Scotland’s colleges have been through a period of major change, which I have reported on previously. Today’s report provides an update on progress on implementing and managing those changes, including the impact on students and staff. It also comments on the sector’s financial position, and the role of the Scottish funding council.
Although the merger process is now complete, colleges are continuing to adjust to changes, including regionalisation, reclassification as public bodies, and new funding and monitoring arrangements. Against that backdrop, the sector continues to exceed national targets for the provision of learning.
However, the Scottish Government is still not able to fully measure the benefits and costs of its merger programme. Since some measures, such as student destinations and employer engagement, lack baseline information, it will now be very difficult for the Government to demonstrate whether its reforms have delivered all the expected benefits.
Scotland now operates with 13 college regions, three of which contain more than one college. Only one of the three regional bodies was able to perform the role that was expected of it in 2014-15 and 2015-16.
There is a mixed picture in terms of student participation. The number of people under the age of 25 in full-time college education has increased by 14 per cent over the past 10 years. Over the same period, the total number of students has fallen by 41 per cent, and the number of part-time students has fallen by 48 per cent. Most of the reductions have been among women and people aged over 25. It is not possible to determine whether those reductions reflect a fall in demand, as data is not collated at national level.
The overall percentage of full-time further education students successfully completing their course increased year-on-year between 2009-10 and 2013-14, but dropped slightly in 2014-15. Colleges told us that the amount of change in the sector, along with efforts to widen access to students from more deprived areas, contributed to the reduction.
Information on destinations for college students was published for the first time this year. That showed that, in 2013-14, at least 82 per cent of students went on to education, training or employment.
Staff numbers fell by 9 per cent between 2011-12 and 2013-14, before increasing by 5 per cent in 2014-15. Staff feedback on the impact of mergers is mixed. Some felt that mergers had been successful, and cited benefits from sharing best practice and offering more opportunities for development, while others had concerns about the impact on workloads of voluntary severance and the reduced number of support staff.
The sector’s financial position deteriorated in 2014-15. Although the overall financial health of the sector is relatively stable, we identified four colleges that face financial challenges. Colleges do not have long-term financial plans that would help them prepare for further financial pressures, such as national collective bargaining, estate maintenance and student support funding.
I have reported previously on significant governance failings in a small number of colleges. The college good governance task group has published its recommendations, which should mitigate the risk of significant governance failures in future.
As you would expect, the SFC undertakes regular monitoring of colleges. That has improved over time, but it has not always resulted in timely and effective resolution of problems. We found that the Scottish Government had not undertaken a comprehensive review of the SFC’s role in the past 10 years, and we recommend that one take place.
My colleagues and I are happy to answer the committee’s questions.