The next petition is PE1549, by Alan Clark Young, on concessionary travel passes for war veterans.
Official Report · Committee
Continued Petitions
Concessionary Travel (War Veterans) (PE1549)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 15
- Hanzala Malik Lab 13
- Kenny MacAskill SNP 3
- David Torrance SNP 2
- John Wilson Ind 1
- Jackson Carlaw Con 1
The record
35 contributionsI think that we have reached the end of the road on this one.
Yes, I think that we have tested this one to destruction.
link
I am quite happy to close this one, because the Government is not going to change its mind.
I wish to support the petition on the ground that it is an important one. We recognise the physical and mental contribution that armed forces personnel make to this country. It is a good petition.
However, I am not sure how far we can take it at this point. The Government might need to explore the possibility of getting transport providers to provide the service without getting remuneration from the Government for it. Perhaps the provision of the service could be a licence condition. I know that it is not the job of the committee to suggest that, but I would be interested to hear whether the transport minister would be inclined to explore that possibility.
I think that, if the Government were going to do that, it would have suggested it. The negotiations that Hanzala Malik is referring to concern financial transactions, unless he is suggesting that the Government should write to private companies—and one public operator, Lothian Buses, which I should mention, as an Edinburgh resident—to ask that they provide the service voluntarily and free of charge, which would have implications for other service users. I think that the Government will have considered that issue.
We do not know what it has considered.
I take your point, Hanzala. I support the premise of the petition and I think that there is merit in the suggestion. However, to be honest, the reality is that we have asked the Government for its position, we have checked out alternatives and made suggestions to the Government about them, but we have not moved the situation forward. I do not know whether there is much more that we can do.
With all due respect, I do not think that we have specifically asked the Government to consider the angle that I have raised. I think that it is worth giving it another shot to see whether the Government takes up that opportunity. If it says no, that is fine, but the fact remains that that is an unexplored avenue.
If anyone deserves to travel for free on our buses, it is the group in our population about whom we are talking. Therefore, I think that it would not be bad to pursue a plea to the Government to support the policy. I am sure that we could make this petition last another meeting.
We might not have specifically asked about that issue, but I am with you, convener. Throughout my tenure as a regional MSP and as a constituency MSP, my experience of asking bus companies to continue running what they view to be unprofitable routes has been fraught with failure—I am thinking about particular bus routes that are used by the elderly; a valid example is that of pensioners in Edinburgh being able to access Seafield crematorium. We have not been able to achieve success in any of those cases. We might not have heard back from the Government on the issue raised by Hanzala Malik, but my experience tells me that all the bus companies will say, “We only run commercial routes, unless you subsidise us.”
It is the purpose of the Public Petitions Committee to try to change Government policy. However, we are not going to change Government policy on this. We have given the Government suggestions and have been told that is not going to change its policy. Hanzala, you are asking us to ask private companies to adopt the policy, and I do not think that we can do that.
I am not asking for that at all. I am asking the Government to ask the transport providers to consider it. I do not think that that option has been considered. Many off-peak buses are half empty. There is no harm in asking the companies to consider adopting the policy, and I would be grateful if they could be asked to do so. I am asking that we suggest that the Government explore that possibility.
Okay. Do other members have a view on that? I think that you are in a minority of one, Hanzala.
I am quite happy to die in a ditch.
As I have said, I do not want to take this to a vote—I always try to get a consensus.
Convener, we tend to underestimate the sacrifices that our armed forces make around the world, and we are demanding more and more.
I do not think that anyone is underestimating that. We have had that discussion. I think that everyone accepts the premise of the petition; our problem is that we have asked the Government to support a concessionary travel scheme, but essentially it has said no. We have given the Government other options and we have investigated what other options are available. If the only option available is to ask private companies to support a scheme, what we are doing in effect is asking the Government to fund private companies to operate a concessionary travel scheme, but it has already said no to that. Whatever way we look at it, the Government would be providing the funding. For the current concessionary travel scheme, the Government provides money to private companies to run bus services. If we widened the scope of the scheme to veterans, which I support doing, it would be the same concessionary travel scheme, but the Government has said that it is not widening it. You are therefore just asking the same question, although you are asking it in a different way.
No, convener. I am asking for something totally different. I want the Government to ask the transport providers to provide a service free of charge. I am not asking the Government to make a payment.
But that is how the concessionary travel scheme works.
At the moment, yes.
Okay.
There are wider issues around the concessionary travel scheme than just whether someone travels for free. For example, there are the cards and the administration behind them. There are a number of factors for the Scottish Government to consider, and there would be additional cost if it was a Scottish Government scheme. However, the Government has made it quite clear that, at the moment, it does not support adding veterans to the concessionary travel scheme.
As I said, it is not just about asking bus operators whether they will allow veterans to travel for free. Some administration behind that would have to be carried out and verified by the Scottish Government, but it has said that it is not going to do that. Like Kenny MacAskill, I have dealt with some of the bus operators and I know that they are certainly not going to say, “Right, we’re going to let these individuals travel free of charge as long as they produce a card.” If they were that magnanimous, surely they would be saying that anybody over the age of 75 or anyone with certain conditions could travel for free as well.
Every bus operator that operates the transport concessionary scheme gets a contribution towards every passenger who travels, and I doubt very much that they would allow one group of individuals to travel free of charge while the Scottish Government has to pay for everybody else to travel.
I am in agreement with your position on this, convener: we have asked the Government and it has said no. It is clearly open to individual members of the committee to make representations to their own political party with regard to including such a commitment in the manifesto that will be put to the electorate in the forthcoming election. However, I think that what the committee can do has now been exhausted, because we have asked the Government and it has said no.
That is the point, Hanzala. I do not know whether you want to take the issue to a vote. David Torrance wants to make a contribution to the discussion; then I will give you the final word.
link
I am fully supportive of your stance, convener. I support the petition but, as Jackson Carlaw said, the Government said no and the petition is not going anywhere else.
I take on board what very experienced members are saying, but I feel quite strongly about the issue. I suggest that the Government might want to speak to the armed forces to see whether their charities want to engage with it to take the petition forward. I think that there is still an opportunity to do that.
Is this the final meeting of the committee this session?
No. Our final meeting is on 8 March.
I do not see what damage it would do if we took one final opportunity to write to the Government to find out whether it would be prepared to speak to the armed forces to establish whether they would be willing to come on board and engage with it to take forward the proposal. If the Government and the armed forces are not willing to take it forward, I will accept that.
I have to say that I think that that would just be a futile gesture, and I do not think that the committee is into doing that kind of thing. Sometimes we leave petitioners disappointed, and I am sure that Alan Clark Young will be disappointed that he has not got the outcome that he wanted to get.
As a compromise, could I suggest that we write to the petitioner to say that he might want to engage with the armed forces to see whether—
I think that we do that type of thing: we make petitioners aware of our conclusions. In this case, the conclusion is that we have tried our best, the Government has made clear its position and we cannot get the solution that the petitioner seeks. On that basis, we must close the petition, and that is my suggestion to the committee.
Could I suggest that we add a small paragraph to the letter that we write to the petitioner to say that, if he wishes to engage with the armed forces to find out whether they are willing to engage with the Government to take forward his case, that might be an avenue and a different angle for him to pursue?
I suggest that you write to the petitioner to encourage him to do that.
If you send me all the details, I will do that. Thank you.
So, we agree to close the petition.
You went down fighting, Hanzala; the armed forces would be proud of you.
In this meeting
Everything on 9 Feb 2016 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 131
- 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 99
- 11:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 20
- 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
- 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
- 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 35
- 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
- 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
- 12:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
- 12:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
- 12:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
- 12:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
- 12:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
- 12:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
- 12:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.