Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Reports

“The 2013/14 audit of Coatbridge College: Governance of severance arrangements”

Wednesday 24 February 2016 Public Audit Committee About 11:45–12:45 Committee business 255 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

255 contributions · showing 1–200
Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Agenda item 3 is an evidence-taking session on the Auditor General for Scotland’s report entitled “The 2013/14 audit of Coatbridge College: Governance of severance arrangements”. I welcome to the meeting our panel of witnesses from the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council: Professor Alice Brown, chair; Laurence Howells, chief executive; and John Kemp, director of access, skills and outcome agreements.

I understand that Professor Brown will make a short opening statement.

Professor Alice Brown Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I will indeed, convener. Thank you very much, and thank you for inviting us to the committee again. We welcome the opportunity to discuss this very important matter and to give a brief opening statement.

First, I must emphasise, as we have emphasised in our written submission, the seriousness with which we take what happened at Coatbridge. We are grateful for the Auditor General’s report and your subsequent hearings, which have shone a very bright and necessary spotlight on the issue.

At the time that the issue arose, colleges were not public bodies; however, they have been public bodies since April 2014. As such, the Scottish public finance manual now applies to them and, as you will be aware, it considerably strengthens the rules on severance. Colleges must now obtain the SFC’s prior approval before severance payments can be made; indeed, it is now a condition of grant.

In our written submission, I stated that the funding council is taking a number of steps to learn crucial lessons from what happened. We understand the need to be more proactive in ensuring good governance across the college sector, and we are already doing that. Although today is not the time to go into specifics, I wish to highlight one such example, which is the funding council’s approach to issues that arose last year with the Glasgow Clyde College board. We will also implement, without delay, the recommendations of the college good governance task group, which our chief executive Laurence Howells is a member of and which will report next month.

I should also take this opportunity to update the committee on two matters, the first of which is our revised severance guidance. We delayed finalising that guidance until the committee’s report on Coatbridge was completed, but it has now been issued.

Secondly, we, together with New College Lanarkshire, asked Mr John Doyle to respond to our letters seeking a return of a proportion of the severance payment that he received, in time to share his response with the committee. We understand from our legal advisers that he has not yet given a substantive response, but he has indicated that he will do so. When we get his response, we will consider next steps with the college.

Again, convener, thank you for this opportunity.

11:45

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Professor Brown, do you, on behalf of the funding council, accept all the contents of our report on Coatbridge College?

Professor Brown
link

We accept the contents of your report—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Do you accept the recommendations?

Professor Brown
link

—and the recommendations. As we said in our written submission, we think that one aspect, which relates to our support for colleges going through what was a major regionalisation process, is not fully justified.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

In that case, you do not accept the recommendations, if you feel that part of them is not justified. That is different from what you advised us.

Professor Brown
link

We accept the recommendations. We were just putting into the public domain additional information to show that we did a lot to support colleges going through the process. As you will recall, 10 mergers took place over a period of 18 months. Anyone who has been involved in a merger process—I am sure that some members have been—will know that it is very complex, particularly when we have to ensure that students continue to be taught well throughout. It is hugely disruptive for students and staff. Now—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

But you will accept that Mr Doyle received £304,000—well above the recommended amount—as a result of poor governance in that organisation and that that affected students. We have advised that the Scottish funding council could play a more proactive role in assisting in such processes, and we have said that lessons have to be learned from the issue. Why do you feel that our recommendation is unjustified?

Professor Brown
link

I am not saying that your recommendation is unjustified.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

That is what it says in your letter. It says that you do not feel that the recommendation “is ... justified”.

Professor Brown
link

It says that it is not “fully justified”. That is because of the additional information that I have given. However, we fully accept that we could have been more proactive, particularly in relation to issuing the severance guidance in a more timely way, at the point of merger. You will recall that we issued merger guidance but that the severance guidance was not reissued. Of course, one of the ironies is that, with the particular college involved—Coatbridge College—the guidance was reissued to it in January 2013, and it chose not to take that advice or follow the guidance. That is a different matter.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I want to come back to the correspondence that we exchanged in connection with business cases. You asked us to amend the Official Report of a meeting to reflect Mr Kemp’s feeling that the information that we asked for was provided adequately. Was the one business case that we were provided with for all the colleges involved the full business case?

Professor Brown
link

That point is rather separate from the point that we have been discussing. Are you referring to the letter that I sent about the information provided to the committee?

Professor Brown
link

When I heard about the comments that were made on the day the committee published its Coatbridge College report that the Scottish funding council had not produced information that the committee had asked for, I was rather alarmed and obviously asked members of the executive why information had not been provided. I was then given the full information about what had been provided, when it was asked for and what had been delivered. That is the point that I was trying to make.

I would be alarmed if the committee did not receive information that it requested, so I wanted to know the circumstances around those points. I am satisfied that, in fact, information that had been asked for at particular times was provided. There was some confusion around a particular request for information in a letter, rather than what was said at a committee hearing, and I think that Laurence Howells has apologised for any confusion around that. However, in no way did we intend not to provide information.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Just to clarify, we asked for all the business cases that could be provided in connection with severance payments to college principals. According to the table in the document that I am looking at, only one business case was provided. I will come back to that in a second. There is an attachment to the document, which I think relates to Langside College, but when I interrogate the document further, it does not look like I have a full copy of the business case; instead, it looks like I have an extract from an annex to the document. We asked for a full copy of the business case, and we have not received a full copy of the business case. Do you understand our frustration?

Professor Brown
link

I certainly do, if that is the case. I ask Dr Kemp to answer that point.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The reason that you have one business case—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

It is not one business case—it is an extract from a business case. The point that I am making is that I have before me a two-page document that refers to various annexes such as annex F, which suggests that I actually have two pages from a much larger business case document. It is therefore fair for the committee to ask whether the document that we have is incomplete.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

This is the first time that we have heard that—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Well, you provided the document, and it is not the full document—

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

But this is the first time that we have heard that concern from the committee. We are happy to follow that up and see whether there are other annexes that have not been provided.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I will come on to the actual issues relating to the business case in a moment, but with regard to the document that we have for Langside College, do you accept that although we asked for the business case we have been provided with an extract? Is that correct? We do not have the full document here.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I am not aware of whether it is the full business case or whether the reference to annexes applies to something else. We can follow the matter up.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Okay.

On the subject of business cases, I have a question—again, for clarity—for Mr Howells. During your evidence session with the committee, I said to you that Mr Doyle might come before us and advise us that other principals had received similar deals. You advised me that, for a deal to be approved over and above the guidance on severance payments to which we have been referred, a business case should be provided. That is what you said. Is that correct?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Our guidance required business cases for exceptional payments outwith the schemes that were generally operating in the other colleges. Apart from Mr Doyle’s case, which was exceptional, all the other principals’ cases and schemes were in line with the general schemes for all staff.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You say that they were in line with the general schemes. Would you expect those schemes to meet the terms in the guidance circular that was issued in the year 2000? Is that correct?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

In the table that you have provided, significant sums are referred to in the column entitled “Contractual pay in lieu of notice”. Given that your guidance refers to the fact that payment in lieu of notice should be avoided except in very exceptional circumstances, we would expect that column to list only one or two principals who found themselves in that exceptional position. Why, then, does the table show all those principals receiving significant sums of public money? It appears that, apart from the cases that have been referred to Audit Scotland, Langside College is the only one that had a business case. When people receive sums outwith the guidance that has been set out by the Scottish funding council, should it not be accepted that the college should say, “If we’re going to pay this significant lump sum, we need a business case”?

There are other payments listed in the table; for example, in one case, there was a pension payment of more than £200,000. Would that have required a business case?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Under the system in operation at that time, the business cases were made to the board. Our guidance was that they should be made and retained, and the information was looked at by auditors later on. The business case did not have to be sent to us at that stage.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You are paying the cheques. You were the accountable officer, Mr Howells, so you were responsible for public funds being paid to those principals under guidance that is more specific than people probably give you credit for. The guidance that was set out in the year 2000 is quite specific about what is required. When you looked at that guidance, did you say to your officials, including Mr Kemp, “Maybe we should ensure that the funds going out the door have a business case attached to ensure that they represent the best use of public money”—or did you just let them go out the door?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

At the time, the decisions on those arrangements were a matter for the individual boards—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

But they were not. It was your job to provide the funds to the boards. Your funds were allowing those payments to be made, were they not?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Indeed. I understand that, which is why—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You were the accountable officer.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Indeed, and that is why since April 2014 we are now in the preferable situation in which arrangements have to be approved by SFC. At the time, they were the responsibility of the boards. We did not—and we do not—run colleges, and we were relying on delegating authority to those boards to take forward those arrangements in the context of our guidance.

I agree that it is regrettable that that did not happen. With the tightening up of the arrangements and the rules, we are now in a better situation. I can only apologise on behalf of the boards involved in the sector concerned that the situation happened. We are now in a much different situation, and the new situation—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

All the apologies that we have heard this morning will keep the official report busy. They are welcome, but we have heard them before, and the issue is to get to the bottom of the situation. There is a table in the documentation that sets out payments that were made over and above the recognised scheme, and it shows that one person received £200,000 as part of the pension scheme. Did no one ever refer that to you, Mr Howells, and say, “Look—this is one of the payments that we have heard about at this college”? If so, did that not alarm you? Was anything ever brought to the funding council that said—

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The cases that were brought to us were those in which the auditors in the colleges and the Auditor General had identified significant governance concerns. They were covered in the Auditor General’s 2015 report, which highlighted the two cases that we know of—North Glasgow College and Coatbridge College.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Let us look at the situation. There was £50 million-worth of public funds going into the merger process. It would have been no secret to anyone that, as part of that process, significant sums of money would have to be used to deal with principals who would no longer be continuing in post as a result of mergers. You would have known that the Scottish funding council was paying money to the colleges to pay off some of the principals. Did you never say, “I need to make sure that whatever funds are being paid to these individuals are appropriate”? I have already referred to a £200,000 pension payment in one of the colleges, and a number of other payments were made. Did you never have any sight of those?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We did not have sight of those payments before they were made. In the case of Coatbridge College, we were aware of what was happening, so we intervened.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You intervened in Coatbridge College only after you were made aware of the issues by the Auditor General.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

No. In the case of Coatbridge College, we were made aware of the situation before the payments happened, and then we were active. The Auditor General’s report came afterwards.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

My final question is one that I have always wanted to ask you. When you became aware that Mr Doyle was seeking payments over and above the recommended level, did it never occur to you that the Scottish funding council should say, “We’re not paying the money”?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We took the judgment at the time to limit any payment that we made to the standard 13 months. I accept the committee’s judgment that, when I went to the board, I could have been stronger. I should have said—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I am not asking you about when you went to the board. Mr Howells, you have the cheque book. The only way that Mr Doyle could be paid the money was for you to say to him, “Yes, this money will be paid to you.” If it had been made clear to him that he was not going to receive the money in the first place and that you were not going to sign the cheque—if you had advised him that the Scottish funding council was not going to make the payment—you would have stopped the process from going any further. Is that not fair?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

At the time, it was the boards’ responsibilities to make those payments—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

To make the decision, yes. It was not your responsibility to give Mr Doyle or the board the money, was it?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

To be clear, we did not write the cheque—

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

In fact, we contacted the college and asked it not to make the payment—

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

It went ahead and made the payment. I appreciate that your question is about what we should have done after that, but—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Was Mr Doyle advised that the payment would not be made?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The payment was not going to come from us. We could have chosen not to make a payment for the proportion that we paid to the college—

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

—but that issue would have been relevant after Mr Doyle had had the cheque paid by the college, despite our asking it not to do that.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I will finish with this question then—perhaps it will make things a bit clearer. Did the Scottish funding council contact Mr Gray, the then college chair, and advise him, “You can agree to whatever payment you want, Mr Gray, but we are not paying this money”? You asked him not to do that, but there is a difference between asking the college not to do that and saying that you are not going to provide it with the funding. Did you do that?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

To be accurate, what we said was that we would not pay above the 13 months; we did not say that we would not pay the college anything in relation to Mr Doyle. That is a fact.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Did you say that you would not pay above 13 months?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

But you paid above 13 months.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

No, we did not.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

And you provided the funds for the 13 months. Is that the sum that is referred to in the payments column?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

12:00

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So you said that you would pay the 13 months. If you had said that you would not pay the 13 months because the college had agreed to pay well above the agreed scheme, would that not have been more appropriate?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

At the time, we made the judgment that the danger in doing what you have suggested was that it would have taken another £100,000—or whatever the figure was—out of the services that the new college could give to students.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

But that was what happened anyway. The money that you paid could have gone to the college sector.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Indeed. That was the judgment that we made at the time. We accept that the committee believes that we should have made a different judgment, and we are now in a different situation.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

If Mr Doyle had been made aware when he was arranging the package and colluding with others on that, that you were not even going to give the college the 13 months, he could not have taken the matter any further. That is the position that he would have been in. He might have tried to take the money from college funds, but that would have been much more of an issue for him, would it not?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Indeed. For the college to have paid that, the money would have had to have come from its general funds. What I could not have done was to stop paying the college any money—that money is necessary for running a college. I paid the college money every month, and it was the college’s responsibility to decide what they paid for in any particular month. Had I said to the college that I would pay it nothing instead of paying the 13 months for Mr Doyle, it would have sent a more forceful message to the college. I accept that we should have been more forceful at that moment, but the college could still have gone ahead and paid the £300,000 out of its funds.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I want to talk more about being forceful. I refer you to the letter of 17 February that you sent to the convener, in which you seem to accept—grudgingly—the recommendations of the committee.

I do not want to pick over the coals, because we have already spent huge amounts of time on this, but for future governance we really need to be sure that this is not likely to happen again.

In terms of being forceful, at the critical meeting of the board of Coatbridge College, which you attended to tell them that you were not paying £304,000 to John Doyle and that you would stay within the recommended guidelines of the Scottish funding council—we would expect no less of you—why did you leave after 10 minutes? Was that your choice or theirs?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I will tell you my experience of that meeting. When we entered, the atmosphere was not entirely welcoming. I had ready what I wanted to say to the board, and as you can see from the minutes of that meeting, I made sure that the board heard the essence of our guidance from me, orally. I made it clear to the board that I would be interested in debating with them and that I would be keen to have a dialogue. I reached a point where no dialogue was happening, although there had been one or two questions. At that point we were invited to leave.

I could have stayed and repeated the points that I had made and, on reflection, maybe I should have been more forceful. That is something that we learned from subsequent events. However, my main purpose at that meeting was to ensure that every member of the board was absolutely clear about our guidance and that they would take that on board.

We have learned from the events, and it is clear that there are occasions when we need to be more forceful. Some of the subsequent events that Professor Brown referred to show where we have been trying harder on that.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

It really does not matter whether or not you were welcome and whether or not the board were talking to you. You had a serious job to do on behalf of the Scottish taxpayer and, indeed, on behalf of the Scottish Government. If you had done that, you would probably have saved the committee an awful lot of time, an awful lot of reading and a huge amount of work. I give credit to every member of the committee, because we have done a thorough job. I retire in three weeks.

I have to say to you that I was very disappointed. I am talking personally, not on behalf of the committee. I was very disappointed with the role of the Scottish funding council. I think that John Doyle and John Gray ran circles round you, which is very disappointing. I stand by every single comment and recommendation in our report, although I appreciate that you say that it was not fully justified.

Did the Government put so much pressure on you to ensure that the mergers happened that you were willing to turn a blind eye to John Doyle and John Gray? I appreciate that Mark Batho was the chief executive of the funding council at the time. The Auditor General mentioned collusion by John Gray and John Doyle after the guidelines were set out to them. Collusion in order to get the remuneration committee to pay almost an extra £200,000 to John Doyle is a very serious matter indeed. In my dictionary, it is fraud.

That will be overlooked, I imagine, although today’s Official Report will go to the police. Do you agree with the committee and the Auditor General that John Gray and John Doyle colluded in order to ensure that the remuneration committee was not fully informed of the SFC guidance and to ensure that John Doyle got significant additional amounts of taxpayers’ money to which he was not entitled?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am interested in preventing the senior team from receiving an unjustifiable package, and I do not want to digress, but if you want to answer quickly I am happy about that.

The point that really concerns me is that you had sanctions but did not use them. The college probably knew perfectly well that you were not going to use them, and that allowed those concerned to help themselves and line their own pockets.

You referred to paragraph 299 of our report. You had sanctions not to pay the money. You decided that you would not bother penalising John Doyle, because that would result in “penalising students and staff.” If you had sanctions that you were not willing to use at any point, did you ever go to the Scottish Government and say, “This isn’t really working. You are giving us sanctions that are worthless. We need greater sanctions to ensure that taxpayers’ money is not wasted.”? You did not use the sanctions that were available to you. Can you answer that point?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Indeed—and I accept that position. I guess that is why the post-2014 arrangements give us a new power in respect of those particular—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am talking about saying, “We have to go over this.”

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I accept that.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

In relation to your report, you are correct. We did not recover the money, or pay nothing for John Doyle’s severance, for the reasons that we have given—we have been there before. During that process, we did not say to the Government that we needed extra sanctions. However, following the event, since April 2014 we have the authority to decide on a more—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You were given sanctions that you refused to use, which made life easy for John Doyle and John Gray. Have you ever used those sanctions?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes. We use the sanction of withholding grant quite frequently. The reason why we did not use it—

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I do not think that we have ever used it in terms of a severance payment.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You have never used it in terms of severance.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I cannot think of an occasion when we have used it in terms of a severance payment.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Do you realise the signal that that puts out? John Gray and John Doyle knew perfectly well that they could do what they wanted.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I will explain why we did not use it, although we did consider it. The reason why we did not use it in the context of the John Doyle and John Gray issue was, as you said in an earlier question, that it was an issue of apparent collusion between two people to achieve—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

It was not “apparent”, according to Laurence Howells: he said that it was collusion.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I am not disagreeing with that at all. However, those two people had exited the college pretty much on the evening that Mr Howells attended the board meeting. Despite our asking the board not to make any payment until we could get to the bottom of its decision, it made the payment and Mr Doyle had the money in his bank account almost immediately after the board meeting.

Our view at that stage was that, once the money had left the college, if were we to use the sanction of not paying the grant or withholding grant for the whole amount, that would have impacted only on the college. As you know from earlier discussions at this committee, we considered other options. For example, we sought legal advice on whether we could recover the sum from board members who had taken a decision that was against guidance. However, the advice was that that was unlikely to succeed.

We considered other options, but we did not think that the options of withholding grant or not applying part of the grant for the merger would work. The money had already been paid to Mr Doyle, and we did not think that if we withheld money from the college there was a prospect of his immediately repaying what he had received.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I can speak for only myself here. Do you understand why I am very disappointed by the role of the Scottish funding council and its lack of supervision, oversight, scrutiny and management of the Coatbridge College severance payments? Do you understand my personal disappointment in that regard?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I can understand the anger of people at that event and our role in it. In our defence, as we said in our letter, we knew about the issue in advance and we tried, using all the powers that we had at the time, to prevent it. However, I can understand your anger.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Attending a 10-minute meeting where you were unwelcome and nobody was talking to you was hardly using all the powers at your disposal. You are a serious government agency with a serious budget, but you allowed yourself to be pummelled around by John Doyle and John Gray. They made you unwelcome and nobody was talking to you, so you left after 10 minutes. I would have stayed there for 10 hours, until they got the message. However, you just walked out the door quietly and meekly—that was not using all the powers at your disposal.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I have accepted that we should have been more forceful. We have learned from that and we are going to be more forceful in the future.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Professor Brown, do you agree that the Scottish Government put considerable faith in the SFC and its central role in the merger of the colleges?

Professor Brown
link

Yes, it did, and the SFC worked in partnership with Scottish Government officials and the change team in taking forward the merger process.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

In retrospect, do you believe that you fully met that faith?

Professor Brown
link

You must remember that I was not chair of the Scottish funding council at the time, so I am reflecting on what happened and have been looking at all the paperwork as well. The Scottish funding council achieved a lot in the 18 months of the merger process, when there were 10 mergers to undertake. In hindsight, given the evidence that has been produced through the inquiries of the Auditor General and the committee, it is clear that the SFC could have done some things better—the funding council totally accepts that.

The matter was brought to the attention of our board again in January this year, when all members got a copy of the committee’s report and a report from the chief executive. We will be looking very carefully at all the steps that will be taken to ensure, as far as we can, that this kind of thing does not happen again.

Another point to note is that we must also think about the issue in the context of a whole governance framework. There are different roles, responsibilities and lines of accountability at play here. Clearly, we start with the appointment of principals and their terms and conditions, the appointment of chairs of boards and their terms and conditions, and the appointment of board members. The committee made a point in its report about the adequate training of those members, which is a point that we are taking up at present.

Within all that, we have the checks and balances of auditors, both internal and external; the SFC; the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator, with which we are in discussions; the Standards Commission for Scotland; and the Commissioner for Ethical Standards in Public Life in Scotland. There is therefore a network and framework of governance that is part of looking at the whole picture. I would say that that framework failed on this occasion and that it failed the public. The committee described the kind of sums involved as eye-watering, and I certainly find them so.

12:15

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I am finding what you say to be a sort of spreading of the blame over everybody.

Professor Brown
link

No, not at all. We accept responsibility for our part in what happened. What I am saying is that when we are looking forward and learning lessons from what happened, we have to think about how that network works effectively to make sure that it does not happen again. It is not about one institution, but we fully accept responsibility for our failure in this respect.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The convener was asking about business cases. I think that it was Mr Kemp who said in response that business cases did not require to come to the SFC but just required to exist and to be presented to the board or the colleges. However, the third paragraph on page 3 of your letter of 17 February states that

“the guidance ... did not require the College to share the business case, for any exceptional payments”.

You specify “exceptional payments”, which implies that normally the business case would be shared but that in exceptional cases, which are presumably where the college is picking up that part of the cost, the business case is not.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We maybe could have written that sentence better. What it means is that where there was no exceptional payment, no individual business case would be needed for a payment. If the principal was simply getting exactly the same deal as everyone else, it was non-exceptional and no business case was needed. Where the deal was exceptional and a business case was needed, that still did not need to be shared with the SFC.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

So you are saying that you do not need a business case if it is just within the terms of the—

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes. Our guidance was that if the principal, for example, was getting exactly the same deal in terms of months for years of service as everyone else, no individual business case was needed and it was just part of the wider scheme.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Would you not still need a business case to say that the deal was justified and appropriate, and that the payback period for it was appropriate?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

It would be implied that the scheme itself covered those issues, because it would cover the length of service that qualified for a particular payment and therefore the payback would be included in that.

I can see your point, though, because outwith the context of a merger, making a severance deal for a principal would have to take into account the fact that another principal would be needed. However, we are talking about the context of mergers and there being fewer principals.

I would like to make a point about the Scottish public finance manual and lessons that we have learned. As we heard earlier, the Scottish public finance manual changed matters so radically that it meant that, in essence, our previous guidance was irrelevant. One of the lessons that we have been very carefully learning is that because that happened, things were happening through a system that was not within our sight at the time. We would not have had to learn that lesson if matters been dealt with otherwise by the SPFM.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

During the course of the process, did you see the SFC in a supervisory or watchdog role in relation to what happened and the payment of moneys?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We had a variety of roles. We were encouraging and supporting the merger programme, but we were aware that we had a supervisory role as well. That is why we intervened to the extent that we did in Coatbridge College. There were other cases where we had to express views on how things were going. Many of those have not come to light, because they were resolved. However, we saw that we had a supervisory role, a supporting role and other roles in the merger process.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The third page of your letter of 17 February states:

“We were successful in preventing the senior team receiving an unjustifiable package.”

If you were successful with the senior team, it seems strange to me that you were not successful with the principal. What was the difference in approach there?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Our approach was exactly the same in both cases. Many of the actions that have been described in earlier committee meetings in terms of our interaction with Coatbridge College were about both cases, because they were both live issues right up until the end, when the board dropped the additional payment to the senior managers but retained the payment to John Doyle.

Our approaches were very similar. We saw all the additional payments as unacceptable. We took the actions that you heard about in earlier meetings. We had the chair and the principal in to express our concerns. By the time that Mr Howells attended the board meeting, we knew that the senior management team package had been dropped, so it was down to Mr Doyle’s payment. In essence, the process was the same.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Given that the same process was in place, why was it successful in preventing the senior team, but not Mr Doyle, from receiving an unjustifiable package?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I was going to say that you would have to ask Mr Gray and Mr Doyle that, but you have done that already, and you have reached your conclusion, with which we agree.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Mr Howells, you stated that you were invited to leave the meeting that you attended. My understanding is that you were there for 10 minutes. Given that there were questions and so forth, you probably did not get to state much in those 10 minutes. How did it come about that you were invited to leave? What did you think as you were asked to leave?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

To be quite honest, there were not many questions. What did I think? I thought that I had got my message across and that there was no one on the board who could possibly not have understood what I was expecting of them, and that I expected them to go into a debate among themselves and challenge the chair and the remuneration committee about the way forward. That is honestly what I thought. It has been suggested that it was perhaps naive of me to think that. I thought that I had got my points across, and I expected the board to say, “We need to follow this guidance.”

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

During the course of those 10 minutes, did you indicate that the funding council would still be prepared to pay the 13-month severance?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The minutes do not record that I said—

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

They do not record very much at all.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I said, “You need to follow your guidance. If you are going to go beyond the 13-month period for everyone else, you are going to need to go through these processes.”

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Did you indicate that you were prepared to fund that portion of it?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I do not think that we talked about our funding at that meeting.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You said that you could not have changed the mind of the board—that is on page 3 of the letter that was mentioned. Presumably, you left that meeting after 10 minutes thinking that you could not change the mind of the board.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I will be honest. I left that meeting thinking that the board had heard what it had to do, and I expected the board members to do that.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

However, the letter talks about your not being able to change the minds of the board. That does not seem logical. If you left believing that they had heard the message, presumably you believed that they would take note of it and do something about it. On what basis did you believe that you could not change the mind of the board? At what point did you start to think that?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I think that, in our letter, we are referring to the whole situation and the aftermath. I am honestly saying what I thought when I walked out of that meeting. If our letter does not give an accurate impression, I apologise.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I have to say that I find the role of the SFC in this matter quite weak.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I want to address two areas. I understand that the senior management’s additional payments were not made on the same basis as that of John Doyle because the letter that they had received expired on 31 July. However, I do not think that the committee has ever seen the letter relating to John Doyle. Have you seen it? If it also expired on 31 July, the board is doubly culpable, because it failed to take cognisance of the guidance that was offered to it. Have you attempted to ascertain that at any point?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I think that our view has been that, if it was not in accordance with the guidance, it should have been set aside.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Yes, but my understanding of the basis for John Doyle’s receiving the package is that it was felt that, on the advice of the lawyers and because of previous correspondence, the board was contractually obliged to pay it. However, that was clearly not the case with regard to the senior management because of the termination letter regarding the original proposals for merger, which had to be submitted to you on 31 July. Am I right in thinking that you did not seek to clarify that and have not done so subsequently? I know that that is shutting the stable door after the horse has well and truly bolted—and bolted pretty fast in this case.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The role of the board and the basis on which the board acted is an important question, and we have not clarified that particular point to my knowledge. As Dr Kemp said, we thought that, if the scheme was not in line with the guidance, it did not stand anyway.

It goes back to the role of the whole board in looking after the affairs of the college and in its responsibility to challenge.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Well, those matters may be sub judice in due course.

Another issue that really interests me goes back to the merger involving Stevenson and Telford colleges in 2011-12, when the severance payments under a regional scheme were for 21 months. That Edinburgh scheme was at odds with the scheme that the SFC was promoting as part of the merger process. Yet again, at Dundee and Angus College in 2012-13, a whole year later, there was another 21-month term under a general scheme. There were two areas in Scotland with general schemes that John Doyle cited in his proposal to have a regional scheme for Lanarkshire, so I have some understanding of where he was coming from. Three principals had got away with 21 months’ severance pay, and some of them got £52,000 and £23,000 in lieu of notice in addition to that. He must have thought, “They got away with £249,000 and £202,000, so why shouldn’t I have a good go at getting the same scheme? It seems only fair. Why should I be penalised and not have the same scheme that others are getting?” What was your comment on those schemes as they went through?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Our view was that we could not justify funding 21 months’ severance pay, and we did not fund up to 21 months.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

No, but did you comment that that was at odds with the guidance? I know that you were not responsible at that stage, because the boards made the decisions. However, as the funding council that handled the public money, did you comment at all on the fact that that length of service was well in excess—at least eight months in excess—of the maximum amount that you were prepared to fund?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We did. Colleges were well aware that the maximum amount that we would fund was roughly a year’s payback, which sometimes meant a 13-month scheme. The 21-month scheme that was offered by some colleges—I stress that the excess above a year’s payback was not paid with our money—was in line with voluntary severance schemes right across Government. We did not say to Edinburgh College or to Dundee and Angus College, “We object to your scheme.” We said to them, “We are not prepared to fund all of your scheme. This is public money and we want to spread it around as much as possible.”

In the case of Coatbridge College, the reason that we objected to the proposed 21-month payment to the senior management team and John Doyle, as we understood that proposal early in 2013—in fact, the payment to John Doyle ended up being for longer than that—was that it was to be for only the senior management team and not the whole college. Had the board come to us and said, “We have reserves. We want a 21-month scheme that will apply to everyone in all the merging colleges, including the principal,” we would not have objected.

Let us be clear that 21 months was a relatively standard scheme across the public sector in Scotland. We were prepared to fund a more meagre scheme, and most of the colleges went for that. The issue with Coatbridge College was the disjunction between the very generous scheme for the senior managers and the 13-month scheme for the other staff. That was what led to our initial objection.

Some of how the Edinburgh scheme was reported in the minute of the remuneration committee meeting at Coatbridge College in January significantly misrepresented it by saying that it was standard across the sector. It was not. It was not alone—there were other such schemes—but it was quite unusual. The minute implied that we would fund the whole thing, but we would not and we did not fund the 21-month scheme at Edinburgh College; we funded up to 12 months’ payback. As you will see in the table that we have given you, the SFC contribution in most cases was considerably less than the whole amount.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

We are not disputing the SFC’s contribution at any point in this proceeding, but you have just said that a 21-month scheme was fairly standard across Government.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes. I think that the standard civil service scheme is 21 months.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

So, the scheme that was proposed for severance as part of this very rapid and fairly forced merger process determined that, although the civil service could offer 21 months’ pay, colleges could not. I am beginning to feel very confused about this. If there is a general Government view that 21 months’ pay is reasonable, it is rather unfair that that can apply to civil servants and the Government but not to college staff.

12:30

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Our view was that, within the limited money that was available—

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

That was the money that the Government decided to give you. The Government gives its civil servants 21 months’ pay as a standard severance package. That was applied as part of the regional scheme in Edinburgh—that is what your table says—and it was applied as part of the regional scheme in Angus. However, because Lanarkshire, Clydebank and the other Glasgow areas did not have that scheme in place, they were not allowed to apply the general Government scheme. Why does the Government say that one class of employee, for which it takes responsibility, is entitled to 21 months’ pay but that it will fund only 13 months’ pay for everyone else? What right does the Government have to do that? Did you point out to the Government that that was at odds with the general scheme that was available?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Should they wish to implement it, the colleges have the right to have a 21-month scheme for all their staff. We objected to the fact that, at Coatbridge College, the scheme was in place for only some staff. Any college could decide to have a 21-month scheme.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

It could do that without a business case. Correct me if I am wrong, but you are telling us that there is nothing exceptional about the Government scheme and that, if someone’s employment history is long enough, they get up to 21 months’ pay.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I do not know the details of the Government scheme and I do not have them to hand at the moment.

We were quite clear that we were trying to achieve mergers across the country. As John Kemp said, we wanted to make the money available to support as many colleges as possible to merge in a very short space of time with the resources that we had. That is why we offered 13 months’ pay, and it is why we encouraged people to use that money.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am not blaming you for what you did in that respect. You operated on the basis of the money that the Government gave to you and, I presume, on the basis of the scheme under which the Government told you to operate—the 13-month scheme.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The decision to limit funding to a one-year payback was taken by the funding council, not the Government.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

But it was based on your examination of the funds. Did you ask the Government to fund 21 months? Did you ask for that in order to follow what Telford, Stevenson, Angus and Ayr colleges did? Those colleges all had a 24-month or 21-month severance payment. Did you ask for that in 2013, thinking that that would be enough money?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We did not ask for 21 months to be funded across the system as a whole. The Government provided a one-off additional sum of money, which I think was £50 million, to support the merger programme and that is what enabled us to afford our contribution of 13 months’ payback—one year’s payback.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

We now know that, as a whole, college redundancies cost £90 million. Therefore, £34 million of that was met from college reserves, which would otherwise have been applied to teaching, students and all the rest. There is a lot of responsibility on the Government for not laying out and funding an absolutely clear programme that was fair in relation to what the civil service had.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I will continue that line of argument. When the Government announced the merger process and gave the funding council the resources to deliver it, was there any discussion between either civil servants or ministers and the funding council about the politically controversial nature of high severance payments?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We were clear what schemes we would offer—

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I know. I do not recall particular attention having been paid to that.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Do you mean high severance payments in the context—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I mean payments of £249,000, £202,000, £126,058, £174,000 and £304,000. Those are pretty high payments by any standard.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I am simply trying to clarify whether you mean payments of 21 months’ salary as opposed to—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

No, I am interested in the sums involved, which you have provided in the table.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

There was frequent discussion with the Government on every aspect.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Certainly, when the issue at Coatbridge College came to light—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

No. As Dr Simpson has just suggested, there was an issue before what happened at Coatbridge College. In some ways, Coatbridge College is a red herring in the argument, because the severance payments there started in 2011-12. At any time, did ministers or senior civil servants say, “Hold on a minute. Are we really going to start paying out £249,000, £202,000, £126,000 and £174,000 in taxpayers’ money?” Was that issue raised at any stage?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

In many cases, the payments are simply the standard scheme multiplied by a high salary.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

That is not what I asked. I asked whether the issue was raised or discussed.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Not specifically.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

There was no interest among senior civil servants or ministers in how much money was going to be used specifically for people leaving the colleges at principal and senior management levels as a result of the merger process.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Everybody accepted that there would have to be a departure of principals if there was going to be change. It was accepted that, provided that that was done within the rules, it was a necessary consequence of merging 25 colleges into 10.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Was there no specific discussion on the level of those payments and how that would appear to an auditor, whether that was an internal auditor, the Auditor General for Scotland or the Public Audit Committee of the Scottish Parliament?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I do not recall any specific discussions. However, the general principle that there was guidance that people should follow was part of the debate.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The Auditor General had produced a report on exits, which was available at that time.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Indeed, and that makes the events a heck of a lot worse.

I question the suggestion that the funding council paid only a certain amount. Let us take the example of the £102,308 that was paid out of a total package of £126,058—the rest of that package will have come from the funding that the college received. Given that the funding council provided the college with all its funding, the idea that it paid only a certain amount is another red herring, is it not? As you will know from the evidence from Coatbridge College, the former principal and chair tried to make that case as well. Those two characters tried to say that the money came from commercial income but they could not justify it. We know that that is not the case.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Indeed. I referred earlier to one of the lessons that we would have learned from this experience had the SPFM not changed things considerably, which is that the system that was in place at the time meant that we did not know the outcome of these things until afterwards. Under that system, auditors would pick such things up and they would either report them to the Parliament in section 22 reports—as two cases were reported—or they would not. Had things not changed, we would have wanted to learn that lesson. If Coatbridge College had been number 1 on the list instead of last, we might have learned that at a different time. We accept that point.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

That is fair.

My other point is on the business case. I want to be clear, as the convener was, that the committee asked about the business cases—you can read the Official Report and see all the times that I asked about the business cases. I was, therefore, not taken with getting a letter saying that I needed to correct my position on that. All along, I was very clear—as was the convener—about the business cases, and what you have said this morning has rather confirmed that. I ask you to back off on that one.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Mr Howells, you became the chief executive of the Scottish funding council in April 2014 and you joined its predecessor organisation in 1994. In that time, were you ever before asked to leave a meeting?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Are you asking whether I had been asked to leave a board meeting or a meeting of that sort?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I had been asked to leave meetings before, although not in the context that you have described. It is not a common event for us to go to board meetings. That board meeting was the first that I had attended in the role of acting chief executive. I subsequently attended a board meeting that I was asked to leave, but I had learned some of the lessons from the Coatbridge College experience and was considerably more forceful in that debate. In answer to your question, that was the first time in that role in that kind of situation.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

I accept that it is unusual for the chief executive of the Scottish funding council to attend board meetings, but what about other staff members? Would they attend board meetings more regularly?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

During the merger process, we attended virtually all the partnership board meetings. There was a lot of interaction during that period.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Was anyone else ever asked to leave any of those other board meetings?

Professor Brown
link

Subsequently, post Coatbridge College and the lessons that we have learned, I have attended two meetings of boards and was asked to leave one, along with Dr Kemp and the chief executive.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

We are here to discuss Coatbridge College, so the convener might stop me here, but can you tell the committee why you were asked to leave those subsequent meetings?

Professor Brown
link

We were asked to leave because the chair said that it was the decision of the board that it would hear what we had to say but it did not want to take any questions or have any discussion and that we would be asked to leave. I objected on a number of occasions and was then accused of not respecting the board. We left under protest and asked for that to be minuted.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Now that that is on the record, I am sure that people will have an interest in the situation. Can you tell us which institution that was?

Professor Brown
link

It was Glasgow Colleges Regional Board.

Professor Brown
link

It happened last year.

Professor Brown
link

Before which change?

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Was it before the new system that we have was introduced?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

It was in March.

Professor Brown
link

Yes, it was in March. It was not specifically to do with severance payments; it was more to do with general governance issues.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Okay. Let us go back to Coatbridge College for a moment. Some of the areas that I was keen to ask about have been covered, but I am interested in the meeting that you were asked to leave, Mr Howells. Did you raise any protests at that meeting? Did you indicate that you felt that that would be inappropriate, or did you just leave?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

My memory is that I attempted to say that I was there to have a discussion. I said that the board must have questions, and I asked what those questions were so that we could talk about them, but I got no response. I think that there were one or two questions, but there was no attempt to pursue that dialogue, which seemed to me to be the right thing to do. I received no response. I reached the point where I had had my say and it was for the board to listen to the guidance and do what was expected of it.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I seek clarity on the £52 million that was allocated to the merger process. Was that specifically for severance payments or was it a more general sum? Dr Simpson mentioned that the amount that was allocated has increased considerably—I think that he said that it was £90 million.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Dr Simpson can correct me if I am wrong, but I think that he was referring to the fact that our funding for the mergers, when it is added to the other funding that came from college reserves and so on, comes to the higher figure. Is that correct, Dr Simpson?

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So how does that differ from the £52 million that was mentioned in the Audit Scotland report?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The £52 million—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Are you over budget? That is what I am asking.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

No. The £52 million is the SFC funding. The figure that Dr Simpson referred to represents recognition of the fact that colleges put in some of their own resources. For example, in Edinburgh, we funded a voluntary severance scheme and paid up to a one-year payback, and the element between that and 21 months came from colleges’ reserves. That is what—

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 182
  3. 11:45 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 255
  4. 12:45 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 15

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.