Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 14 June 2016 Economy, Jobs and Fair Work Committee About 10:00–10:15 Procedure 41 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Showing Gordon Lindhurst only · show everyone

Gordon Lindhurst’s contributions

20 contributions
Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

Under agenda item 4, we will discuss and agree the committee’s approach to work programming and the suggestion of holding what is termed a business planning day—or an away day, which I think is the technical term that some use for that.

Members will all have seen paper EJFW/S5/16/1/3. Do we wish to hold a business planning day as suggested in that paper?

Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

The clerks will liaise with individual members to establish a suitable date for everyone. In light of what Gordon MacDonald has just said, the date might have to be earlier in August or possibly in early September.

Are we agreed on the suggested approach?

Members indicated agreement.

Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

I move on to the question of the committee’s business in the coming session. Members will all have seen the previous committee’s legacy paper. The suggestion is that we consider the items in that paper at the business planning day and decide whether we wish to use it as a basis for the committee’s further work. I take it that there is no difficulty with that.

Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

The clerks will note that and may bring something back to the meeting in two weeks’ time, when we can discuss the matter further.

Does anyone have any other suggestions?

10:15

Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

In the first instance, the clerks could compile an email distribution list, which will be shared with committee members. We can see how we take that forward, if people wish to take that approach. We could discuss the idea further at the next meeting, if anything arises.

Do members wish to draw attention to any other points in the legacy paper for people to consider prior to the meeting in two weeks’ time, when we will discuss the legacy paper and how it fits into the business planning day?

Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

You might want to look at that and bring something to the committee.

Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

Are you suggesting that there should be a mix of witnesses?

Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

It may be helpful to have that sort of thing, although one has to be careful not to have too much simply anecdotal evidence.

Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

Indeed. In addition there are questions about how the views that would be expressed and the comments that would be made would be recorded, and how people would be selected to come to those informal meetings. We could have professional witnesses on one side and, on the other, people who have particular issues that they wish to promote. It is important that we have regard to those people but—as you said—there is a need to strike a balance.

Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

I think that Dean Lockhart wants to comment—or has your moment also passed?

Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

I will take one more point from Andy Wightman, then perhaps we can move on to the next part of the discussion, because we are starting to get into detail that we can work out as we move forward.

Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

The European Union referendum falls under Westminster’s remit, not the Scottish Parliament’s. I am not certain that we will have, on 28 June, a clear position on the relevance of the referendum result on this committee, given that it will have taken place only five days before then.

Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

If we invite the Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work to come, he may well have comments to make on the referendum result and how it may impact on Scotland. It may be that that issue will arise. Whether the referendum will have a huge impact will depend on which way the result goes.

Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

Is everyone content to invite the cabinet secretary to our next meeting to outline the Government’s proposals or its programme? He will take one view or the other on whether to go into the topic of the outcome of the referendum on the European Union, but we will allow him to take up the issue if he considers it appropriate to do so. We will also ask SPICe to provide a report—to the extent that it can—for our meeting, which will be five days after the referendum. Is everyone happy with that approach?

Members indicated agreement.

Gordon Lindhurst Con The Convener · Lothian
link

We will invite both the Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work and the Minister for Business, Innovation and Energy—who I think is Paul Wheelhouse—to the next meeting. The clerks will get in touch with members on timing, which will depend on the commitments of the cabinet secretary and the minister on that day.

Unless members have anything else to raise, I thank everyone for coming, and I look forward to working with you over the next five years.

Meeting closed at 10:30.

  1. 10:00 Interests Procedure · 12
  2. 10:00 Convener Procedure · 2
  3. 10:00 Deputy Convener Procedure · 2
  4. 10:00 Work Programme Procedure · 41

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.