Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Reports

“The 2015/16 audit of Moray College”

Thursday 22 June 2017 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee Evidence session 273 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

273 contributions · showing 1–200
Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Item 2 is evidence on “The 2015/16 audit of Moray College”. We have already taken evidence from the Auditor General for Scotland and Audit Scotland, so I welcome today’s witnesses. From Moray College, we have assistant principal Anne Lindsay, board chair Peter Graham, board vice-chair and chair of the finance and general purposes committee Murray Easton, and director of finance Nick Clinton. From the University of the Highlands and Islands—UHI—we have principal and vice-chancellor Clive Mulholland and secretary and chief operating officer Fiona Larg.

Before moving to questions, I will briefly set out some background to this evidence session. The Auditor General told us:

“We are seeing a failure of financial management, which at the highest level manifested in the need to ask for what was effectively emergency funding from UHI in 2014-15 and in 2015-16 so that the college could pay its bills and meet its financial obligations. That should not happen in a public body”.—Official Report, Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee, 18 May 2017; c 27.

The funding in question amounted to almost £700,000 in 2015-16. It is also worth noting that Moray College’s staff costs accounted for 72 per cent of its gross expenditure in 2015-16, which is higher than the Scottish average of 63 per cent. It is estimated that those staff costs will increase to 78 per cent for 2016-17.

I now invite Peter Graham, the chair of the board, to make a brief opening statement.

Peter Graham Moray College
link

Thank you very much. I am chairman of the board of Moray College, and you have taken the first three lines of my introduction, in which I was going to introduce people. I apologise; I will just catch up.

We want to get to the root cause of the financial situation. Although the financial year in question is 2015-16, almost all the underlying issues existed at the end of 2014-15. As with most significant incidents, there is no single cause. The situation arose as a result of a number of risks being exposed by a series of circumstances, events and behaviours that came together during 2014-15 and combined to create a sequence of deficiencies across the college’s system of internal control, which resulted in the breakdown of financial management.

The biggest contributing factor was the poor performance of the then financial director during 2014-15, which was something that could not have been legislated for. That was followed by a leave of absence during 2015-16. I must point out that Nick Clinton has been in place for only three weeks as our new financial director, so it is important that there is no cross-referencing or mixing up of financial directors.

Underlying risk factors that affected the wider control environment at the time included the following: the regulatory framework; changes in the education sector since 2014, including the Office for National Statistics reclassification process and associated changes in financial reporting; budgetary pressures, including reductions in funding, as well as inflationary pressures on payrolls and other costs; budgetary control, including weaknesses in process, compliance and systems; internal reporting, including inconsistencies in data and irregular timing of reports; senior management team factors, including changes at principal and assistant principal levels and compassionate leave being taken; and board factors including, for instance, the chair of the finance and general purposes committee having personal issues that meant that he was unavailable for a large part of that period.

There were also UHI factors: the role of the regional strategic body was still being defined and implemented, and there was the interrelationship between the two institutions. There were Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council factors, such as agreement to requests for early drawing down of funds from April 2014.

There was a fair catalogue of errors and mistakes, but the management and the board of Moray College believes that the issues that are within its control have been and are being subsequently addressed. Thank you very much.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you. I will direct the first question to Anne Lindsay, if I may. I believe that there was some confusion about your attendance today. Will you clear that up for us, please?

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

I am not aware of any confusion over my attendance. I think that the college decided that the best approach was for the financial expertise people—our director of finance and our convener of the finance and general purposes committee—to come today. As a senior executive member, I am happy also to attend.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Right. Thank you.

I will look at the voluntary severance scheme, but before I do I have a brief question for Mr Graham. Did I hear correctly in your opening statement that you put a lot of the difficulties down to the poor performance of a previous finance director?

Peter Graham Moray College
link

Yes. I ask Murray Easton to answer on that for me.

Murray Easton Moray College
link

I was not there at the time—I have been in the position on the board for only the past year—but it seems that what happened was that the finance director at the time had been there for a considerable time and had built up a strong level of trust with the board and the management team based on his track record. There had been nothing to suggest anything untoward in his performance—there had been no financial irregularities up to that point and no evidence of anything other than good and competent management of the college’s financial affairs. It was only in that last year that somehow his behaviour changed. It seems that there were a number of contributing factors, including all the pressures of the changes that were brought in by the ONS reclassification, budgetary pressures on him, and other things that Peter Graham alluded to.

That does not necessarily mean that the underlying procedures and controls in the college were broken. There were some weaknesses that we picked up and addressed, but we could not legislate for that apparent change in behaviour, in which a new principal at the time and the FD, under pressure, resorted to a style of behaviour that seemed to be more about holding the line of the budget and not releasing bad news and being focused more on financial reporting obligations to the SFC than on using good financial data to run the affairs of the college.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

The previous financial director is no longer there.

Murray Easton Moray College
link

That is correct; he went on sick leave during 2015-16 and left the college in the middle of last year.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Do you recall the terms under which he left? Was it a straight resignation, or was there—

Peter Graham Moray College
link

Can I answer that?

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Yes.

Peter Graham Moray College
link

It was a compromise agreement. It is confidential between the college and him, but it was a managed departure.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Right. Let us look at compromise agreements and voluntary severance. There is a proposed scheme. Are you in a position to give us an update on where the voluntary severance scheme is, please?

Peter Graham Moray College
link

I am. We are still, with the assistance of the UHI, answering questions to the Scottish funding council, with a view to putting together a scheme. Applications closed two weeks ago. I do not think that it would be fair to the parties who have applied to go into individuals, but there were a dozen applicants, 10 of whose applications we have made a business case for accepting. We are still in discussion with the Scottish funding council. As late as last night, we were talking to John Kemp.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

I think you said that 12 people have applied. Are any of the 12 members of the senior management team or senior members of the college?

Peter Graham Moray College
link

Yes.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Are you prepared to say—

Peter Graham Moray College
link

I cannot. That would not be fair on those members of staff or our position. I am discussing the matter with the Scottish funding council. We are answering questions with it and are dealing with the matter and moving it forward. I do not know whether Clive Mulholland would like to add to that.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Yes. The university, in its role as a strategic body, and the Scottish funding council are working with the college. UHI, too, has a series of questions about what is being proposed. That is still under discussion with the Scottish funding council, at the minute.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Are you at liberty to say what proportion of the 12 applicants are from the senior management?

09:00

Peter Graham Moray College
link

No, I do not think so, really. I would want the Scottish funding council to advise me on how I should proceed with that. For me to suggest that there are members of staff who may or may not be leaving at this stage—we do not know; we have not got the funding council’s agreement to our proposals—would be very difficult and unfair to those members of staff.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

But it is fair to say that it is at least a possibility that, in a situation that is considerably challenging, some members of the senior management team who perhaps could be said to have got the college into this situation may be leaving with a large pay-off in the not-too-distant future. Is that fair?

Peter Graham Moray College
link

I am afraid that I disagree with that. That is extremely unfair. I think that the current senior management team did everything that they could to help during the period, including Anne Lindsay, who stepped up to be vice-principal when the principal was away and when the other principal left. As far as I can see, the board addressed the issues.

Remember that I joined the board in August last year. I have been chair for a month, during which time I have done little else but this, as you might expect. However, the position, as far as I understand it, was that the senior management team very much stepped up to the mark and caught the problem at the point where things were going wrong. The principal left and the financial director was managed out of the business. The management team then moved very quickly, with UHI help, to start to remedy the situation.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Is it felt that, of itself, the voluntary severance scheme will work? If we accept that some senior management and some, I guess, academic staff are going—

Peter Graham Moray College
link

And support staff.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

And support staff. This concerns me, because it rather strikes me that the end product that a college sells is, if you like, the ability to teach pupils. How do you—

Peter Graham Moray College
link

Can I point you to your own figures at the start? You said that 72 per cent of our income went on staff and that the average in Scotland was 63 per cent. We need to address that and bring the figure into line with the other colleges, but we are not allowed to make redundancies, so we have to do it in this way. That is our ambition, and I think you will see that our financial recovery plan is already achieving that.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

I accept that, but if the product is the provision of teaching—the provision of education—is it possible, in your view, to cut staff through a voluntary severance scheme without diminishing that product?

Peter Graham Moray College
link

I believe so.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Have you done the analysis? Is there a business plan?

Peter Graham Moray College
link

Of course we have: we have very detailed analysis that we have submitted to the Scottish funding council. There is for every individual who has applied a business case that shows where they sit. We have spoken to their curriculum leaders and we have dealt internally to manage the transition so that it is not an influence on students. We have spoken to the unions and have assured them that we would not be taking any of these actions if we were unable to show that they would not impact on students and the student experience.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I would like to talk about governance. What is the size of the board of Moray College?

Peter Graham Moray College
link

We are currently in transition. It was 18, but we have three members who are at the point of resignation. The previous chair, who was the acting chair for a year—he was the vice-chair—Ash Major, will now leave even his position as vice-chair at the end of the month, and two other members of the board are retiring. Next week, we will interview three candidates who are coming forward to fill their places. We are not sure whether we wish to maintain the size of the board at 18 or gradually reduce it, but we are trying to make sure that we have a proper transect in the classifications that we need on the board.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Eighteen seems quite a large board.

Peter Graham Moray College
link

Yes, it does. It is a legacy that I have been left, and it is something that we will strive to amend. On any board, there are those who appear not to turn up from time to time and we need to have a managed process to deal with that, which we are putting in place.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Looking back at the role of the board over the past few years, as the difficulties arose, did the board receive regular financial updates all the way through?

Peter Graham Moray College
link

Obviously, I was not there at that time, as I joined the board in August last year. That question is probably for Murray.

Murray Easton Moray College
link

I was not there either, but the evidence suggests that the quality and the timing of the information were not what should have been expected by the board and the finance and general purposes committee. The information was not adequate.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Looking as far back as 2014-15, the auditor said that the board and committee minutes did not evidence decisions that were agreed. What was the point?

Murray Easton Moray College
link

The point of what?

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The point of minutes that did not say what had been agreed.

Murray Easton Moray College
link

I do not know. All that I can say is that it is not that way now. I cannot comment on what happened at that time.

Peter Graham Moray College
link

Can I add to that?

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

We are trying to explore how the situation arose in the first place and ensure that it does not happen again, so we need to understand what went wrong and where the disconnects were.

Peter Graham Moray College
link

I could not agree more. There were failings, but we do not have the evidence. The people who were there at the time are no longer there and are no longer employed by the college—they are away from the institution—so I do not quite know how we can get that evidence. We know that the information was poor.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Looking forward, Murray Easton just said that it is not that way now and that proper records are kept, including proper records of decisions that have been taken—is that so?

Murray Easton Moray College
link

Absolutely. I would not say that the records that were kept at the time were not correct, as the basic accounting information was sound. What we are talking about is deficiencies in the process of sharing management information with the senior management team and the board. Different information was being shared in reporting to the SFC; different information was being held on the accounting system for forecasts, not for the accounts themselves; and inconsistent information was being given—and not on a timely basis—to the board.

What we have in place now is what I would call single data flow. It is a single set of financial information, and its primary purpose is to enable the management of the college to use that financial information to run the affairs of the college. The same core data set is then used to feed the Scottish funding council reporting requirements and the needs and requirements of the board, and that is done on a timely basis. We have quarterly management accounts, and we have an understanding about there being no surprises whereby, if anything comes out during the quarter, rather than wait until the next meeting of the finance committee or the board, the finance director will share that information with relevant members at the time to allow a live conversation to be had.

Peter Graham Moray College
link

Can I ask Murray to take us a little bit into the future?

Murray Easton Moray College
link

Do you want me to talk about the financial recovery plan?

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Can I just ask a question? I am still looking at the historical side and trying to understand some aspects of that. At what point did UHI become aware of the difficulties, and what action was taken at that point?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

I will start off, and then I will ask Fiona Larg to come in. We became aware of the difficulties in June 2015, and we had to make a cash advance to the college. At that time, we took a report to our own finance and general purposes committee, and we then wrote to the college asking for an explanation of how it got to that position and for certain things to be done. We engaged with the college very quickly, and we sought additional information. We wanted a recovery plan, as we wanted to see what the college was going to do to get itself out of that position.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You became aware that there was a problem in June 2015. There were difficulties at that time with the board getting financial information and dealing with the situation. What support did you give it?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

We offered lots of support. We offered the support of our existing financial staff, and we offered support at an individual level.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

No, it was not. That was the board that existed at that time; there is a different board now.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Do we know why that assistance was not accepted?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

I can only speculate, because I do not know what their thoughts were. At that stage, we were transitioning from a structure in which the relationship was directly with the Scottish funding council. Under the Post-16 Education (Scotland) Act 2013, the university became the regional strategic body, and, during that transition, there was some resistance in the relationships between the college, the regional strategic body and the funding council.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I presume that the college did not just say, “No”; I presume that it said, “No, because—”.

Fiona Larg University of the Highlands and Islands
link

I would say that it was not, “No, because—”; it was much more that the college felt that it had the situation under control. We had several meetings with the chair, board members and senior staff in the college at the time—

Fiona Larg University of the Highlands and Islands
link

We continued to ask a lot of detailed questions for many months. Not all the information that we asked for was provided when we asked for it, but, over several meetings, we were able to get more information. Certainly, the college resisted direct intervention by us at that stage.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You just accepted that over an extended period.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

No, we did not. We pushed and pushed as hard as we could to get the information, but the board at the time was not willing to engage with the regional strategic body. We did get the information, however. As Fiona Larg said, we managed to extract the information from the board, and we got various data sets from the college.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

According to the Audit Scotland report, the board of the college was struggling to get information, so the information that it gave you must have been fairly limited.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Yes, you could say that. As it is an independent college, its board has a responsibility to ensure that the information that it provides to the regional strategic body is correct, so we have to go with the information that is provided to us by the college.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

If you knew over an extended period that there was a problem and you knew that the college was refusing assistance, what did you do other than press it? Surely, you escalated the matter up the line.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

We did, but we worked with the college and started to get the information out of it. We had a number of meetings with both the chair of the board at the time and the principal.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

To whom did you escalate the matter?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

We escalated it to the finance and general purposes committee of the university and then to the university court.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

And outside the university?

Fiona Larg University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Yes, to the Scottish funding council.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

What advice did it give you?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

The Scottish funding council worked with us to help the college as much as we could.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The SFC got in touch directly with the college.

Fiona Larg University of the Highlands and Islands
link

No, it got in touch through UHI.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

It was through UHI. I am trying to see where—

Fiona Larg University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Any letter that went to the college was copied to us. Basically, the funding council was making sure—

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

What did the funding council tell the college?

Fiona Larg University of the Highlands and Islands
link

That it was concerned.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You saw the letters. What did they tell the college—that it had to engage with you?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Not so much in those words, but they said that the problem needed to be fixed and, as we were the regional strategic body, we all had to work together to solve the issue.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Was that not a bit weak? You had had months of problems, a board that was not engaging, inadequate financial information, a deficit situation and a college that was looking for funding. You escalated the matter and—nothing.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

I would not say that it was nothing; it just took a lot longer than we were hoping it would. We have learned our lessons from the situation. The explanation that I would give is that, at that stage, when we were transitioning into the regional strategic body role, there were complications around relationships. Relationships were difficult at that time, when it came to who was supposed to be talking to whom. Since then, we have tightened up on that and we are getting much more regular financial information from all the partners. We have also put in place new committee structures in order to have much greater oversight. We will be much more directive and interventional in the future, because that is our role as a regional strategic body.

09:15

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Do you think that, if you had been more decisive when the problem arose, it could have been fixed a lot more quickly?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Potentially, yes. It was a learning exercise for us as we transitioned into a regional body.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Do you believe that now, as a regional body, you have the authority to intervene and direct the colleges?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Yes, we do.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

It seems to me that, in the past, you escalated the matter to the SFC and it just lay on somebody’s desk.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

We have also made changes to governance. I will ask Fiona Larg to explain the appointment of the people who are on the board now.

Fiona Larg University of the Highlands and Islands
link

I will put it into context. We took over the regional strategic body responsibilities on 1 August 2014. At that stage, we had legacy boards in each of our five incorporated colleges. Part of the Post-16 Education (Scotland) Act 2013 provided that, when the new boards came in, it was UHI as the regional strategic body that made the appointments of the chairs of the colleges and all the independent members, but it took quite a while to transition to the new boards. At that stage, the Moray College board had been appointed by Moray College itself and had a feeling of autonomy and much greater independence from UHI than the current board has, because the current chair and independent members were appointed by us. That has been a major change.

There was also a legacy of regular financial and performance information not being provided to UHI under the previous regime, because, up until 2014, all that we funded was higher education. It took some time to work with the partners to get them to provide all the data that we now get on a regular basis.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

We are keen to ensure that this does not happen again. If I am interpreting correctly what you say, you believe that you now have clear guidelines—for want of a better word—on how you would approach the situation in the future and that there would be direct intervention at a much earlier stage.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Yes.

Fiona Larg University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Yes.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The SFC does not seem to have backed you up with any particular strength when you approached it with the original problem. Am I wrong?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

No, I would not put it like that. There was confusion over the relationships between the college, the regional strategic body and the Scottish funding council, which was not—

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

We were all unclear. It did not help that, at that time, the board continued to write to the funding council when the roles were shifting to the regional strategic body.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You are satisfied that that would not be the case going forward.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Yes, I am. We have put in place what Fiona Larg has described and other measures. We will be much more directive in the future.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I would be interested in seeing a copy of those rules or guidelines.

You say that you now have a process. I presume that that process is documented.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

At a governance level, that process is followed through the appointments that Fiona Larg has just talked about. At the executive level, we have changed the executive structure within the university and created two new bodies. There is a partnership council that involves all the principals, and we have started to scrutinise much more closely what is happening in each of the partners. We also have a new SMT that has a number of the principals from the partners on it as well. Interruption. Excuse me—my hay fever is playing up this morning. Together with the governance structure that we have put in place and the new data sets that we are getting, those bodies give us confidence that we have much better control over what is happening across the partnership.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I hope that that structure is not as bureaucratic as it sounds. Do you have a documented process for dealing with issues that arise in colleges?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

No. There is no specific protocol as such, because a multitude of issues could arise in a college. We could spend all our time in writing processes or protocols.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I am thinking of a particular case in which a college is—for want of a better word—failing.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

We have a process in that the data set that we would use to examine the situation and the data that we would look at would be considered at a number of levels and the matter would then be escalated. It would be considered at the SMT and the partnership council and then escalated to the finance and general purposes committee of the university and, ultimately, the university court as the regional strategic body. In addition, we have a further education regional board that is made up of all the chairs of the colleges. It is quite a complicated governance structure.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Yes, it is. Have you ever thought of simplifying it?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Yes, I have.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

We have made changes to the governance structure within the limitations that we have at the minute.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you, Mr Beattie. I think that Jackie Baillie wishes to carry on the questioning in that regard.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

It is just a short supplementary question to the college, rather than UHI.

I think that the witnesses would accept that this is not—and I am sure they are not suggesting that it is—simply down to one person. The board and the senior management team have responsibilities too. I entirely accept that the three gentlemen here came in after the event—in the case of Mr Clinton, three weeks ago. I appreciate that it is difficult for them to answer for things that they do not know about. However, Anne Lindsay was there for the duration of the process and stepped up to the plate at least once if not twice to take the senior position. I wonder, Anne, if we could address to you some of the questions about what happened, what was done to fix the problems and what interaction there was between you and UHI. What did they ask of you? What did you do or not do in relation to those requests? We need a fuller picture from somebody who was actually there.

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

We had a principal in place from August 2014 until March 2015—they were in post only for eight months. I was not in the college for some of that time, but that is not relevant. When I picked up the role in March 2015, it became clear to me fairly quickly that we did not have the financial management information that we had had previously. As well as all the other contributing factors that we have already discussed—they should not be underestimated, to be fair to the teams—that year we had an unexpected and significant drop in our higher education student numbers. During that period—from August to March—we had not in any way altered our budgets to line up with the fact that we would have less income through having fewer HE students. From an operational point of view, that was the key impact that made the cash advance necessary. For whatever reason, we had not altered the budgets. In our normal processes—we follow them now, obviously, but we also followed them before—the budgets are set on targets and every September/October, once the student numbers are in, we realign them. That has served us well in the past. However, in that year, we had a significant drop in HE students that was not recognised.

As soon as I became acting principal in March 2015, we made an incredible number of changes to our budget controls. There is no doubt that, for whatever reason, the position really had deteriorated over a short time. I found that it was very difficult to ascertain our financial position. It took us some time, working with our FD, to establish where we were. That would not occur now—absolutely not—and it would not have occurred before then either, to be honest. It cannot be overstated just how long it took us to look forensically at all the accounts and all the finances for that period. That genuinely took time.

As a member of the executive, I worked quite directly with the director of finance at UHI at the time and sought help. In terms of the best way forward, I also immediately contacted our internal and external auditors. I contacted the SFC directly, because, as Fiona Larg said, regionalisation was emerging at the time. SFC told me that my link was through UHI, and I was comfortable with that. I received support directly from the executive team at UHI, and that helped.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

How long did it take to get the finances to a position in which there was a degree of clarity?

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

We had quite a bit of clarity by about June or July. We also immediately improved the information that we were giving to the board. I completely agree that the information given to the board between August and March was not fit for purpose. It was not inaccurate; it was just lacking in detail and there was the minimum in terms of commentary—there was very little discussion of variances and so on. We immediately improved the information that went to the board. Again, that took a while. Over 2015-16, we were still identifying financial issues—they are in the report—that had an impact on our cash flow the following year, and it took us some time to recognise them. Also, because of our financial situation, we immediately looked at trying to reduce our non-staffing costs as much as possible; obviously, student services and teaching were paramount.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Just so that I am clear, according to what you are saying to me, it took from March to June or July to get some clarity.

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

To get initial clarity, yes.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Okay, we will agree to use the term “initial clarity”. At that stage, you were talking to the board about the issue, but then the problem repeated for another year.

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

We continued to improve the information that was going to the board over that period, but I accept that it was not totally sufficient until the new board was in place.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

You required a cash advance of a similar magnitude the following year, so the problem remained.

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

We required a cash advance the following year. I think that one of the factors that caused that was the £368,000 cash advance in 2014-15—to be honest, that was a large amount of money to have to pay back in one year. We always recognised that that might be difficult to achieve. Although I was surprised at the size of the cash advance required the following year, we always considered that there might be a cash advance issue due to the £368,000 in the first year.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Can you clear something up for me? I might have misheard, but I think that I heard UHI say that the college did not accept help, yet you seem to indicate that you did. What is the truth?

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

I personally received help on the executive side. I cannot discuss the board and its relationship with UHI’s finance and general purposes committee.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

I can clarify that. There was a good relationship with the executive and with Anne Lindsay in particular. The real challenge came from the board, and the pushback came from the board itself. I reiterate: it is a different board from what we have today.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Thank you, convener—I will leave it there. I am sure that other members will pick up the issue.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

I want to be absolutely clear about this. Fiona Larg said that various bits of performance and financial information were not being provided to UHI to allow it to help. Does that cross over with the period that Anne Lindsay is talking about?

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

It does, in the sense that, in June 2015, the college was still trying to ascertain whether we had all the financial management information that we were used to having. From my perspective, it was not that we were not willing to send the information; we genuinely had difficulty in extracting the information for some time. We did a forensic check of our entire finance system. We put incredible new systems in place. We changed our software. We changed the work of the finance team. We immediately had significant information at executive level in terms of budgetary control. To be honest, my primary aim was to ensure that we were in control of our budgets again because, in my view, we had not been for a while. My primary aim was to ensure that we had budgetary information.

In the sense of providing higher-level information, we always provided what we had, but we were sometimes not able to justify or explain why the figures were as they were. It was a dramatic deterioration over a very short time.

09:30

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Okay, but Fiona Larg’s evidence was along the lines that UHI just was not getting the information. You seem to be saying that you did not have the information to give and were taking steps to remedy that. Why were you not telling UHI that you did not have the information to give it? What you are saying is not what I understood from Fiona Larg.

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

I personally was discussing matters with UHI’s director of finance, who was of some support. I am not an accountant. In fact, UHI provided quite good financial support and told us what the key areas were and so on. I personally had a good relationship with UHI.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

Just for the record—

Murray Easton Moray College
link

It might be helpful if I could add a little clarity. There is an obligation on the college to do quarterly financial returns to the Scottish funding council. Those returns were submitted on time and would have been available to UHI. It would have had access to that level of information. The issue was whether the quality of the forecasts in the returns was appropriate and accurate or whether the forecasts were masking reality, such that, although UHI had information, that information was not telling the story of what was happening in the college. That appears to have been what was happening. Information was out there, but it may not have been appropriate and up to date.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I will pursue that. Mr Graham explained that a litany of problems arose and that they seemed to arise quite suddenly. From what he says, the previous finance director, under whom all this appears to have happened, served the college well until a series of events seemed to happen at once. Obviously, something went wrong. I do not want to get into personalities, but did nobody think to suspend the finance director, given what was found out, and at least bring in someone from outside to get it sorted? Did he remain the finance director throughout the period?

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

The finance director very shortly thereafter went on sick leave.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Was he replaced by a temporary replacement?

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

Eventually, but not for some time. It was not initially established when he would return. Another accountant in the college had her duties extended, and she led us through the period of getting back on track with all our information. We had a qualified accountant in the organisation.

However, there is no doubt that we were underresourced. We have to remember that we are talking about 2014-15, and I genuinely do not think that we can overestimate the real impact on finance staff of the things that were happening. We had regionalisation and we had the new reporting framework following the ONS reclassification of the college framework, so we had considerable change. My reflection is that, in finance, we perhaps gave too much time and priority to ensuring that all the reports were returned to UHI and the SFC and not enough to what I would class as the core finance role. There is an element of there being so much change that it was genuinely quite overwhelming, but I have to say that the staff who remained dealt with it all very well immediately thereafter.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Thank you. You said that, when you were put in charge of things, you notified the internal and external auditors pretty quickly. What did they do?

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

My reason for informing them was to ensure that Moray’s problem was well known, because ensuring that we let everyone know that we had problems was paramount for me. Both sets of auditors were generally very supportive, and I had great discussions with them. We talked through different strategies for financial recovery. We talked about priorities, and, of course, the priority was budgetary control, which, at the time, was lacking. Both sets of auditors provided quite a bit of support in the brief initial timescale.

Once we had resolved our budgetary control issues and implemented the new systems—after a period of about six months had elapsed—I asked the internal auditors to do a specific audit on budgetary control, cash flow and so on to ensure that what we had put in place was fit for purpose and effective and that we were implementing it according to our own procedures. Although they made one or two recommendations to help us improve further, overall the internal auditors were satisfied that we were back on track.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

You notified the SFC. What support did it provide?

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

I contacted the SFC directly, because, as I said, at the time we were literally just forming the Highlands and Islands FE region. Its response to me was that, due to regionalisation, I had to contact UHI instead. I had already done that, and I continued after that—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The SFC batted it back to UHI, basically.

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

Yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Did the SFC leave it at that? Did it come back three months later to check? Was there no monitoring from the SFC?

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

No. As Murray Easton said, we returned all the reports—we never missed a report—and the SFC did not come back.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It did not come back at all?

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

No. UHI—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Right. It was very hands-off.

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

The SFC? Absolutely.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Can I widen this out a bit? Obviously, the University of the Highlands and Islands has a unique arrangement, given that it is made up of 13 colleges that are, in effect, also FE colleges. Building on what Colin Beattie said, if you start with Moray College, for example, you have the finance and general purposes committee, then you have the board, then you have UHI and, within that, a partnership board and other boards, as well as full-time staff and so on and the new appointee, and then, at the top of the tree, you have the SFC. It is little wonder that there was mayhem, is it not? How many bodies are involved? It must be a very bureaucratic and slow process with that number of people involved.

My question is for Clive Mulholland. What is the role in the Highlands and Islands of the SFC, UHI or the regional college board and the colleges? How much autonomy do the colleges have? Where do you come in, and where does the SFC come in to tell you what to do? What sanctions do you have if a principal or a board of a college decides that they do not agree with you? What sanctions do you have, if any, to impose your point of view?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

I would not say that it is mayhem; I would say that it is very complicated. UHI is unique. It is a very different sort of university. The only way that a university presence in the Highlands and Islands could be created was by bringing the colleges together. We are a federal university; we are federated with the individual colleges. We have a number of relationships with them, which is where it gets complicated. The 13 colleges are academic partners of the university, so they deliver the higher education element. There is a partnership arrangement, but the university is also now a regional strategic body for further education funding. We play a number of roles, and that can be difficult to work through politically, particularly as we cover an area that is bigger than Belgium. It goes from the Shetland Islands all the way down to Argyll, and the pressures and challenges in each location are very different. We have a challenging position there in itself.

We had to consider that there was no location anywhere in the Highlands and Islands that would have the critical mass necessary to create a university. By bringing all the colleges together we were able to create the University of the Highlands and Islands, which has performed incredibly well. In the last research excellence exercise, we performed incredibly well for a university that is only four or five years old.

We are young, we are growing and we are developing. We still have a lot to learn. We have the complications of the regional strategic body, which came into being in 2015-16, so we have had to work and feel our way through them. Unlike a traditional university or an institution with a single governance structure, where you can be very directive, in a federated relationship you have to bring people with you, in a lot of cases. We have the geopolitical dimension of the partnership as well.

My view is that, over time, the governance structures will change. I am not clear on how long that will be, because it will depend on how fast there is an appetite for change, but it is a complicated structure. I have been in the Highlands and Islands for three years. I do not claim to understand the politics completely, but it took me about a year and a half to start to understand how the relationships all work.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Is there not a built-in conflict of interests? The roles of higher and further education are distinct. Obviously, the colleges are involved in further and higher education. You now act as the regional college board as well as the university. It is a two-headed monster, is it not?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

We have turned that on its head. We see this as an opportunity. We are the first tertiary university in the UK, so we cover further education and higher education. We are proud of the fact that we are tertiary. We are breaking down a lot of the barriers around traditional education and the separation between further and higher education. Half of our higher education students do a vocational course first and then want to go on to higher education. We see that as being very distinctive. We see ourselves as mapping closely against the learner journey and as putting students at the centre. We see ourselves doing things that are very different. The problem that we have is that we come up against barriers because the structures are all set up for further education or higher education. We get difficulties when it comes to that.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That leads to my next question: has the time not come to recognise that you are a different beast from the rest of the higher and further education system? Would it not be much more effective just to have one unified management structure, recognising the reality of the situation, perhaps with local boards looking at specific local issues? Have we not created an unnecessarily complicated situation where it is difficult for anybody to really be in control, particularly when something goes wrong? It seems to be getting batted from pillar to post.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

That is one option. There are other options that could be looked at to simplify the situation. We are looking at simplifying it. For example, we have just gone through a period where we had a strategy working group from across the partnership, and we have agreed changes that, we hope, will simplify and clarify where accountability sits. We have signed an agreement with all 13 partners on the process and where accountability, responsibility and decision making sit. We have started on that journey. I am not sure where that journey will end up. I suspect that it will end after my tenure as principal.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

To clarify, the SFC gives you as a university a budget from higher education funding. In terms of further education, does the SFC give money to the board for distribution, or does it specify how much each of the 13 colleges will get?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

We have two funding streams: one is the higher education funding stream, like any other university has, and the other is a further education funding stream, like any other college has. They both come into the institution. The higher education budget is managed through the court, as normal, but, because we also have responsibility as a regional strategic body, we have set up a committee called the further education regional board. That is a committee of court, and its responsibility is to manage the further education budget on a regional basis. The money comes into the region.

09:45

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It comes into the region. I hear the point about managing the budget, but do you allocate the money between the colleges? Do you decide how much money Moray College gets?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

In essence, yes. The further education regional board, acting as the regional strategic body, allocates it on a regional basis.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Right. They could get funding from your higher education budget as well, obviously.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Sorry, I am not clear about what you mean.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Presumably the colleges offer higher as well as further education.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

The colleges get two income streams. They get a further education income stream and a higher education income stream from the university.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

How long do you expect to be there? How long do you think your tenure will be?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

As long as I keep performing well, I would like to think that I will be there for a period of time.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

You have given the impression that you doubt that much will change in your time.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

No. What I was trying to say was about the timescales. Things move quite slowly in the Highlands. If it were to be so, change could happen in the next few months, or it could take three, four, five, six or seven years.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Does it not require some national leadership to drive the change?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Potentially, yes. Any political support would be great.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Given what we have seen not just in this college but in at least one other college that has had problems out of the 13—we are seeing it later—it seems to me, sitting here, to be an unnecessarily bureaucratic and complicated arrangement that could be simplified. There is an opportunity to take a more innovative approach and have a more unified higher and further education system in the Highlands and Islands, which I would have thought was very much in tune with the needs of the Highlands and Islands community.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Anything that simplifies the system would be welcome. We are a hugely complicated beast, but I would ask you to look at the institution’s achievements over the past 10 years. We have had the university title for only four years, and just last week we were awarded research degree-awarding powers by the Privy Council. We are clearly demonstrating our achievements. However, we could do a lot better. That will be the challenge for us in the next five to 10 years: how do we build on that foundation? Anything that simplifies the system and makes it easier for us to do that would be welcome.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

My final question is this: if a similar situation arose in any of the 13 colleges in the future, do you feel as though you are equipped to deal with that situation and expedite the solutions that you think are required quickly and timeously?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

We have better, more accurate information, and we get that information in better time. The university is now clearer about its role as a regional strategic body, so in the future we would be much more directive and interventionist.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

And you have the necessary powers to do that.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

We do.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

I have a very quick question on a matter that has arisen from Mr Neil’s line of questioning. I presume that you could absorb some of the financial difficulties created by, let us say, Moray College by taking budget from Lews Castle College and sending it to Moray, could you not?

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

In theory, we could. I do not think that Lews Castle College would be very pleased about that. What we have is a mechanism—a model for funding—that we inherited from the funding council when we became a regional strategic body. We have been transitioning into a model that we think is more appropriate for the Highlands and Islands, because the best people to make the judgment about what is needed in the Highlands and Islands are the people there: the boards, the universities and the colleges working together. We have been funded on a regional basis, and our role is to provide the regional educational opportunities. We can move funding around and change the model to incentivise and deliver on areas where there is need.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

There is a finite pot of cash, so when one college needs a cash advance you would have to pull it from somewhere else in the budget.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

We have pulled it out of the university, because the university is able to have reserves. Through the further education aspect, there are no reserves, but we can use higher education reserves that the university and partners have earned. We can use those for support, but the key challenge is not just providing the cash advance but determining the root causes and trying to make sure that such an advance is not needed in the future.

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

I accept that, but, just to be absolutely clear, if a college requires a cash advance to make it sustainable, you will use university reserves to make that advance.

Clive Mulholland University of the Highlands and Islands
link

Yes. We can use those reserves.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I will begin by going backwards slightly. Peter Graham was quite frank in painting a picture of what had gone before, which I think that everyone would agree was pretty chaotic and dysfunctional. I am keen to hear what lessons have been learned and what difference the new board and the senior executive team are making.

It is fair to say that Anne Lindsay is the only person on the panel who has been at the college throughout. Will you say in your own words what the culture was like in the college? If the culture changed in that peak-chaos period, what was that change? Now that you have stepped up to be the most senior person, what leadership qualities and expertise have you brought, to change the culture?

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

Of course, it has to be recognised that, since February 2016, we have a new principal, David Patterson, who is unable to be with us today. If he were here, I think that he would be informing you that we have done substantial work towards a new strategic plan. We have worked with and consulted staff, stakeholders and various groups to take that forward. A key part of the strategic plan is values, communication, culture and support for students.

On the finances, which we are discussing today, we have been working for 18 months or perhaps longer on our financial recovery plan. Now that we know our baseline and where we are, we are looking at taking forward our financial recovery plan. The plan has two streams and is based on growth through the university. We are developing at least two new degrees just now, which, obviously, we will share with our partners, and we have other plans to grow our HE numbers. We are looking to increase our commercial income, because we feel that we need to do that in the current environment. We are looking at taking forward various projects to increase our income, outside grant income.

Also, we have looked at reducing our costs. It was clear that our staffing costs were too high. Although this was not our first consideration, we very much tried to revisit the funding model, to see whether we could get more funding. However, we are where we are. The VS scheme that we have in place just now is one method. I have looked at our staff costs: in the past 15 or 18 months, our staffing has steadily reduced and we have not filled vacancies to the same extent. We have very strict parameters that we use in that regard; we consider the impact on students, staff and service delivery.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I appreciate your expansive answer. I was keen initially to look back at some of the behavioural issues, because I want to be satisfied that the right skills and the right people are now in place. I wonder whether, from your experience, you can say which skills were lacking in the previous board and whether you are confident that the new board has the necessary skills to be effective in its role.

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

With regard to the board of management?

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

I have certainly noticed and welcomed a significant difference in the new board that was formed last August. I have been attending meetings only recently, after our principal went off on sick leave. I have just had two financial and general purposes committee meetings that were very rigorous and detailed. We talked a lot about our current position and where we sit with regard to the financial recovery plan. The board is very supportive, but there is an element of rigour.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Can you see what skills and experience might have been missing before, and what the difference is? You talked in quite general terms. I am looking for examples of the people who are on the board and what their CVs have brought to the role.

Anne Lindsay Moray College
link

Perhaps there is more knowledge and experience of finance matters on the board now. I think that the previous board would have recognised that.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Okay. Perhaps Peter Graham and Murray Easton will say what might have been lacking before and what you are bringing—

Murray Easton Moray College
link

Can I just offer—

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

May I just ask the question, please? What are you bringing to the board?

Murray Easton Moray College
link

Let me offer a little clarity. When I look back, the picture that I see—from what I have seen, read and understood from conversations—was not necessarily a chaotic situation. There was nothing to suggest that the college’s books and records were not being properly maintained or that the procedures generally were inappropriate, nor was there anything about the capability of the board.

I know that this discussion has come out of the audit report for 2015-16, but the root cause was 2014-15, and, if we strip away everything else about process, procedures and people, we see that the financial model—the financial framework—under which the college was operating had broken down. That was the root issue—not the cause but the issue. In simple terms, we had got to a position where the cost base was exceeding the total income that was provided by funding and the commercial income that was generated by the college. The financial model had broken down, and that was what gave rise to the need for an advance of £368,000 at the end of 2014.

The issue around that was that information was of poor quality and was not being presented fairly and in a timely manner, so that, outside management, who were primarily responsible, the secondary lines of defence—that is, the board and the finance committee, UHI, the auditors and the SFC itself—were not able to see the issue unfold as it happened. It was only once we got to the end of the year that the size of the financial hole became real, and that is when people reacted. It could and should have been picked up earlier, but it was not.

By that time, the cash flow was negative. We had an end-of-year cash deficit. Two things need to happen at such a point: people have to try to fix the budget model so that they generate positive cash, and then they have to address the hole that they have already created. If that does not happen, the situation gets worse, and that is what happened in 2015-16. The size of the hole grew from £368,000 to £568,000—the amount of the advance. The rest of it was just about awareness and then resolution.

We now have a financial recovery plan that has addressed the issue and changed the business model for the college. We now have a two-and-a-half-year plan, so that, by the end of not the academic year ahead but the following one, we will be in positive income and generating positive cash flow. That was the core issue that needed to be fixed. It was not just about a chaotic context; the underlying financial model was broken. That is what management, with the current board, has addressed, and we are already halfway towards achieving the recovery plan.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Would a competent team have picked up the problems earlier?

Murray Easton Moray College
link

Absolutely. I am saying that, within the senior management team, I would expect the principal and the finance director at the time to have been sharing the information with the wider senior management team and with their finance committee and the board. That is what did not appear to happen—the sharing of the up-to-date situation and the bad news, and an understanding of the extent of the problem and why it had occurred. If it could have been addressed earlier, the hole would not have grown deeper and deeper.

Peter Graham Moray College
link

Can I come back to your question relating to—

Liam Kerr Con The Deputy Convener · North East Scotland
link

I will let you in, but I ask the witnesses to keep answers concise, as time is getting on.

Peter Graham Moray College
link

Can I come back to Monica Lennon’s question about the ethos of the board? What Clive Mulholland is having to work with throughout all the colleges in UHI is an historical set-up that predates the revised education legislation. There was a team of people who had been there for a long time. To say that they were complacent is to use too strong a word, but people were relaxed and comfortable with the FD and the situations that were going on.

10:00

What Clive Mulholland has now, particularly at Moray College and probably as a result of all this, is a board that is much more structured around looking towards UHI and the future of that relationship. We are already discussing a unified accountancy package, which will be structured via UHI—we can see centralised services coming out of that, which gives some of the savings that people are looking for. However, I suspect that if change is imposed on college boards, it will meet resistance. I have been to a couple of further education regional board meetings, even in my new role as chairman. There are people who are stuck in their little class and saying, “I want, I want, I want”, instead of, “Look, we’re all in this together. We need to work this pie so that it is to the advantage of all”.

Probably the biggest significant change on the board at Moray College is the willingness to move into the future in a proper and managed relationship with the UHI—the openness of the bookkeeping and the interrelationship with our new financial director. In the past two weeks, the financial director has already been to meet the UHI’s FD. We have already discussed how we intend to move forward our finances. These changes of ethos, which I think is what you were asking about, are significant, because we are new to the game. We are not looking at the history, and we are not burdened by the relationships that there were historically. We have come in with a view. The reason that I have applied is because I want Moray College to be like Magdalene College in relation to the University of Cambridge, or something like that.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I was just hoping to hear that there has been a look back to the past, so that lessons have been learned and the same mistakes will not be repeated.

  1. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. Section 22 Reports Evidence session · 273
  3. 10:15 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 106

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.