Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Common Agricultural Policy Futures programme: An update”

Thursday 29 September 2016 Public Audit Committee About 09:30–11:00 Evidence session 210 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

210 contributions · showing 1–200
Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Item 3 is our evidence session on the AGS report entitled “Common Agricultural Policy Futures programme: An update”. I welcome from the Scottish Government Liz Ditchburn, director general economy; Jonathan Pryce, director for agriculture, food and rural communities; and Mike Neilson, director of digital. I understand that Liz Ditchburn has an opening statement.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Thank you for the opportunity to present evidence to the committee.

At the outset, I pay tribute to two groups of people. First, I pay tribute to the farmers and crofters who have had to cope with delays and significant uncertainty with their 2015 payments. As a Government, we have not delivered the level of service that people should be able to expect. The Cabinet Secretary for Rural Economy and Connectivity has already apologised for that, and I repeat that apology.

Secondly, I recognise the many staff in the Scottish Government, both in area offices and in Edinburgh, who have worked tirelessly to try to recover the situation. The commitment and perseverance shown by staff are humbling.

The Audit Scotland report makes for very challenging reading. The findings are critical and the report makes important recommendations. Earlier this month, the cabinet secretary confirmed to Parliament that the Government has accepted the recommendations in full and has published its formal response to the report.

I took up post as director general on 1 May this year. From the start, the permanent secretary made it very clear that getting the programme back on track was critical. She asked me to look at it as an immediate and urgent priority, and it has remained my top priority throughout the summer.

The Audit Scotland report covered progress up to April. I will lay out some of the most important developments since then. Many of those have their roots in actions that were taken in the first few months of the year, but others have been put in place more recently.

We now have additional senior capability in the main contractor and in the Scottish Government. Responsibility for information technology delivery is firmly back with the contractor and stronger commercial management of the contract is in place. We have strengthened and rationalised governance arrangements, and we have tracking and monitoring information on payments, which enables us to triage and direct action where it is needed—using dedicated teams, for example, to work on high-value cases or particular groups of cases.

We have a central control room for key periods to prioritise, accelerate and co-ordinate actions across IT, business and finance processes, and we have a more flexible deployment of people so that we can move resource around—for example, area office staff have come to the centre or supported other offices.

What progress have all those, and other, actions enabled since April? Highlights include the completion of the payments made under the 2015 national loan scheme, of which 94 per cent has now been recovered; a significantly improved application window for 2016 applications, with an increase in online applications from 65 per cent to 76 per cent; and almost £310 million-worth of basic payment scheme, greening and young farmer payments being made by the 30 June deadline. To ensure certainty for farming businesses, a loan scheme for 2016 has been confirmed. Critically, savings have been made that reduce the monthly financial burn rate, so that we are on track to achieve CAP compliance for the £178 million programme budget.

Although it is heartening to see that progress, there is absolutely no room for complacency. We estimate that 209 applicants have still to receive a final 2015 instalment and 401 have still to receive a CAP payment. Finalisation of every last 2015 payment must remain a priority.

I turn briefly to how that experience relates to the broader question of assurance for digital programmes. Mike Neilson will want to say more about this later. In June, the Auditor General said:

“the roots of the situation lie right back at the beginning”.—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 30 June 2016; c 7.

It is also clear that optimism bias has played a part, as have challenges in getting sufficient skills and capability.

Informed by that, by other experiences, both good and bad, and by best practice, the Scottish Government plans to introduce a strengthened assurance process. Critically, it will be mandatory, not advisory, and will establish a set of stop-go reviews, to be carried out by independent experts. The Scottish Government will be live testing and refining that approach from now until the end of the year, with a view to introducing it formally in the new year.

The committee might want to ask whether, if an approach of that kind had been in place at the start of CAP futures, the programme could have turned out differently. I believe that it could, and that it is not too late for those new processes to add value to CAP futures. We are planning an independent technical assurance review, the results of which will inform a broader stop-go review under the new processes.

Thank you for your patience in listening to the overview. I look forward to following up with more detail in answer to your questions.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you very much. The first question is from Colin Beattie.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

How many staff have been fired or disciplined as a result of the process? The Government has in effect suffered substantial losses. If that happened in the private sector, there would certainly be severe repercussions. I would hope that, in the public sector, the people concerned would not again be placed in a position where they could create such a disaster.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

As the Auditor General said in her evidence to the committee in June, it is absolutely clear that people did their very best to address the problems that they saw and to take actions as they saw fit. As she also said, the challenges lay a long way back in history. My personal impression from coming new to the issue is that the failure is not for lack of effort, commitment or will. The overall impression of people not trying or not operating effectively is not a picture that I recognise.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But someone is responsible.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Indeed. Ministers and senior officials are ultimately responsible. That is the stance that we take in addressing those issues.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But the ministers were not down at the coalface handling the issues on a day-to-day basis.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

But they are ultimately responsible and accountable to Parliament, as are officials.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Of course, but there were people on the ground who were managing the project.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Yes, and like the people in the centre at headquarters, they have worked tirelessly. They have tried everything possible to make sure that payments get through to farmers as quickly as possible.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

That is not as firm a response as I hoped I would get.

I would like to focus on the wider picture. I have a specific question on the Auditor General’s report, which is obviously a little historical now, as it was published some months ago and a lot has been done since. However, as you said, it does not make for good reading. Paragraph 10 says that disallowances amounted to

“one per cent of the total CAP payments made in Scotland between 2006 and 2013.”

Is that in line with the experience of other countries, or is it better or worse?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

My understanding is that it is around the middle of the pack, but I ask Jonathan Pryce to say more about that, as he has the details.

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

The position compared to the 27 member states is that Scotland’s performance is around the middle. The disallowance was 1.1 per cent of the value paid out over that period. For the UK as a whole, the comparable figure was 3.6 per cent, which places the UK, including Scotland, as the third highest country in terms of percentage of the total value paid out that was paid in disallowance. That gives a sense of the range.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I have a couple of questions on a wider area. There has been a question about the management of the CAP project and other IT projects that previous committees have looked at. Often, there has been a lack of skills and management ability. Have we resolved that problem or are we going to find the same problem in future? How are you addressing skills shortages? Are we learning from other countries about how to do this better?

10:00

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

I will say something briefly from my perspective as the accountable officer for the programme, and I am sure that Mike Neilson will want to say more about the overall skills picture.

It is important to recognise that, to make this work, we need skills in two different places. First, we need sufficient skills within the Scottish Government to enable us to be intelligent clients for external expertise and advice, and a lot of improvement work is in hand. Secondly, I expect that we will always want to continue to work with skilled contractors and expertise from outside Government. There have been challenges in projects such as CAP futures in relation to market availability and getting those skills at reasonable prices.

On the broader economic growth opportunities for Scotland, it is important to increase digital skills across the economy, and the digitisation of businesses is a big theme across Government. However, the nature of the market can make it challenging for the public sector to access the skills that it wants.

I ask Mike Neilson to say a bit more about the plans that are in place.

Mike Neilson Scottish Government
link

The two big issues that we will address today as part of the overall picture will probably be the assurance framework and skills. For now, I will focus on skills.

We recognise that there is a shortage of the relevant skills in Scotland as a whole, and that we face challenges. You will be aware that we set up the central Government digital transformation service 15 or 16 months ago, the purpose of which was to try to ensure that, at the critical initial stages, the people who lead programmes and projects have the right support. That is being done by a combination of bringing permanent staff into the digital transformation service and drawing on contractors and others, as appropriate and in line with the way the market operates.

There has been considerable interest in the service, which has worked on 22 projects across a wide range of organisations, from the Scottish Public Pensions Agency through to the forthcoming employability programmes. I think that the Auditor General said in her earlier evidence that she considers that to be the right approach but that it is yet to be proven. Although we can show that progress is being made with activity supporting a wide range of organisations—both in establishing their programmes and in resourcing them and getting programme directors, technical architects and so on—the proof of the pudding will be in how the projects evolve over time.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

My understanding is that skills shortages are fairly common. How are we competing against other countries to try to attract skills? I am thinking about both south of the border and continental Europe.

Mike Neilson Scottish Government
link

Skills Development Scotland has run a major campaign on a Scotland-wide level, rather than looking at just the public sector, but it has also targeted a number of countries including Poland and Estonia in order to try to draw people into the Scottish economy. That is a significant factor.

The digital transformation service has been using a wide range of recruitment routes in order to get at the specialist skills and we have been quite successful in a number of areas. There are areas where it continues to be difficult, such as cyber. We have a mix of something around 50 per cent permanent staff and 50 per cent contractors or fixed-term appointments, which reflects the realities of the market. Some people will only come in for fixed periods.

We recognise that skills is a continuing issue. We are trying to ensure that, within the framework of UK civil service pay and recruitment, we can offer attractive packages.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You did not indicate the success rate of efforts to bring in people from elsewhere.

Mike Neilson Scottish Government
link

I do not have a percentage in my head. We have found that we can recruit technical architects, business analysts and programme managers, but we are finding it harder to recruit in relation to cyber and, in some cases, senior programme directors.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

It would be interesting to understand where the skills gaps are and where you have been successful in filling them. The Public Audit Committee looks across a wide range of projects. Some have not been good; some have been a bit better. It would give a better understanding of the national position if we could see where the skills shortages were.

Mike Neilson Scottish Government
link

We are about to run a skills survey in central Government, which will help us to update the position. Skills Development Scotland is doing a piece of work on the gaps across the economy.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Do you not think that it would have been helpful if a skills survey had been done before?

Mike Neilson Scottish Government
link

We did one in 2014, so this will update that.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Although technical IT skills are definitely part of the challenge, equally important in projects such as this one are commercial skills, working effectively with contractors—there is no point having a contract if we do not work effectively with the contractors to get the best out of that relationship—and operational process skills. The programme is not just about IT, but about all the processes. For example, on interaction with farmers, there is a need to understand what good customer service should look and feel like. We need to make sure that we continue to build operational skills. Mike Neilson might have the detail on this, but commercial skills is another area where the Scottish Government is actively building its skills base.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I want to try to keep our discussion to themes, because there are a lot of different issues that we want to explore, Alison Harris wants to ask about the IT system, which is a big issue. Quite a few members want to come in on that. I ask members to keep their questions quick and brief; I ask for brief answers, too.

Alison Harris Con Central Scotland
link

If I am reading the information that I have in front of me correctly, it basically says that some cases are far too complex for the IT system to process and pay out on. I hear what everyone is saying about skills and so on, but this is a major expense and a huge IT system. I hear about operational skills, and without wishing to be facetious, the bottom line is “Computer says no.” Why has someone, somewhere along the line, not suggested that more human input is needed, with cases being taken to a back room to be dealt with? It would then be a matter of somehow getting the IT system sorted, overriding it when it cannot cope and bringing in a human element to process the case.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

You are right that there is a critical choice to be made about which cases can be effectively dealt with through the system and which will always require manual intervention. You need to get that right so that you do not try to design a system for a level of complexity and variation that just cannot be dealt with easily. Currently, we need both the system and the human interaction. There are also cases that will always be heavier in terms of human intelligence and interaction. You are raising absolutely the right questions.

In the technical assurance review, I think that we will want to look at whether the line is drawn in the right place or whether we are trying to get the system to deal with certain cases when it might be better to unravel them by taking them out of the system and putting them into manual processes.

There has to be a sufficiently high volume and a sufficient level of standardisation to make using a computer system worth while, otherwise it may be quicker, easier and cheaper not to design such a system and to do the work outside that system. Those are the lines that we want to reassess and check that they are in the right place.

Alison Harris Con Central Scotland
link

I fail to understand why we are reassessing those matters having spent all this money. The issues should have been identified and dealt with earlier in the process and not so far down the line.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

The system is designed to have manual processing alongside automation of claims. I think that that is the way it will always need to be. It is always worth reviewing and checking the system so that we can then ask, with hindsight, whether we could have done it differently. Perhaps we could have done it differently, but that does not take away our responsibility to look at and assess the system now and confirm whether it is in the right place.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Will the £178 million system pay out next year?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

In terms of what—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Will it pay out basic, greening and other forms of payments next year?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Yes.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Then why have you announced a loan scheme?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

We recognise that farming businesses need certainty. According to the cabinet secretary’s latest statement on the issue, we expect the payments to be made from early in the new year through to—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

What is “early in the new year”? I have heard that civil service definition on the programme for the past three years.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

We have a plan that suggests when that will happen—

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

What we do not want to do is to give commitments and promises that we cannot keep. We know the window in which those payments will be made and we have much higher confidence in the system operating than we did in the previous year. However, we recognise that what farmers need more than anything is certainty and, ideally, cash flow as soon as possible, which is why the decision has been made to put the loan scheme in place. It is a really important step.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

We hope that it will pay in November.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

It is a separate system that we built for the 2015 loan—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Who pays that cost? That is a different budget.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Let me check, but I think that that is a budget within the Scottish Government.

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

We already have the capability to make those loan payments.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

So the £178 million IT futures programme is not the computer system that will pay out the loans.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

It is not.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

It is coming out of the Scottish Government’s operational budget.

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

Very little development work is required to enable those payments to go out.

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

There is a cost in staff time in processing those payments. It is mostly an opportunity cost for staff time.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Yes.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

The Auditor General reported in the spring that there was £15.7 million left, but she expected that to be exhausted by November. Is that fair?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

The situation has moved on since then. Let me give you the latest position. The current situation is that, since slightly earlier than the Auditor General’s final report, we have been able—through significant effort by both the Scottish Government and our main contractor, CGI—to make savings that mitigate the risk that Audit Scotland identified. The monthly expenditure has reduced from £4.5 million to £3.6 million, and those underlying savings will be added to by savings that CGI is committed to making at its own risk.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

“Savings” is a moot word when we are talking about £178 million.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

The savings are primarily made up of two things. There has been significant success in reducing overtime—overtime is not the right way to staff a programme over the long term—and in exchanging more expensive staff for staff who are paid within the standard day rates that we feel we should be paying. Those two things have made a huge difference.

We also have savings from the procurement of a specific project—the land parcel information system—that has come in cheaper than we projected.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Was that not supposed to be £31 million?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Sorry, no, the LPIS—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

The land mapping cost was £31 million, according to the Auditor General.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

The original estimate for the land parcel information system was £6 million and the cost is now about £3 million, so I think that that must be something different.

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

Yes—it is £3.5 million.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

All those savings take us to a situation in which we have £34 million left to spend out of £178 million, and our plan shows that that will deliver the elements of CAP compliance. That budget will last through to March 2017 with £3.5 million remaining, which is money that we need to hold for some specific projects that are part of the business case. Those projects start now but will continue beyond March 2017. One is the land parcel information system and another is a process called SACAMS.

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

SACAMS is the scheme and customer account management system.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Another project is a piece of functionality called claims to payment. Those things need to go over the financial year boundary as they are at a particular stage of development, and we have enough money to continue financing them.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

You are aware that no crofter or farmer in Scotland has received a letter or notification saying how much they should have had and whether they can appeal that. When will they receive that letter? Will you confirm whether they can appeal the amount on the basis of the utter mess that you have created?

10:15

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

The first thing that I should say is that we absolutely regret that we have not been able to issue the full range of letters. We are having to prioritise the payments, and rightly so, but we fully recognise that that is not the situation that we wanted to be in and that, for farmers, it is distressing and can cause confusion and concern.

Because we are prioritising the payments, and because the risk of disallowance through late penalties remains important, we will not be sending out letters before 15 October.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

That will be after the loan period closes.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

No. I confirm that people will not be disadvantaged in their ability to appeal or to seek a review. The 60-day period for review will be triggered from the date of the letter and not the date of the payment. No one will have a shortened period for challenging or seeking a review of the information that they have been given.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

But people will have to apply for the loan by 12 October.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

That is for the 2016 loan.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I know that it is not easy to understand this, but we are talking about businesspeople who are trying to run a business, and they have to think about tax and accounting. People have not been told how much they are going to get and they are expected to apply for a loan even though their accountants will be saying, “Wait a minute—you don’t even know what you should have got or whether you can appeal that.” You have got this the wrong way round; you are leaving people in the dark.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

People know how much they have got, because they can see it coming into their bank accounts.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

But they do not know what it is for or whether they can appeal what they have been awarded.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Absolutely—we completely agree. People can see how much they have got because they can see that money coming into their bank accounts. I completely agree that the letters are also important, but we have had to prioritise payments over letters.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

It is an area on which we very much hope to be in a better position next year but, for now, that is where we are.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I note from the Audit Scotland report that NFU Scotland has said that a significant number of individuals have yet to receive a balance payment for their 2015 claim and that some have received nothing at all.

Mention has been made of the complexity of the IT system. NFU Scotland and others have said—fairly—that they know that area office staff are working flat out and that it looks as if they cannot do any more than they are already doing, but the system appears to be completely broken. Can we be confident that the CAP futures programme will ever be capable of delivering the payments to an acceptable standard, not just for 2015 and 2016 but into the future?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

First, I am sure that the experience for 2016 will be very different from that for 2015. We are starting to see the evidence of why we can be confident about that. The period when farmers were trying to make applications as part of the 2015 process was extremely challenging. Jonathan Pryce might want to say more about that, but we know that the system was not stable and that farmers were unable to use it effectively, with the result that it had to remain open for a significant period.

The 2016 application window has gone very much better. We now have the first year of making payments through the IT system under our belts. I am referring to the 2015 process. Of course, none of us wanted to experience the challenges that we have experienced in getting those payments out. We have not done that as quickly as we would have liked, but the system is now completing that cycle, and that puts us in a much better position for repeating the cycle next time round.

We can be confident that the system is functioning. It is making payments, and it will make payments for 2016. We will see significant improvements. However, as I said in my opening statement, we are asking ourselves the same questions that you are asking. We are asking whether the system is the right one for us to build on into the future and whether it has sufficient stability that we can continue to rely on it. That is why we are doing the independent technical assurance review, which will give us an independent view of the system at that point.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I would like to reflect on a few of the things that you have said. You will make the next run of payments early in the new year.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

That is the current plan.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Right. In reply to Monica Lennon, you discussed whether the system will ever be fit for purpose. I take it that your position is that it will be.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

We have a system that is functioning. It comes back to the question that Ms Harris asked, which was whether it is the optimum system for the future or whether we might want to review whether some of its elements might need to be handled in different ways. We will use the review to look at those questions.

We have a system that is functioning and making payments for 2015. There is no reason to suppose that it will not make payments for 2016, or that it will not make them more quickly, because the functionality that we have is working for 2015. However, I am not going to hide the fact that we need to do a different set of things for 2016. We still need to put in place a set of things for functionality for 2016. They are scheduled in a series of what are called in the jargon “drops”, which are new areas of functionality that will be put in place between now and the end of the year. We have a firm commitment from the contractor on that process, which it is putting in place, and on the delivery dates for that functionality.

That is the basis on which we are confident that we will use the system for the 2016 payments. Does that mean that we should not step back and ask ourselves a question about the future? I do not think that it does. We should ask that question.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Have you not just spent £178 million on a system that you might not even go forward with?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

The review could conclude many things. Mike Neilson might want to say a bit more about what reviews of this nature do. However, it could conclude that the system as it is is absolutely fine and that we should just continue as we are.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

I am just trying to describe the kind of conclusions that the review could come up with. It could conclude that some aspects of the system are extremely strong, robust and well built but that other areas have challenges and that we should look at whether there are other options.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

They would cost more money, would they not?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

We would address such questions by asking what the benefits and costs would be and whether we would be in a better position as a result.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

For the avoidance of doubt, when will the 600 payments that are outstanding for the current year be made?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

I will check my numbers to ensure that I am giving you consistent numbers. We have 209 payments still to go for people who have been paid something, and 401 people still have to receive a payment. It is important to say that that is an estimate. There are still eligibility questions to be dealt with in the processing, so those numbers could change, but they are our current estimates. We aim to complete all those payments by the middle of October. We recognise that that is important for farmers and to fully avoid late payment penalties.

There are several categories within those numbers, and Jonathan Pryce might want to say a bit more about them. For example, cross-border cases, by their nature, tend to take a bit more time and we sometimes rely on getting information from other paying authorities. There are also cases involving transferring entitlements through a private contract clause, which require to be dealt with in another way, and there are some inspection cases.

We are looking at those different groups and we believe that we have fixes in place, or processes that we need to put in place, that will enable them to be processed by the middle of October. There are always particularly challenging or difficult cases, and cases where information is not available. There is a possibility that some of them could go beyond that deadline, but we are confident that the majority will certainly be paid by the middle of October.

Jonathan, do you want to say a bit more about the types of cases and the actions that we are taking?

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

I will take the committee through the plan from now until the middle of October. As Liz Ditchburn said, the first cases that we expect to begin paying in a batch are those that involve the private contract clause. We hope to be able to begin making those payments from today, because some more IT functionality was put in place overnight. I did not get an update on that prior to coming to this meeting, but we expect to have more IT functionality that will enable us to begin paying private contract clause cases. If that is not done this week, it should be done next week.

We should start paying the inspection cases that Liz Ditchburn mentioned, which are affected by the private contract clauses, next week, and we would expect to start paying the cross-border cases from the end of next week or the beginning of the week after. That puts us in a good place to complete the vast majority of those cases—with the financial value that remains outstanding—by 15 October.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

You mentioned late payment penalties. Will you elaborate on that?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

As I am sure you know because you have seen the report, the system for European funding is that there are two kinds of disallowance or penalties—financial penalties for late payment and disallowance through other means.

The financial penalty risk that Audit Scotland raised strongly in its report has largely been mitigated, for two reasons. The first is the progress that we have been able to make with making payments across the summer, and the second is the waiver that the European Commission put in place to not use penalties during the period 30 June to 15 October. We are still in a penalty-free period.

It is critical to get out as many payments as possible—ideally all of them—before 15 October. If a small number go over that deadline and there are a small number across the UK, we will come to the final number within the UK. It is not Scotland alone that is responsible. There is no separate ring fence of penalty, if you see what I mean; it applies at the UK level. We will need to wait for final figures to come in from all the UK paying authorities to understand whether the risk is zero or whether there is a small risk of some penalty. The numbers that are mentioned in Audit Scotland’s report are extremely large, but they are no longer of concern.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

The summary says that

“the Scottish Government started a five-year programme to improve its business processes and IT systems”

in 2012, so the programme has been going on since then. When was the IT system procured? Why were the problems not picked up until the system started going through the process? As we know, many people in our agricultural sector had to suffer as a result.

Page 16 of the report also says:

“Software to process and validate applications was still being developed when the application period closed.”

Why? Why was that not all in place and functioning before any of the applications were started? Is the software still in the process of being developed? You have said that there is an on-going review of the software. What are the delivery dates for functionality? What is the end date for the review?

What was different from previous years? You say that you are waiting for a lot of information about different applications but CAP payments have been going on for years. Has the information changed? Are we looking for more information? How is the system different from what it was previously?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

I will start, but I think that Jonathan Pryce will also want to come in.

There are a few important principles and pieces of information to establish. When the European Commission negotiates and agrees the common agricultural policy, it sits in a period of years. We are now in the first year of the new CAP that runs from 2014 to 2020—I think that that is the correct terminology. This is, therefore, a different CAP that operates in different ways from the previous scheme. That is a set of policy changes and choices that the EC and member states made as they designed the new process; this is a new way of operating agricultural subsidies. That is the first thing to say.

Secondly, one of the biggest challenges that the programme faced in the design—it is an interesting lesson that Mike Neilson and others will take into account as they look at other projects—was that we were trying to specify and design the system before the European regulations for the 2014 to 2020 period had been finalised and agreed. In effect, we were trying to design while not knowing exactly what would come out. As you can imagine, that was an extremely challenging situation. Procurements take a long time and systems take a long time to develop, so the design work had to start in some shape or form at a point at which the information to make those decisions was not complete. That is the nature of the beast.

10:30

Agricultural policy is a devolved area, so Scotland made policy decisions. We start with the core European regulations and then have some flexibility to amend, adjust and decide how we want to design our scheme for the particular area. Europe tries to finalise a set of regulations and, alongside that, there is a process in which Scotland decides how to apply those regulations here, where to change them and where to use the flexibilities that are allowed.

There was a new common agricultural policy in the programme and significant uncertainty about what the final system would look like, which is fundamentally why so much of the functionality and so much of the work was so close up to the system needing to operate.

Finally, we require specific information about particular farms on particular dates. That is not the same information. There always needs to be new information every year, as we are finding out what is happening on the farm at that time in that year. That is the nature of the application.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I am interested in what you are saying about Scotland deciding to do things a little differently. Who made that decision? Did someone in the Scottish Government make it?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

It was ultimately ministers who did so.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Is there any good practice in other European countries that we can learn from?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

In terms of what?

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

In terms of how they administer their CAP payments.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Are you talking about the information technology aspects of systems?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

I do not have any information on that. I do not know whether Jonathan Pryce wants to say anything about it.

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

Very different decisions were taken across all the parts of the United Kingdom about how to implement the common agricultural policy in its new, more complex form. It is very clear to me now that the decisions that were taken in the middle of 2014—I think that they were taken in June 2014—brought in enormously more complexity than we imagined. We knew that we were at the behest of the industry to try to fit the policy to Scotland’s circumstances, and we tried to accommodate its requests. We had concerns about the complexity and we discussed all of that but, at the end of the day, we still went for three payment regions.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Was that at the industry’s request?

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

Yes, that was at the industry’s request. The complexity consequences that came out of that were even more extreme than we expected.

In other parts of the UK, the Welsh and the Northern Irish have used a single region. England went through its troubles with the common agricultural policy back in 2006-07, when it moved to a regionalised model. It had its pain then, although it still has some pain this time round. Those were the most significant differences across the different paying agencies.

The other difficulty that we faced was the fact that our previous IT infrastructure was not capable of supporting the new, more complex CAP. Relatively uniquely, we were building not just a new CAP but the entire infrastructure for it, including the IT infrastructure, at the same time.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I have a supplementary question. Surely the whole of Europe had to go through exactly the same process. It had to adapt to a new system. I appreciate what you say about other countries having problems, but I am not aware of any countries that have had such problems—particularly Ireland, for example. Why did we not take best practice and learn from other countries to make things right?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Jonathan Pryce might want to say more about the process that was undertaken at that time. However, France has had more severe problems than we have had; it is at an extreme that makes Scotland’s problems look small.

You raise the interesting question of whether Europe ought to be thinking about procuring a single system, and there are indeed some areas where Europe procures single systems that can operate across all countries. There is increasing collaboration on some single systems and single solutions that can work across the piece. When we find ourselves in multilateral settings, it is important to continue to ask whether one solution can work and can contain sufficient flexibility for all. However, that is not the route that Europe has gone down for this particular set of things. Different countries’ processes and systems look very different, which is why it has been challenging to try to have a single system in this case.

We need to think about the current set of problems, but we also need to think about what kind of future we want. There is a real potential to move to the increased use of remote sensing technology to replace some of the current processes. There are therefore potential technological solutions for the medium term that we ought to continue to think about. Rationalisation with other member states is also an interesting proposal.

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

There would have been simpler options available to us, which we have seen in other countries. We considered the redistributive model that Wales has looked at as an alternative to the three regions but, in the end, we came down on the side of the industry, which wanted the particular arrangement that we have. The industry is not unhappy with the policy but is obviously and understandably very unhappy with the delivery of the policy—particularly its implementation through the IT system. You should bear in mind the fact that it was not just the IT system that became complex but also the processing tasks that have to be carried out by all the area office staff.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

Convener, thank you for allowing me to take part in today’s committee meeting.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

It is a pleasure.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

In return, any of this committee’s members is most welcome to come to a meeting of the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee, where they will be accorded the same courtesies that I have been given here.

I declare an interest, in that I am a member of a farm partnership.

We have heard a lot about the excellent and extra work of the staff in the area offices, who are the forward-facing staff that have had to deal with the problems that farmers have faced on the ground. However, neither I nor my committee have been able to get to the bottom of what the extra cost for those staff has been. How much overtime have they put in? What has it cost the Government? How many extra staff have been taken on?

Furthermore, can the witnesses give an estimate of the cost to farmers of getting only 80 per cent of their payment in the early part of this year and estimate the cost of that to the economy? Those are real costs that somebody has to bear and they relate specifically to this project, which has been faltering since September last year as far as the staff in the area offices are concerned.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

I ask Jonathan Pryce to respond to the questions on overtime and staffing costs. I think that we have some information on them.

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

We have some detailed information. However, I am conscious that Mr Ewing gave evidence to the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee last week and that we received a letter from the clerks this week setting out what information we will write to you about.

I will give you an overall impression of the overtime costs. The cost in 2015-16 for overtime for the area office staff, which covers some of the current processing year, amounted to £348,000. In the previous two years, the overtime costs ranged from £184,000 to £210,000. It is common for the area offices to work overtime and, because they are used to doing so at peak periods, there was a good response from them when we asked for more effort over the recent period. You will see that, for overtime costs in the area offices, the difference between this year and the previous years under the old system is of the order of £100,000 to £150,000. However, as I said, we will write to you with more specific details on the overtime.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

It is my understanding that approximately 70 extra staff were taken on to assist. Is that correct?

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

Do you mean in the area offices?

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

I am afraid that I do not have the figure for the total number of staff. I think that 70 might be the right figure, but staff were brought in temporarily and I am not sure that we ever got as high as an additional 70 all of the time or that we peaked at that. Again, we will write to you and the REC Committee with that information.

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

It comes out of the rural payments budget—the budget that supports the administration and staff in the rural payments and inspections division.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I have a couple of quick questions. First, just following up on that issue at this stage, what is your global estimate of the net additional cost of this fiasco to the public purse?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

As I explained earlier, we are on track to deliver the CAP compliance within the £178 million budget, so there should be no additional cost there. You are perhaps raising questions about the ways in which we have had to flex priorities. There is no new money to spend on the programme. If we have to increase staffing in one area, we will remove it from other areas. It is always about flexing our resource to meet the needs.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That is why we need a detailed account. This is the Public Audit Committee. If you are shifting staff from one resource to deal with the issue, we need to know the implications of that. If staff are to be moved from an existing service to provide additional resource, that suggests that other services will suffer. We need a comprehensive statement on the staff costs and all the other costs that Mr Mountain mentioned. We are the Public Audit Committee and it is our job to look at that. When can we get that statement?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Jonathan Pryce has something to add.

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

I was just going to say that, throughout the process of the development of the new CAP, there was clear acknowledgement at a European level of the administrative costs. Leaving aside the IT and the costs of building the new IT infrastructure—we had to do that anyway, to an extent—it was acknowledged that the additional complexity of the CAP would lead to at least 15 per cent additional administration costs in the paying agencies. That was the view of the European Court of Auditors in a report that it produced. I forget the year, but it was something like 2012 or 2013.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

We need a very detailed account of each line item where there is an additional cost and what that cost is. We need to know how long the cost exists for and in which financial years the costs have been met. We have had figures all over the place. We need a list, on one piece of paper, of all the additional costs, setting out why they were required. If there were additional staff, that was still an additional cost, so we need to know where they came from and which services they had previously been providing. We need a much more detailed account rather than bits and pieces, which is what we are getting at the moment. We need a comprehensive statement of the costs.

My second point follows Colin Beattie’s earlier question. Ms Ditchburn rightly said that responsibility ultimately rests with ministers. As we know, the relevant cabinet secretary is no longer in post. Ms Ditchburn mentioned people’s willingness to work and all the rest of it, but one word that she did not use is “competence”. I am not referring to people in the area offices; I am referring to the senior management in the rural affairs department. Who is taking responsibility for this fiasco? How many heads have rolled? How many people have been promoted despite their incompetence? Who is taking responsibility in the civil service?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

I am. As the current director general, I am clearly responsible for the delivery of the programme.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Yes, but you were not responsible for the original fiasco. Who is responsible for that? What is happening?

10:45

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

I challenge your question about competence. I genuinely do not think that this is about saying that individual X has been incompetent and individual Y has not. There is no single point of failure in the programme. The programme has faced challenges over a long time. The Auditor General herself says that the roots of the situation lie a long way back and that people have worked extremely hard to put the programme back on track.

This is not a programme about which you can say that there was a single point of failure—that if only a particular person had done their job differently, it would all have been okay. There were complexities in the environment, which we have talked about before—there was the absence of a clear set of regulations at the beginning of the process. The programme has tried its very best to deal with those complexities. People have done the very best that they can with what has been available at the time.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The point that I am making is that your predecessor and, indeed, the director of the rural affairs department from 2012 onwards had overall direct managerial responsibility for the programme. It has been a total failure, so why has there not been a price to pay for that failure?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

That kind of action can be taken only if it can be demonstrated clearly where the failing was and why a certain person was negligent in their duty. That is not our analysis of the situation. Neither, I think, is it the Auditor General’s analysis of the situation.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I think that people in Scotland would find it amazing that nobody in the civil service has been disciplined or sacked as a result of this. The cost to the public purse is obviously very substantial indeed, whatever the final figure is. The fact that no heads have rolled in the civil service is, frankly, unbelievable. In any other organisation—in the health service, for example—that is what would have happened. When I was the health secretary, I had the disagreeable role of having to dispose of the services of a chief executive and a board chairman because it had all gone wrong on their watch. However, it seems that, in the civil service, nobody takes the ultimate responsibility.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

We can take actions such as you have described only when the evidence supports that, and that is not my understanding of the situation. I say again that we will see what information we can provide on the costs within the operations budgets. However, if the £178 million, which is the business case approved figure, delivers the programme, I will consider the programme to have been delivered within that budget.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

As a member of the committee, I disagree with what you are saying and I think that other members do, too, judging from their reactions. The civil service has to take its share of responsibility. The people at the top are responsible for managing these projects. It sends out completely the wrong message that, in every other walk of life, people in such positions take responsibility when there is gross failure and the only organisation in Scotland that seems to be exempt from that is the senior civil service.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

I repeat that we, as senior leaders, are—absolutely—responsible for the delivery of the areas for which we are responsible. However, we can take action only if that is what the evidence tells us to do. We sit within a series of proper human resource procedures, which means that we can take those actions only if we have the evidence.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That is a Sir Humphrey answer, which is extremely unsatisfactory. Can I just—

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

It is the answer.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Maybe we need to take the matter up with the minister.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Maybe we need to take it up with the permanent secretary, because it is a civil service matter.

My final point is this: clearly, since all this happened, we have had the Brexit vote. Irrespective of how long the Brexit process takes, it seems to me that, as agriculture is a devolved responsibility, there will be the option for Scotland and this Parliament to look again at how best we can support our farming communities. We should not be spending money unnecessarily on equipment that might only have a lifetime of three, four or five years.

Has any thought been given to the implications of the Brexit decision and process in relation to how we go forward? One would imagine that there will be a fundamental policy review on how to support the farming community once that responsibility is devolved to this Parliament, which it must be after the Brexit talks are completed. However, we do not want to be spending a lot of money if we are not going to get a return over a long time.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Thank you very much for that question. We are indeed looking at those issues. The first thing to say is that it is extremely welcome that we now have the UK guarantee of at least the pillar 1 CAP payments all the way through to 2020—which will be the completion of the 2014 to 2020 period—and at least some of the pillar 2 funding. As I am sure that you are aware, some moneys have not yet been guaranteed, but we still have a total of around £4 billion-worth of payments for the CAP period to 2020.

The business case was that we should have a system that would manage and administer that £4 billion. That is still a sensible decision to have taken. We need a system to do that.

As you rightly say, there is significant uncertainty and we do not yet know how many options will play out. Whatever the situation, though, there is an important debate to be had about the right way to support the farming industry and the way in which, as a country, we would like to do that. I am sure that Mr Mountain’s committee, the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee, will very much engage in that debate, which is one that we would hope to have with the farming industry and others who have interests in the rural economy and indeed in the economy generally. There is a very important set of questions, but we have a level of certainty around the immediate period.

Alison Harris Con Central Scotland
link

I want to come back on one final point. You said that you had identified £34 million of savings—I know that the word is not quite accurate.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

No, sorry. Out of the £178 million budget, we have £34 million left to spend between now and March.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Because we have made some savings.

Alison Harris Con Central Scotland
link

That is what I was saying. You can categorically tell the committee today, 100 per cent, that the system will be CAP compliant before that budget runs out.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

That is what our current plans are telling us. I would be very foolish if I sat here and gave you an utter, unconditional guarantee, because some things may happen between now and March that mean that that budget will be under more pressure; some things may happen that mean that it will be under less pressure. Our current plans, which have been stress tested and have a firm commitment from the supplier behind them, tell us that that budget will take us all the way through to March and will deliver us a CAP-compliant system.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

We will be monitoring it very closely. We have a strong commercial management arrangement in place now. Our commercial manager is sitting down with the contractor—they are actually sitting in the same room, so they are working very closely together. They are looking, all the time, in an extremely dynamic and reactive way, at how they can increase savings or deal with any unforeseen circumstances.

That monitoring will go on and the programme board and the executive steering committee will take receipt of the information that comes out of that. If we see anything heading in the wrong direction, we will, at that point, say, “What are our options? Can we make more savings? Are there other actions that we can take to bring that back on track?” It is the standard process—it is not rocket science, but it needs to be done, and done well—of close monitoring, close commercial management of the contract and acting quickly if we see things moving off track.

Alison Harris Con Central Scotland
link

But we still have the possibility of the budget running out.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Not according to current plans. Our current plans are robust. Of course, there are always unforeseen—

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Absolutely, but I am sitting here before you saying that our stress-tested plans, in which I have confidence, will deliver that budget all the way through to CAP compliance.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

First, I should apologise. I should have done the Edward Mountain bit there and thanked you very much for coming along. I think that, like Colin Beattie, I thought that I was still on the committee. The convener should be grateful that I have not called her Paul Martin today.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I am grateful for that.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Let me ask one final question, which is about Audit Scotland. In its update in May, it recommended that the Government should

“develop and test a disaster recovery solution”.

Have you done that?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Let me just make sure. I have not got this in my head, but yes—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I thought that you would probably recognise the phrase “disaster recovery solution”. It is quite emotive.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

The situation—it is the information that we gave in our published response—is that there is a full IT recovery provision in the event of a major incident, which is specified to deliver no more than 72 hours’ loss of service and a loss of transaction data of no more than one hour for all the systems on the new futures platform.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

So there is a disaster recovery solution in place.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

There is one in place for all the systems on the new futures platform. The first failover test of that system is planned for November and the regular cycle testing will follow that.

The only caveat that I wish to put on all that is that, for the time being, the business continues to rely on a land parcel information system that is based on old infrastructure and will not support modern recovery systems. We are exposed to a level of risk, in a sense, for the interim period, but the future system is compliant with the disaster recovery processes that you would expect to have in place. Did you want to say anything, Jonathan?

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

I would simply add that the land parcel information system has a full offsite backup of the data, so we are not saying—

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

No, no. In this case, 400,000 records are on the land database.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Digital records.

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

Yes, digital records are on the land parcel information system.

It is perfectly possible to recover all that data if there is a problem with the infrastructure. However, it would not be done within the 72-hour period that is possible on the modern infrastructure.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

With my earlier question, I was looking for comfort from the panel that we could be confident looking to the future. I have heard the evidence. Although people have been frank, the response is not convincing. Alex Neil’s characterisation of the matter as a “fiasco” is probably fair.

I have a couple of questions on the back of what my colleagues have teased out. You have talked about the increase in staff—there is an increase of about 70 staff at any one given time; perhaps we will get more information on that—but it strikes me that if people are being brought into a complex environment temporarily, they are not getting a lot of time to understand what is going on. Is any training involved? I would like to hear more about those issues. What impact is bringing in people from other departments having on other parts of the business? If contractors have been brought in, what induction process has been undertaken?

Stress testing was mentioned. What about the stress that the staff on the ground are experiencing? We are hearing a lot about the staff in the area office. I really would not like to be in their shoes. It sounds as though they are working around the clock. There is also a lot of public interest in the issue. What is it like for the staff? Are people going off sick? Is support in place to ensure that their physical and mental health is not affected?

To return to my original point about confidence, there have been a lot of questions today about the system. On the one hand, we are hearing that there are checks and balances and risk controls in place and we have been talking about disaster recovery, management and so on; on the other hand, when you were asked to pinpoint failings, what has gone wrong and where the fault lines are, we hear that there is not really any evidence on that, so it has not been possible to pinpoint human error. Is this fiasco—this disaster—that we are talking about wholly down to IT error? Is there an element of human error? Can we get some honesty around that? It is difficult for us to leave here feeling confident if we are still not getting clear answers about why things have gone wrong and why they continue to go wrong.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

I will ask Jonathan Pryce to talk about the staff welfare issues, which are extremely important and very much on our minds and I will take your first question.

I am fairly new to a programme that has a long history. It is clear that there is no single point at which you could say, “If we had only done this differently. If that person had only done that differently.” It is a complex and cumulative set of problems that have compounded themselves but that, as the Auditor General said, dates right back to the beginning. The nature of the cumulative failures is that you find yourself locked into a position where you seem to have very few options: farmers must get their money; we must make those payments. It is very hard for people in those circumstances.

When people are trying to take decisions, they are faced with a really challenging situation: farmers must have the money. We try to do everything that we can in the situation, but by then the die is already cast and we are locked into a restricted set of solutions.

The really important thing about the work that Mike Neilson is leading on the new digital assurance processes and why they should mean that this should not happen again is that they enable you to step back and force you to look again at questions such as, “Is this our only option?” and “Do we understand the costs and implications of the complexity that we’ve chosen as a policy basis?” If we had been able to say at the time, “Do you know what? This set of choices you’re making makes the whole system pretty undeliverable”, would we then have made a different decision? I think that those are the questions. We do not know, but the process that we are putting in place will enable us to have different conversations in future.

This is a complex and cumulative series of failures, but we need to enable people to step back from that and allow an independent view to come in. A lot of it is about correcting optimism bias, which I think runs very deep.

11:00

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

With respect, you have addressed the question with reference to very generic terms such as systems, options, stepping back and so on. The difficulty for someone in my position who does not really understand the sector is that you have not really been able to pinpoint and get to the heart of what went wrong. I am not convinced that lessons can be learned if we continue to speak in broad-brush terms about the system.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

Lots and lots of lessons have already been learned and are feeding into the way we think about the—

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Do you have an example of one of those lessons?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

For example—and this brings us back to an earlier exchange—we have learned that we must be realistic and build in contingency. It sounds simple, but we must be utterly realistic and absolutely disciplined about putting contingency into our plans to ensure that we do not fall prey to optimism bias and say, “We hope to make payments in month X,” when that is not underpinned by a plan that has been sufficiently challenged and stress tested, and has sufficient contingency to give us certainty.

The hard-learned lesson is that when people find themselves in the same situation in future and are tempted to say, “Well, if this, this, this, this and this worked, we could just do it”, they should step back and say, “No, we cannot make that commitment because we cannot have sufficient certainty around delivering it.” That is one of the most important lessons that we can learn to make sure that we are always competent.

Jonathan Pryce will talk about the staff questions, which are extremely important.

Jonathan Pryce Scottish Government
link

Indeed. Understandably, because this is a professional discipline for the agricultural staff in the area offices, we have a training and induction programme for them. In practice, when we reinforced area office staff, we did so by bringing people back, sometimes from retirement, or by redeploying them from other parts of the Scottish Government that they might have moved into, as a result of which they were no longer involved in agriculture. We did quite a lot of that in the course of the year. As I have said, there is quite a lot of turnover in the area office staff, simply because they move into and out of agriculture and the wider industry, but they go through a good induction programme.

The pressure on staff in the area offices has been high, as indeed has the pressure in the centre. However, from the statistics that we get through our human resources management information, we cannot discern any increased levels of sickness absence or absence levels related specifically to stress. Because of my concern for staff welfare, I have looked closely at the management information, but I have seen nothing in it that is significantly out of line with other parts of the Scottish Government. There are always differences in different areas, but when we look at it across the piece, nothing is flashing red in the management information. That being said, from my experience and contact with individuals, I know how hard they have been working, the long hours that they have been working and the stress that they are facing.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I can see that Ms Ditchburn wants to add something. Can you make it quite brief, please?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

I am sorry—I will try.

Monica Lennon is absolutely right to focus on the area offices, because those people are in the front line and are having to have conversations with farmers, who, rightly, are concerned about when the payments might be made. When I ask people in the area offices the same question, one of the things that they say has made the situation more manageable for them is the fact that their work has peaks and troughs throughout the year. There are particularly intense periods—for example, when certain processes are being gone through or inspections are taking place—and then there are periods of lower intensity. I think that that has helped them to maintain equilibrium throughout.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

That does not check out with what the Audit Scotland report of May 2016 says.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Do you want to tell the panel what the report says?

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

On page 36, it says:

“Staff have been working hard and there is a risk of burn-out”.

It goes on to say that staff

“have been working at a very high pace for the past 18 months”.

That suggests a degree of consistency in the way that they have been working; it does not suggest that they have been working in peaks and troughs, as has been alluded to.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

As Jonathan Pryce said, there are no peaks and troughs in some of the headquarters and IT-related work. Some of that central work has been intense the whole way through. There is a high risk of burn-out in that.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

What is being done to ameliorate that risk?

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Have you done a staff survey?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

A staff survey is done every year. One is about to be carried out, so we will have an interesting new data point. The annual staff survey will be carried out between 3 October and 31 October this year.

In addition, the contractor has done a survey of its own staff, which shows that morale has increased significantly during the past few months.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Does anyone want to probe any further on the staff issue?

Gail, did you have a final question?

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

It is just a quick one. Allan Bowie, the president of the NFUS, has been quoted as saying:

“Audit Scotland has questioned whether the CAP futures programme will ever be fit for purpose”.

Do you think that what we have heard today will give the industry confidence going forward?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

I think that I have already answered that question directly. Will the industry have confidence?

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

We—the teams, the cabinet secretary and officials—stay in close contact with the NFUS in an effort to understand the views of its members. It is also important that we hear from farmers who are outside the mechanism of the NFUS. The NFUS is an important stakeholder, but it is good to hear from a range of diverse voices.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

The NFUS does not represent the whole of the agricultural community.

Liz Ditchburn Scottish Government
link

I am keen to deepen engagement with the industry. I recognise that the NFUS is a critical part of the industry, but I would like us to be able to engage with more people directly and not through intermediaries.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 74
  3. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 210

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.