The final petition on today’s agenda is PE1630, by Fiona Webb, on nursery funding for three-year-olds. As members will see, we have received a number of written submissions since our previous consideration of the petition.
The Minister for Childcare and Early Years has provided clarification on how the eligibility requirements operate and has noted that, although the starting points of funded early learning and childcare create differences in the amount of free provision that a child may access, the Scottish Government does not consider that that disadvantages children. Members will see from the minister’s submission that the Scottish Government recently consulted on its policy in that area, and it has yet to provide its own response to the consultation.
Reform Scotland supports the petition, noting that in its estimation only 50 per cent receive the full two-year entitlement. Unison does not support the petition, because it does not consider it to be child centred; instead, it cites recent research that supports a supply-side funding scheme. Children in Scotland and the parenting Across Scotland group have also emphasised the importance of taking a child-centred approach to the issue. Voice Scotland and COSLA have noted the challenges of meeting the existing arrangement and the increase in funding that would be required from the Scottish Government to support the petitioner’s call for action.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action on the petition? It is just happenstance with regard to when a child is born that determines whether they get two years of nursery funding. If the issue is one of cost, I simply note that we would not make statutory provision that said, “It’s too expensive to educate everybody at five, so we’ll just educate half of you.” That might be a flippant way of looking at it, but I am not sure that this is a question of cost if what we are talking about is an entitlement. After all, we have already said that all children should have access to that childcare. However, I am also mindful of what Unison and other groups have said about how the terms work.