Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Changing models of health and social care”

Thursday 16 March 2017 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 10:00–11:00 Committee business 72 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

72 contributions
Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We move on to consider the Auditor General’s report entitled “Changing models of health and social care”. We did not have time to consider the report at our meeting on 9 February. I apologise for that and thank the panel for coming before us again today.

I welcome our witnesses from the Scottish Government. Paul Gray is director general of health and social care and chief executive of NHS Scotland, Shirley Rogers is director of health workforce and strategic change, Christine McLaughlin is director of health finance and Fiona McQueen is chief nursing officer.

Paul Gray does not wish to make an opening statement, so we will move straight to questions, the first of which is from Alex Neil.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

As this is the first public meeting that I have been at since my recent incident, I put on the record that I received excellent care from the Scottish Ambulance Service and the cardiac unit at Edinburgh royal infirmary. It was second to none. I think it is worth while to record that, given the bad publicity that the national health service gets—very unfairly—on a day-to-day basis.

I will begin with a simple question. We know that health inequalities are one of the major reasons why we have such a substantial health challenge in Scotland, but the “Health and Social Care Delivery Plan” seems not to deal with health inequalities. Indeed, it barely mentions them. Why is that?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

First, I am pleased that we were able to look after you, Mr Neil. I am glad to see you back—despite your question. Laughter.

The arrangements for the governance of the implementation of the delivery plan include a strand on population health improvement—I will ask Shirley Rogers to say a bit more about that—because we regard the improvement of the health of the population and the work that we do on prevention as being absolutely essential to the longer-term development of an engagement with the population that helps everyone to understand what they can do to develop and improve their own wellbeing as well as what the services, and not just the health service, can do.

I ask Shirley Rogers to say something about how we plan to integrate that with the overall delivery arrangements that are already in place.

Shirley Rogers Scottish Government
link

It is very nice to see you looking so well, Mr Neil.

Shirley Rogers Scottish Government
link

Public health and population health improvement is one of a very small number of key themes of the delivery plan, and you will see quite a lot of attention around primary care and all the initiatives around public health improvement and through that lens. We are also proposing in the plan to bring together a public health resource for Scotland to try to make sure that we have a cohesive and strategic approach to public health and population health.

We are taking forward a number of strands of work around alcohol, obesity and all the social inclusion areas around health. We have spent a lot of time looking at investment in health visitors, for example, to try to put that process in place. We also have the early years collaborative work, which I know you are familiar with and which is about giving children the best possible start.

The programme takes all those pieces of work into account and tries to bring them together into something that is comprehensive and can give us measured deliverables, and that is really where we will be targeting the firepower of the delivery plan over the next four or five years. That involves trying to make sure that we have comprehensive plans in place across the piece and proper programme management to make sure that they are delivering the sorts of outcomes that we need.

As you are well aware, some of those ambitions go way beyond the lifetime of any Government and into the next 20 or 30 years to try to improve population health in those ways. In this, the first of the delivery plans, we set out the principles that we will take forward with the view that, over the next few years, we will be able to learn, develop and put forward additional proposals that will improve the situation.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I agree with all of that and would not object to any of it, but there are matters that I do not see in the plan. For example, it is clear that the deep-end practices have a major role to play in reducing inequalities. We need to get away from the flat funding of general practitioners so that we positively discriminate in favour of those who need the additional resources to reduce inequalities in order to prevent some of the health problems that we face. However, there is nothing in the plan to tell me, for example, what additional resources deep-end practices will get, the anticipated impact of additional resources and when and where the practices will get them. That is the kind of information that I would be looking for in a delivery plan. The inverse care law has been with us since about 1971, but we have never really tackled it. It seems to me that, as the evidence mounts, we have to tackle it.

On a wider point, the Government is introducing a child poverty bill to set targets for 2034 to reduce child poverty. There is nothing in the plan about what contribution health and social care will make to achieving those targets. I would have thought that that kind of strategy would need to be in a delivery plan.

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

Just to be clear, the issue of public health improvement is covered in pages 16 to 20 of the plan, so it is not just mentioned in passing. As the committee will know, we are putting additional resource into primary care. Negotiations are going on at the moment on the contractual basis of the engagement with general practice, and we are building on our commitment to having multidisciplinary teams and a hub-based approach.

I take Mr Neil’s point about deep-end practices. As the delivery board, which Shirley Rogers chairs, develops the detail of its proposals, certain matters will inevitably come to the surface. However, additional funding is already in place. A £128 million transformation fund was set up, and I will bring Christine McLaughlin in soon to say a bit more about the components of that and the additional investment in primary care. I do not think that we are disagreeing, Mr Neil, about the importance of primary care and its centrality to the shift in the balance of care. That underpins a great deal of what we do and will help us to move more activity out of the acute sector and into primary and community settings, bearing in mind that we are speaking in the context of health and social care integration. If the committee would find it helpful, the finance director can say more about the detail of the funding.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I think that we are all familiar with the overall funding figures, but the issue in a delivery plan such as this is the distribution of the funding. If we just continue with the previous distribution of funding, the “worried well”, as Duncan McNeil used to call them, will continue to get massively unfair access to the health resource and social care resource compared to the access that the people who need it more and most get. Obviously, things such as dealing with the use of tobacco and—I hope—eventually implementing minimum unit pricing for alcohol will help with public health and help reduce inequalities. However, there is an issue about the NHS and social care resource, because I do not see a strategy in the plan for dealing with the inverse care law that is any different from how we have unsuccessfully dealt with it over the past 30 years.

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I will bring in Christine McLaughlin shortly, but I point out the work that we are doing on the alcohol framework, on delivering the maternal and infant nutrition framework, on the mental health strategy and on supporting mental health in primary care. All that work is intended to tackle the clear position that, if someone lives in a more deprived area, they will find services harder to access and will be more likely to be unwell. We are not disputing those facts at all. The components of what we are doing in the plan are central to tackling that issue, and the investment that we are making in physical activity and the work that we are doing on building success in schools among other things are intended to tackle that issue.

I take your point about the importance of specificity in what we do about things such as deep-end practices. Perhaps Christine McLaughlin can say a little more on that.

Christine McLaughlin Scottish Government
link

The funding is implicit in everything that we are trying to do, rather than being a ring-fenced component for tackling inequalities. In the spend on primary care, there is an overall metric about shifting £250 million into primary care and shifting £500 million overall from acute to community services. As you know, the deep-end practices are a very specific area and our approach is more about trying to understand how we can enable things like GP clusters to have the impact that they need to have in the parts of the country where they need to have it. We are also using data on variation to understand why there is a higher prevalence of certain conditions in particular parts of the country and how we can deal with those.

It is about having a whole-system data-driven approach. We are trying to approach the funding by being more flexible and less mandatory at the centre about how that money is best applied locally. The finance is there to go where it needs to be directed to get the most benefit.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I do not dispute any of that—all of it is right. However, when you read the document, it looks like a mixture of a statement of intent and a wish list, rather than a delivery plan. The English business plan for the national health service, which is also done on a national basis, is much more detailed in that it gives likely impact assessments and sets out where resources will be distributed and how they will be delivered.

Let me give you an example from early on in the plan. It says on page 8—I do not disagree with this aim—that

“By 2018, we aim to: Reduce unscheduled bed-days in hospital care by up to 10 percent ... by reducing delayed discharges, avoidable admissions and inappropriately long stays in hospital.”

We have been doing that for years, but how are you going to do it so that you achieve the target? The plan tells me what the target is and what you want to do, but it does not tell me what you will do differently in order to achieve that target. The plan is riddled with that problem. It is not a delivery plan; rather, it is a statement of intent and a wish list, with which I would not disagree. It does not tell me how it will be delivered, what the impact assessment of the various measures is or what the resource allocation is. I can see those things in the English plan, but I cannot see them in the Scottish plan. I am happy to park that and give you some time to think about it.

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

The best thing that I can do is to give you three pieces of assurance and then offer the committee something in writing if that would be helpful.

First, the plan relates to the budget that we have—the sum of money given to health and the money available in other budgets, including local government—and is therefore a funded, rather than an unfunded plan. Secondly, the level of detail that Mr Neil is asking for is precisely what we are working through with the delivery board. That is why we have a delivery board. It is not simply aspirational. We are confident that the sums of money that are available are sufficient to deliver what we have been asked to do. Thirdly, Mr Neil spoke about risks to delivery. Of course there are risks to delivery—things change over time—but we have programme management and governance arrangements in place to deal with that. That is why we have governance and oversight.

If the committee would find it helpful, I would be more than happy to provide a more detailed breakdown of the components of the plan, how it will be delivered and at what cost.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

As an example, in a delivery plan, I would expect to see figures relating to where, when and why money is being spent and what you are doing differently that will make a difference. I would also expect to see some estimate of the impact that that will have on health inequalities and achieving the targets and why that will be different to what has been done before. We need to wait and see what Harry Burns’s review of targets says, but the media concentrate all the time on when we miss our targets, even though we are doing excessively better than the health service down south. You do not get credit for that; you only get abuse because of missing the targets.

The question that we have to ask is: how will you achieve the targets for accident and emergency and all the rest of it in future? The treatment time guarantee is a good example. The plan does not tell me how, between now and the end of the plan period, you will achieve the treatment time guarantee. That is what I mean. You have to bring all this together so that somebody who comes new to the matter independently and neutrally can see the total picture. I do not see it as a plan; I see it as a worthwhile document, but in essence it is a statement of intent and a wish list, not a plan as I would understand one.

10:30

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Do you have a question?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

No—I think that Paul Gray has offered to come back to us.

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I am happy to go further on the matter, convener, or to take other questions—I will be guided by you—but I have committed to writing to the committee with more detail, as Mr Neil has asked, and I am happy to do that.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

If you could, please. Do you wish to comment on Mr Neil’s last point, or do you just wish to write to us?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

What we have is a plan for delivery. We have given specific dates by which we intend to do things, and I have committed to writing in more detail about the underpinning finances and where they will go. I believe that it is a robust plan, and it is underpinned by data, evidence and clinical advice. We are happy to share all of that with the committee if it would find that helpful. I would describe the plan as a firm proposition, not as Mr Neil has described it.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

One area that really concerns me is integration joint boards’ integration of care at very local level. The Auditor General’s report highlights the poor progress on that. It says:

“Evidence suggests that the new partnerships with statutory responsibilities to coordinate integrated health and social care services, integration authorities, will not be in a position to make a major impact during 2016/17.”

That is a bit of a worry.

Paragraph 30 of the report says that

“A common issue with many of the new care models being introduced across Scotland is a lack of evidence about the impact, implementation costs, efficiency gains or cash savings, and outcomes for service users.”

That seems to be a big grey area, but it is such an important area, and you highlight it in your delivery plan as being fairly essential. Can you give me a feel for what is happening in that regard?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

The “Changing models of health and social care” report was prepared by Audit Scotland in March 2016, before the first full year of operation of integration, which we are now in. A number of developments have taken place in the course of the first full year of integration that give me confidence that we are heading in the right direction.

Not every partnership is at the same point on the trajectory—there is a degree of unevenness. However, I have 10 or 15 examples here—I promise I will not go through them all—of areas where integration is working well, which can give us confidence. I will share those examples with the committee in the written response that I have already agreed to give to Mr Neil.

I will give the committee two examples now, however. I met representatives of Ayrshire and Arran NHS Board and the integration partnerships a week past Friday, and I saw how that health board is managing patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease heart failure and diabetes much more effectively, which has resulted in a 49 per cent reduction in emergency admissions and a 36 per cent reduction in bed days in the first six months, for that case load. I can provide more detail on that.

The Dumfries and Galloway integrated hub has developed a single point of access for community health and social care services, which is bringing together health and social care services called STARS—short-term augmented response services—and the third sector for people who are registered with two general practices in Dumfries. I can also provide more detail on that. It has reduced the referral time from GP to care input by up to 15 days, there are quicker interservice handovers and there is increased capacity. It has also improved communication, staff morale and team working. There is evidence that those measures are working.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Has there been an effective transfer of budgets to make that happen? That seemed to be the key thing that was delaying integration—everybody had their own little fiefdom, which they would not give up. How effective has budget transfer been and how has it been achieved?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

The first year of any operational delivery is clunky, to use a non-technical word, and we learned a lot in the first year on budget setting. There was a great deal of to-ing and fro-ing, and a great deal of debate, discussion and negotiation about budget transfers. I will not pretend otherwise. We have been through that process and the evidence suggests that it will be much smoother this year. I will bring Christine McLaughlin in on that, in a second. We are learning from what we have done—as people always do—and improving as we go along, which is the right process. I am not claiming that such a transformational change as the integration of health and social care will go from nothing to perfection in two years—nothing of that scale will, or would. However, I have clear evidence of progress in local areas.

Issues of governance, leadership and trust have been worked through because those were essential precursors to effectiveness. Delivery on the ground is now making a difference. If the committee would find it helpful, the finance director will say a bit about the budget process.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I would be interested to hear that.

Christine McLaughlin Scottish Government
link

Paul Gray is right: for the first year, there was due diligence in advance and, through the year, people understood what their resources were able to buy and where there were levers or pressures.

As partnerships plan for the 2017-18 financial year, there is a much greater level of engagement all round between integration authorities, NHS boards and local authorities. That does not mean that everybody agrees all the time, and there are still issues in some parts of the country about signing off on the resources to deliver the plans that are in place, but there is much more sharing of information, and integration authorities and chief officers are part of the discussions about how resources are used on a more day-to-day basis.

We are in some places starting to get into shared risk and shared ownership in relation to delayed discharge performance and how we share investment in new services that we are looking to plan, for example. There is definitely evidence of more mature relationships in respect of budgets. It will not be until we get into the bigger issue of how that impacts on the acute sector, for example, that we will see some of the traction and some of the metrics. However, on delayed discharges, we are starting to see good work and progress in respect of the number of people whose discharge is delayed.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

On page 9 of the delivery plan, under “Shifting resources to the community”, you say that by 2021

“spending on primary care increases to 11 percent of the frontline NHS Scotland budget.”

Is that an arbitrary figure? What is it based on?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

The figure is based on our assessment of the correct relative share to get the shift that the evidence suggests we need, so it is not an arbitrary figure. It is also part of a negotiation between the Government and the representative bodies, as all those things are the subject of negotiation. There is clear evidence that putting extra capacity into out-of-hospital care provides an opportunity to transform services and deliver better outcomes.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Good morning, panellists. Paul Gray talked about governance, leadership and trust. We are seeing a massive change in the NHS, with a shift from acute to community care. As we know, and as we have heard in previous evidence sessions, members of the public are attached to buildings—they see hospitals as the main places to provide care. In a lot of cases, they are suspicious and slightly wary of change when it happens on such a big scale. What is the Scottish Government doing to engage with the public to raise awareness of the policy to shift the balance of care? What discussions, consultations and public engagement are taking place on why services need to change?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I use the term “shifting the balance of care” as shorthand, but I suppose that the public would not engage particularly well with that phrase. Concrete examples of what would be different and better for them are helpful to the public. For example, the rapid elderly assessment care team in West Lothian visits people in their own homes and provides multidisciplinary care. People learn about and come to appreciate that service by experiencing it. That is hugely important. Abstract statements of what might happen are hard for people to grasp.

We are working with the health boards and integration boards to ensure that there is the appropriate level of engagement, as defined by the Scottish health council. The great benefit of the integration boards is, of course, that they engage local authorities’ elected members. I believe—I say “I believe” because I have seen it—that local authorities have well-developed approaches to engagement with the public, which we benefit from and learn from. Through the processes that have been established, we are ensuring that there is appropriate engagement. The issue is to make that engagement specific and—I was going to say “concrete”, but that might bring us back to buildings—real, rather than making generalised propositions about “shifting the balance of care”.

We should not start the conversation in the wrong place. We should not say, “We’ve got this building and we’re going to knock it down” because a sentence like that always gets people nervous—and rightly so. Instead, we should start the conversation by saying, “Here are the developments in healthcare that would allow us to provide you with a better service. Here is how that could be delivered. Here is how you can be engaged in deciding and agreeing what your care should be.” That would result in be a much better conversation.

Engagement does not just come through the forum of health boards or integration partnerships directly. For example, the conversations that are going on in the context of the national clinical strategy, particularly on realistic medicine, are between clinicians and individuals about what care would be best for them. Most often, when people are engaged in decisions about their care, the outcomes are better for them. Most people prefer not to be overtreated.

The chief nursing officer could say more about that, if that would be helpful to the committee.

Fiona McQueen Scottish Government
link

As Paul Gray and Gail Ross have said, people are anxious about what happens to buildings. The relationship between clinicians and the public is incredibly important. We know that the public trust clinicians’ decision making. We need to help people to understand that they can have better outcomes at home or in more local settings from treatment for which they would in the past have needed to go to hospital. I suspect the care that Mr Neil received is a slightly more acute version of that situation, with a rapid transfer to a hospital—and perhaps not to the nearest hospital—and a much shorter length of stay there before going back home. The community always appreciates good outcomes when its experiences them. We will have that dialogue with people through the whole strand of realistic medicine and in progressing the national clinical strategy.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

We are all involved, including local authorities and NHS boards, in reassuring members of the public that they will receive the best possible care. What is the best way for NHS boards to engage with the public?

10:45

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

That is a big question. The short answer is that it depends what the issue is. I can give examples of methods that are not good ways of engaging with the public. One is letters, because people cannot ask a letter a question. Engagement with the public must involve people engaging with people. If I was to give one fundamental answer to your question, that would be it.

Giving people something to see works: if you are describing a facility, you should, as early as possible, give folk an idea of what it will look like and where it will be located. If you are describing a new care pathway—in other words, a new way of treating people—you should get someone to talk through it and perhaps use a case study with a patient and a clinician having a conversation, rather than produce a dry document that says, “Here’s the new care pathway” for a particular condition, which in a sense is asking people to work out what the change would mean for them. I much prefer to give people something to look at or to hear and—above all—the opportunity to ask questions. We should not be afraid of being challenged. The public have some really good ideas about what would be best for them.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

When massive change is taking place in a big organisation, the best advocates for that change are often the staff themselves. Are your staff fully informed about and on board with the changes? Are they able to talk to the general public about what those changes are and what they will mean?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I will bring in Shirley Rogers and Fiona McQueen on that point, because it is hugely important. I do not think that we always get that element right. We have partnership arrangements that work well and are well regarded, but if we are talking about investing in talking to people, we need to treat our staff and the public well. That is essential.

The best part of my job is going out and talking to people, staff and patients, because that is where I learn most. I believe that the leaders in health and care systems ought to devote a significant proportion of their time to speaking to the people who deliver the services and the people who receive them. That is how they will learn whether the system is working. Shirley and Fiona will both have things to say about that.

Shirley Rogers Scottish Government
link

I will pick up a couple of themes and address the specific point that was made. To go back to Alex Neil’s observations about what is different, the planning and delivery processes that are signalled in the plan give huge—and, I think, very welcome—prominence to national, regional, local, community and individual aspects. If we lose sight of those aspects, we will miss a trick. The prioritisation that Alex Neil was talking about, whether that relates to general practices or to particular needs, is addressed specifically by our not determining things at national level and instead allowing local communities and IJBs to prioritise actions.

That approach is important for a number of reasons—not least in relation to Gail Ross’s point about communication. It is important because it means not only that communities get what they need but that communities themselves are advocating for the changes that they want. That is really important.

We are creating a national narrative, but we are also making sure that we are taking the approach that I have set out. If I think about what I have been doing in the past three months since we published the plan—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

If you could make your response a bit tighter, that would be great. Thank you.

Shirley Rogers Scottish Government
link

I will do my best.

We have spent a lot of time talking about health to all the communities. We have talked not only to chief executives and chairs, but to staff—nurses, human resources people, organisational development people and all the rest—so that they can do precisely what Gail Ross described. The focus of this year’s NHS event is on people making change happen. We will have not just 10 or 12 people but 156,000 people talking to their communities about the changes that are proposed.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

My question follows on from Alex Neil’s questions on the recommendations in the Audit Scotland report on financial flexibility for NHS boards. I appreciate the answer that you gave about that aspiration, but I want to drill down into the detail of what steps have been taken to follow up on those recommendations and what financial plans are being prepared.

Christine McLaughlin Scottish Government
link

There is, perhaps, a narrow point to be made about how boards achieve financial balance in individual years as well as a wider point about generally living within your means and having sustainability.

On the narrower point about flexibility, I hope that our position is quite clear: we provide services that give boards a level of flexibility from one year to another. That is, by and large, something that we can plan for; with, say, a major new project such as a new hospital, we can plan for that over a number of years. You will know that a number of boards are facing financial sustainability issues and, as you will recall from our discussions on NHS Tayside, we provide financial assistance that we look to have repaid.

Just now, we are working with boards on their five-year plans, which will underpin the delivery plan; at the end of the month, boards will be giving us their local delivery plans, which will focus in detail on 2017-18. We will therefore have plans for individual boards and, as part of the delivery plan, we are now asking them to start to work on a regional basis. I expect to move to a position where we would look to provide regional resource envelopes, which would give another level of flexibility—a regional level, if you like, sitting one layer down—in the deployment of resources. If money were to become a barrier to moving or sharing a service, we would want to take such barriers away.

The portfolio—and, indeed, the Scottish Government—needs to be able to balance overall, but within those parameters we are doing everything that we can to provide flexibility. In return, we ask boards to look far enough ahead to understand the longer-term position, to plan as much as they can for the knowns and the unknowns and to be really clear in the risk assessment that they carry out.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

That leads nicely to my next question. What work are you doing with boards to drill down at a more local level and ensure that there is sufficient resource and investment in the community to meet the objective of shifting the balance of care from hospital to the community?

Christine McLaughlin Scottish Government
link

As part of next financial year’s funding settlement, we have put in place some very clear criteria, including our expectation that the total sum of money being spent on non-acute areas will be maintained. That might be only one sentence in a letter, but it marks a real shift in clarifying the direction that we want to go in with the resources that are spent in the NHS.

In that respect, we have made it very clear that we expect spend on integration authorities, which amounts to about £8.2 billion, to be maintained, and spend on primary care and mental health to be maintained, too, as a minimum. The additional investment that we are putting in, such as the £70 million for primary care and the additional money for mental health, should be over and above that core recurring funding, and we have asked for assurance from boards that that is being delivered. It is quite a crude measure, but it means that we expect best use of the resources that are being maintained in that area. We will see in the local delivery plans that we receive at the end of the month the boards’ assurance and their descriptions of how they are doing that work.

Ross Thomson Con North East Scotland
link

On how to ensure that funding levels are maintained—this touches on a question that Colin Beattie asked—I note that the delivery plan states that you will

“Ensure Health and Social Care Partnerships increase spending on primary care services, so that spending on primary care increases to 11 percent of the frontline NHS Scotland budget.”

Given that, according to a previous answer, that has been subject to negotiation, and given your comment that you are looking for assurances, what can you do to ensure that that funding level is met? Where are the details and the plan to back all of that up and to allow us to monitor whether it is being achieved?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I will answer very briefly, and I would like to ask the convener a question, if I may. When I said that it is subject to negotiation, I was not suggesting that the 11 per cent is subject to negotiation.

Convener, I know that you have other business today. Can you give me guidance on how long you would like to allow for this session? We will then try to tailor our answers to an appropriate length.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We have time, Mr Gray. I am not as concerned as I was a few minutes ago, so please say what you need to say.

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

Thank you very much. I will hand back to Christine McLaughlin, but first I want to make the point that I am not suggesting that we will negotiate the 11 per cent in a different direction, but what happens to it must necessarily be the subject of negotiation.

Christine McLaughlin Scottish Government
link

We have written back to the Health and Sport Committee in some detail to give clarity on that point. There are a number of measures. There is the 11 per cent, but I think that the bigger point is the shift of the £500 million by the end of this parliamentary session. The modelling that we have done suggests that that should be a realistic projection over that timeframe. In fact, if that level of sum cannot be achieved, there will be no shift in services on the ground.

The assurance comes not so much from the money and the overall conditions that we set, but from the ability to see a service that was provided in an acute hospital being provided in a different way in the community.

We now need to build up the detail of those individual changes on the ground to understand how they all come together. I can give you that detail in our assumptions. By the end of this parliamentary session, we should have more than £14 billion in healthcare. The additional cash investment needs to get directed to the areas that we need it to get directed to. We have a level of planning assumptions about health funding in cash terms over that period, which allows us to have a bit more certainty about how, if the position continues, funding will be directed. On that basis, getting to that £500 million shift does not seem unreasonable to me.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Mr Gray, based on the evidence, what is better when it comes to social care and the public purse—private providers or carers who are directly employed by a local authority?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

Generally speaking, continuity of care is important, so bringing in providers from time to time is much less likely to lead to a good outcome for people. It is not that there cannot be a good outcome, but you would want to be sure that you were using an approach that provided continuity of care.

The same quality standards would be expected, were we occasionally to use the private sector—there would be no difference. I believe that having care provided by the national health service, which I speak for specifically, is the right thing to do, because, as the leader of the national health service, I am able to put in place a set of standards, a set of behaviours and an expectation of integrity, and I ensure that those things are followed by having in place systems and processes such as iMatter and engagement with partnerships. Therefore, I believe that that approach is most likely to yield good care.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You are talking about having carers who are directly employed by the IJBs.

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I am talking about carers who are directly employed by the NHS. Similarly, local authorities have directly employed staff who are subject to local government standards and guidelines. Again, I focus my answer on continuity of care and the ethical standards of the public sector.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

My next question might be more for the Auditor General. We know that it costs the health service three times as much to employ an agency nurse as a contracted nurse—we have discussed that before. Do you know what the cost difference is between social care workers who go into people’s homes and are employed directly by the NHS or the IJB, and those who are employed by private companies such as Avenue and other care providers?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I do not have that level of detail. The information could easily be got for you, but the problem is that it will vary from area to area. I am perfectly happy to provide it, to the extent that it is available.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Could you, please? That would be useful. I will make the same request of the Auditor General.

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

Yes, I can do that.

11:00

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Page 18 of the delivery plan states the intention to

“Consult on a new strategy on diet and obesity.”

Am I right in thinking that an obesity strategy is due out from the Government any day now? Does the delivery plan refer to the same thing?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

As far as I am aware, yes. Our approach is to have a consultation on an area that we believe needs to be given further impetus. That is why we are doing it.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

If the obesity plan is due out any day, why consult on a new strategy?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

We are putting out a plan for consultation.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I see. That clears that up.

Paragraph 36 on page 21, which is about getting it right for every child, states:

“In addition to actions included in the main components of work above, we will drive this agenda through: continued implementation of Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014, in particular, the Named Person and the Child’s Plan”.

My reading of that is that the implementation of the named person and the child’s plan is continuing. Has that changed since John Swinney’s statement a couple of weeks ago?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I am genuinely not entirely sure what question you are putting to me.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

On page 21, paragraph 36, which is on GIRFEC, states quite clearly that the actions recommended by the plan include continued implementation of the named person scheme. Is it continuing to be implemented, or has its implementation halted since the Supreme Court ruling?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

The civil service will proceed in line with what the Deputy First Minister has said. That would be my answer to your question.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

My interpretation of what he said was that there was to be a pause. I take it that your civil servants will be pausing the implementation of the scheme. Is that right?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

The delivery plan was published in December 2016, when the situation was as it was then. If ministers subsequently introduce a pause, we will operate in line with what the Government and the Parliament agree.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Do you know that civil servants and NHS boards have paused implementation of the named person scheme?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I know that we react to what ministers say exactly as they would expect us to. The CNO can confirm that.

Fiona McQueen Scottish Government
link

As part of the delivery plan, there is a commitment to 500 additional health visitors. Part of the work that we did on supporting young people through early intervention to reduce inequalities involved introducing what we call a universal health visiting pathway, to standardise how our health visitors support families from pre-birth to school age. Some of that can, at times, be conflated with the named person scheme. The named person has duties and responsibilities, which have been paused and are being reviewed, but we are continuing with getting it right for every child and with implementing the universal health visiting pathway, which means additional home visits for families by a qualified health visitor.

We are continuing with that element, which would support the implementation of the named person scheme in terms of data sharing and responsibility. As Paul Gray said, one element of the process has been paused, but the benefits of other elements, such as having additional health visitors to support families in a more comprehensive way, are continuing. However, we are cognisant of the legislative issues.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I would like to ask a supplementary to that, because it is now three years since we decided to increase the number of health visitors by 500. How many of those 500 have now been appointed?

Fiona McQueen Scottish Government
link

I can send you the specific numbers. We have trained more than 398, and on top of that we will be training an additional 163 health visitors in 2016-17. We are moving to be on target for implementation of the target for the number of health visitors in training, if not qualified. We are making good, steady progress.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

When do you reckon we will have 500 additional health visitors actually working?

Fiona McQueen Scottish Government
link

That is a moveable feast. I can give more accurate projections and trajectories in writing.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I thank everyone for their evidence this morning.

11:05 Meeting continued in private until 11:18.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 147
  3. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 72

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.