Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Reports

“The 2015/16 audit of Lews Castle College”

Thursday 22 June 2017 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 10:15–11:00 Committee business 106 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

106 contributions
Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Under item 3, we will take further evidence on the 2015-16 audit of Lews Castle College, which is based in the Outer Hebrides. I welcome Iain Macmillan, the principal of the college, and I welcome back Clive Mulholland and Fiona Larg of the University of the Highlands and Islands. For clarification, the UHI is the regional strategic body for Lews Castle College, as it is for Moray College.

I will briefly set out some background to this evidence session. Lews Castle College has failed to meet its further education targets for eight years, albeit by a small margin and with extenuating circumstances in some cases. According to the Auditor General’s report, in one of those years, the Scottish funding council or the UHI sought to recover funding from the college.

We will explore how the college spent the public money that it received for activity that it apparently did not deliver; what role the UHI played in supporting or challenging the college; the impact of the college’s underperformance on other colleges within the UHI region; and how the college will now ensure that it delivers the appropriate volume of learning for its students.

I invite Iain Macmillan to make an opening statement.

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

Thank you, convener. I will take a couple of minutes to set some of the context. As a college, we submitted a one-page summary of the actions that have been taken recently by the new board, to show the steps that we have been taking to address the issues that the Auditor General outlined in her report.

The college has a new board in place, and the independent members of the board have been appointed by the UHI. The new board has been fully in place since last September, so we are just coming to the end of its first full cycle of activity. The board is very focused on the challenges that the college faces, particularly with regard to student recruitment and the impact that failure to meet student recruitment targets has on the finances of the college.

In addition to conducting the formal board business, the board has met separately to consider specific issues relevant to the sustainability of the college. In those sessions, we focused first on risk and developing and upgrading the risk register for the college. Subsequently, we met to discuss curriculum and to develop a curriculum action plan that would change the way we delivered curriculum in the college as a result of the challenges that we face. A further such meeting is planned for early August to consider finance and to develop a financial strategy response to take account of all the challenges that we face and to ensure that, in future, we have everything in place so that we are able to respond to the changes in our action plans. It is all very well to plan to do something, but we are in a fairly volatile situation and, because we are very small, small changes have quite a significant impact on us. We are conscious that we have to develop a plan that is able to respond to particular scenarios, so we are looking to do that in August.

A key part of the finances for the college is the allocation model that is used for further education activity. The introduction of a new system in 2015-16 simplified the model. Quite a number of complexities in the previous funding model were lost as a result, and that has caused us difficulties in the Highlands and Islands in particular, because we receive funding and activity from the Scottish funding council, but we have had to develop a mechanism to allocate the funding and the activity.

Funding was fairly straightforward to the extent that, because the funding council had allocated the same amount of funding to the region, the same amount of funding was allocated to each college. However, the activity levels were a bit more complex and it took us, as a region, with the help of the funding council, until the autumn of last year to put in place a model that allowed that activity to match the funding. For 2017-18, we have new allocations of activity, which have reduced Lews Castle College’s activity to the level that we have been achieving in the past two years. As a consequence, we have had a reduction in funding, which we have factored into and been able to accommodate in our budgets going forward. As with all these things, it will be challenging for us to meet that, so that is one of the reasons behind our strategic work in August on the budgets. It is important for the committee to understand that we are moving forward, that we are recognising these observations from Audit Scotland and taking them seriously, and that we are responding and will continue to respond.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I would like to talk a little bit about governance. The college has been underperforming now, to a greater or lesser extent, since 2008-09. What action did the board take about that?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

The college has been underperforming in terms of student activity levels. We are conscious of the challenges that we face in terms of the demographic changes that are occurring in the Outer Hebrides. The board considered some additional strategic responses, particularly in regard to curriculum, employer engagement, student engagement and marketing.

10:30

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But the Auditor General says that those strategies did not work.

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

They did not work in attracting the level of students that we needed. Again, some of the strategies that we could put in place will not halt some of the demographic changes.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

It says in the report:

“there is little evidence of the board taking effective action”.

Are you able to comment on that?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

There is little evidence of the action that the board took resulting in an improvement in the situation—I think that that is fair to say.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The UHI came on the scene in the latter part of the period of underperformance. At what point did you become aware that there was a problem, and how?

Clive Mulholland
link

If you look at the position of the college—this is picking up from where Iain Macmillan left off—you will see that it is in quite a fragile area. Its funding until 2015-16 came directly from the funding council, so a model has been in place for a period. We have taken that over and continue to fund at the minute based on that model. However, we as a region are looking at whether that model is appropriate for us in the Highlands and Islands. We are aware of that and we are aware that the college is not necessarily underperforming but may be overfunded. If we had stripped out that overfunding straight away, the college would be in an incredibly difficult position. There is the context therefore of the environment in which it sits. However, that does not mean that we should not be doing anything. We are starting to take action now. Through the further education regional board, which allocates the FE funding, we are looking at what the appropriate amount of funding is for this college and other colleges.

Iain Macmillan mentioned the demographic difficulties. We know that they are there and, with the college, we are starting to look at how we address those. The technology that we use in the UHI enabled it to exist in the first place. We use a lot of what is called network teaching. We have the opportunity to start taking the college out from the Hebrides and to teach across Scotland rather than trying either to attract students in the Hebrides or to bring students in. We are starting to work to become much more sustainable.

Those are the plans that we are now starting to look at with the college. We are saying, “Right, where are the areas that you’ve got expertise?” For example, with traditional music, we can start to teach out from there. We recognise that there is an issue around funding but, if we had just funded based on the model, then, given its activity levels, the college would be in a very difficult position. We are looking at this on a regional basis with the college as part of the university.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

When did you become aware that there was a problem?

Clive Mulholland
link

We have been aware since we saw the 2015-16 figures that there is a difference between the activity and the funding. We have been aware of that since we inherited that model from the funding council.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Did the funding council know about that?

Clive Mulholland
link

Yes.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

It was aware that it was subsidising the college.

Clive Mulholland
link

I am sure that it was. I cannot comment for the funding council, but we just adopted the model that the funding council had.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Clearly, there are certain colleges that might, as you say, be in a fragile area and need a bit more support. Do you think that the college is capable of being turned around from a financial point of view?

Clive Mulholland
link

Yes, I do. It requires the support of the university to be able to do that. We need to look at new ways of working. For example, we are looking at having shared services. At the minute, we do more videoconference teaching than anybody else in Europe. Shetland College runs that for us. We have an opportunity to look at services and try to support the local college. We could put services in different colleges that are in difficulty. I am not saying that that is the whole solution, but that is part of the solution for dealing with a region that is quite fragile. I think that we get our strength from being part of a larger grouping through the university, rather than being colleges that operate in isolation. Colleges can access some of the capacity and capability that might be missing in a very small college.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

My understanding is that the board consists of 13 members. Is that still the case?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

That is correct, yes.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

That seems quite big for a small college.

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

Thirteen is the minimum that is required by the Post-16 Education (Scotland) Act 2013.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The Auditor General’s report says that there has been quite a turnover, although that is obviously a little bit historical now. At that point, seven experienced members had left, including the chair. Are the remaining six still on the board?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

Yes. I think that three of the independent members who were on the previous board are on the current board. The remaining members on the current board were staff members, and of course me.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Obviously, the previous board did not respond particularly well to the situation and failed to take the action that was required. Is the current board fully informed and engaged in taking the action that is required? Has UHI actually signed off on a recovery plan?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

The new board is fully engaged. It is taking a more active role in what we are doing, in an operational sense, to respond to the problem. In terms of our recovery plan, the information that we have put together on how we, as a college, have dealt with the reduction in funding has been passed to the UHI. It has been approved and has been through the committee process within the UHI. As far as I am aware, it has been accepted.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The UHI has approved the plan. Do you have to send it to the funding council as well? Is it engaged in this at all, or is it handled at regional level?

Clive Mulholland
link

This is handled at regional level, because we are the regional strategic body. The main role of the regional strategic body is to ensure the provision of further education in the Highlands and Islands. It is not necessarily to preserve the colleges, although the colleges are obviously the main delivery vehicles for that. Our main responsibility is to ensure the provision of further education in the Highlands and Islands.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Good morning to you. The last time the committee discussed this issue, I tried to spring to the defence of the college a wee bit in recognising its size. I questioned—reasonably, I think—whether it is really fair to apply the regional characteristics, targets and so on to a college like this in the Western Isles. I want to give you, Mr Macmillan, an opportunity to tell us about the kind of issues that small, rural colleges face. What we are hearing from UHI, quite fairly, is that there are all sorts of interventions to help, but that kind of tells me that the model does not really work hugely well for your college.

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

It is a very difficult one; I realise that, and it is probably something that I could talk about at length. One of our challenges is that although we are the smallest incorporated college—we are tiny, certainly in comparison with large regional colleges—there is an expectation that we will engage at national and regional level in exactly the same way as larger colleges do. We do that—we engage at regional and national level; but it probably takes a disproportionate amount of the college’s time and resource to contribute. It would be useful if there were something in the funding regime that recognised that. Basically, we are funded on a per capita basis—for the number of students that we have. Within that—from that very low base—it is difficult to fulfil all the requirements, from governance right the way through to contributing at all the different levels. I recognise, from doing that and being involved in a lot of discussions at national level, that it is very hard to put in place one mechanism that satisfies the requirements of a large regional college and of a college like ours. We have a voice at regional and national level and we try to influence that; whether anybody listens is a different matter.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

We compared Edinburgh College and Lews Castle, and the same sort of criteria applied to Edinburgh as applied to you. Some colleagues around the table were, well, if not surprised at that, just a bit concerned. The notion that you were seen as failing for eight years in a row sat a wee bit uncomfortably with me because of those criteria.

My colleague Colin Beattie asked whether you had to have 13 members on the board, and you said that you had to because those were the rules. It seems to me that we need a flexible approach that recognises the obvious differences in places such as the Western Isles.

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

What we have, in the regionalisation process and in the changes that have come to us, is an opportunity to compensate for the challenges that we have as a small college by linking in to services that are available from the university or other colleges in the Highlands and Islands.

There is a need for us, as colleges, to work more closely together. Clive Mulholland, I think, spoke about sharing services. There is an assumption that sharing services is always about back-office services, but we already share, to a large extent, teaching; we certainly do across higher education and we will be looking to do that more and more at further education level. We will be looking to develop curriculum collectively so that each college is not developing the curriculum individually for itself.

There is expertise that we all need, whether financial, legal or in marketing. We need to be able to share that because Lews Castle is probably too small to function independently from colleges in the rest of the region. There is a need for us to work together. We have recognised that for a long time but, as islanders, we also protect our autonomy, maybe more than most. Therefore, there is a need for us to find an accommodation with partners that allows that to work well.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Do you find that you need more assistance by way of technology, online capability and so on to deliver what you do, much more so than perhaps Edinburgh might?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

We have well-developed expertise in using technology, because we realise that that is what will keep us sustainable. The college has played a significant part in developing the university and, in particular, network courses. At one time, a disproportionate number of the courses offered across UHI were led from Lews Castle because we recognised that we needed to do that. Clive Mulholland identified earlier the opportunity for us to provide some of that learning and teaching from Lews Castle to other people. Because we recognise that need, we are probably better placed and more motivated to make use of technology and break new ground. We have been doing that quite significantly, and I expect that we will carry on doing so.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Do you have decent broadband speeds that allow you to participate fully and properly?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

We are getting there. The broadband debate is an interesting one. We have first-class communications into the college sites, and there will be some improvement over this summer, but there are plenty of issues in individual pockets in the islands.

10:45

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

If you were to capture all of this and make a recommendation for change, assistance or something that would help your college, what would it be? Would it be to break free of the straitjacket of the one-size-fits-all approach?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

If somebody could sort out the VAT landscape so that we could provide services between individual colleges and individual colleges and the university, that would open the door to a whole load of sharing that we currently cannot undertake without incurring a 20 per cent VAT charge. I am an accountant by profession so, for me, that is the one infuriating thing that is really blocking us from addressing some of the bureaucratic challenges that we have. If somebody could unlock that door for me, I would be really grateful.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Just to pick up on that a wee bit, what do you mean? You are constantly paying VAT for service sharing or—

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

Yes. It is because we are separate organisations. Except for teaching, because education services provided directly to students are exempt from VAT, all other services incur a VAT charge of 20 per cent.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Why would you be particularly damaged by that compared with other colleges?

Clive Mulholland
link

Can I come in here? For some of the support services, such as student support, we are looking at whether we can provide a unified service across the whole region for all the colleges. We think that we can do that much more efficiently and actually improve the quality, because we will get better consistency. The problem is that there is a 20 per cent VAT charge on every partner straight away if the university provides it, so there is an extra 20 per cent saving on top to make before you even start to make savings. I think that that is what Iain is referring to.

Clive Mulholland
link

HMRC.

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

We are working on it.

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

Yes.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you. On a point of clarification, Mr Macmillan, you said that you are an accountant by trade. Currently, you are the principal and chief executive; and you are also the senior financial officer, I believe.

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

Yes. When I was made principal, we did not replace the director of finance post. We have a finance manager, so we do have a professional accountant who looks after the day-to-day operational finances.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Just for clarity, am I right to say that, in effect, you are doing all three roles: principal, chief executive officer and director of finance?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

At the highest, strategic level, yes. I do not play any part in the day-to-day operations but—

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Do you envisage that continuing?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

When I took on the role, we expected that we would be able to move fairly quickly to a shared services situation within UHI and that some of the financial expertise that I am currently providing would be available from somewhere else within the network. I do not believe that we need a full-time finance director. What we need is that other brain and other viewpoint, which we would be better getting from somewhere else within the sector.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Just to be absolutely clear, do you envisage it continuing?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

For the short term, yes; until we can find a solution.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Can I just go back and build on Willie Coffey’s points? We are here because the Auditor General has done a report saying that, for the past eight years, you have not met your targets, essentially. Obviously, for colleges, unlike universities, the main catchment area is the local community. I suppose that that is even more true of an island community. We are all very well aware of the demographic challenges—population changes, age structures and so on—particularly in island communities, and the Hebrides has had more challenges than most. May I start from the beginning? Who sets the targets? On what basis are the targets set? Are the targets realistic for an island community such as that on Lewis?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

From my point of view, the targets have been too high, but the funding that we receive relates directly to the targets, and the amount that we receive is what we need to sustain the level of activity that we have in the college. With this new model, we have started to move away from the way in which things have been traditionally. I would say that the targets are too high, but I would not want to see all the money that directly relates to the targets being taken away.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I can absolutely understand. I worked in the old Cumnock and Doon Valley District Council—fortunately, I did not work for the council. I remember that the then chief executive—this is 30 years ago, I was very young at the time—used to complain about the Scottish Office looking at the funding for graveyards in rural areas in exactly the same way as it looked at the funding for graveyards in urban areas. It was a lot cheaper per unit, if I can put it that way, to maintain a graveyard in an urban community than it was in a rural community, because in a rural community there were 16 major settlements and every village wanted to retain its own graveyard, ergo the costs of doing so were much higher.

I have two questions. I think that you have answered the first one by saying that the targets are too high. What input do you or your board have into the setting of the targets? I presume that it is the SFC who set the targets originally? Is it an iterative process, or are they handed down from on high in Edinburgh—it decides what the targets are, end of story? What is the process for setting the target?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

Traditionally, up until this year, our targets have been very much based on targets that were set a number of years ago. If I am correct, 2010-11 was quite a major change point for the FE sector for funding and activity. All the activity levels that we have had since have been based on the position in 2010-11. There has been so much change in the sector since then—as a result of regionalisation et cetera—but the targets have not really been revisited.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The targets were set by the SFC.

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

Yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Did you have any input into the targets at the time?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

In terms of setting them, no, not really. You would look at them and say that you accepted them. We have always had the opportunity—or did in the past—to say yes or no to the targets, but it is one of those questions to which the answer has to be yes, because you do not really know what the consequences of no are.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That is my point; you would be nervous about saying, “We can’t accept that target,” because then your funding would be cut. The second point, and this is where the analogy with the cost of graveyards in Cumnock and Doon Valley 30 years ago comes in, is about the unit cost of delivering a quality further education service in Lewis where, by definition, you have far fewer people—or units, if I can put it that way. It is a lot easier in a bigger college to reduce your unit cost because there are maybe 20 or 30 people in a class, whereas you would be lucky to get five or six people—maybe 10—in a class.

Are you saying, first, that the original targets were probably unrealistic to start with, and you did not have much of an input to them; and, secondly, that there is not sufficient recognition of the additional cost of delivering FE in a community such as Lewis? Would that be a fair comment?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

It is a fair comment. There are mechanisms within the funding process. We have been in discussions and we do get a premium for remoteness and rurality.

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

No. One of the challenges in looking to do things at a national level is that there will always be a difference of view or opinion between urban and rural. Finding the right balance will always be difficult.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Is it your opinion that, although there is a premium it is not—if I can put it this way—generous enough to recognise the reality of the cost pressures that you are under in a remote rural island community with a very small catchment and an ageing population? Am I right in saying that Lewis still has a falling population?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

Yes. Let us assume that, for full-time courses, the average class size is 20; the highest average class size that we have had over a year has, I think, been nine. In theory, therefore, it costs us twice as much per student to deliver courses, but we do not receive twice as much funding per student.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Obviously some of that can be addressed by sharing services in the future, but it seems to me that there is a fundamental in-built unfairness if targets do not reflect the reality of the situation and if the subsidy or the money that go to the college do not reflect the true additional cost—particularly unit costs—of being in a remote rural island community. It seems to me that we need to get those fundamentals right before we can judge whether the college is performing properly or not.

Clive Mulholland
link

Can I come in there from the university’s perspective? We are funded for further education on a regional basis.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I am not blaming you, by the way.

Clive Mulholland
link

I am going to come on to that. I have an ask.

We are funded on a regional basis, so even though the college has underperformed and has not met its targets, the region as a whole has; in fact, it has overperformed. Our responsibility is to look at the situation on a regional basis. However, when the region includes colleges like Lews Castle College that are in very fragile areas, there are difficulties, and education is more expensive to deliver. If we had taken the decision, when the funding model came to us, to fund the college based just on activity levels, it would have had a catastrophic effect on the college.

We have to do two things. First, we have to try to reshape the college to get it to a better position. The other thing is this—and this is the ask. We argue that it becomes a political decision about what you are willing to fund, because the college may never be completely self-sustaining in its own right. That might be possible for the college as part of a larger organisation, but we argue that because of the additional teaching costs we should get increased funding for each student. It follows that, if you make that political decision, you support regional development.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

On wider economic issues, every successful Government’s policy since the Parliament was established has been to do what we can to increase the population and, especially, to retain younger people in the island communities. Therefore, reducing in any way the quality and range of services that are provided by a college such as Lews Castle College will work against that policy because, clearly, the age profile of people who go to college is younger. It seems to me that we need to be very clear about the wider policy issues in relation to a community like Lewis. Inverness is at the other end of the spectrum and is supposedly the fastest-growing city in the UK, if not in Europe. Therefore, as you say, UHI is dealing with Inverness at one end and Lewis at the other and it has to be recognised that the two are in completely different scenarios.

Clive Mulholland
link

The primary purpose of the UHI being set up was to stop the drain of young people out of the region.

Clive Mulholland
link

It was absolutely clear that when young people went to the central belt or elsewhere for education, they never came back.

Clive Mulholland
link

We have been very successful in retaining them, but that comes at a cost. In a regionally dispersed organisation, the costs are much higher; we have to maintain 13 libraries, 13 learning and resource centres and all that goes with them.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The answer is for us to get control of VAT here and then abolish VAT on the cost of services between the colleges. That might fund the additional resources that we need for colleges such as Lews Castle College.

Clive Mulholland
link

If you could get rid of VAT, we would be delighted.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Unfortunately, at the moment, we do not have control over VAT—but I am sure that that will change, Liam.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Is that relevant, Mr Neil?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Of course it is. It is relevant to what the witnesses were saying.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

We will move on.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I want to pick up the discussion that Alex Neil has led so capably. We settled on the point that what is set nationally will not always work at the local level. Has the college or UHI made a case to the Scottish Government about that apparent mismatch?

11:00

Clive Mulholland
link

Yes. I take every opportunity that I can to say—my colleagues across the partnership say it, too—that we face very big challenges that are unlike those that are faced by other universities in Scotland.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Do you think that the Scottish Government recognises those challenges?

Clive Mulholland
link

Yes, I think that it does. I think that everybody recognises the challenges. The difficulty is in what to do about them.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Thank you.

I know that previously a large number of your students were part-time learners and older students. Given the change in national policy, what are the learning opportunities for students who are over 24 in the island communities?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

We still have a wide range of learning opportunities, but what has happened as a result of the changes is that we have had to focus more on our full-time courses. Our resources are being taken up by the full-time courses, so we do not have the capacity to develop new activities for other groups. We have been working at building that activity back up again and trying to make sure that we are providing interesting and useful opportunities for people. In the past we were offering courses when nothing else was available, so it was a lot easier to attract people to come and do them, but we now have to be a bit more innovative and make things more interesting in order to attract people to come in. That has been difficult in the financial climate that we have had.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I am sure that, as part of the work that you are doing, you are always taking the needs of local employers into account. Are you able to say something about the local labour market and any change in trends since the new policies came into effect?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

Yes. We have been touched particularly hard, I think, by the downturn in the oil and gas industry. We have very good pathways through to qualifications on the engineering side of our activities that provided good opportunities, for young people in particular, to be trained to work in the oil and gas sector. Many of those people went to work offshore, but they maintained their homes and families on the islands. That has been a difficult transition for us because the assumption, particularly among young people in terms of their aspirations and perceptions, is that that tap has just been turned off, which it has not.

There are still opportunities in oil and gas but, unfortunately, much of the media coverage is about oil and gas being in crisis and about big reductions. That has resulted in fewer young people wanting to take engineering qualifications. We are looking to address that and to encourage more people to get back in there, because there is still work; there will be work available for them.

We have had particular challenges in respect of the construction trades and industry. There are quite a number of courses that we still offer, but in which the numbers are getting so small that it is becoming very difficult for us to maintain traditional construction industry trades courses. We are working with the trade bodies and companies to try to do something about that.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

That is helpful. I will finish. Are you getting support from the industries themselves? I know that the Audit Scotland report talked about how your marketing efforts have perhaps not been effective. Is there more that the industry can do to support your work?

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

Yes, there is always more that the industry can do. We will not be able to train apprentices if they are not actually taken on by companies. Companies have, at times, been finding it difficult to even recruit traditional apprentices because—again—there seems not to be the motivation to go into an industry that is perhaps seen as uncertain and in which work is not guaranteed.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

I have a great deal of sympathy with the points that my colleagues make about the numbers and how it is all arrived at. My difficulty is that the college has effectively been funded for eight years—or, if you like, on eight separate occasions—in excess of what it needed for it to deliver. There has to be an argument that somebody is funding that and that the other colleges are almost subsidising that shortfall. That begs a question of UHI. As I understand it, you recovered that funding—which is, if you like, overspend—on only one occasion in eight years. Why did you not recover the money? Who made the decision, and based on what criteria?

Clive Mulholland
link

UHI was not responsible for that funding before 2015-16. The Scottish Funding Council funded the college before that.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

I was going to ask about the SFC afterwards, so perhaps you could deal with that now.

Clive Mulholland
link

The SFC funded the college, so that is a question that you need to ask it. We are aware of the situation that the college is in. The problem is—as I said—that if we were just to claw that money back instantly from the college, it would have a huge impact on it. We do not want to do that. We want to work with the college to develop as sustainable a model as we can. Again, that is another reason why you have a regional university and all the colleges within it.

The analogy that I would make is to a traditional university. The situation is a bit like that. There are some faculties that are seen as the cash cows and they support the others; for example, engineering and the business faculties quite often cross-subsidise humanities faculties. In our case, we work together as a collective of all those; with 13 partners, we will always be in a position in which some are up and some are down, because the local challenges are very different at different times. As a group and an institution like that, we have to try to manage that process.

Ideally, I would like every college to be self-sustaining and to deliver a surplus that we could use to reinvest in the business, but there are certain restrictions on us. One way of dealing with that is for us to get better at what we do. As I said earlier, the other way is to push harder for additional funding for the region and to get recognition of the fact that it is more expensive to deliver across large parts of our organisation.

Iain Macmillan Lews Castle College
link

Can I comment on that? I understand what the deputy convener is saying, but I have difficulty with some of your wording because it suggests that we are, because we are spending all the money that we receive, somehow using money in a way that is improper. We spend the money on delivering the learning and teaching that we offer across the piece. We are not using the money in an improper way; we are using the money to the best effect that we can in terms of what we offer. The reality is that if UHI or the SFC were to take the money back, they would find that we have spent it on delivering services. It is not that we have that money sitting somewhere or that we are not working for the benefit of our students—albeit that there are not as many of them as in the targets that have been set for us.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

I certainly did not intend to imply anything like that; let me give that reassurance.

Mr Mulholland made a good point, but is there not a risk that other colleges in the fold will look at what has happened over eight years as almost a disincentive for them to meet their targets? Irrespective of whether you were able to do so, they will be looking at the situation and saying that UHI recovered the overfunding—if I can put it that way—on only one occasion out of eight years, so why should they strive to meet their targets? Why could they not just do the same thing?

Clive Mulholland
link

I can answer that. We now have a process in place. It goes back to some of the questions that, I think, Mr Neil was asking earlier about involvement in setting the targets. We inherited the model from the funding council. In relation the seven years before that, you would have to ask the funding council.

We inherited the model and we are in a transition at the minute. We did not want to do anything that would put one of the colleges in peril and at risk. We now have a process in place, through our further educational regional board. All the partners can input to that, and they determine how they will allocate the resources among the partnership. We are reducing the credits that are given to Lews Castle College; that is a deliberate decision. We are moving away from the status quo, but we want to do it in a managed way. As you suggest, I do not want us to be in a position in which people think that they can just sit back, so we are changing that process. The process will continue to evolve over the next couple of years as we refine the funding model.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

I have one final question, just to wrap up. Are you aware of other colleges in the fold that are experiencing difficulties in achieving their targets?

Clive Mulholland
link

Some of them are quite close to that, but—again—that is a reflection of their fragile environment, and it is a reflection of the financial environment that we are in, at the minute. None of them, however, is in the position that Moray College is in.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you. Colleagues have no further questions. I thank the witnesses.

11:11 Meeting continued in private until 11:30.

  1. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. Section 22 Reports Evidence session · 273
  3. 10:15 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 106

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.