The next petition for consideration today is PE1676, by Tony Rosser, which calls for a review of the Land Registration etc (Scotland) Act 2012, in particular with regard to the cadastral map and the provision of supporting materials. Following our initial consideration of the petition, the committee wrote to the Scottish Government and Registers of Scotland.
In its submission, the Scottish Government indicates that it has no current plans to review the use of the cadastral map. It states that powers are available to ministers under the act to make an order to change the mapping system, where there is sufficient evidence that there is a better alternative. It indicates that it is not aware of a better alternative. The keeper of the registers of Scotland confirms that Registers of Scotland has “no capacity issues” under the current system but considers that it would be
“impractical and extremely resource intensive”
for it to take its own view on the accuracy of updated information provided by Ordnance Survey.
In response, the petitioner argues that, under the current system, the potential for errors to be made remains, with no opportunity for owners to approve the changes. In response to the views presented by the Scottish Government and Registers of Scotland in relation to costs and resources, the petitioner states that
“significant costs and delays are borne by property owners at present”,
and suggests that those should be borne by the Scottish Government and Registers of Scotland.
In relation to the provision of supporting materials, the Scottish Government notes that the act requires solicitors to take reasonable care to ensure that all information is accurate and up to date but states that this is an operational matter for Registers of Scotland. The keeper of the registers of Scotland indicates that Registers of Scotland does not consider it necessary to ask solicitors to provide supporting materials, such as death certificates, as the solicitors are
“under a professional duty to act in the best interests of their clients”.
The petitioner reiterates his position that provision of supporting materials
“negates the possibility of error and, in extreme cases, could prevent fraud”.
The act will be included in the Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee’s work on post-legislative scrutiny.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?