Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 15 June 2016 Finance Committee About 10:30–11:00 Procedure 23 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Showing Michael Russell only · show everyone

Michael Russell’s contributions

12 contributions
Michael Russell SNP The Convener · Argyll and Bute
link

The next item involves consideration of the legacy paper. Two points are particularly important. However, first, having read the legacy paper on several occasions now, I think that we should record our thanks to the members of the previous Finance Committee and to its convener and deputy convener for the work that they undertook. This is a robust and informative legacy paper and it should give us food for thought, particularly in shaping what is going to be a busy and complex series of actions over the next few months.

We need to do two things to start up the process: one is to invite the cabinet secretary to give evidence to us at our next meeting, because it is important that we know what he and the Government are thinking about the matters that are in front of us; and the other is, at that meeting, to look at our work programme.

I want to make a couple of points before I ask Alex Johnstone to contribute. We have a clear role to fulfil in budget scrutiny. Our hands are tied, to some extent, with respect to what we will be doing at certain times of the year. When the budget process starts in September, we have a clear run through until January or early February with the things that we have to do.

In addition, Parliament will, for the first time, be giving serious consideration to matters of taxation—the budget scrutiny model that we operate on is predicated on spending money, not raising it. That change creates a new situation, which we and the Government have to consider, from the point of view not just of timescale but of how that scrutiny goes forward. We have a budget scrutiny model that is much respected and has been effective. I would not want to lose that. Equally, though, we will have to adapt it.

The first task that we have to undertake is our budget scrutiny and, as ever, we must negotiate that with the Scottish Government. However, we must also, along with the Government, address the issue of how we put in place a new model. That will require parallel actions to take place over the winter and into the spring.

There are other issues that each of us will bring to the table that relate to our interests in the subject and, ultimately, our interests in the constitution, which we will want the committee to consider. In the period until January, the space for us to do that will be very limited. It is more likely that we will have time and space thereafter, probably from the beginning of February until the summer. That is likely to be our annual programme.

We hope to have an away day in August to start to take those issues forward and to help us to get to grips with some of the complex issues that we will be dealing with. I have asked the clerks to consider how else we can do that. Those of us who were in the previous Parliament and who nodded sagely when the fiscal framework was going through have not necessarily engaged in the greatest detail with it, and it is now incumbent on us to do so.

To sum up, we need to look at the budget process and the process of putting in place a new construct for scrutiny. We will also have our own issues to bring forward. Those are all things that we need to address.

Michael Russell SNP The Convener · Argyll and Bute
link

That should certainly be passed to the clerks for consideration for the work programme.

I believe that the intention is to have the Fiscal Commission present at the away day for an informal presentation. I will meet the chair of the Fiscal Commission and have a first conversation before the summer recess. I will report on that, and we will have a chance to meet all the members and have a conversation. We will require to establish a close relationship with them.

Michael Russell SNP The Convener · Argyll and Bute
link

Everything that is said in this discussion will be considered and refined by the clerks in the work programme. In essence, we are laying out the ground. The issues that you mentioned are all important.

I hope that we will have the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Constitution at the committee in two weeks’ time. Members—particularly you, Patrick—will want to raise with him one or two key issues from the legacy paper. It is not my intention to suggest questions for members in the briefings that the committee will have. Members will want to ask their own questions but, as questions occur to them, they might want to ask SPICe or the clerks for further information to allow those questions to be filled out.

There will be a chance to influence the timescale strongly because we are talking about a new budgetary model.

Michael Russell SNP The Convener · Argyll and Bute
link

There is an established protocol and it will require to be considered as we go on. Obviously, the committee will have to be happy that we can make a recommendation to Parliament.

Michael Russell SNP The Convener · Argyll and Bute
link

That point requires to be built into our work programme both in relation to how we scrutinise the budget and as a special item.

Michael Russell SNP The Convener · Argyll and Bute
link

You are absolutely right about that. Although we cannot go into any detail, that will be imperative. There is no question but that that will require to be done.

I am entirely in the committee’s hands over the way in which we operate but, during the discussion about committee reform in the previous session, there were suggestions about ways in which committees might operate through rapporteurs. This committee has used rapporteurs before, has it not?

Michael Russell SNP The Convener · Argyll and Bute
link

We might work through rapporteurs or small groups, with the committee’s consent, because we will be pressed. The committee will meet once a week; I really do not think that it is sensible for committees to meet twice a week but other things will have to be done. I hope that the committee will agree to work in slightly different ways from time to time. We should develop the confidence in each other that will allow that to happen.

11:00

Michael Russell SNP The Convener · Argyll and Bute
link

That is an important point. There is secondary legislation, too, which I suspect will be considerable in the context of the implementation of tax powers. We will have to look at that.

Michael Russell SNP The Convener · Argyll and Bute
link

If there are no further comments, I think that the clerks have a clear indication of the initial priorities. I think that we have agreed to invite the cabinet secretary to come in two weeks’ time. I suggest that, at that meeting, we consider a paper on our work programme in private—that is the normal approach. The paper will take account of the points that have been raised in this meeting and in the legacy paper. We will then be able to discuss in more detail what we might do. We will also know what things look like post the Brexit vote, so we will have an idea of what will fit in. Do members agree to take the paper in private?

Members indicated agreement.

Michael Russell SNP The Convener · Argyll and Bute
link

We have come to the end of the public part of the meeting. We move into private for item 7.

11:03 Meeting continued in private until 11:10.

  1. 10:30 Interests Procedure · 14
  2. 10:30 Convener Procedure · 15
  3. 10:30 Deputy Convener Procedure · 6
  4. 10:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  5. 10:30 Committee Adviser Committee business · 24
  6. 10:30 Work Programme Procedure · 23

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.