Act of Sederunt (Fees of Solicitors and Shorthand Writers in the Court of Session, Sheriff Appeal Court and Sheriff Court Amendment) 2016 (SSI 2016/316)
Item 4 is consideration of two negative SSIs. I refer members to paper 2 and, in particular, to the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing on the act of sederunt, particularly page 2. I will take the liberty of reading exactly what that says, because it refers to a strong recommendation from the previous Justice Committee on the Courts Reform (Scotland) Bill:
“The Committee seeks assurances that there will not be a substantial rise in the level of court fees to pay for the reforms in the Bill and will monitor closely the outcome of the next consultation on fees in 2015 and consequent statutory orders.”
I remind members that the act of sederunt proposes a 24 per cent increase in court fees. It was very much the opinion of the previous Justice Committee that there should not be
“a substantial rise in the level of court fees to pay for the reforms in the Bill”.
As a member of the previous committee, I am more concerned with the actual figures than with the percentages. We are talking about £18. I am reassured that people who are on low incomes are exempted. The SPICe briefing says:
“The current exemption regime covers those on income-based social security benefits such as income support. Those in receipt of Civil Legal Aid are also exempted from paying court fees. This is notionally available to those with disposable incomes of up to £26,000”.
I do not know how this works, but is it possible to get more information on some of the comments that were previously made? We are told that, two years ago, the Scottish Government said that it would take some time to get to full cost recovery but it is now saying that it has achieved it.
The briefing also states:
“The Scottish Government has indicated that it intends to look again at fees in 2018. At this stage, it is hoped to have better data”.
If we consider the negative side of that statement, does it mean that the Government is proposing the change with poor data?
The act of sederunt is part of a 10-year programme to recover the full costs, which started in 2006. It is appropriate that we proceed with it at this stage.
I agree with the comments made by John Finnie and Stewart Stevenson. The briefing clearly says:
“court fees are a small part of the cost of taking court action.”
I am inclined to look at the figures rather than percentages. That is the sensible way to proceed and I would not want to hold up the act of sederunt in any way.
I am not familiar with the background to that. John Finnie is right to pick out some of the safeguards that are in the system.
It would be helpful to understand what the trajectory is if, as Stewart Stevenson says, the process has been on-going since 2006. I am not clear why any undertaking would have been given to a previous committee that the direction of travel would not have continued along the path that this appears to be part of.
The point that has been made about the overall level of fees and the safeguards that are in place offers some reassurance, but I am at a disadvantage in not knowing the earlier undertakings that ministers appear to have given to the committee.
The principle was access to justice and that that should remain when looking at court fees; there should not be a substantial increase.
I take on board John Finnie’s point that the increase is relatively small in monetary terms. An important principle has been laid down today. If it is the will of the committee—it certainly seems to be—to approve the SSI, I am minded to move that we do that.
If there are no further comments, does the committee agree that it does not want to make any recommendation in relation to either of the SSIs?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.