The next petitions, both of which are by James Mackie, are PE1673, on the operation and running of child protection services in Scotland, and PE1675, on attendance at children’s hearings. We last considered the petitions at our meeting on 23 November, when we agreed to join them together for consideration and to seek a response from the Scottish Government on the action called for in them. Members will note that we have received responses from the Scottish Government and a response from the petitioner. We have also received three other submissions on PE1673, from three individuals with an interest in the petition.
Members will recall that PE1673, in particular, sets out issues in relation to a number of elements of child protection and the Government response provides commentary on those points. In addition to addressing the various points of the petition, the Government response also refers to two specific areas of work: the reconvening of the child protection systems review group in April 2018 and the work being undertaken by the independent care review, which is chaired by Fiona Duncan.
The petitioner’s response addresses the points made in the Government’s response, as do the submissions from Maggie Mellon and Gary Clapton. Overall, the view offered by the petitioner and others is that the practical experience of the operation of child protection systems differs from what is envisaged by the regulations and procedures that govern the system.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?