbeing, it should have tried to fix that harm by going to relevant regulators—that relates to the regulations that we discussed under the previous item—before applying for a right to buy.
The right to buy is powerful and far reaching, particularly as it introduces an element of compulsory purchase. It will add to the existing community right to buy, which has operated successfully for more than 15 years. Most recently, we have had the successful community buyout of Ulva.
The affirmative regulations cover the more substantive elements of the package of instruments. They are largely concerned with the matters to which ministers must have regard when considering whether land is eligible to be purchased under the right to buy as well as the prohibitions that are placed on the owner while an application is being considered.
In considering whether land is eligible under part 3A, ministers must have regard to matters that are set out in the regulations. As part 3A is a compulsory right to buy, it is right that ministers have regard to a number of different matters when considering whether land
“is wholly or mainly abandoned or neglected, or”
is being used in a way that
“causes harm … to the environmental wellbeing of a relevant community.”
Regulations 3 to 5 set out matters to which ministers must have regard in relation to the physical condition, designation or classification and use or management of the land.
Regulation 6 sets out the matters to which ministers must have regard in relation to environmental wellbeing. They include whether the use of the land has caused a statutory nuisance or whether the land has been subject to a closure order or notice under the Antisocial Behaviour etc (Scotland) Act 2004.
Regulation 6 considers whether harm is being caused to environmental wellbeing. Some stakeholders want environmental wellbeing to extend to social and economic matters. That was debated during the passage of the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Act 2015, which inserts part 3A into the 2003 act. In assessing whether land is eligible for part 3A, some social considerations can be taken into account but only if they result in harm to a community’s environmental wellbeing. It is important that we do not try to stretch the meaning of environmental wellbeing too far because, if we do so, it will break in court. However, I recognise the importance of social and economic matters being taken into account, and I have instructed my officials to explore ways in which that might be achieved.
Part 3A is a compulsory purchase right and we absolutely do not want that to interfere with individuals’ homes. That is why land that is someone’s home is excluded under the 2003 act. However, if that land is occupied under a tenancy, it is not automatically excluded. That allows a community body to apply for land even where there is a tenant in place, but part 3A does not interfere with a tenant’s rights under their tenancy and the regulations take account of protections that are offered to tenants by other legal arrangements.
The first of the negative instruments—the Community Right to Buy (Abandoned, Neglected or Detrimental Land) (Compensation) (Scotland) Order 2018—sets out how any person, including an owner, who incurs additional costs as a result of complying with the 2003 act can claim compensation under section 97T of the act. The second—the Community Right to Buy (Abandoned, Neglected or Detrimental Land) (Applications, Ballots and Miscellaneous Provisions) (Scotland) Regulations 2018—covers a wider range of subjects that relate to the process that a community must follow when applying under part 3A, including the ballot that advertises the fact of the application and what costs a community body can claim from the Scottish ministers.
I know that the committee will have questions and I am happy to answer them.