In June 2013, the newly established Scottish Police Authority signed a contract for £46.1 million with Accenture to deliver a national information technology system for Police Scotland. The system, known as i6, was intended to replace more than 130 IT and paper-based systems inherited from Police Scotland’s predecessor forces, and to transform how Police Scotland records, manages and analyses information. The system was planned to go live in September 2014, with full national roll-out by August 2015.
In July 2016—three years after signing the contract—the Scottish Police Authority and Accenture mutually agreed to terminate the contract for the i6 programme. The contract was signed by the SPA, but day-to-day management rested with Police Scotland.
The i6 programme failed because of disagreement about the scope of the programme, the interpretation of the contract and the extent to which Police Scotland’s requirements were met by Accenture’s solution. The disagreement arose despite an 18-month procurement process, which we found had followed good practice and included intensive engagement with potential bidders. The disagreement surfaced almost immediately after the signing of the contract in June 2013, and permanently damaged trust, relationships and confidence between Police Scotland and Accenture. The signing of a contract variation agreement in April 2014 reset relationships and put the programme on a more positive footing, but that proved to be temporary.
One of the factors that contributed to Accenture being awarded the contract was its experience of delivering an IT system to the Guardia Civil in Spain. Initially, it was believed that the majority of the i6 system could be based on that system. As time went on, however, it became clear that a significant amount of the system would have to be built from scratch.
The approach to software development that was used in the i6 programme meant that Police Scotland finally received the i6 system for full user testing in June 2015. At that point, Police Scotland identified fundamental problems with the system. In August 2015, Accenture indicated to the i6 programme board that its confidence about meeting the revised go-live date of December 2015 was at 91 per cent. However, following an analysis exercise, Accenture revised its estimated go-live date to April 2018. At that point, the SPA, Police Scotland and Accenture undertook an options appraisal exercise to agree the best way forward.
Following that exercise, the SPA and Accenture entered into negotiations and agreed to terminate the programme in July 2016. They agreed a settlement of £24.65 million. That figure included a refund of all the money that had been paid to Accenture—a total of £11.09 million—plus an additional payment of £13.56 million.
As you said in your opening remarks, convener, the failure of the i6 programme means that some of the benefits of police reform that should have come from it have been, at best, delayed. There are also wider implications for the modernisation of the justice system.
Our audit concentrated on the history of the i6 programme and the factors behind its failure. I have asked the auditors of the SPA to monitor information and communications technology developments as part of the annual audit process. That is particularly important given the emphasis that is placed on the use of technology in the recently published draft policing 2026 strategy. I also put on record my intention to publish in May this year a report on the lessons to be learned from this and other ICT projects that I have reported on.
Alongside me are Mark Roberts and Catherine Young, who have worked on the project. As always, we will do our best to answer the committee’s questions.