Item 3 on the agenda is consideration of the Auditor General for Scotland’s report “Changing models of health and social care”. The Auditor General is staying with us for this item. I also welcome from Audit Scotland Carol Calder, Jillian Matthew and Antony Clark, who is an assistant director. As before, I invite the Auditor General for Scotland to make an opening statement before I open up the session to questions from members.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Changing models of health and social care”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Caroline Gardner 23
- Jenny Marra Lab 12
- Colin Beattie SNP 7
- Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland 7
- Liam Kerr Con 4
- Alex Neil SNP 4
- Monica Lennon Lab 3
- Antony Clark Audit Scotland 2
The record
62 contributionsThe report assesses how national health service boards, councils and partnerships are transforming the services that they deliver to meet the changing needs of the population. It also considers some of the challenges to delivering the Scottish Government’s 2020 vision of enabling everyone to live longer, healthier lives at home or in a homely setting by 2020 and the actions that are required to address those challenges. In the report, we have put a strong focus on supporting learning and improvement by providing examples of the kinds of services that are being developed and the kinds of things that need to be done to make that transformation and increase the pace of change.
Obviously, it is vital that people can receive effective care when they need it, at home or in a homely setting if possible. It is also important that people have a say in the care that they receive. The Government’s 2020 vision aims to do that, but the shift to new models of care is not happening fast enough to meet the growing need, and the new models of care that are in place are generally small scale and are not widespread.
The committee will know that health and social care services are facing increasing pressures from an ageing population and a tightening financial position. We have reported on that previously. In this report, we provide more detail on some of those pressures, including the growing pressures in general practice and the increasing number of emergency admissions to hospital, particularly for people aged 85 and over. Those pressures on health and social care services are likely to continue to increase in the next 15 years and more. For example, our analysis suggests that, if the population increases as predicted and services continue to be delivered in the same way, the impact across the system will be significant. Compared with 2013, there could by 2030 be an extra 1.9 million GP appointments and 1.5 million practice nurse appointments; an extra 20,000 home care clients and 12,000 more long-stay care home residents; and 87,000 more emergency admissions to hospital, with an additional 1.1 million bed days.
It is clear that our existing services cannot continue as they are and that health and social care services will need to be delivered differently to cope with the increasing pressures. I want to make it clear that new approaches to health and care are being developed in parts of Scotland. We have summarised those in exhibit 6, which is on pages 20 and 21 of the report, and we have given more detail on particular examples in a supplement to the report, which members should have.
Those emerging models are generally designed to prevent admissions to hospital or to get people home from hospital more quickly. For example, NHS Tayside is providing enhanced community care to elderly people who are at risk of admission to hospital and GP practices in Govan are trying out new approaches to patient care in one of the most deprived areas of Scotland. Several partnership areas are making good use of data to understand the needs of their local population and how services are currently being used. Good examples include Perth and Kinross, West Dunbartonshire and East Lothian. Those partnerships are using the information to look at how services can be provided more effectively and closer to people’s homes. At the same time, ISD Scotland is developing a database of linked health and social care data, and ISD analysts are working in each partnership area to provide expertise and advice.
However, more needs to be done to make the transformational change that is required. NHS boards and councils will need to work with the new integration authorities to develop and adopt innovative ways of working that are different from traditional services. That will involve making difficult decisions about changing, reducing or cutting some services in order to invest in others. It will also require a significant shift in how all of us across Scotland access, use and receive our services.
The Government needs to provide stronger leadership in making that change by developing a clear framework to guide local development and by consolidating evidence of what works. The Government could also do more to help to remove some of the barriers facing NHS boards and councils by identifying longer-term funding to allow bodies to develop sustainable new care and by identifying a mechanism for shifting resources from hospital to community services.
As always, my colleagues and I are here to answer the committee’s questions.
Thank you, Auditor General. I open up the meeting to questions.
I draw the committee’s attention to my entry in the register of members’ interests, as an elected member of South Lanarkshire Council.
The report says that a “focus on short-term funding” is having an impact on service delivery. There is increasing reliance on the private sector to help to meet targets, and it is clear that that is not demonstrating value for money. Do you see that trend continuing? If that is not inevitable, what steps need to be taken to reduce the reliance on the private sector?
That is a very good question. There is a lot in there, so if you will forgive me, I will pull back just a little bit.
In my reports over the past three or four years, I have highlighted that the focus on targets to which you referred has clearly had some real benefits in bringing down the times that people wait for elective care, admission to accident and emergency, and other things that matter to all of us. At the same time, however, the targets have tended to draw attention to what is happening in acute hospitals instead of what is happening in the health and care system as a whole, and there is a real risk that they can make it more difficult to develop the sorts of systems that would prevent people from being admitted to hospital by providing some of the care that they need at home or much closer to their homes. I have therefore recommended on a number of occasions that the focus on targets be reviewed, and I was delighted with the cabinet secretary’s recent announcement of such a review. I think that, as part of the wider view of what the system needs to do, the targets themselves need to be seen as part of the system rather than in isolation.
The other part of my recommendation that you referred to relates to longer-term financial planning and longer-term streams of funding. At the moment, it is not clear whether the Government knows that the shift that it wants can be achieved within the funding that is available for the NHS and care services over the life of this Parliament. It is clear that additional investment has been made; indeed, I have set out the figures in the report. In the past, the Government has been committed to protecting spending on the health service, but we do not know whether that is enough to make this shift. We therefore need to model what the costs of a new model of care would look like and to ensure that the funding that is in place is there for long enough to let local services right across Scotland plan for what is happening.
An additional £30 million has been announced for this year in the budget, and quite recently we have had the four-year £300 million change fund. However, my reporting on the change fund found that it was often used for quite small-scale and time-limited projects that had a local impact but which did not shift the whole system, and it is that system-wide and longer-term financial planning that I think is needed to really transform services.
Thank you for that.
The case studies in the report are useful in showing that there is already good practice out there, but my attention is drawn to the comment that
“Councils and NHS boards are finding it difficult to agree budgets for the new integration authorities.”
That issue should be looked at in the context of real-terms reductions in NHS and council budgets. To what extent do you feel that those reductions are making it difficult for councils and NHS boards to reach agreement? Have you seen any examples of areas across the country where more progress is being made than in others?
There is no doubt in my mind that it is harder to set new ways of delivering services—which is the intention behind integration authorities—at a time when budgets are under pressure than it is at a time when they are growing. When we reported on progress on setting up the new integration authorities back in December, we found that there were some real risks to their ability to deliver what is expected of them. Now that they are formally up and running, as they have been since 1 April, we are carrying out some more work on their progress. Antony Clark might be able to give us a bit more information on what we know about that without pre-empting the follow-up reporting that we will be doing.
We are in the relatively early stages of planning the next phase of our audit work on health and social care integration, but we will be assessing how well the governance arrangements are leading to shifts in services. In our previous report, we were very focused on how well the integration authorities were putting in place the structures and processes that they needed to plan together, but our focus looking forward is on whether all of that is actually making a difference.
We know that there have been some delays in agreeing budgets in some health and social care partnerships, but that situation is not universal across Scotland. Some places have been able to agree their budgets relatively easily. I think that it depends, to an extent, on the quality of the relationships that they have in place that they developed over time.
This will be my final question for now. The report says that at this stage there is still
“a lack of evidence about ... impact ... and outcomes for service users.”
Given that that is the most important aspect, what improvements do you feel need to be made with regard to local accountability and scrutiny? The report says that it is very difficult to carry out an extensive cost benefit analysis because of what appears to be a lack of local costs information. What steps are being taken to address that? What more can the Scottish Government do in that regard?
That is one of the big recommendations in the report. For reasons that I entirely understand, the Government is encouraging local areas to find their own solutions. Given that every population and every community is different, that the services that are currently in place differ from place to place, and that the skills and experience that professional staff and community groups bring are different, this is absolutely not about taking a cookie-cutter approach, whereby we try to do the same thing across Scotland. However, there is also a real risk in taking an approach that lets a thousand flowers bloom and means that people try different things in different parts of Scotland without the support and guidance that we ask for in the report. Some things work and some things do not, and we never really know what made the difference. We do not know what made the successful approaches work in practice and what went wrong with the ones that did not work.
We are certainly not seeing the overall shift in services that we need to. I draw the committee’s attention to exhibit 8 on page 27 of the report, which shows the amount spent on acute hospitals compared with the amount spent on community and social care services over the four years between 2010 and 2014, when the 2020 vision was first launched. It shows that there was no shift at all over that time. That is a stark reminder that, for all the good work that is going on, we are still heavily reliant on acute services and the shift is not happening locally.
What we would like to see—there is a checklist in the report that the team will be able to point me towards—is that when people set up their projects, there is much better support for them that says how whether the project is working will be measured, how we will learn from that and how the approach can be spread across the area and across Scotland so that that investment has the biggest possible pay-off. We think that that is the counterbalance to the Government’s focus on outcomes. The outcomes approach is widely celebrated, not just in Scotland but further afield. However, alongside the outcomes there needs to be a plan and we need to know what progress is being made. We think that that bit is missing at local level and that the Government can help to push it forward. For the record, exhibit 9 on page 30 of the report sets out what we think should be in place when people plan and deliver their local services.
link
Auditor General, I think that I detect a subtle change in the way that this report has been produced. I welcome its focus on success stories and on alternative models that are being tried up and down the country. That is really helpful, and it indicates that people are experimenting with the new models and that there might possibly be some transfer of good practice. That is really positive.
Auditors are always delighted to be called “subtle”, as that is not our usual image. We are genuinely trying to be helpful and to fill the gap by using our insight across Scotland to look at what is working and at what is needed to make the approaches that work much more widespread.
link
I refer to paragraph 5 on page 8 of the report. I want to look at how you gathered the evidence. We have previously talked ad nauseam on the committee about the problems with the figures that are produced nationally and the fact that, while the situation is improving, this is a big beast to get accurate information from so that we can use it usefully. You say that you gathered evidence by
“analysing national and local information,”
which helped you to identify “pressures in the system”. You also say that you carried out “projection analysis”, conducted “desk-based research” and worked closely “with one partnership area”. That sounds a bit narrow.
I will ask Jillian Matthew to talk you through how we did that work. I can see that that list might look narrow. In many ways—this reflects the slightly different approach that you focused on—the report was a much more outward-looking piece of work than many that we have done in the past, because we wanted to get a grass-roots perspective. Jillian, do you want to give a flavour of that?
Yes. I will say a bit more about the approach. We liaised closely with colleagues across the Government on different strands such as primary care, secondary care and the improvement side of things. We drew on the knowledge that was already there and examples that they were aware of. When we started the audit, we wrote to all the health boards and councils across Scotland to explain the audit that we were doing, to ask what kind of things were going on in their areas and to invite them to point us to any good practice that they wanted to share.
We did not go to every area in Scotland and we did not look at every different type of model, but we tried to cover a good range of what was going on. We pushed across various networks, including through ISD, because it is doing a lot of close work with different boards to help them to understand their data and what is going on with services. We put the feelers out quite widely to find out where there was good practice. We struggled to find a lot of widespread practice, but we tried to draw on different examples to demonstrate the different types of things that were going on. We tried to highlight where some of the challenges are and what different bodies are doing to overcome them in an effort to be helpful on the different approaches that can be taken.
10:15
link
As the Auditor General said, what is in paragraph 5 looks a wee bit narrow on the surface.
The report is similar to previous reports in that it says that progress is being made but not fast enough and not all at the same pace. One of the themes that I pick up is leadership at the local and national levels. The Scottish Government has left a lot of the leadership at local level to suit local needs so that what is necessary locally can develop along the broad guidelines and paths that everybody is following. In saying that you want the Scottish Government to provide more leadership in various areas, you seem to be saying that perhaps a more centralised approach would be more effective. That is not the way it has been done, but is that what you are trying to get across?
I would not use the word “centralised” at all, Mr Beattie. As I said in response to Ms Lennon’s question, we are not looking for a cookie-cutter approach that pretends that each part of Scotland is the same and that the same model of care will work in each part. That is obviously not the case.
We have two concerns. First, the vision is very clear and it has been in place since 2011, but progress towards it is very slow. I pointed Ms Lennon to the exhibit that shows that the balance of spend between hospital care and community and social care services did not really shift in the four years after 2011. A lot of support is being given—we list the joint improvement team, the quality, efficiency and support team, the work that ISD does and some other elements—but it feels to us as though that support is quite unco-ordinated and it is hard for local services to get good information about what is being tried elsewhere and what makes a successful change programme work.
We are therefore looking for something that provides a framework that will help local partnerships and services to see what the vision looks like in practice, to work through what it looks like in their area and to do the financial modelling and planning.
It might be useful to draw an analogy with what we have seen in relation to the Government’s priority on educational attainment recently. Yesterday, the Deputy First Minister announced a plan for a clear outcomes focus on attainment and for how Education Scotland and the Scottish Qualifications Authority will work with schools and local authorities to move people in that direction. Different approaches will be used in different areas but there will still be a clear plan. We are talking about something similar here. It is not micromanagement or centralised control; it is clear and more aligned support between the outcome and the local plans.
link
Coming back to information, paragraph 20 on page 14 talks about quite a big gap in information. How good is the information that the Government and local authorities are working on? Is it robust or are there real gaps that are causing them problems or delays?
The gap that you are referring to is specifically the lack of information about GPs in primary care. I will ask Jillian Matthew to expand on that in a moment.
We have reported to this committee in previous sessions that, in Scotland, we have extremely good information about hospitals and acute care. It is probably among the best in the world. We have got much less information about what is happening in communities. Given the clear focus of the 2020 vision on people’s homes and homely settings, that is a really important gap.
As has been pointed out, there is a big gap in data on primary care and general practice. That caused us problems when we were looking at the scale of the issue and the demand for general practice services. However, we pulled together various bits of information, and exhibit 5 is an infographic on the pressures around general practice. There is other information that we would like to see and which would be helpful locally for boards and partnerships to use—
link
That was just an example. Are there other areas where there are big gaps? The Auditor General mentioned local information perhaps not being as robust as the information from hospitals, which has been well honed over the past few years. Do we still have major information gaps locally that are causing problems with integration?
The gaps in data around GPs and primary care are probably the most significant. That is partly because information that was collected until about 2012 is no longer collected. There are plans to collect new information, but those plans are not fully in place yet. It is also partly because, under the new clinical strategy, GPs and primary care are seen as being at the heart of making the shift. We know that there are pressures on general practice, which we set out in the report, but we do not currently have good information about how many GPs there are, how many hours they work and how that matches the needs of the population. That information—it is really quite basic—would let you invest in GPs in the right way and get the new GP contract negotiated in ways that would let GPs play the role that they are expected to play in the new clinical strategy.
link
First of all, thank you for the report, which I found very clear and accessible. Because we have been speaking about GPs, I will ask about that topic. You mentioned that the pressure is likely to increase over the next 15 years and that, by 2030, there would be an extra 1.9 million GP appointments. The strategy is all about—or at least in major part about—preventing admissions to hospitals.
Obviously, this is a very people-intensive industry, and your report contains a clear infographic about the pressures on GPs. What is going to be done about the shortage of GPs? Page 37 of the report talks about £2.5 million being allocated to explore the issue. Do I take it from that that the work on recruitment and retention is not on-going yet and that we are still at the stage of exploring the problem?
This is not quite the case. GPs are an unusual part of the public service workforce, because almost all of them are independent contractors who are contracted to NHS boards to provide general medical services. Therefore, the health service is not in a position to plan that workforce and recruit in quite the way that it can for hospital doctors and nurses and so on.
As you said, we have an exhibit in the report that aims to show the pressures on the GP workforce. It is clear that those pressures are significant and that they are getting worse, partly because of demographic changes. GPs are expressing concern about their workload at the same time as we are seeing an increase in female—and male—GPs looking for a better work-life balance.
The Government would be better placed to answer your question about how the £2.5 million is being used. I think that it would probably also say that what will make a bigger contribution to resolving the problem is the new GP contract that is being negotiated. That will fundamentally review the terms under which GPs provide general medical services, how they work and how they are paid for that work. The hope is that the new contract will not only improve recruitment and retention, but will enable GPs to play a central part in the new clinical strategy.
Do you want to add anything to that, Jillian?
No, I do not think so.
link
Other jurisdictions have had difficulties with GP contracts. Do you see anything in the pipeline that gives cause for concern?
As you would expect, auditors are not in the business of speculating. We are keeping a close eye on the Government’s policy commitments and the progress that is being made. At this point, it is too soon to say what outcome will be achieved, but it is a matter on which we will keep our audit work focused over the period up to the contract agreement and then, as it comes into effect, in the years at the end of the decade.
link
As I said, I found your report very interesting. Page 19 addresses the issue of the new care models that are being introduced and talks about
“a lack of evidence about the impact, implementation costs, efficiency gains or cash savings, and outcomes”.
However, page 28 says that the Government lacks
“a clear framework of how it expects NHS boards and councils to achieve”
progress in the areas for action and concludes that
“there are no clear measures of success”,
the previous page states that the Scottish Government now plans to launch
“a new national conversation on the future of healthcare in Scotland.”
What I take from that is that the Government almost seems to be saying to organisations on the ground, “Look, here’s the intention but, rather than telling you what success looks like or how to achieve it, we’re going back into a national conversation on what is going to happen.” Is that a fair summary?
I do not think that that is quite the conclusion that we have drawn. The starting point is that there is a clear vision for 2020, which is, as we say in the report, widely accepted and recognised as being the right way forward. The Government has taken an outcomes-based approach to its overall set of priorities, which, again, is recognised as being an effective way of focusing on what is most important rather than on short-term measures or inputs and outputs. However, given the scale of the challenge that is presented by our growing population, the needs that we will all have as we get older and the financial pressures on public services, there is a need for something between that vision and what individual partnerships, health boards and councils are doing on the ground.
In response to Mr Beattie’s question, I said that there has recently been a shift in relation to education, with a national delivery plan that addresses the outcomes and what schools and local authorities are doing. My sense is that we need something similar in relation to the health and social care vision, not to micromanage it or centrally control it, but to give people more support in thinking through how they go about deciding what is best in their area, how they do the long-term financial planning and how they measure whether they are moving in the right direction.
As it is less than two years since I was the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing, I declare that as an interest.
I want to pick up on the point that Monica Lennon made in relation to South Lanarkshire, which is a good example of what is happening elsewhere. Progress is being slowed by—if I may put it like this—haggling between the health board and the council about the budgets for the partnerships. I think that that is going on right across the country, and it defeats one of the major purposes of having the partnerships in the first place.
Is it not time for us to consider a different approach at national level instead of having the health side of the funding of the partnerships going through the current route, which is from the Scottish Government to the health board and then from the health board, through negotiation, to the partnership, and the social care budget going from the Government to the local government settlement, then to the social care part of the local authority’ s budget and then to negotiation with the partnership? Would it not make more sense and help to deal with some of the problems that you have identified if the Scottish Government directly allocated a health and social care budget to each partnership, with the residue on the health side going to the health boards and the rest of the local government settlement, excluding social care, going to local authorities?
The legislation that governs my role explicitly precludes me from commenting on the merits of policy. That is the Government’s job. I am here to look at how it is implemented. Having said that, in this report and the one that we published on the integration of health and social care at the end of 2015, we have also said how complex some of the arrangements are.
I am conscious that the committee is likely to take on a role in post-legislative scrutiny. If the committee wanted to look at implementation of the legislation that set up the integration authorities, we are well placed to support you, given the range of work that we have done in that area.
Convener, I propose that we consider that offer later, when we look at our work programme.
Yes. It is an interesting idea and the committee should certainly consider taking up the offer. Do you have any further questions, Mr Neil?
I have a question about the slowness of progress. It seems to me that some of that slowness is due to the social care sector’s inability to deal with the additional demand that would come from reducing the number of people who are hospitalised. As we know, in Scotland at any one time, about a third of the people in hospital do not need to be there, but are there because of lack of social care provision in their community. It seems to me that, with the introduction of the living wage throughout the social care sector from 1 October, we need to put a bit more emphasis on, and oomph behind, further improvements in the social care sector to enable it to have sufficient capacity.
10:30
Recruitment and retention is a major problem; payment of the living wage is not the only issue. All the evidence shows that the major problem is the lack of a career structure in social care. Do we need to put our foot on the accelerator to bring about further improvements in the social care sector? That should include provision of proper funding to care providers: two years ago, in a joint statement with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, we admitted that funding needed to be dramatically improved to enable us to deal with the challenges in social care.
In parallel with that, we need to put our foot on the accelerator on the community health hubs, which are based on the model in Alaska, where dehospitalisation is done to a massive extent. If we did both those things across the country, would not that have a major impact on how quickly we could realise the 2020 vision?
There is no doubt that we need to invest in transforming social care. Just as the health service has been overfocused on the acute sector and on acute targets, which has made it more difficult to think about the wider system, social care services have been very bound up in getting people out of hospital as quickly as possible rather than in pulling back and considering how to keep people healthy at home for as long as possible.
The only note of caution that I would sound is that looking at any bit of that in isolation is not very helpful; we need to pull back and look at the system as a whole, which is what tends to happen in the great examples that we give in our report. In such cases—in Scotland and further afield—a whole-systems approach has been taken.
My final question is about the need for a strategic business plan. I commissioned one, but it disappeared after the reshuffle. A strategic business plan provides the connection between the vision and making it happen. I think that you are saying that rather than just having guidelines and frameworks and visions, there is a need for the Scottish Government to produce a strategic business plan on how we can make integration happen by 2020.
Over the years, I have spent a long time arguing with the Public Audit Committee about what a business plan might mean in relation to police reform and other areas. What you describe sounds like what we intend when we talk about having a framework that describes what the new models might look like, a financial plan and a list of milestones and targets on progress.
You said that information on general practitioners has not been collected since 2012. Given the shortage of GPs, what impact does that lack of information have on your ability to scrutinise GP services and on the Government’s ability to forecast public spending on general practice?
That does affect our ability to do our work, but much more important is that it has an impact on the Government’s ability to plan public spending and services. The new clinical strategy, which has been widely celebrated in the health and social care world, is strongly based on GPs playing a much wider role in the future and on their being at the heart of services for all of us, with hospital being used only when it is absolutely needed. To do that, we need enough appropriately skilled GPs in the right places, and they need to feel that they are being appropriately rewarded. It is a drawback not to have the information to plan that and to think through the implications of the new GP contract. There are plans in place to fill that gap, which is, as far as we know, still there.
Jillian will respond on the question about information.
All that I can say about information is that ISD has, for the past few years, been working on a new system to fill that information gap. It was through ISD that information was available up to 2013. However, we do not yet know what the new system—which I think is due to be available in the next few months—will look like or what kind of information will be available. We are keeping in touch with ISD on that.
Do you know why the information ceased to be collected and why a gap has been allowed to occur between the old system, under which information stopped being collected in 2012, and the new system, which is to come online in the next few months?
I think that the system before was based on a sample of general practices across Scotland and there were issues around how representative the information was; the figures were scaled up to estimate what they would be Scotland wide. There were also issues with how the data were collected. It was seen that the system could be greatly improved: unfortunately, it has been stopped while the new system has been implemented, which is why no information is available for the past few years.
It is worrying, when there is a GP crisis, that we have a four-year gap in the information. Are you saying that we do not know how many GPs there are in Scotland, and how many hours are being worked by general practitioners?
We do not have good enough information about that. We have pulled together the information that is available, using estimates from surveys and other places, to give the committee the information in our report. However, in my view—as the report says—that information is not strong enough, given the pressures that we know currently exist and the central place of GPs in the new clinical strategy.
We have talked about the integration joint boards’ budgets. Just a couple of months ago, it was reported in the press that those budgets would not all be set by June. Your report was published in March; do you know whether all the integration joint boards have now set their budgets?
They have not all done so, as far as we know. Antony Clark can update you on the position.
We do not have information across all 31 IJBs at the moment, but we will look at that as part of the next phase of audit work on health and social care integration. We will also explore the extent to which there have been delays in budgets being agreed between health and local government partners.
You do not know whether all the IJBs in Scotland have set their budgets for the next year.
I do not want to give the committee misleading information. We know from our audit work and the from the same press coverage that the committee has seen, that there have been problems. We also have a concern that some budgets that have been set may not be realistic or fully agreed between the people who will have to deliver them. I do not want to give the committee a headline figure that does not do justice to the complexity of the picture throughout Scotland.
I am interested in the part of your report where you talk about the balance between local provision and national guidance and strategy on health and social care. We have rehearsed the subject already this morning, and I am sure that it is something that Alex Neil, as a former cabinet secretary, has wrestled with. During the election, that balance was discussed at length in the context of local accountability and differing needs. Your report comes down on the side of saying that there needs to be some national guidance on outcomes. What kind of framework of priorities or—I hesitate to use the word “targets”—structure would be useful to ensure sustainability and equality of delivery throughout Scotland?
From paragraph 51 of the report onwards, we try to set out what we think is needed. I stress that we are talking not about centralised control or micromanagement but about bridging the space between the clear vision and what happens on the ground. We think that it would be really helpful for the Government to clarify the immediate and the longer-term priorities that partnerships should be focusing on.
In the report, we give some examples of the approaches that people are taking, many of which are about short-term prevention—avoiding people needing to be admitted to hospital because there is no good community alternative in place—all the way back upstream to helping people to stay active and healthy for longer so that they are less likely to need admission to hospital as they get older. We talk about the need for a clear framework and the type of models that need to be tested, which we have tried to put into six categories, some of which involve short-term prevention and some of which are population health models. We have set those out in the exhibit that is at the centre of the report.
We talk about the need for a long-term funding strategy that gets a better estimate both of how much money might be needed in the long term to run the new overall health and social care system, and of what—if anything—is needed for double running or investment in development of new services. We also talk about how the Government will measure progress—what milestones it expects to see in place for things such as the balance of spend between acute hospital-based services and community-based services, through to shifts in the number of people who are being admitted to hospital and the number of people who are being looked after in care homes rather than in their own homes. All those measures would let the Government know whether progress towards the vision was being made as planned.
For five years, we have had the 2020 vision that recommends a shift from acute to community spend, but your report clearly identifies that that shift has not happened. From your analysis, what are the pressures on Government that are preventing it from making the shift that it wants to make?
As well as clarity about the support for local partnerships that we have just been talking about, there are a couple of other clear barriers that get in the way. One is that it is always harder to make a shift when funding is constrained than when it is growing. We had a decade at the beginning of this century when public services had huge amounts of investment, but we are not in that position now and, without doubt, it is harder to make a shift when you have to press down on costs across the piece.
In response to Ms Lennon’s earlier question, we touched on the effect that the acute targets have had on the health service. All of us understand why those targets exist; quick and predictable access to acute care matters to us. However, in the long term, it matters much more to us to have good community-based services that will look after our parents and—in not so very long—us, as we get older and need that support at home. We need to be shifting the conversation away from whether 12 weeks’ wait for elective surgery or four hours’ wait for A and E is right, to talking about the sort of care that we want to be provided in communities across Scotland.
Something else that we touch on in the report, but have not talked about today, is the need for a shift in the culture that we are all part of in relation to the health service. It is easy for all of us to see a hospital, to recognise it, and to have a real emotional attachment to it. They are where most of us were born, where parents have died and so on. One can see a hospital; it is much harder to see some of the services that we are talking about and to recognise the good work that they are doing. We have not yet found a way of involving people right across Scotland in the community empowerment agenda and the wider political debate about why the 2020 vision is a much better way of providing health and social care than the things that lots of us think about when we think about the health service. I would pull out those three things as priorities.
Thank you very much. Do colleagues have any more questions for the auditor general and her team?
link
There is just one thing. On page 18, paragraph 27, reference is made to the Scottish Government working
“closely with the ten test sites over the next two years to offer support and guidance and share learning.”
We touched on the suggestion that there is perhaps a need for the Scottish Government to be more involved across the board. Do we know the dimensions of what the Scottish Government is going to be doing with those 10 test sites? Is it going to be giving the level of guidance that you seem in the report to be indicating is required or will it be something totally different?
Jillian Matthew will talk you through what we know about the 10 test sites.
When we were carrying out the audit, that idea was still in the very early stages and it was not entirely clear what the role of the Government was and how it was linking with the sites, apart from their having been identified as 10 pilot sites at which to try out different ways of working. We will be picking that up with the Government during this year as part of our annual overview of the NHS, so we will find out what progress has been made with the pilot sites and what learning is coming out of them.
link
So at this point, you do not know what it means?
We do not know entirely, but we will be picking that up with the Government this year.
link
I have a quick question. Forgive me—I am just in the door in the committee, so this question may have been answered in the past. The services and levels of pressure that you are talking about in the report are a function of use; they are a function of people needing the services. More use requires more funds, at whatever level that use is. Can you help me out? Can you point me to any work that is being done on preventative measures that mean that people do not need to access the services at any level in the first place?
That is a really good question, which brings us back to my response to the convener’s earlier question. We talk about prevention in very broad terms, but it can operate in a wide range of ways. Many of the examples that we talk about in the report are very narrow—for example, about preventing frail older people in particular from needing to be admitted to hospital when they have a fall, an infection or something. That is obviously important, not only because of the pressure that such admissions place on the health service but because it is not good care for most of those people. Most of us do not want our parents to be in that position.
However, we need to be thinking about prevention in the big sense, from how we avoid admission at the point where somebody is frail and struggling to stay at home, to how we build primary and community healthcare services that know who is at risk—who are the people who are hanging on now but may be vulnerable to winter, bad weather, colds, flu and so on—and all the way back to how we keep whole populations more active and less likely to be falling into that category in 10 or 20 years.
There are projects looking at those levels of prevention. What we are not seeing at the moment is the very strategic approach that Mr Neil outlined, which would let you plan what you intend to do and assess the priorities and how you might take pressure off the system to release resources that you could invest further upstream. We are looking for that strategic approach.
I thank the auditor general and her team very much for their evidence today.
10:45 Meeting continued in private until 11:21.
In this meeting
Everything on 30 Jun 2016 →- 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:00 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 86
- 09:45 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 62
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.