The next petition is PE1629 by Jennifer Lewis, on magnetic resonance imaging scans for ocular melanoma sufferers in Scotland. The eight written submissions that we have received on the petition have been circulated to members.
Cancer Research UK and Macmillan Cancer Support Scotland did not consider themselves able to offer a view on the action called for in the petition. In her submission, the petitioner suggests that
“this serves to reinforce our contention that clinicians and oncologists alike are often unaware of the particulars of our disease”.
According to the submission from the Royal College of Ophthalmologists, ultrasound is, in line with national guidelines, the accepted mode for surveillance in England, and it notes that MRI should be used for high-risk patients or where an abnormality is indicated by ultrasound. The petitioner argues that that demonstrates how definitive MRI scans are considered to be. She also points out that the current guidelines are under review and adds that it would be helpful to seek the views of medical, rather than ocular, oncologists.
The Scottish Government submission advises that the policy of the Scottish ocular oncology service is in line with the national guidelines, but it adds that there is
“variation amongst the four UK centres as to which is the most appropriate form of surveillance to adopt”,
and suggests that that is down to lack of evidence. OcuMel UK suggests that MRI is “the scan of choice” for the centres in Liverpool and Southampton, and that appears to be supported by Professor Ottensmeier as well as by Dr Iain Wilson, who refers to MRI as being the “gold standard” for identifying metastases.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?
10:45