Thank you, convener. The report is our first look at the overall landscape of higher education in Scotland. I will outline the context that Scottish higher education operates in, as it is a bit different from the other sectors that we audit.
As you know, the Scottish higher education sector is successful and internationally renowned. Higher education is a devolved area except for funding and policy relating to the United Kingdom research councils and Innovate UK, the UK’s innovation agency. Other aspects of UK Government policy, such as UK immigration policy and English higher education policy, affect the higher education sector in Scotland. Scottish universities generate funding from a wide range of sources, both public and private.
Although universities are independent, they operate within an environment of multiple stakeholders, regulators and accountabilities. I do not appoint their auditors, as I do for the other bodies on which I report to the Parliament, but since 2010 I have had formal powers to undertake performance audits of bodies that are funded by the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council, and that is the basis of the report.
In 2014-15, the Scottish Government provided £1.1 billion in funding for universities through the Scottish funding council and £623 million in fees, grants and loans for individual students. Scotland’s economic strategy is clear about the contribution that higher education makes in supporting Scotland’s economy, but we think that the Scottish funding council needs to do more to ensure that the funding that it allocates to universities makes the maximum contribution to those national policy aims.
Overall, the sector was in good financial health in 2014-15. Total income was £3.5 billion—up 38 per cent in real terms over the past decade—the sector made a surplus of £146 million and it had reserves of £2.5 billion. Those are all large sums that you will recognise. Universities increasingly use their surpluses and reserves to fund investments in their estate and to subsidise some of their activities, particularly research.
Despite the positive overall picture, however, there is wide variation across the sector and a number of underlying risks. Income is increasingly concentrated in the ancient universities, some universities rely heavily on Scottish funding council funding, which creates risks at a time of continued pressure on public finances, and the surpluses and reserves that I mentioned are heavily concentrated in a few universities, particularly the University of Edinburgh and the University of Glasgow.
The European Union referendum result has increased uncertainty for the sector, with the possible impact on the public finances generally adding to risks to EU funding for Scottish universities and the effect on EU students and staff. The challenges facing the sector include potential further reductions in Scottish Government funding; risks to its ability to continue increasing its income from fee-paying students from the rest of the UK and outwith the EU; the need to invest in the estate; and the challenging new national targets on widening access.
Turning from universities to students, I want to highlight just two points. First, it has in recent years become more difficult for Scottish undergraduate students to gain a place at a Scottish university. That is mainly because applications have risen faster than the number of funded places available for them; since 2010, applications have increased by 23 per cent, while offers have increased by 9 per cent. We have recommended that the Scottish Government and the funding council carry out research to assess the impact of the limits on funded places on access for Scottish students.
Secondly, recent changes to student financial support increased the amount of loan funding available to all Scottish students, while the amount of funding for bursaries and grants fell. As a result, levels of student debt are increasing. Scottish students from more deprived areas continue to have higher levels of debt than students from less deprived areas, and the gap is widening.
As I have highlighted, universities, the funding council and the Government face a number of significant challenges to this very successful sector, and we recommend that they work together to address them. It is essential that the Government ensures that its approach to funding higher education is sustainable in the medium to long term if its policy priorities are to be delivered.
My colleagues and I are, as always, happy to answer questions.