Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Scotland’s colleges 2016”

Thursday 6 October 2016 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 09:45–10:00 Committee business 68 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

68 contributions
Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Item 3 on our agenda is an evidence-taking session on the Auditor General’s report entitled, “Scotland’s colleges 2016”. The Auditor General is joined by Mark MacPherson, the senior manager of Audit Scotland; and Stuart Nugent, the audit manager.

The Auditor General will make an opening statement.

Caroline Gardner
link

Scotland’s colleges have been through a period of major change, which I have reported on previously. Today’s report provides an update on progress on implementing and managing those changes, including the impact on students and staff. It also comments on the sector’s financial position, and the role of the Scottish funding council.

Although the merger process is now complete, colleges are continuing to adjust to changes, including regionalisation, reclassification as public bodies, and new funding and monitoring arrangements. Against that backdrop, the sector continues to exceed national targets for the provision of learning.

However, the Scottish Government is still not able to fully measure the benefits and costs of its merger programme. Since some measures, such as student destinations and employer engagement, lack baseline information, it will now be very difficult for the Government to demonstrate whether its reforms have delivered all the expected benefits.

Scotland now operates with 13 college regions, three of which contain more than one college. Only one of the three regional bodies was able to perform the role that was expected of it in 2014-15 and 2015-16.

There is a mixed picture in terms of student participation. The number of people under the age of 25 in full-time college education has increased by 14 per cent over the past 10 years. Over the same period, the total number of students has fallen by 41 per cent, and the number of part-time students has fallen by 48 per cent. Most of the reductions have been among women and people aged over 25. It is not possible to determine whether those reductions reflect a fall in demand, as data is not collated at national level.

The overall percentage of full-time further education students successfully completing their course increased year-on-year between 2009-10 and 2013-14, but dropped slightly in 2014-15. Colleges told us that the amount of change in the sector, along with efforts to widen access to students from more deprived areas, contributed to the reduction.

Information on destinations for college students was published for the first time this year. That showed that, in 2013-14, at least 82 per cent of students went on to education, training or employment.

Staff numbers fell by 9 per cent between 2011-12 and 2013-14, before increasing by 5 per cent in 2014-15. Staff feedback on the impact of mergers is mixed. Some felt that mergers had been successful, and cited benefits from sharing best practice and offering more opportunities for development, while others had concerns about the impact on workloads of voluntary severance and the reduced number of support staff.

The sector’s financial position deteriorated in 2014-15. Although the overall financial health of the sector is relatively stable, we identified four colleges that face financial challenges. Colleges do not have long-term financial plans that would help them prepare for further financial pressures, such as national collective bargaining, estate maintenance and student support funding.

I have reported previously on significant governance failings in a small number of colleges. The college good governance task group has published its recommendations, which should mitigate the risk of significant governance failures in future.

As you would expect, the SFC undertakes regular monitoring of colleges. That has improved over time, but it has not always resulted in timely and effective resolution of problems. We found that the Scottish Government had not undertaken a comprehensive review of the SFC’s role in the past 10 years, and we recommend that one take place.

My colleagues and I are happy to answer the committee’s questions.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I am contrasting the responses that we have received from the SFC and from the Scottish Government. The SFC’s response seems very clear—it indicates straightforwardly whether the SFC agrees with the various recommendations. However, I am less clear about the response from the Scottish Government.

Caroline Gardner
link

I had the same reaction when I read the response from the Scottish Government. I think that you would need to direct that question to the Government.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

It is possibly something that the committee will want to take up.

Page 26 of your report lists some key messages about college finances and says that the Scottish Government’s approach to funding colleges for depreciation is complex. Could you explain what is complex about that issue?

Caroline Gardner
link

I knew that you would want to drill into that issue.

Depreciation is not complex to accountants and people who understand it—I acknowledge that that does not cover many people in the world. It is a straightforward way of recognising the fact that fixed assets deteriorate in value over time and that there is a cost to that.

The way in which depreciation has been funded in colleges in the past has been unusual, and the change to colleges being classified as public bodies has added to the complexity. Stuart Nugent will talk you through that.

Stuart Nugent Audit Scotland
link

Prior to being reclassified, colleges were provided with cash funding to cover all elements of cost, including depreciation. As depreciation was not a cash spend, colleges were free to save that money and put it towards the reserves, or spend it. If they spent it, that would result in a deficit.

Following reclassification, colleges can no longer apply that money to their reserves. They can still spend that money but, if they do, it will result in a deficit, as before. However, the Scottish Government has approved certain items of expenditure that that money can be spent on, such as student support payments, repayment of loans and issues around specific regional pressures. If the cash that was set aside for depreciation was spent on those items, that would result in a technical deficit, which the Government would understand and accept as such and would not view as a normal operating deficit. That is the difference between the situation before and after reclassification.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

That makes things a bit odd. What is the total value of the money that we are talking about?

Stuart Nugent Audit Scotland
link

The total value in 2014-15, including the repayments of loan debt, was £17 million.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

That is not a small sum for the colleges.

I want to ask about an issue that we have discussed before: arm’s-length foundations, or ALFs. What are colleges doing with them now? I know that when they were set up, colleges moved initial funding into the ALFs to avoid losing it. Are they still putting money into them? Have you looked at ALFs at all?

Caroline Gardner
link

Yes, we looked at them as part of our review of the 2014-15 accounts. Mark MacPherson will talk you through the changes that we have seen this year.

Mark MacPherson Audit Scotland
link

Colleges are still transferring money into ALFs—I think that the figure for 2014-15 was £7 million. As far as we can determine, ALFs are operating as intended; colleges are paying in money, making applications and, in most cases, getting the money back. Colleges might have their applications refused—indeed, that has happened with a few colleges—and other bodies can apply to the ALFs for money, provided that it is for the intended purposes of further education. That, too, has happened in a few cases.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Where did the £7 million come from?

Mark MacPherson Audit Scotland
link

Colleges can still generate surpluses and, at a certain point in the year, they will make an estimate of how much they think they might be able to transfer into the ALF for, I guess you could say, safe keeping—if it can be guaranteed that they will get it back.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

So they are putting public funds into the ALFs.

Mark MacPherson Audit Scotland
link

Colleges can generate their own income, of course, so—

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But it is still public money, even if it comes from commercial operations.

Mark MacPherson Audit Scotland
link

I think that it depends on how the colleges have generated it. Presumably, if they can fund whatever it is they have been paid to deliver from commercial income, that is within their—

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I think that that is more than just a grey area. As they are public institutions, any income that they generate becomes public income.

Caroline Gardner
link

As we discussed with the committee in the previous session in relation to Coatbridge College, colleges generally are not able to account for their funding as being public or private. There is a good deal of allocation of costs between different headings, and colleges are accountable for the funding that they receive from the funding council. I think that the overall management of their budgets is a matter of proper public interest and interest to this committee.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Is the amount of funds in the ALFs increasing?

Mark MacPherson Audit Scotland
link

I think that it decreased over the period since last year. Colleges made a large transfer in the first year that they existed, because they had reserves that they were able to transfer. Now that they are operating on a year-to-year basis, the amounts that they are able to transfer are smaller. As we say in the report with regard to capital funding, it is clear that they have to rely on some of the money sitting in the ALFs to pay for some of the changes that they want to implement. I expect that, over time, the funds in ALFs will reduce.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But Audit Scotland will keep an eye on the matter.

Caroline Gardner
link

Absolutely.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The other issue that keeps coming up in these reports is the Scottish funding council. For example, on page 35, you say:

“The SFC’s role in regulating college governance is not clear and”

as we have seen

“it has not been effective in ... some issues”.

Are there any indications that it is getting better?

Caroline Gardner
link

As we say in the report and as I said in my opening statement, we think that the funding council has got more effective at monitoring what is happening in colleges. It is not always clear that its monitoring has led to the resolution of problems instead of simply identifying them; indeed, we saw a good example of that in Coatbridge College. However, it is also true that the funding council’s role has expanded markedly over the past few years, with big changes in both the council itself and the further and higher education sectors for which it is responsible. That is why I have recommended that the Government review its role and how well equipped it is to carry it out.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Might there be a conflict of interest with the SFC increasingly becoming a regulator as well as the organisation that dispenses funding?

Caroline Gardner
link

I do not think so. Colleges and indeed higher education institutions are accountable to the funding council for the money that it distributes on behalf of the Government. It does not seem to me to be a conflict of interest that the funding council is monitoring their financial health and how well they are fulfilling the funding conditions. However, as I have said in the report on colleges and the report on higher education, I think that there is room for the funding council to do that in a more strategic way.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Last year, you recommended that the Government and the funding council publish financial information on the costs of and savings achieved through the merger process. On page 12 of your report, you say that many of the costs of the merger, such as the costs of harmonising pay, were not included in the SFC’s assessments. What other factors have been omitted from those calculations?

10:00

Caroline Gardner
link

The funding council has now published its summary of the costs and benefits of the merger programme. We think that there are two broad areas for which it does not provide the full information that we would expect to see. The first of those areas, as you have identified, is the full cost of the mergers, particularly the cost of harmonising terms and conditions across the colleges that have merged, which is potentially quite significant.

The second area is the benefits that the mergers were intended to achieve. There is some good information and examples of colleges working better after merger, but there is no baseline information on some important questions. My team will keep me straight, but I think that, for students, there are the questions of their destinations and their satisfaction with their studies and, for employers, there are the measures of employer engagement. The evaluation says that there are improvements in employer engagement but there is no baseline to compare that with. Without that full picture, it is hard to be clear what the full costs were and whether the intended benefits have been achieved.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

In the absence of that baseline, it is not possible to establish whether the estimated £50 million of savings has been achieved.

Caroline Gardner
link

It is difficult to be clear about whether the full benefits have been achieved and the full costs have not been captured. The evaluation takes account of the amount of money that the funding council provided directly to colleges to support mergers, but we know that colleges incurred costs in significant areas such as harmonising the terms and conditions of their staff. That information has not been captured and played into the evaluation.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Will it be possible to fully capture all that information or is it too late to go back and get that baseline?

Caroline Gardner
link

That is a good question, and why we have been recommending it for the past couple of years. In some ways, it should be possible to go back and calculate the cost information although the further out we get, the more difficult that becomes. At this point, it would be difficult to go back and generate baseline information that was not collected in the first place.

We have been reporting on reform programmes across the public sector for a while and we have been clear from the start about the need to have good baselines so that we can see what has changed as a result. That did not happen in this case and it will be difficult to go back and generate that baseline information.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Does that mean that it will be difficult to provide evidence that the original aims of the process have been fully achieved?

Caroline Gardner
link

The further that we get from the point of merger, the more difficult it gets.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Thank you. You report big falls in certain subject areas as a result of cuts in part-time places. Exhibit 4 on page 19 illustrates that very well. We see that courses such as computing and health have fallen by almost half, which is quite significant, and in your statement, you talked about the reduction in the number of part-time students and the gender dimension whereby 53 per cent of the decrease is women.

Looking at the courses in exhibit 4, what is the impact of the cuts on those subjects? Is there a vocational aspect to the courses? Do we know what students are doing now to acquire the skills that they would perhaps have obtained through those courses?

Caroline Gardner
link

Stuart Nugent will come in on that in a moment. It is worth saying initially that, to a great extent, the changes reflect the Government’s policy decision to focus funding on full-time courses that were likely to lead to a qualification that would lead to employment, therefore directly vocational courses are likely to be gaining.

One of our concerns was that a full assessment was not done of that change and the funding council’s later funding change and what they meant for students. We do not have enough of an overall picture of demand for further education to know what is happening to the students who were displaced by the process.

Stuart Nugent Audit Scotland
link

One of our recommendations is that the funding council should look to assess the demand for college places, which would allow us to answer the question of what has happened to the students who no longer attend college. Are they still applying? There is currently no national picture of demand for college places across the country. Individual colleges have their own information systems but there is not a national picture, so we made our recommendation in light of that.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I have a quick follow-up to Monica Lennon’s question. You talk about student numbers decreasing, particularly among women and people aged over 25, but you said in your statement that the data is not collated at national level. Are you able to say categorically why those reductions have happened?

Caroline Gardner
link

From paragraph 28 onwards, we talk about the policy changes that led to those reductions. In 2009, the Scottish Government asked the funding council to focus its funding on the courses that were most likely to lead to employment, which led to less funding for courses that did not lead to a recognised qualification or which were less than 10 hours in duration. That is an entirely appropriate policy choice for a Government to make—it is what Governments are for. Further, a shift in the way in which the funding is allocated through into the funding policy has had an impact on the way in which students are counted. We think that that is what is behind the reductions.

Our concern is that the Government did not carry out an impact assessment, in advance, of what was likely to happen to the people who were not able to gain places in further education as a result of the changes. As Stuart Nugent said, information on demand for FE courses is not collected across Scotland. Although individual colleges have their own information, they do not know whether a student who they turned down for a place went to a college elsewhere, so we do not have the overall picture. It is not clear whether people simply moved somewhere else or were unable to access further education that they would have been able to access before the policy change was introduced.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Turning to the recommendations in the report, you have said that the Scottish Government and the Scottish funding council should work with colleges to determine the current condition of the college estate and prepare a plan to ensure that it is fit for purpose. Is there a concern that the college estate across Scotland is not fit for purpose?

Mark MacPherson Audit Scotland
link

We just do not have the data. In the report, we talk about some work that the Scottish funding council has undertaken to try to assess the areas in which there has been less investment but, as our recommendation suggests, we need to make a proper analysis across the piece. I am sure that, at individual college level, many colleges will have made an assessment of their own estate, but that needs to be brought together to allow any funding decisions to be made on the basis of solid evidence.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Was your concern about the college estate driven by the 77 per cent reduction in capital funding for colleges?

Mark MacPherson Audit Scotland
link

We do not necessarily have a specific concern about the college estate. Our concern was that, when limited capital investment is available, you need to make best use of it. If no one has a clear picture of the overall state of the estate throughout the country, it might be difficult to allocate funding that becomes available.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

In response to my question in the previous agenda item, you explained why there has been a reduction in capital spending. Have any other public sector bodies in Scotland experienced such a huge reduction—77 per cent—in capital spend?

Caroline Gardner
link

As we said earlier, we will come back to the committee with any detailed comparisons that we can provide. However, we know that the Scottish Government’s overall capital departmental expenditure limits budget reduced more significantly than its revenue budget did over the period since 2010. Different public bodies have different ways of compensating for that. At the moment, councils are really the only bodies that can borrow, and they have used that to continue investing in their capital assets over the last period. Other bodies have not had the same ability to do that.

There has been some investment in the college estate through things such as public-private partnerships. However, as Mark MacPherson said, we do not have a clear picture, as we have for the national health service, for example, where there is a regular condition survey that gives the assurance that the estate is fit for purpose or estimates how much investment will be needed to bring it up to an acceptable condition.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I notice on page 26 that the Scottish Government is now looking to PPP to mitigate some of those capital funding cuts in future. Do you think that its plan of £300 million will be sufficient or is it hard to say?

Caroline Gardner
link

At the moment, we just do not know. Without that regular condition survey, it is difficult to be clear what is needed. At the moment, the plans are centred on public-private partnerships because that is the only way that the Government has had to complement its capital allocation through the block grant. From next year, there will be new borrowing powers for the Scottish Government under the Scotland Act 2016, but all of that has long-term revenue consequences, so the Government and the funding council need to be clear across the budget of where the priorities are for investment and what the long-term effect is of “paying that back.”

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I am interested in that, because the Government always tells us that it has moved away completely from PPP but, from the report, that is clearly not the case.

You talked about the 41 per cent reduction in overall student numbers and, from the graph in exhibit 9, it is clear that overall funding to the college sector has reduced—it seems to have reduced to the tune of £150 million since 2009-10. Given that reduction in spending and the reduction in the number of students, is it fair to say that the college sector has taken a huge cut?

Caroline Gardner
link

The reduction in funding to the college sector has been very significant. Obviously, it is more significant than the reductions in the health service and local government. The Government has had to respond to a very significant reduction in the budget that it has had available since 2010 because of the direct relationship between the UK Government’s budget and the block grant that funds Scottish Government services. Choices have to be made on that. There is a question for Government, looking backwards, about how it has made the decisions on allocation and, looking forward to future budget discussions, how it will make those decisions.

It is also important to note that the reduction in funding has reflected a shift in policy, which Mr Kerr asked about earlier. There has been a reduction in the number of students but a significant increase in the number of full-time students coming through of 14 per cent over the same period.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You said earlier that, although there has been a reduction of 41 per cent in the number of students, you do not have the data to show a reduction in demand. Locally, over the years, I have seen information on numbers of applications. Why is that not collected? Surely, in relation to funding places at college, it would be a priority for Government to have a clear idea of how many young people, or just people, want to go to college? Why is that information not collected?

Caroline Gardner
link

We think that it is really important that it is collected. As you say, individual colleges know how many applications they receive, how many offers they make and how many students accept those offers. However, if they do not make an offer or a person does not accept an offer, they do not know whether that person is doing nothing or is moving to another college to take the same course or a different course. We have that information for higher education in Scotland and we think that it is important that we have it for further education, because of the shift in policy and because of the increasing recognition that the link between school, college and higher education is important in allowing people to fulfil their potential, however well they do in the early years.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Is it one of your recommendations that the Government needs to collect information on applications?

Caroline Gardner
link

Yes, it is.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So it is quite possible that hundreds if not thousands of students want to go to college but cannot, but we just do not know.

Caroline Gardner
link

It is possible, but we do not know. It is equally possible that those students have accessed further education in a different college, perhaps doing the course that they wanted or a second preference. It is possible that they have gone into employment of some sort. Without collecting that information across Scotland, we do not know. That seems to us the key thing that the funding council should resolve with colleges as a matter of urgency.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

If the higher education sector has collected that data for so long, why has the further education sector not done so?

Caroline Gardner
link

There is a system to do it across Scotland for higher education, but there has not been a system for colleges. In the past, colleges have been seen much more as local institutions and the way in which the funding has worked for students has meant that the issue has not had the same priority. However, it now clearly has that priority, for all the reasons that we have discussed this morning.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Do members have any further questions?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I have a couple of questions. Obviously, the thrust of the policy change was to get a closer alignment between college courses and employment. The latest available figure shows that 82 per cent of leavers from college had a positive destination. How does that compare to the same figure in 2009, when the new policy was introduced?

Caroline Gardner
link

The information was published for the first time for 2013-14. I think that we saw a very slight reduction between 2013-14 and 2014-15. It is not clear what the reasons for that reduction were, but that is obviously an early warning that colleges and the funding council should pay attention to ensure that the policy is having the desired effect.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

So we do not know what the destination figure was before the policy was changed.

Caroline Gardner
link

The first time that the information was published was for 2013-14.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Okay. The other figure that strikes me is the drop-out rate. The figure for those staying on improved from 59 to 64 per cent, although it slipped back a wee bit last year. However, even in the best year, there was still a 36 per cent drop-out rate, which is very wasteful, is it not? Why is the drop-out rate so high and what can we do to reduce it?

Caroline Gardner
link

We have not had the chance to look at that in detail yet. We have heard from colleges that the changes that were going on in the system and the attempts to widen access for students might both be contributing to that. That is one reason why having the data is so important and why colleges and the funding council should be exploring what is happening across Scotland and in individual colleges so that we can reverse the trend. As you say, it is not good for students and it is not a good use of the public money that Government is spending in the area. Addressing that has to be a priority.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I thank our witnesses very much for their evidence.

I suspend the meeting briefly before we take the next item.

10:16 Meeting suspended.

10:20 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 77
  3. 09:45 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 68
  4. 10:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 131

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.