Item 2 is evidence on an Auditor General for Scotland report. I welcome to the meeting from Audit Scotland Fraser McKinlay, director of performance audit and best value; Antony Clark, assistant director; Gemma Diamond, senior manager; and Gill Miller, audit manager. I invite Fraser McKinlay to make an opening statement before I open up the meeting to questions from members.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Supporting Scotland’s economic growth: The role of the Scottish Government and its economic development agencies”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland 22
- Jenny Marra Lab 15
- Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland 9
- Colin Beattie SNP 9
- Alex Neil SNP 4
- Antony Clark Audit Scotland 3
- Monica Lennon Lab 3
- Alison Harris Con 3
- Gill Miller Audit Scotland 3
- Gail Ross SNP 2
- Liam Kerr Con 1
The record
74 contributionsThank you and good morning. I will make a brief opening statement and then, as ever, we will be very happy to try to answer your questions as best we can.
I am delighted to present to the committee the Auditor General’s report “Supporting Scotland’s economic growth”. The report reviews the arrangements that are in place to support Scotland’s economic growth; it focuses in particular on the roles of Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise, which together have a specific remit to support economic growth across the whole of Scotland. The report provides an overview of the landscape in which the enterprise bodies operate and assesses how they support development and delivery of the Scottish Government’s economic strategy.
I will summarise the findings under two main headings: first, the wider arrangements and framework for supporting economic growth and then, more specifically, the role of the enterprise bodies. Before I do that, it may be worth reflecting on the fact that a lot has happened since we published the report in July. Obviously, we knew about the Brexit result at the time of publication, but Brexit is more to the fore now than it was when we did the audit work. Also, we have a new programme for government. Those points make the report’s recommendations even more important, if anything, than they were when we did the report.
The starting point for the audit was to look at the Government’s economic strategy, because that is what determines the enterprise bodies’ plans and activities. As members would expect, the strategy is a high-level document that sets out the Government’s approach to achieving its overall purpose of sustainable economic growth. However, the Government does not set out in its strategy or elsewhere how its various economic policies and initiatives will be implemented. It is important that the Government be clear on how it will achieve its ambition of sustainable economic growth. In that sense, the “how” is as important as the “what”.
We absolutely recognise, though, that supporting economic growth is complex; it is not straightforward for many reasons. First, a number of factors influence the economy, many of which are outside the control of the public sector—the worldwide downturn in oil and gas, which has, as members will know better than I do, affected many communities across Scotland, is one such example.
We also found that a high number of organisations and partnerships are involved in planning and delivering economic growth activities, which can be confusing for businesses and other customers that are trying to access support. We recommend that the Scottish Government and its partners clarify the roles and responsibilities of all the bodies that are involved, and that they raise awareness of the activities and support that are available.
As I said at the outset, the context for supporting economic growth is continually changing. Public sector economic strategies and interventions have to respond to, and be appropriate for, the economic climate, whether during periods of recession, growth or uncertainty. New financial powers for the Parliament and the United Kingdom’s exit from the European Union will undoubtedly influence how the Government takes forward economic growth in the future.
Taking all that into account, we recommend in the report that the Scottish Government strengthen its approach to developing, delivering and monitoring the strategy. That includes developing clear timescales and actions and setting out specific responsibilities for public sector bodies. Importantly, we recommend, too, that the Government review progress against those to ensure that the actions are effective and are making a difference, and that the strategy remains relevant and fit for purpose.
Finally, we found on the whole that Scottish Enterprise and HIE are performing well. Their business plans and activities are based on a wide range of evidence and each of the bodies has a good understanding of how to respond to opportunities and challenges in its respective area. We found good examples of the enterprise bodies working well with partners to achieve a real difference, and we found that their customers are largely satisfied with the support that they receive.
As ever, we identified some areas for improvement. Both bodies offer similar support that is tailored to the needs of their customers’ environment, but there are lots of different arrangements for delivering the support, and the rationale for those different arrangements is not always clear. We found that there is scope for them to deliver some activities more efficiently—for example, their support to growth sectors.
Although we found that the enterprise bodies are performing well against their individual performance measures, it is much more difficult to measure their contribution to the national outcomes. It is important that the Government understands better the contribution that the enterprise bodies are making individually and collectively to the economic strategy, and to the economic growth targets more widely.
Finally, the committee will know that the Scottish Government’s skills and enterprise review is under way. We understand that the review will now be done in two phases. We will take a close interest in its outcome; we have said in our report that we hope that it offers the opportunity to take forward some of our recommendations.
As I said at the outset, I am very happy to take questions and to help the committee this morning.
Thank you very much, Mr McKinlay. Liam Kerr has the first question.
link
I have just a couple of questions at this stage. I will come back in later, if there is time.
The report mentions throughout that
“The full range of public sector support for businesses is not known which creates a risk of duplication and inefficiency.”
Are you able to give us more detail on that and on what, on a practical level, can be done or is being done to address it?
I represent North East Scotland, which is covered by Scottish Enterprise. You talked about support being tailored to the needs of the environment—the north-east has some very big cities, but it also has some areas that are more akin to the Highlands. Can you comment on how Scottish Enterprise is addressing that issue, if it is, and will it be able to do so in the future or is there a better way to do things?
Thank you. I will take the first question first, and then ask the team to come in. On the point in our report about the full range of support, we recognise in the report that there is a lot of very good activity across both bodies and in other places. We do not touch so much on local government in the report, but clearly it is also an important part of the story, particularly in respect of the business gateway.
Our observation is that we could not find anywhere that the totality of the support that is on offer to business is captured, so we do not really know what collective support there is. Some work was undertaken a while back, but it did not progress. We think that it would be helpful for the Government and the enterprise bodies, in particular, working with other partners, to do a mapping exercise in order to understand what is being made available, and so that we can assure ourselves that, where similar services are being delivered in different ways, that is happening for a good reason and not just for historical reasons. When we asked people questions on that, the response was sometimes, “It’s always been done that way.” For us, that is always a good indication that we should check whether the approach still makes sense.
We noted that, because there are so many different levels of support on offer, an attempt has been made to bring all the forms of support together on the Scottish Government’s new website, mygov.scot, but given that there are more than 600 funding streams, it is extremely difficult for a business to navigate its way through that. We should make sure that the Government keeps the business in mind and thinks about what support that business might want. A business will not necessarily know what the structure is or whom to turn to. It should be able to make its way through the process and to find out about the totality of what is on offer, rather than having to know whom to turn to.
We make it clear in the report that economic development activity operates at national, regional and local levels, and we highlight the challenges and the opportunities of the introduction of, for example, city deals in places like Aberdeen. The roles of the parties in city-deal activity need to worked through. We are aware that such issues are being considered by the Government in its review.
I will turn briefly to Mr Kerr’s second question about the north-east and Scottish Enterprise. We did not set out to comment on the structure of the enterprise landscape—which, for us, includes the geographical split—nor is it our place to do that, although we highlight the fact that there are some areas where there is overlap between Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise.
Our sense is that in the north-east Scottish Enterprise has—as it has everywhere—a pretty well established mechanism for trying to understand what the big issues are, what the high-growth sectors are and where the big opportunities lie, and it supports that. However, there is, as we say in the report, no doubt that the roles of Scottish Enterprise and HIE are different; they are similar in many ways, but HIE also has a role in community development. I guess that that is something to reflect on in relation to the more rural parts of the north-east and, for that matter, some of the more rural parts of lowland Scotland, which SE looks after, too.
There is a lot in the report to be positive about, and I welcome that, but I am very mindful of the fact that a huge amount of public money—£2.2 billion—is being delivered to the five strategic partners. I am quite surprised by the fact that we do not have an agreed definition of economic development—albeit that we have the high-level goal of delivering sustainable economic growth. To what extent does the fact that there is no agreed definition of economic development activity present a problem? It comes across in the report that it is extremely difficult to get a picture of the full landscape of support and of exactly where public money is going. What do you think about that lack of clarity?
You will appreciate that sometimes, as auditors, we seek clarity and simplicity. We genuinely understand that the landscape is not simple or straightforward, and I do not think that we are recommending that we should spend for ever coming up with a definition of economic development. However, it is important that we have a better and agreed understanding of how much money is spent on such activity. We think that there is a bit of a gap between the overall strategy, which is sound, and the enterprise agencies having a clear idea of what they are doing. We need to think about how we make the connections between those two things.
If we are spending £2.2 billion on the five agencies that the Government has said are key to economic growth, we can do more to understand better how that contributes to the new economic strategy and “the four Is” that we talk about in the report. Therefore, a definition of economic development is important only as a means to an end. I would not want to engage in a theoretical exercise to define economic development. The purpose is to understand how the money is being spent in order that we can ensure that we are making most progress and getting best value for that £2.2 billion.
09:15
I, too, think that the report is very good, but something sprung to mind. There seems to be a lot of emphasis on where the five agencies and the £2.2 billion are involved in the city deals. Is it a matter of raising awareness of the fact that those five agencies are available to the places that will not be part of city deals? I am conscious that they are sort of left by the wayside.
On whether it is about raising awareness, people are involved in the city deals, region deals and growth deals. Many different versions are growing up; in fact, I note that there is some stuff in the papers today about the Ayrshire deal and the Diageo plant in Kilmarnock. A huge amount is happening. What is important is maybe not so much awareness, but understanding the role of the five bodies in the new world of city deals, city region deals and such things, because they are very new, as the committee knows.
The funding in city deals is complex. Glasgow has the most well-advanced deal, but lots of other variations are coming through, as I mentioned—for example in Ayrshire, Stirling and Tayside. There is a job to be done in figuring out what role—if any—the strategic forum partners have in the city deal framework. That needs to be done quite quickly, because the city deal experience, or movement—if that is not too grand a word—is gathering momentum and pace, and it is really important that we understand how the deals contribute to the overall strategy and the role of the strategic forum partners.
That is okay, but I really meant raising awareness in areas that are not involved with the city deals. Basically, I am looking to get a little more value for those areas. Where would that value be?
I am happy to share with the committee an interesting wee bit of work on city deals that we did a while ago. It turns out that not many council areas are not involved in some kind of city deal—although obviously they are at very different stages of development. However, there is absolutely a question, which Alison Harris has raised, about ensuring that no parts of the country are left behind. That is part of ensuring that—in relation to Scottish Enterprise and HIE, which have a specific job—parts of the country that are not in regional growth deals, or whatever we want to call them, understand why. Is it just because they have not got involved, or is there a good reason for that? It is about ensuring that good support is in place.
I endorse that point. It is important to ensure that places are not left behind.
Thank you.
link
The first comment that I want to make about the report is one that I have made before about reports. There is a lot of repetition in it. There must be a way to trim reports back by not having them continually repeat certain facts.
Have the Scottish Government and the enterprise boards accepted your recommendations in the report?
That is a question that the committee might want to ask, Mr Beattie. As you know, we go through a process of factually clearing reports to ensure that the facts in them are clear. We do not necessarily expect the Government to write to us formally to say whether it accepts the report, but we keep an eye on whether recommendations are being implemented.
I know that you asked the chief executive of the national health service the same question in an earlier evidence session. From our perspective, it is helpful to get that on the record.
As ever, it is rarely a case of the Government saying yes or no to all the recommendations. There is a lot in the report, and it is entirely legitimate to have a bit of a discussion about the recommendations. That said, we have not received any allergic reactions to them. Nobody has thrown up their hands in horror and said, “No, we can’t possibly.” Therefore, we are operating on the basis that we would expect the recommendations to be implemented.
link
Convener, maybe we could write to the Government and to the enterprise boards and ask them whether they have accepted the recommendations that have been made.
Yes.
link
I am looking at paragraph 41 of the report. Fraser McKinlay mentioned Brexit and the EU. The paragraph clearly indicates that EU funding is very important to us. Will you be following up on that? I do not mean Brexit in its totality, because that is rather a big picture, but on specific issues such as the ones that you have highlighted in your report. Will you keep those issues on your radar and follow them through?
Yes, very much so, Mr Beattie. It is a big focus of work at the moment. I will not bore you with the detail, but Audit Scotland has a team in place that reports to the new financial powers and constitutional change board. We already had a board for the new financial powers for Parliament, because that is core business for us, but with the decision on the EU, we have added constitutional change to its remit. As you say, our focus will be primarily on the impact on the money—what is coming in from the EU, what happens to it and, importantly, what the impact will be on public bodies and services. Therefore, the issues will very much be front and centre for our work during the next wee while.
link
Good. I am looking at paragraph 79 of the report, which touches on the question of why things are done the way that they are and why forms of support are done jointly, on behalf of the other body or separately. It seems to me a bit odd that you do not know why. Other than the fact that it has always been that way, were there any other indications?
There is a bit of a mix. Some matters are clearer. In relation to some of the newer services—I refer you to some of the preceding paragraphs, particularly 77 and 78—there has been a clear decision for one agency rather than the other to take the lead. There are good reasons and sound rationale for that. However, in other cases, it really is a matter of things being how they have always been done. The organisations come in various guises, have been around for quite a long time and have developed their own ways of working. We are saying that the on-going review gives us a great opportunity to take stock of all that, to make sense of the situation, and to at least ensure that how it is currently done makes sense.
Our sense is that there probably is an opportunity to do things more efficiently and to join up in some places. Although there are differences in the areas and the contexts in which the bodies operate, there are also quite a lot of similarities. We hope that an outcome of the review might be how we can join up some of those matters more effectively.
link
There must be efficiencies to be achieved that the bodies should be achieving.
Yes, you would hope so.
link
Overall, the report is very positive. You comment:
“Scottish Enterprise and HIE have performed well against their agreed performance measures”.
However, I was interested in paragraph 96, which says:
“Although performance targets in each of the last five years have mostly been exceeded, the Scottish Government has not challenged the enterprise bodies to increase their annual targets.”
Does that mean that targets are too easily achievable?
This is probably an area where auditors could be accused of being a bit mean and never being pleased because if the Government had not been meeting its targets, I am sure that we would have had something to say about that, too.
All we are saying is that, in a world in which the Government has for quite a long time been exceeding targets, it is reasonable to ask whether it is sure that the targets are challenging enough. That is the point that we are trying to make in paragraph 96. It is good practice to review your objectives and targets anyway, but if you consistently exceed them—in some cases by some margin—it is reasonable to ask that question, just to check that they are stretching and challenging enough, given the scale of the economic challenge that we have ahead of us.
link
In various places in the report you have commented on the difficulties in measuring economic activity and the achievements of the investment that has been made. In paragraph 113 you say that Scottish Enterprise has
“a model to measure the overall impact of its activity”.
Maybe you could fill us in on that one.
Sure. I will kick off, then I will ask the team to come in. We are trying to make the point that, individually, the bodies have quite good systems in place to do exactly that. The connection between what they are doing and the delivery of the economic strategy and the outcomes that are in the national performance framework are the bits of the system that need to be looked at.
Absolutely. We looked at the enterprise agencies, which do a lot of evaluation work to determine what is and is not working and how they can change what they do. In particular, Scottish Enterprise has developed a model for its impact. However, there is no way to assess the agencies’ collective performance, so there is no way of looking at common performance measures so that the Scottish Government can see what is being achieved by the two enterprise agencies. Again, there is a gap in the sense that we do not know how the performance of the enterprise agencies contributes to the national performance framework. We recommend that steps be put in place so that we can see more clearly how the enterprise agencies’ activities contribute towards the outcomes of the national performance framework.
link
That makes it a lot clearer. We know what the activities of the individual agencies are and what they are contributing—it is not as if we have a blank space there.
No.
link
It is just that we do not know how the activities feed into the national performance framework.
That is it exactly.
Gail, do you want to come in?
I asked you a question at another committee about the renewables investment fund.
Yes, and we are gathering information on the renewables investment fund for you. We will provide information to you on what money was and was not spent on that.
Thank you.
I have a further question on Scottish Enterprise, with regard to paragraph 87 of the report. You have not made any comment on Scottish Enterprise’s performance, so perhaps it is acceptable. However, you referred in paragraph 87 to investment risks and stated that
“a return on investment has been made on 20 per cent of completed investments”.
Do you have a view on whether that represents a good performance and good value for the public purse? You also stated that write-offs were in the region of £39 million, which looks like a lot but perhaps you can put that in some context for us.
Again, I will kick off, then ask the team to come in with some detail. The starting point is to remind ourselves that the point of having state enterprise agencies is for them to get involved in risky things, otherwise we would not have them. We therefore always expect there to be a greater number of things that do not work in that area because the enterprise agencies’ job is to intervene when the market will not. In that sense, it is quite difficult to assess whether the agencies’ performance is good, bad or indifferent, because they operate in a risky environment. The team might have some detail to add.
We wanted to ensure that the agencies had processes in place to enable them to assess the levels of risk that they were entering into and that the governance arrangements had the right approvals in place so that they knew that they were entering into a riskier investment, had discussed the risks and opportunities, had board-level approval and were keeping an eye on the investment and any additional support that was needed to make the best of it. We saw that the enterprise agencies do have good governance and risk management processes in place that allow them to take the risky decisions that they sometimes need to take, in a well-managed environment.
Thank you.
I want to draw out the difference between operational performance and impact, because I think that the report gets mixed up about the difference between the two and uses phraseology interchangeably, which is not appropriate. For example, the report states that the enterprise agencies have assisted 11,200 businesses. If I assist a new-start business to expand in an area—let us say that it is a printing works—and one of the effects of that is simply to make people redundant in another local business that has been running for, say, 30-odd years, the net impact of my intervention will be a lot less than the impact of the help that I gave to the new-start business.
It seems to me that there is no indication in the report about the displacement impact of interventions—for example, what the dead weight was and whether that would have happened anyway without the intervention of the enterprise agency. If it would have, why are we spending public money on it?
What was the added value of, say, account-managed companies? How much more did they grow than they would have done without the support that they received? We cannot measure value for money until we know the net added value of the intervention. That is not performance per se; performance is about throughput—the number of businesses assisted, the number of businesses account managed, the number of inward investment projects and the estimated value of those projects, and the number of jobs created. Some of those are about performance and impact. With jobs, for example, we would be looking at net jobs, not gross jobs. I do not think that that really comes out here. At the end of the day, we are about measuring value for money, which is based not just on the operational performance—it has to be on the net impact.
At a higher level, we are spending the guts of £400 million on enterprise support and related activity—
Is this a question, Mr Neil?
09:30
Yes, it is.
Let us suppose that we considered spending £100 million of that £400 million on transport infrastructure investment instead of enterprise support. Would we get a far bigger bang for the buck? I think that what you are saying is that no one is asking that question, let alone giving us an answer, before budgets and targets are being set.
I have two issues. One is the difference between operational performance and impact—it is impact that really matters—and the second is the opportunity cost of spending the money in other ways that would boost economic growth more than what is happening.
Particularly on your second point, it might have been better if we had said what you have just said, because that is our point. When we talk about understanding how much is spent, reviewing the impact and being clearer about milestones and measures, it is exactly that kind of discussion. How do we know that spending nearly £400 million in this way, on these things, in pursuit of the economic strategy and the outcome is good value, and indeed better value, than spending it in a different way? Your point gets right to the heart of the difference between measuring inputs and outputs and measuring outcomes. I know that that is very jargony—it is easy for us to glaze over—but it is really important. The input and output measures are helpful and tell us so much, but so what? What difference does it make? We say in the report that that aspect could be better.
One of our recommendations—again, we could probably have worded this more clearly—is that it should be made clear whether the support to individual businesses or involvement in task forces continues to add value. That is the point that we are trying to make. How do we know that the support that has been provided, either to a sector or to an individual business, is adding value?
Your question about what would have happened if we had not done this is a difficult one to answer. It is a fair question but it is quite tricky to construct an evaluation framework that would allow us to answer it meaningfully. There is always an element of that. Of course support must be based on good evidence, and of course there has to be sound process but, at some point, a judgment has to be made that this business—as opposed to another business—is worth backing.
The enterprise agencies do a mixture of both. They have their performance measures, which are sometimes the output measures, but they also do a lot of evaluation work. They look at specific interventions and, in the evaluation at a local level, will specifically consider additionality, displacement and all those other factors. Scottish Enterprise in particular publishes all the evaluation work that it does on a separate website, so you can go in and see what work it has done.
As Fraser McKinlay mentioned, it is about the wider, whole-system impact. The enterprise agency can do that evaluation work, but it is more important for all the agencies that are involved to come together to look at the wider impact—
Can I just pick you up on that point? Before I became an MSP, I was involved in designing evaluations systems for Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise, based on Treasury guidance and so on. The purpose of the evaluation methodology was to identify the contribution of Scottish Enterprise or Highlands and Islands Enterprise; it was not to identify everybody’s contribution.
Why can we therefore not gross up or use their work as an indicator? To be fair, I think that it is a robust indicator of what they believe to be the net added value of their intervention as agencies. Okay—it would not be a perfect system, but if you were to add up the estimated net added value, surely you would begin to get a picture of the combined estimated added value of the agencies.
Absolutely. The agencies are not starting with a blank sheet of paper; a lot of good work is going on, and it is simply a case of joining things up so that that can be seen. The environment is very complex; indeed, we found a lot of very complicated partnership-working arrangements on the ground, which, although they worked, highlighted the need for consideration of how things might be added together. Certainly there is the basis for a system that we think can be built on to help us put in place a better measurement of impact.
Part of the challenge, Mr Neil, is that not all agencies have as well-developed models or ways of doing things as Scottish Enterprise or HIE. After all, that, in a sense, is their core job.
One of the points that we are making brings us back to definitional issues with regard to economic development. The Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council obviously does lots of things with regard to with universities and colleges. However, although that makes a contribution to economic development, it does not evaluate in those terms and in a way that would allow us to add such things up.
So might there be a case, then, for having within Government a central evaluation unit that would carry out all the evaluation, including that of Scottish Enterprise? Would that not get consistency and robustness into the methodology right across the board?
Our recommendation is that Government needs to think about how it does exactly that.
Why has Scottish Enterprise to date not been measuring its contribution against the national performance framework?
I will again ask the team to come in here, but I would not say that Scottish Enterprise does not do that work at all. It is attempting to connect what it is doing with the outcomes framework, but our challenge is that what it does is perhaps not—what is the word?—specific, accurate or meaningful enough, particularly with regard to the relationship between the new economic strategy, which was published last year, and the outcomes in the national performance framework. I guess that what we are saying is that there needs to be more rigour and more of a specific attempt to do that sort of work. Is that fair, team?
The individual enterprise agencies try to map their outcomes against the national performance framework, but that very much happens from the bottom up. We want to be able to look at particular outcomes and indicators in the national performance framework and see which public bodies are making a contribution in that respect and the kind of contribution that is being made. That would mean that, if an indicator moved, we would know which public bodies had had the most impact in making that happen, and that is what we are not seeing at the moment. Public bodies align themselves with the national performance framework and its outcomes, but only on an individual basis, and we want a more coherent picture of how the bodies join together in that respect.
Colin Beattie asked about performance targets. The report says that Scottish Enterprise exceeded those targets, but who sets them?
The enterprise agencies set their priorities and performance targets in their business plan each year, which is all agreed with the Scottish Government. The Government signs off that business plan at the end of the year to show that it agrees with the priorities and performance measures that have been set.
So the only external audit of their performance is that which is carried out by Audit Scotland and this Parliament. Is there any other external scrutiny of their performance?
As we have described in certain parts of the report, there are elements of external input to individual bits of work and how they are done. That is important. However, one of the reasons why we were very keen to do this piece of work is that it has been a while since we looked at the totality of the role of the enterprise bodies and their contribution to the Government’s stated objectives and outcomes. Our job is to bring this to Parliament to help you do your job and ask these kinds of questions of the whole system, if you like. It is not that there is no independent challenge or external input—there is—but what we are trying to do today is to give you a whole-system look.
A couple of weeks ago, I visited the Dundee hub of the developing the young workforce programme, which is tasked with implementing the recommendations of the Wood commission, and the people there told me that they were undertaking a mapping exercise of all the available economic support. Then I read paragraph 36 on page 18 of your report, which says:
“Scottish Enterprise, HIE and councils attempted to identify the public sector support that was available for businesses to pinpoint any duplication or gaps. They did not complete this exercise due to the complexity of all the bodies and initiatives involved.”
How can the developing the young workforce team of five in Dundee do a mapping exercise of public economic support when Scottish Enterprise cannot complete the task because it is too complex?
That is a good question. First, we would be delighted to speak to our developing the young workforce colleagues to see whether there is anything that we have pulled together in the audit that would help with that piece of work. It would be a helpful and important piece of work, especially given the intended audience. In a sense, it is a mirror image of the work that was attempted.
Given that the whole point of that exercise was to try to understand the complexity, it seems slightly odd to say, “Well, it was all too complex, therefore we did not finish it.” That is why we have recommended that there is a piece of work to be done in that respect.
There certainly is. The developing the young workforce agenda is not mentioned in your report, perhaps because it is new. However, I do not think—correct me if I am wrong—that business gateway is mentioned in the report either. I presume that that is because it has been devolved to local authorities, but it is part of the overall landscape with which it sounds as if Scottish Enterprise is still struggling to come to terms.
I have another question on account management. It says somewhere in your report that some account-managed businesses said that they were not sure why they were even account managed any more. Can you give us a bit more detail on that?
Again, the team will help me with the detail. Account management is interesting, and we refer in the report to the need to better figure out when Scottish Enterprise exits an account management relationship. There are pretty good procedures, processes and evidence in place to identify in the first place the potential high-growth businesses that would require to be account managed, but there is a question around the point at which such organisations are able to stand on their own two feet and do not need to be account managed any more.
It was interesting to us that some businesses—although by no means all—said that they were not sure why they still received account management. It was not clear to us whether there was a good reason for that or whether it was because we were just keeping going. There may be some industries in some parts of the world that are so critical that one might want to continue with account management, even if a business appears to be big or well-established. In other areas, one might have to think about whether the time, effort and money could be better used somewhere else. The key point in our report is the need to be clearer around how and when Scottish Enterprise exits the account management relationship.
It strikes me that, if a business is wondering why it is still account managed, that is a problem in terms of reviewing public spending.
Going back to the point about performance and scrutiny, you allude to the situation in Northern Ireland, which you note has quite a good way of assessing its agencies and the economic impact. Can you draw some comparisons?
Gill Miller may want to say a wee bit about Northern Ireland.
As part of our exercise of looking at the Scottish Government’s arrangements, we were looking at what other organisations did, and we came across the Northern Ireland example, which we thought was best practice. Northern Ireland clearly sets out on its website how the strategy has been developed, what the evidence base is, what the stakeholder feedback is and how that has contributed to the development of the economic strategy. The strategy consisted of high-level documents, similar to the Scottish Government’s work. However, underpinning that economic strategy in Northern Ireland was a detailed action plan that set out clearly the roles and responsibilities of all the public bodies.
As we have said, all public bodies have some role in contributing to economic growth, but Northern Ireland sets out clearly who is responsible for what, when the action will take place and how it will be measured. A year down the line, the action plan will be reviewed to see whether individual bodies have done what they were meant to do, look at the impact that the strategy has had, and consider what that will mean for the economic strategy as a whole and whether it needs to evolve. We thought that that was good practice—it was a good example of how to measure how well the economic strategy is being implemented.
Is it one of your recommendations that we adopt a similar robust approach here in Scotland?
We do not specifically recommend that the Scottish Government adopts that approach, but we think that it should consider taking on board those elements of good practice.
I have one last question. Case study 2 in the supplement 3 document is the Dundee central waterfront project. The document states:
“The EIA estimated that for every £1 invested by Scottish Enterprise, £16 would be generated for the Scottish economy.”
Can you tell me how that is calculated?
Before Scottish Enterprise or Highlands and Islands Enterprise make any investment, they carry out an economic impact assessment to look at areas that we mentioned earlier such as additionality, dead weight and the added value that they believe will accrue if they make that investment. That is normally undertaken either by Scottish Enterprise’s in-house economic team or by external consultants.
We reviewed those economic assessments to see what the impact would be. We did not audit them, because we are not economists. We were not in a position to be able to say whether the assessment was correct or incorrect. We were simply checking to ensure that the agencies had undertaken that exercise prior to making the investment.
In case study 2, you state that Dundee’s productivity will rise
“to Scottish levels by 2020”.
How is that worked out? I hope that it is absolutely true.
I cannot give you a specific answer to that question, but it is one of the criteria that are assessed when Scottish Enterprise is developing its investment decisions. We can probably provide you with further written information on that following the meeting, if you would find it helpful.
That would be helpful. As there are no further questions on the report, we will move on. I thank the witnesses very much indeed—your evidence has been very useful.
09:46 Meeting suspended.
09:50 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 29 Sep 2016 →- 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 74
- 09:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 210
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.