Good morning, convener. I am pleased to have the opportunity to speak briefly to this draft SSI.
The draft Home Detention Curfew Licence (Amendment) (Scotland) Order 2016 amends section 3AA(5) of the Prisoners and Criminal Proceedings (Scotland) Act 1993 by repealing paragraphs (f) and (g) of subsection (5), which in turn refer to sections 16 and 17 of the act. Section 3AA(5) of the 1993 act provides a list of circumstances to which the Scottish ministers’ power to release a prisoner from prison under section 3AA(1)—known as home detention curfew or HDC—does not apply. HDC is a form of release from prison for up to six months prior to the halfway stage of the prisoner’s sentence. During that period, the prisoner is tagged and is subject to a curfew condition, which is remotely monitored.
Section 3AA(5)(f) of the 1993 act, which the SSI seeks to remove, permanently prevents the granting of HDC to a prisoner where the prisoner has previously been released on licence but has then been recalled to prison either for non-compliance with their licence conditions or because they have received a further sentence of imprisonment before the expiry of their sentence.
Section 3AA(5)(g) permanently prevents the granting of HDC to a prisoner where the prisoner has previously been released from prison during the term of their sentence but has then been returned to custody during that time for committing a further offence.
The repeal of those two paragraphs will mean that such prisoners may be able to obtain HDC. However, their release will still be at the discretion of Scottish ministers, exercised via the Scottish Prison Service. The granting of HDC is not guaranteed. In deciding whether to grant HDC, the Scottish ministers, via the Scottish Prison Service, are obliged to carry out a stringent risk assessment and to take account of the need to protect the public.
The repeal of the paragraphs implements one of the recommendations that was made in October this year by the electronic monitoring in Scotland working group, which consisted of experts from the Prison Service and the police as well as independent researchers, social work practitioners and a representative of Scottish Women’s Aid. In making the recommendation, the working group pointed to the fact that permanently excluding low-risk prisoners from applying for HDC does not recognise an individual’s progress in terms of rehabilitation and improvements in compliance and motivation to desist from offending. Indeed, the working group considered that the fact that someone was recalled at 18 years of age for breaching their HDC licence should not preclude them from applying for HDC at a later stage of their life.
Finally, it should be noted that a number of exclusions from HDC will remain. Those include life prisoners, sexual and violent offenders who are serving an extended sentence imposed under section 210A of the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995, and sex offenders who are subject to the notification requirements in part 2 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003.
I am happy to take questions.