Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 14 June 2016 Economy, Jobs and Fair Work Committee About 10:00–10:15 Procedure 41 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Showing Gordon MacDonald only · show everyone

Gordon MacDonald’s contributions

8 contributions
Gordon MacDonald SNP Edinburgh Pentlands
link

I am the only member here who was on the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee in the previous session, which carried out an inquiry into the internationalisation of Scottish business. When we looked at the situation with the chambers of commerce, UK Trade & Investment, Scottish Development International and so on, we saw that the picture was cumbersome and mixed. To give us some breathing space to identify other topics that we can look at later in the year, I point out that paragraphs 59 to 61 in the legacy paper propose that we look at the remits of Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise. That might be a good start. The subject is apolitical, which gives us the opportunity to get our teeth into it. Also, Audit Scotland is due to release a report on it during the summer, and I believe that the Government is also looking at the subject. It might be something to start off with, especially if we bear in mind John Mason’s point that if we have a planning meeting late, we still have to be up and running for the beginning of September.

That is only a suggestion but the topic is in the legacy paper.

Gordon MacDonald SNP Edinburgh Pentlands
link

Before the election, the then Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee looked at the living wage and fair work in quite a bit of detail. I am not averse to looking at the subject again, but to do so now might be too soon after what we did in the previous session.

If we wanted to look at some way of growing our economy quickly—as Dean Lockhart suggested—an idea might be to consider our airports’ situation. Edinburgh airport is growing—I think that it recently hit 11 million passengers in a year. We could replicate the situation whereby people who are travelling to America can go through immigration in Dublin airport; it creates a fantastic input and draws a huge number of flights through the airport, which has a knock-on effect on trade and tourism. That might be worthy of discussion.

Gordon MacDonald SNP Edinburgh Pentlands
link

We really started having away days—which I think work really well—to any great extent only in the second half of the previous session of Parliament. The then Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee had one in Paisley—from memory, it was when the committee was looking at fair work. We invited unemployed people, small businesses and agencies that help people into work to an informal meeting. I am concerned that how Parliament has worked means that we have developed “professional” witnesses—no matter what the topic a committee is looking at, the same witnesses always turn up. I would be happier if there were more informal meetings at which we could hear from the front line about what is really happening, rather than the information being filtered through a lobbying organisation.

Gordon MacDonald SNP Edinburgh Pentlands
link

Yes. We do not have to have a guest speaker. When we have had such meetings before, there have been maybe six or seven groups and one MSP sits with each group and acts as a facilitator. Usually a clerk or someone takes notes so that we have feedback from the discussions. Those meetings worked particularly well.

We have also had round-table meetings—the main one was in the members’ coffee lounge. When I was on the previous session’s Infrastructure and Capital Investment Committee, we invited a lot of small businesses to come in one evening. It was good to hear first-hand information about potential legislation that was to go through Parliament. I cannot remember what the legislation was, but we got a bit of feedback. In my view, those things work better that way.

Gordon MacDonald SNP Edinburgh Pentlands
link

Absolutely: it is about striking a balance between the two.

Gordon MacDonald SNP Edinburgh Pentlands
link

So far, in the discussions at informal meetings—of which I have now attended three—no individual has come along with an axe to grind. Such meetings are about moving the agenda forward; the approach has worked well. That does not mean that what you describe might not happen, but so far—touch wood—it has not.

Gordon MacDonald SNP Edinburgh Pentlands
link

We are talking about a result that could, whichever way it falls, have a massive impact on our economy. For you to turn around and say that it is not a matter that the committee should consider seems to me to be a wee bit disingenuous, to say the least.

  1. 10:00 Interests Procedure · 12
  2. 10:00 Convener Procedure · 2
  3. 10:00 Deputy Convener Procedure · 2
  4. 10:00 Work Programme Procedure · 41

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.