link
I am happy to support the proposal to have Derek Mackay and the Fiscal Commission engage with the committee in the near future.
I will pick out one or two issues in the legacy paper. One is the recommendation that the committee should lead a wider debate in Scotland about tax policy. I struggle to see when we will have a chance to do that. We are about to break for the summer recess and, not long after the recess, a draft budget will be published. It seems that there is no space for that wider debate about tax policy to take place. It would be regrettable if we simply had to dinghy that aspect of the legacy paper. It is worth noting that that will be a lack.
On the timescale of the budget process and the impact on other committees, during the previous parliamentary session, other committees justifiably complained on a number of occasions that they were unable to make the judgments that they needed to make. The issue that irritated me most frequently was that the carbon assessment of the budget was not produced in time for the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee to do its budget scrutiny. There are a number of other examples that relate to the remits of other committees that will report to us on the budget with regard to their portfolios. We need to put pressure on the Government to ensure that those committees have the information to enable them to do their job.
I will also say something about minority government. Experience tells us that, in a period of minority government, there can be much more substantial changes to legislation as it goes through the Parliament and, when substantial changes are made to a bill, the financial memorandum as introduced might bear little relation to the final bill that is passed. I notice that there is a recommendation in the legacy paper that the Government should be asked to give some sort of post-stage 1 update on the financial memorandum. Perhaps that proposal needs to be beefed up in the context of minority government so that the Government is asked to give an assessment of the changes that are under consideration by Parliament. We might want to make other changes to the budget process in the context of minority government, but that is one aspect that might be relevant.