Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Audit of higher education in Scottish universities”

Thursday 6 October 2016 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 09:00–09:45 Evidence session 77 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

77 contributions
Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

The next item is an evidence session on the Auditor General for Scotland’s report “Audit of higher education in Scottish universities”. I welcome Caroline Gardner, the Auditor General for Scotland, and, from Audit Scotland, Antony Clark, assistant director; Tricia Meldrum, senior manager; and Kirsty Whyte, audit manager.

I invite the Auditor General to make an opening statement before I open up the session for questions from members.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Thank you, convener. The report is our first look at the overall landscape of higher education in Scotland. I will outline the context that Scottish higher education operates in, as it is a bit different from the other sectors that we audit.

As you know, the Scottish higher education sector is successful and internationally renowned. Higher education is a devolved area except for funding and policy relating to the United Kingdom research councils and Innovate UK, the UK’s innovation agency. Other aspects of UK Government policy, such as UK immigration policy and English higher education policy, affect the higher education sector in Scotland. Scottish universities generate funding from a wide range of sources, both public and private.

Although universities are independent, they operate within an environment of multiple stakeholders, regulators and accountabilities. I do not appoint their auditors, as I do for the other bodies on which I report to the Parliament, but since 2010 I have had formal powers to undertake performance audits of bodies that are funded by the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council, and that is the basis of the report.

In 2014-15, the Scottish Government provided £1.1 billion in funding for universities through the Scottish funding council and £623 million in fees, grants and loans for individual students. Scotland’s economic strategy is clear about the contribution that higher education makes in supporting Scotland’s economy, but we think that the Scottish funding council needs to do more to ensure that the funding that it allocates to universities makes the maximum contribution to those national policy aims.

Overall, the sector was in good financial health in 2014-15. Total income was £3.5 billion—up 38 per cent in real terms over the past decade—the sector made a surplus of £146 million and it had reserves of £2.5 billion. Those are all large sums that you will recognise. Universities increasingly use their surpluses and reserves to fund investments in their estate and to subsidise some of their activities, particularly research.

Despite the positive overall picture, however, there is wide variation across the sector and a number of underlying risks. Income is increasingly concentrated in the ancient universities, some universities rely heavily on Scottish funding council funding, which creates risks at a time of continued pressure on public finances, and the surpluses and reserves that I mentioned are heavily concentrated in a few universities, particularly the University of Edinburgh and the University of Glasgow.

The European Union referendum result has increased uncertainty for the sector, with the possible impact on the public finances generally adding to risks to EU funding for Scottish universities and the effect on EU students and staff. The challenges facing the sector include potential further reductions in Scottish Government funding; risks to its ability to continue increasing its income from fee-paying students from the rest of the UK and outwith the EU; the need to invest in the estate; and the challenging new national targets on widening access.

Turning from universities to students, I want to highlight just two points. First, it has in recent years become more difficult for Scottish undergraduate students to gain a place at a Scottish university. That is mainly because applications have risen faster than the number of funded places available for them; since 2010, applications have increased by 23 per cent, while offers have increased by 9 per cent. We have recommended that the Scottish Government and the funding council carry out research to assess the impact of the limits on funded places on access for Scottish students.

Secondly, recent changes to student financial support increased the amount of loan funding available to all Scottish students, while the amount of funding for bursaries and grants fell. As a result, levels of student debt are increasing. Scottish students from more deprived areas continue to have higher levels of debt than students from less deprived areas, and the gap is widening.

As I have highlighted, universities, the funding council and the Government face a number of significant challenges to this very successful sector, and we recommend that they work together to address them. It is essential that the Government ensures that its approach to funding higher education is sustainable in the medium to long term if its policy priorities are to be delivered.

My colleagues and I are, as always, happy to answer questions.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you very much, Auditor General. I invite questions from members.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Good morning. On page 46 of the report, you point out that

“Scottish students from deprived areas have higher levels of student loan debt than students from less deprived areas”;

indeed, you said the same in your opening statement. Are the costs associated with going to university and the prospect of debt presenting a barrier to school leavers from deprived areas?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The straightforward answer is that, at the moment, we simply do not know. That is why we have recommended that the Government and the funding council carry out more research on the impact of the current approach to funding higher education to understand the effect of current policy decisions now and in the future.

I ask Tricia Meldrum to talk you through that in a bit more detail.

Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland
link

A 12-month review of the funding of student support has been going on and is due to report early next year, and we will see what the implications of that will be.

We have also had the report by the commission on widening access, which made a number of recommendations on opening up access to students from a wider range of backgrounds, particularly more deprived backgrounds. The first action in that respect will be the appointment of a commissioner for fair access, who will take forward that programme, working with the Scottish Government, the Scottish funding council and universities. Those are all issues that will be looked at in that programme of work.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I see that, in his response to the committee, Paul Johnston, the director general of learning and justice, suggests that progress on implementing the recommendations of the commission on widening access is contingent on the appointment of a commissioner for fair access. Do you agree with that assessment?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The appointment is obviously a very important symbol of the Government’s commitment to widening access and to taking forward the commission’s recommendations, but it is only one of the recommendations that the commission made. So far, there has been a delay in making the appointment—I think that an announcement on how it will be taken forward was made this week—but it is certainly not the only thing that is needed to answer the questions that we have set out about the number of places available for Scottish students and the effect of the student support system in Scotland on students from different backgrounds.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

On the issue of student debt, you say on page 44 of the report:

“Scottish student debt has increased in recent years as financial support has shifted from non-repayable bursaries and grants to loans”.

Student debt levels rose by 14 per cent between 2013 and 2015 and are projected to average around £20,000 by 2019. What impact is that having on student retention rates?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Again, the issue is not well enough understood in terms of research. We can all speculate on what the effect is, but a matter of concern is that, as we set out in exhibit 18 on page 47, students from the most deprived backgrounds are ending up with the highest levels of debt. That particular exhibit shows levels of debt from the most deprived fifth all the way through to the least deprived fifth. Students from the most deprived backgrounds are ending up with more debt at the end of their studies. The more reliance there is on debt to fund studying, the more that picture is likely to become a problem. That is why we have recommended research to explore that further.

Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland
link

The information that we have on retention rates, which is from 2013-14, shows that, overall, 8 per cent of students did not stay beyond their first year, so 92 per cent stayed beyond that. However, again, there was wide variation between universities. The University of the Highlands and Islands had the highest number of students not staying beyond their first year, with a figure of 20 per cent.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

It is an important theme in the report. On page 49, the report notes that

“It will ... be difficult to achieve the national targets for widening access to higher education for students from deprived backgrounds.”

You recommend that

“The Scottish Government, SFC and universities need to work together”,

as you said in your statement. Would more funding help to meet those widening access targets?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There is no doubt that more funding would help, because it would help to keep the number of funded places increasing at a similar rate to the increase in applications. That increase in applications seems to be the underlying cause of the growing gap. We know that the pressure on public finances is real, and that it is likely to continue, whatever we hear in the autumn statement in November and whatever the Scottish Government’s draft budget looks like after that.

As always, there are choices to be made. We are very conscious that the choices that are made about higher education sit within the Government’s wider programme for government and that there are always trade-offs—that is what government is about. That is why we think that it is so important to properly understand the impact of the policy choices that have been made and to tease out any tensions or inconsistencies that there might be.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I want to pick up on funding. On page 20, in paragraph 35, you say that the Scottish funding council

“allocated £1.1 billion to universities in 2014/15, a reduction of six per cent in real terms, since 2010/11”.

You say that that “reflects reduced funding received” by the funding council from the Scottish Government. Do you feel that that level of funding is sustainable?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is a question for Government rather than for us. We recognise that there is pressure on the Scottish Government’s budget overall. From next year, there will be significant choices to make about the use of the new financial powers, but they will not be a magic wand that will massively increase the amount available for public services across the piece.

On higher education, we are concerned that the ambitious policy commitments around widening access and the funding of student support will butt up against some of the cost pressures that universities already face as a result of their difficulty in raising income from other sources, particularly tuition fees from students from the rest of the UK and from outside Europe. It is really important that the Government and the funding council, together with universities, understand how those pressures will be faced. The committee might decide to explore that further with the funding council and the Government to see how they are developing their thinking on the way in which those challenges will be balanced in the medium to long term.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I have one final question. On 7 September at the Education and Skills Committee, Professor Andrea Nolan from Universities Scotland said that your report

“indicated quite clearly that the sector’s sustainability is not being addressed. We need the funding for a sustainable sector that will recover the cost of our teaching and our research, while recognising that we are in difficult times.”—Official Report, Education and Skills Committee, 7 September 2016; c 26.

Do you agree with Professor Nolan’s assessment?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is really the message of our report. As I said, the sector is internationally renowned and generally very successful, but it faces real pressures in relation to the funding available to it, the costs of continuing to deliver what it does and the Government’s policy priorities. We have identified ways in which those tensions can be managed, which are to do with universities continuing to seek efficiencies, investing in new ways of delivering research and teaching, and working together in doing some of that.

More generally, it is for the Government and the funding council to work with universities to really understand how Government funding can have the biggest contribution to the things that the Government wants to achieve and so support the sector, which is one of Scotland’s strengths.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

To pick up on Monica Lennon’s point about the debt levels of students from deprived areas versus those from less deprived areas, would you not expect that students from deprived areas would have a higher level of debt simply because they qualify for access to the funding to a greater extent than students from less deprived areas and because they have the need for it?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Intuitively, that makes sense; it is certainly a pattern that we see more widely than just in Scotland. The issue is the one that Ms Lennon asked about—whether we understand the impact of that on students applying to Scottish universities and taking up places. There is not good enough information about that part of the mix. In England, there is good evidence that higher levels of loan funding for higher education are not deterring students from applying. We simply do not know what the picture is in Scotland at the moment, and having that picture would help to make good policy decisions.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Will you follow up on that in due course?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have recommended that the Government and the funding council should do that, and we will certainly follow up on our recommendation with them once the committee has finished its deliberations on the report.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Have your recommendations been accepted by the various parties?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The committee has written to the funding council’s director general and chief executive. You have submissions on the issues before you today. The Government’s response to that point is slightly ambiguous; it might be something that you want to follow up with the Government after the session.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You have talked about research and development. Various parts of the sector have concerns about that area. Will you keep an eye on the issue and follow up on it? Only in time to come will we understand the impact of Brexit.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Our concern is that the Scottish funding council’s strategy for research and funding research in universities is somewhat out of date. It has not been revised for a while, and that needs to happen in order for the funding council to be clear that its funding is having the effect that it needs to have. We know that there are challenges with the research funding that is available from other sources not covering the full costs of research.

I will ask Kirsty Whyte to talk you through the issue.

Kirsty Whyte Audit Scotland
link

We know that the funding council is starting to review its approach to research. We identify in the report that Scottish universities’ performance on research is improving. Between 2008 and 2014, the annual exercises that assess how well universities do research, if you will, show that improvement. However, at the same time, the research funding has not got any bigger, which means that the research budget has been spread more thinly, and some of the very high-performing research universities saw a reduction in their research funding after the 2014 exercise. As we say in the report, that raises issues around sustainability.

As the Auditor General mentioned, research is traditionally an activity in universities that does not cover its costs. Last year, universities recovered about 80 per cent of the full economic cost. The amount that they recover depends on the source: some universities that win a lot of charity funding recover only about 65 per cent of the full economic cost of those activities, while the proportion increases to more than 80 per cent for the UK research council funding. As the Auditor General said, that places additional pressure on universities and raises sustainability issues.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

A point that comes up all the way through the report concerns the SFC and how it handles funding and various other things. Is there a problem with how the SFC handles matters?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have said in our report on universities and in our report on further education, which appears a bit later on the committee’s agenda, that the funding council’s role has changed significantly over the past few years—in both sectors, there have been major reforms to how funding is allocated and to the responsibilities that the funding council carries out. However, its role has not been reviewed for at least 10 years. In the light of that and of some of the problems, particularly in further education, that this committee has looked at, we have made a recommendation that the Government should look again at the funding council’s role and make sure that it is clear and that the council is properly equipped to carry it out. The Government is progressing that as part of the current review of the skills and enterprise agencies.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The commercial operations of the universities, which are fairly extensive and lucrative, are not gone into in any great detail—the report does not go into great depth on that issue. Have you looked at it to any great degree?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There is an exhibit in the report, which one of the team will point me to in just a moment, that shows the sources of income for different universities. You are right: they vary hugely.

Exhibit 11 on page 34 of the report shows income profile by university. Members will see that some of the 18 institutions that we looked at have a very heavy reliance on Scottish funding council grants—those institutions are at the bottom of the exhibit. More than 80 per cent of the income of the University of the Highlands and Islands comes from Scottish funding council grants. The figure goes right down to less than 20 per cent for the University of St Andrews. The other income that the universities receive is from a range of different sources.

Obviously, the more that universities rely on public funding, the greater the risk that puts them in at a time when public funding is under pressure, as it is across the UK and in Scotland currently in respect of funding council grants, tuition fees and UK research councils’ research funding. We have not looked directly at universities’ success in generating commercial income, but it is very clear that they have had very differing levels of success and differing approaches to generating income outwith what they get from the funding council and in student support. That highlights our concern that, although the sector as a whole is in reasonable financial health, some universities are much more at risk than others in the current climate.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

On exhibit 11, given the value of the commercial element to the universities, would there be merit in taking a closer look at that?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There certainly would be. I think that the universities themselves pay a great deal of attention to that. They have different assets, sources of expertise and capacities to generate commercial income. That is one of the reasons why we have recommended that the funding council should take a closer and more transparent interest in the financial health of individual institutions. We think that that is not well enough understood outside the universities and that that approach could lead to better funding strategies by the funding council, or to better identification of opportunities for collaboration between universities or with other parts of the public sector and business, for example.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Does the success—or otherwise—in the commercial sector of the universities compare well with the success of universities south of the border or elsewhere?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It depends very much on which universities you are talking about. Kirsty Whyte might be able to give you some insight into that.

Kirsty Whyte Audit Scotland
link

We have not looked at that in a lot of detail, but universities in Scotland and in the rest of UK, particularly in England, are focusing on the innovation agenda, the further commercialisation of research activities and company spin-offs. We know that Scotland overall is quite successful in spin-offs per head, if you will, in the higher education sector compared with the rest of the UK, but the funding council, the Government and the universities are working on that, and they could certainly look at it further.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Before I get to what I want to ask, I would like to follow up on that point. Are you aware of any studies in that respect? It seems to me that the sector delivers a much wider benefit to the economy than simply producing graduates. What, aside from putting students through university, is or appears to be the wider return on investment?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

On page 11 of the report, we reference a study that was commissioned by Universities Scotland from the economic consultancy Biggar Economics. It estimated that the contribution was around £7.2 billion, which is obviously quite a favourable return compared with the £2 billion or so—£1.1 billion plus £600 million—of direct Scottish Government investment in universities. It is clear that there is always some judgment to be made in that respect, but that will give members a feel for the economic benefits. All of us who live in university cities recognise the wider benefits that come from the liveliness and openness that universities bring.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I enjoyed reading the report—I thought that it was very good, as usual. Although the sector is operating in what is clearly a very challenging environment, it continues to produce extraordinary results, and that should be acknowledged and commended. However, have you been able to draw any conclusion on the outcomes or long-term scenario if nothing were to change in relation to the funding? In order to meet challenges, the various institutions might, for example, sell off some of their estate, seek fee-paying students or use the reserves that you mentioned, but I would not have thought that that would have been sustainable for any length of time. At some point, an institution will have sold off all the estate that it can sell off. What would be the outcome if nothing were to change?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I will ask Antony Clark to respond in a moment, but our concern is that there are very different groupings within the 19 institutions referred to in the report. The four ancient universities are, for a range of reasons, more successful in bringing in a wider range of funding. As they tend to be the places that build up surpluses, they have reserves available for investment, and they are more likely to be able to get into a virtuous spiral of being able to invest and to build their success from there.

The universities that are much more reliant on Government funding, particularly at a time when that funding is constrained right across the Government’s budget, tend to be the ones that have fewer opportunities to generate income from other sources, so they run the risk of the kind of vicious circle that you have highlighted in your question. That is not by any means a foregone conclusion, but it indicates what the risks are unless the Government and the funding council, together with the universities, are able to understand the interplay between their various priorities and ensure that the public funding that goes in achieves the maximum contribution to both the Government’s policy aims and the sustainability of individual institutions.

Antony, do you want to comment?

Antony Clark Audit Scotland
link

Yes. The report highlights the fact that although we talk about “the sector”, it is, in a way, not a sector but a range of different institutions that serve different audiences, have different markets and provide different services that deliver different outcomes. We think of universities as being involved in higher education, but they do different things for different people.

The report highlights a series of risks that face the sector collectively, but it is clear that the institutions need to think through what market they want to be in and how they might grow or retrench in the face of the challenges from Brexit and the financial pressures on the public sector. We are very aware from our fieldwork that institutions are quite alert to that. For example, they have business planning processes in place as well as oversight boards for principals and boards. However, there is a role nationally for an overview of how the institutions work collectively to support their economic goals and the broader learning outcomes that are set out in the Scottish Government’s strategy.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I assume that, if a university sought to commercialise itself further by bringing in fee-paying students, it would have to provide courses that attracted those students, which would be to the detriment of courses that did not. Is there an issue in that regard?

Antony Clark Audit Scotland
link

It is not possible for me to answer that question, but it is clear that institutions that have a good reputation in the UK and internationally are likely to draw in fee-paying students. They clearly want to position themselves as bodies that have particular skills. There is probably something in what you have said, but I am not sure that the evidence that we have gathered confirms it one way or the other.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Sure.

Tricia Meldrum talked about the research on Scottish students. Concerns are frequently raised with me that very good Scottish students are unable to get a place at universities in Scotland because the cap has been hit. Do you have a comment on that? Have you found out anything about it?

Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland
link

We have laid out information and data on that in the report. As the Auditor General said in her opening remarks, we found that the number of applications from students has been increasing faster than the number of places that are funded. Working through the data, we managed to identify the number of people who did not get a place at all through the process.

We set that information out in paragraph 95 on page 41 of the report. In the most recent year for which the information is available, almost 9,000 applicants—potential students—did not receive any offers at all, which is about one in five of those who applied. There is no information available about what subsequently happened to those people, so we do not know whether they got a place at a college or whether they worked for a while and then reapplied to university. Therefore, we have recommended that there be more research to enable us to understand what is happening and how the limit on the number of funded places is impacting on different groups of applicants and applicants from different backgrounds.

09:30

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

My question follows on from what Liam Kerr was asking about. If there is a differential between the increase in the number of places and the increase in the number of applications, what would be the order of magnitude of the additional cost of bringing the increase in the number of available places up to the same growth level as the increase in the number of applications?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is a difficult question to answer. The commission on widening access looked at that and made some estimates, but it made some other recommendations about balancing demand and the available funding by, for example, making the Scottish degree programme shorter so that it cost less by comparison—in other words, getting more student funding for the same amount of money—and making articulation more straightforward so that students could do some of their studying in further education institutions and then carry on into higher education. It is for the Government and the funding council to think through both the impact of the number of funded places and the related issue of widening access to enable students from more deprived backgrounds to come through.

Tricia Meldrum might be able to give you some figures from the commission’s work. It is not simply a matter of the amount of funding per extra student that you include in funded places.

Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland
link

I am sorry, but I do not have those figures. I can say, though, that the commission makes the point that because this is a whole-system issue that starts in the early years and continues through school, college and university, you cannot fix it, as it were, just in universities. It is a matter of planning across the whole system.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That is true for some things. However, the capacity—the number of places—is not a whole-system issue; it is surely a decision based on the availability of resources. I accept that getting a higher percentage of kids from poorer backgrounds into universities will require a whole-system approach that probably needs to start even earlier than primary education, but funding capacity to keep pace with the increase in the number of applications has nothing to do with primary education. It is a resource issue. Everything else being equal, if we had to close the gap by providing additional money, what would be the order of magnitude of the cost of closing the gap?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I ask Kirsty Whyte to address that question.

Kirsty Whyte Audit Scotland
link

I must apologise—we have not done that calculation, but we are happy to get back to the committee on the issue. The easy option would be to multiply the amount of grant funding by the additional demand; however, it is not quite so simple to work out the level of funding, because it depends on where demand is directed. Some courses such as medicine will be much more expensive than, say, social sciences courses. The calculation is complicated—it is not an easy one.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I am not suggesting that it is easy; I just wondered whether you knew the order of magnitude of the funding that it would take to close the gap. It would be useful if you were able to give us an indication of what the funding gap is.

Secondly, have you looked at productivity in the university sector? I think that the issue merits investigation.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Not in this audit. As you will recognise, the audit covers quite a lot of ground, and we were keen to keep it manageable.

The funding council requires universities to generate efficiency savings as part of their conditions of grant. In recent years, those savings have been at the 3 per cent level but, if we look further at the recommendation from the commission on widening access, there must be scope to reconsider the organisation and funding of teaching and research, the extent of collaboration across universities and the range of things that would come under productivity, efficiency and what we get for the money that we spend.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Do we have too many universities in Scotland?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is not a question that I can answer.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That was a nice way out.

Brexit means that, at some point in the next five or so years, EU students will not get free education in Scotland; their doing so has been a consequence of the abolition of tuition fees. We want to maintain a cosmopolitan and internationalist approach to recruiting students to come to Scotland. At the moment, we fund EU students to come to Scottish universities. How much does that cost the Scottish Government?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

One of my colleagues will in a moment be able to give me a figure for the number of EU students funded by the Scottish Government. Before that, though, I should flag up the point that it is not entirely a one-way bet; the universities are concerned that they get a significant and disproportionate share of EU research funding that comes into Scotland. Moreover, because of that, many research and teaching staff come from the EU, and there is a concern about losing them.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The Scottish Parliament information centre briefing on EU funding indicates that our money gets recycled in Europe and then comes back to us and that, when we take everything including the common agricultural policy into account, we still have a notional surplus of about £800 million a year. The funding for that is available if we repatriate the EU funding to the Scottish Parliament for our notional share, but that is not the case with the funding for EU students.

I do not want fewer students from Europe. The more students we have from Europe and the rest of the world, the better it is for the education system, our economy and our society. However, I am interested in the round figure of how much we spend on providing free higher education to EU students.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I think that Tricia Meldrum has tracked the figure down for you.

Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland
link

I have the numbers for students. In 2014-15, there were 20,805 EU students and 29,000 students from other countries outwith the EU.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

What share of the budget is spent on EU students who get free higher education here?

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I think that Kirsty Whyte has the answer to that.

Kirsty Whyte Audit Scotland
link

In 2014-15, the Government spent just under £25 million on tuition fees for EU students.

Alison Harris Con Central Scotland
link

I, too, enjoyed what I thought was a valuable report. I am delighted and proud that the Scottish higher education sector is doing so well and is internationally renowned, but your statement that the

“financial position masks underlying risks”

rings alarm bells for me. I understand that it is spread between the older universities and the new universities but if we do not address the situation now, we face a potential crisis in five or 10 years’ time. Do you have any more thoughts on that or do we need to take that back to the Government and the SFC?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have tried to capture our thoughts in the recommendations. The sector has real strengths—it is one of the things of which Scotland can be most proud—and there are challenges that it to some extent faces as a whole but which are really focused on particular universities that do not have access to the same range of income as others.

Part of the challenge is to understand how the Government’s different policy priorities—free tuition for all Scottish students, widening access for students from more deprived backgrounds and continuing to fund world-class research—interplay in the sector as a whole and in individual institutions. That is important, as is understanding the impact of decisions about student support and tuition fees on the decisions that Scottish students and potential students make about where they want to apply to. We have tried to capture that in the recommendations. It is not an easy fix, but sitting down now, understanding how those things interact with each other and thinking through how the nearly £2 billion every year can be spent to the best effect seem exactly the right things to do.

Alison Harris Con Central Scotland
link

And if we do not get it right, we face a potential disaster.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There are certainly risks to the sector and particularly to some institutions.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I have a couple of questions about capital funding. We know that students are attracted to universities for multiple reasons, one of which is obviously good facilities. Therefore, the reduction of 69 per cent in capital funding seems absolutely huge—although it is trumped by the 77 per cent reduction in capital funding for colleges, as mentioned in the report that we are about to look at. Are there any other parts of the public sector in Scotland in which there has been such a huge reduction in capital funding?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I will ask colleagues whether they have any comparative figures; if not, we might be able to come back to the committee with that information.

It is important to note that the capital funding element of the Scottish Government’s budget, which over the past few years has been very largely funded through the block grant, has taken a significant hit and, indeed, has been hit to a greater extent than revenue funding. Exhibit 12 in the report shows that the drop in funding body grants has been counteracted, to an extent, by an increase in universities’ use of internal funds—in other words, surpluses and reserves—and an increase in borrowing and loan funding, particularly over the past few years.

We absolutely recognise how important that is. Universities need to make sure that their estate continues to be fit for purpose with regard to not only teaching but research, which often brings with it particular needs, because it enables them to attract staff and students and therefore affects their long-term sustainability. It therefore seems to us that that is a key issue, which is why we focus on the importance of the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council’s having a clear strategy for how it will allocate that capital funding to the universities over the medium term.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You mentioned surpluses, but I think that we know that there are certain universities that have healthy surpluses and universities that do not. The University of Dundee, for example, is currently running a deficit. From the point of view of equity across higher education, how does that affect the quality of different universities? Is there not an inequity there?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is another illustration of the variability across the whole sector. We know that Edinburgh and Glasgow universities account for a large part of the reserves that are available across Scotland. I think that the overall figure is £2.5 billion, a large amount of which belongs to those two ancient universities.

As I said in response to Liam Kerr, there is a danger that, while the successful universities will be able to invest in and build on their success, those with a greater reliance on public funding will find it more difficult to invest in that way, so there is a risk that they will decline. The availability of funds is a key part of the long-term sustainability of individual institutions.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Sticking with sustainability, I want to go back to Liam Kerr’s important point about the economic impact of universities. As parliamentarians, we are all acutely aware of that; indeed, we and Government ministers often trumpet the fact that we have so many universities in the top 100 in the world. How will the reduction in research funding impact on our universities’ economic impact and their standing in the world?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Research success is key to both those things. I will ask Kirsty Whyte to talk through what is happening with the different streams of research funding, because it is not just the Scotland Government funding that is provided through the Scottish funding council that has an impact in that respect.

Kirsty Whyte Audit Scotland
link

Indeed. As I mentioned earlier, universities have traditionally struggled to recover the full economic cost of research activity. Many funding streams are deliberately designed in such a way that they do not provide 100 per cent of the funding that is required for the activity in question. There is an in-built element of efficiency, in an effort to make universities deliver efficiencies, but a tight research budget and funding package place pressure on universities’ ability to generate surpluses elsewhere in their activities to cover those costs, as the Auditor General has said.

09:45

The University of Dundee was mentioned earlier. It is successful in generating research income, but a lot of that comes from charity sources, which makes it difficult for it to continue to cover its costs. Similarly, the fact that research council and industry funding is not 100 per cent funding continues to place additional pressure on universities in generating surpluses and making efficiencies in order to be able to continue their research output.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

If universities continue to attract good amounts of research funding but the Scottish funding council cannot cover the 20 per cent gap, is there a risk of some research going by the wayside, with an effect on the research standing of our universities?

Kirsty Whyte Audit Scotland
link

It is really up to universities how they want to position themselves and what financial strategies they develop to address that. Universities will consider their own research profiles and identify where they can create surpluses and how they can attract alternative incomes, including, for example, recruiting more students from non-EU countries.

The SFC also has a role to play. In our report, we recommend that it look across the sector at the risks and the information available in order to identify the challenges.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

As members have no further questions, I suspend the meeting in order to change witnesses. Thank you all very much.

09:46 Meeting suspended.

09:47 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 77
  3. 09:45 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 68
  4. 10:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 131

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.