What is now the second item on the agenda is to hear evidence on the draft Environmental Authorisations (Scotland) Regulations 2018 from the Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform, Roseanna Cunningham, and Joyce Carr, head of the Scottish Government’s water environment team. Good morning. Do you want to make an opening statement, cabinet secretary?
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Environmental Authorisations (Scotland) Regulations 2018 [Draft]
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 16
- Graeme Dey SNP 8
- Joyce Carr Scottish Government 6
- Stewart Stevenson SNP 3
- Mark Ruskell Green 3
- John Scott Con 3
- Claudia Beamish Lab 3
- Alex Rowley Lab 3
- Richard Lyle SNP 1
The record
46 contributionsI think that that would be helpful.
Obviously, effective environmental legislation is essential if we are going to continue to protect Scotland’s natural resources, and our legislation has to be efficient and risk based to ensure that any associated burdens on business are proportionate. The draft regulations represent a significant step forward in providing more efficient, effective and risk-based protection of the environment.
The existing legislation for our key environmental regimes has evolved over a number of decades and, as a result, the current framework of environmental regulations has become more complex than it needs to be. The four main environmental regimes for water, waste, pollution prevention and radioactive substances currently have different procedures and timeframes for granting authorisation, carrying out monitoring, and taking enforcement action for non-compliance, and many sites have multiple authorisations, multiple inspections by different inspectors, and different monitoring arrangements. That is inefficient for the regulator and the operator. The new, integrated framework, for which the draft regulations are the first step, will create a common set of procedures for those core regulatory components.
The majority of the components that make up the new framework already exist in one or more of the existing four main regimes. For instance, the framework uses a similar tiered system of proportionate controls as that which was introduced in the Water Environment (Controlled Activities) (Scotland) Regulations 2005, which is now accepted as an efficient and successful approach. That provides a simple, transparent and integrated system that makes compliance easier and more straightforward for business.
The framework also includes a broader fit-and-proper-person test to strengthen the Scottish Environment Protection Agency’s powers to ensure that the right person holds the authorisation. That will provide a level playing field for business and ensure that disreputable operators or criminals are unable to obtain or keep authorisations. It will also ensure that people and communities—and particularly those who are directly impacted by activities—are properly engaged in decision making.
In addition to the common set of procedures, certain technical provisions are required for each of the four main regimes. They will be contained in technical schedules.
We plan to implement the framework in tranches, starting with the provisions for radioactive substance activities, which are contained in the technical schedules to the draft regulations. The technical requirements for the water pollution prevention and waste activities will be added in subsequent tranches, so the committee has that to look forward to.
I am confident that the integrated framework will provide an effective and efficient approach to the protection of our environment, while minimising the burden for business, and I ask the committee to support the instrument.
It strikes me, on reading through the instrument, that the fit-and-proper-person test is, in practice, a big improvement on what we have had until now. Is that a fair assessment?
It probably is. That is one of the things that we were keen to do, partly because we had indications of issues arising out of the way in which things have been managed until now. It will basically streamline different approaches in different regimes, and that means that it will be easier across the entirety of that area of activity to see who would and who would not be a fit and proper person. SEPA will have a duty to grant or transfer an authorisation for a regulated activity only where it is satisfied that the proposed person is a fit and proper person to carry on the activity. There are some ways in which that will make SEPA more able to be proactive when it comes to waste crime and repeat offenders, and I would expect that to be welcomed by pretty much the majority of people—perhaps not the waste crime repeat offenders themselves, although that is as might be anticipated.
At the moment, SEPA can consider only environmental offences, but the framework will allow a wider range of offences to be taken into account. Involvement in serious organised crime demonstrates a disregard for the law, and we believe that people who show such disregard should generally not be considered fit and proper people to be carrying out certain activities. There will be other benefits, but the instrument is framed so as to create a better test and a test that works across all the regimes.
Excellent. I will open the discussion up to members, starting with Stewart Stevenson.
I want to talk about the narrow issue of dealing with radioactive substances in the offshore sector. In your helpful letter to us, cabinet secretary, you refer to the preparation of a section 104 order under the Scotland Act 1998, and I have two questions relating to that. First, who has been looking after this area up until now? Secondly, will the section 104 order give ministers powers to change the regulations, or is it just a one-off to implement the particular regulations that are before us?
I will ask Joyce Carr to answer that.
Our ministers already have powers under the Radioactive Substances Act 1993. The section 104 order is merely to extend the new regulations to the offshore sector. It is simply that, in terms of procedure, because the Radioactive Substances Act 1993 is being repealed, we need to go through that process to ensure that the new regulations can apply to the offshore sector, as they do at present.
So the net effect is nil.
Correct.
Thank you.
link
Cabinet secretary, you mentioned that one of the objectives of the draft regulations is to ensure that people are informed about and engaged in decision making. I wonder how that will actually take effect on the ground.
Let me give an example. Near Dunfermline, there is a former opencast coal site called Muir Dean, where distillery waste was being pumped into the ground over the weekend, causing an enormous stink. A few miles up the road is the Mossmorran ethylene plant, and in both those cases communities do not know who is responsible for regulating the sites. There is confusion about whether it is Fife Council or SEPA, and confusion about the current process of regulation under the Pollution Prevention and Control (Scotland) Regulations 2012. How will the new integrated framework allow communities to engage more in decision making? How will it look at the front end—the community end? If someone has an environmental problem, how will it benefit them?
Community councils, for example, were involved in the consultation, so the consultation reached into that area of activity at a basic community level. There ought to be a relatively widespread understanding that this change is in process.
I do not want to get drawn into attempting to discuss individual sets of circumstances. This would not be the right place to do that. I would expect, however, that there is a fairly widespread understanding that SEPA is likely to have a role and what that would be, and that local authorities will also have a role in some cases, depending on what the activity is. I would be surprised if most communities did not regard SEPA/local authorities as their first port of call when these things go awry.
Community councils have already been involved in the consultation and should be aware that it has been taking place and have a widespread understanding of what it means.
It is important to understand that the draft regulations bring together existing frameworks into a more coherent framework. I do not want to say that nothing has changed, but neither do I want to make it sound as though everything has changed. We are streamlining a process and making it easier and more straightforward, whether for people who are regulated or for those who have concerns.
Once the integrated framework has been rolled out, I expect that the process will become easier for people to understand, because they will not be dealing with different rules in different sets of regulations. I suspect that that is what has caused some of the confusion up until now.
link
You referred to “SEPA/local authorities”. The confusion may arise over where the responsibilities of each organisation start and stop. If I am in a community with an environmental problem, where do I go?
How will the integrated framework change the process, regardless of the issue, and make it more streamlined for the concerned citizen? Does it provide a new portal? At the moment, the responsibility seems to lie with one organisation and/or another. I would not know which one to go to.
I would imagine that most people’s first port of call would be SEPA. If it is a local authority responsibility, SEPA would direct the person to the local authority. The local authority obviously has lots of responsibilities, particularly because it is the planning authority and the environmental health authority.
Unless you are proposing to take powers away from local authorities—I assume that you are not, although you may be—there will continue to be situations in which both the local authority and SEPA have a role. The regulations are not about setting up a one-stop shop. SEPA is most likely to be the first port of call for people with a concern and it will know whether it is better to direct the issue to a local authority.
In most cases, SEPA responds in one way or another. Although people may not always be content with the outcome or the results of what SEPA does or does not do, usually it will be the first port of call for the vast majority of people.
Will you expand on the missing of the transposition deadlines?
Some of that was beyond our control. I am looking in my briefing for the detail of what happened, which was tied up with changes south of the border. It was not entirely our doing. We have written to the committee with some elaboration. There are various sets of United Kingdom regulations that cover a mix of reserved and devolved measures that could not be accommodated straightforwardly in existing regulatory positions—the requirement for a section 104 order is an example of that. We have been caught with an issue that has not really been of our making.
We have been advised by the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy that the European Commission is unlikely to do anything in terms of infraction in the UK before the year’s anniversary of the transposition deadline. BEIS is also conscious that trying to align the different jurisdictions has been a problem. I do not know whether Joyce Carr will be able to say anything further. It is not about assigning blame, but we have been held to a timescale that was not entirely of our making.
09:45
In your letter to the convener, you say that you will bring forward a consultation. Do you have a timescale for that? I presume that it will be a Scottish consultation.
I do not know. Are you aware of a timescale for the consultation, Joyce?
The consultation will be brought forward as soon as is reasonable. My colleagues who deal with radioactive substances have been actively working on the consultation. The constraint is the legal resource to develop the draft regulations, so that is what we are waiting for.
That constraint lies within the Scottish Government.
Yes.
I want to look at the other end of the community engagement and the role of the new regulatory regime as it integrates. Can you give us any reassurance about the feedback to communities on significant issues such as those relating to Mossmorran and the spreading of sewage sludge at Glentaggart in my constituency? What is the process whereby communities know what decisions have been made?
SEPA is in the early stages of implementing a sector approach to regulation, and sector plans will be at the heart of everything that SEPA does. That approach is designed to develop confidence in the system so that people have easy recourse to the sector plans.
There is a 24-hour pollution hotline and a mobile phone app for members of the public. There might be a question about how many members of the public are aware of the hotline and the app, but I will ensure that questions are asked of SEPA about it perhaps needing to up its publicity activity on those resources, which are for reporting any possible pollution incidents. That should give reassurance to the public that when something happens, people are able to register an issue straight away. Communities have to be kept informed of incidents as they emerge and have clarity on whose role it is to respond.
In a sense, that work is constantly developing and I do not think that we will ever get to a point at which that is a perfect activity. However, I hope that the public are aware of the 24-hour hotline and the mobile phone app or, if they are not, that those resources can be brought to people’s attention. Those resources allow people instant access to information and, once an incident is happening, that instant access is important.
I am aware that SEPA engages with people through public meetings, particularly in areas in which there are on-going situations, and I expect that that activity will continue. The authorisations framework will streamline and simplify the message that can be sent, but it will not change that activity.
To take the example of Glentaggart, because I know quite a lot about it, could there be a commitment by the Scottish Government to put up any results and decisions on the SEPA website so that that can easily be accessed by the public? Perhaps that happens anyway—I do not know. If not, could it be done?
We can certainly raise that issue. There is a provision for publicity notices.
That is not relevant here.
Is it not relevant in this case?
SEPA publishes all decision making on its website.
I was just reading from my notes about publicity notices, which are matters for the courts. There is a process by which publicity orders can be made but that is perhaps a big bit of artillery that is beyond what you are talking about just now.
It might be that people are not engaging with what is already available through SEPA, which suggests that SEPA needs to be a bit more proactive about what is already available. If all its decisions are published on its website, that should perhaps be better publicised.
The work that SEPA did around the flooding activity is possibly a case study of how well SEPA can manage the publicity around issues, so it might perhaps need to think about extending that particular way of dealing with things across a wider set of regimes.
I know that you do not want to talk about specifics, but I can say in all honesty that, when you look at specific cases in Fife, you can see that there is a problem with regard to people’s confidence in SEPA. For example, in Dunfermline, from Thursday to Sunday, the smell was so horrendous that people were being physically sick, but there was a lack of communication from SEPA and the council with regard to what was going on. Along with that, there is the fact that, although a final written warning has been given to Mossmorran, nobody understands what that really means, because SEPA has not issued detailed information about why it has issued the warning. Further, there is the fact that it took a year and a half to get a conviction in connection with the issue at the former naval base at Lathalmond, as well as the fact that SEPA will not clean up the area but has not published the details of why it will not.
Every time that I come across cases involving SEPA, I ask myself whether it actually has the power to act on behalf of communities, because, time and again, communities are let down. I hope that we can see more joined-up working, but a number of questions need to be answered on the problems that communities have with SEPA in cases in which SEPA seems to be either powerless to act or unable to address issues.
There were a load of issues wrapped up in that which are not easy for me to unpack in the context of this conversation; not least of those issues is the fact that, once something goes into the judicial system, SEPA does not have control of the timescale, as it has no control over court proceedings. I can answer in terms of generalities—for example, as soon as something goes into the justice system, the timescale is out of SEPA’s control. However, I cannot address very particular sets of circumstances; I would just have to promise to write another letter.
If a case takes a year or 18 months to go through the court, it is not SEPA that is causing the delay; the normal court processes are slowing things down. I appreciate that that is frustrating for people, but it is what it is—and that applies to a lot more than SEPA. We need to be clear about which aspects of what we are talking about are within SEPA’s control and which are not.
That suggests to me that some people think that we should revisit the legislation upon which SEPA was set up in the early years of this Parliament. I am not sure that that is a point to which I can respond off the top of my head without looking at a lot of the detail about individual decision making, so that I can understand why, in some cases, SEPA clearly believes that it does not have powers when it does have them.
What right does a community have to challenge SEPA? In the Lathalmond case there were convictions, but the mess is still there. SEPA will not clean it up because that would cost more than £1 million, and it says that the site is safe enough. The judge in the case was highly critical of SEPA—
I am not familiar with the case—
What rights do communities have to appeal a decision of SEPA not to clean up a site?
We are straying away from the regulations. However, Alex Rowley has made some interesting points. Cabinet secretary, will you write to us about the rights of communities, not necessarily in the case that Alex Rowley mentioned but in circumstances such as that? Also, will you respond to the point about what a final written warning constitutes?
Okay. We can do that.
Thank you. If Mr Rowley has no further points to make, it would be useful if you could write to the committee about the generalities, rather than the specific case to which he referred.
If members have no more questions, we move to item 4, which is the debate on motion S5M-12403.
Motion moved,
That the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee recommends that the Environmental Authorisations (Scotland) Regulations 2018 draft be approved.—Roseanna Cunningham
I invite members to comment on the motion.
link
I am quite happy to support the regulations. It makes a lot of sense to provide a more integrated framework and I welcome the first tranche of regulations, on radioactive materials.
Ahead of the next tranche, particularly the pollution, prevention and control regulations, I would like to learn how the approach will work on the ground and whether there will be improvements, in particular to environmental reporting for communities.
I mentioned the odour nuisance in Dunfermline, and Alex Rowley raised the issue too. On Thursday night, a post on Facebook was shared nearly 2,000 times, and if members read the threads they will see that there was continual debate about whose responsibility the issue is. People were asking whether the responsibility is SEPA’s or Fife Council’s, and whether anyone knows what is meant to be spread at the site, as opposed to what was actually spread. There are major issues to do with information flow.
Obviously, that case is not entirely relevant to the regulations that we are considering; it relates more to the PPC regulations, which will come later. When we get to that second tranche, I will be interested to hear what improvements SEPA will make and how it will make the front end seamless for communities, which often need information quickly.
If members plan to refer to specific cases, it would be really helpful if we could get an indication of that. As members will appreciate, there are enormous differences from case to case, with every case probably turning on specific information. If I am to be helpful in such circumstances, it would help if cases were flagged up to us, so that we could do a little work to understand them and therefore, perhaps, be able to explain more clearly why a particular set of circumstances is what it is.
10:00
Yes, but you have picked up on that point and perhaps you can also respond to us in the letter that you are going to write to the committee.
Those of us who have been councillors would say that any pollution or smell is the responsibility of the council’s environmental department, rather than SEPA, because the council is on the ground. The council can then contact SEPA. There is a SEPA office in my constituency that I contact regularly if I have a problem. On this occasion, I agree with the cabinet secretary that that is what people should do.
I support the regulations. In our previous discussion, we talked about the generality of the processes for community engagement right through to the feedback at the end. I hope that our earlier conversations will help with that, because it is very important if we are to have a Scotland that really involves its communities in the processes that protect them.
No other members have any points or queries to raise. Do you wish to wind up, cabinet secretary?
No, I think that our conversation has been sufficient.
Motion agreed to,
That the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee recommends that the Environmental Authorisations (Scotland) Regulations 2018 draft be approved.
10:01 Meeting suspended.
10:03 On resuming—
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportNo recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.
In this meeting
Everything on 29 May 2018 →- 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 46
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 123
- 11:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.