The next petition is PE1607, on congestion charging in major Scottish cities. This is the third of Mr Gregson’s petitions. At our last consideration of the petition, we agreed to write to the Scottish Government, COSLA, the Scottish local government partnership and the Mayor of London. We have received responses from COSLA and the Scottish Government, plus a submission from the petitioner. The Scottish Government maintains its position against road pricing now and in the future, and COSLA suggested that the issue might be discussed when the third report on policies and proposals is published. The petitioner repeats his query as to why current legislation is not used by local authorities.
Do members have any suggestions for action on the petition?
There is probably a fear factor, as far as local authorities are concerned. I know that when I was on Falkirk Council and the City of Edinburgh Council was planning to introduce congestion charges, we in Falkirk were all for it. However, I wonder whether we would have been so in favour of it had it been proposed for Falkirk. Local authorities are probably reluctant to take a bold decision on congestion charges.
Is there anything in the legislation that makes it more difficult for local authorities to consider congestion charges, rather than it just being a question of local authorities saying, “Well, look what happened in Edinburgh. Let’s not go there.”? Is there something in the legislation that causes problems for local authorities with regard to considering congestion charging?
There could well be. Perhaps Angus MacDonald, who has much more experience of local government, knows whether congestion charging is difficult for local authorities to approach.
I think that local authorities are looking at other measures in this area. Car parking in Glasgow, for example, is expensive and I think that Edinburgh has reduced its speed limit to 20mph in the city centre. Councils are taking different measures to address perhaps similar problems.
Would it be worth checking whether current legislation blocks local authorities from having congestion charges? We could address that specific question to COSLA if it has not already answered it. The other option is to defer further consideration of the petition until it becomes clear whether the relevant issues will be included in RPP3.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.