Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

NHS Centre for Integrative Care (PE1568)

Tuesday 9 February 2016 Public Petitions Committee About 11:00–11:45 Petitions 99 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

99 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Our third item of business is evidence from health boards on PE1568, on access to, and funding and promotion of, the NHS centre for integrative care. I welcome to the meeting Catriona Renfrew of NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, Dr Hugo van Woerden of NHS Highland, Dr Harpreet Kohli of NHS Lanarkshire and Professor Alex McMahon of NHS Lothian.

Members have the usual briefing and background materials on the petition, which will allow us to ask questions. Before that, I point out a correction to paragraph 4 of our briefing note, which should refer to “inpatient integrative care beds”, rather than “homoeopathic beds”.

With that, we move straight to questions. Does any member want to kick off?

Okay. A question has been raised with me about the new facility at Gartnavel. If health boards have decided not to put funding into supporting the CIC and there are people with chronic pain from within your health board areas who are already being treated, where will they now be treated?

Catriona Renfrew NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

There are a number of different strands around the centre for integrative care. A new national chronic pain service is being developed, which will be available to all health boards. There is also the homoeopathic service, which is part of the centre for integrative care at the moment. There is a range of other services, including mindfulness, cognitive behavioural therapy and allergy treatments, but the chronic pain service is the specific service that boards will expect to get from the centre when the new contract is in place with the Scottish Government.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Is that what health boards have decided they specifically do not want to fund?

Catriona Renfrew NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

That question would be better put to the three other health boards. There are shades of difference.

Dr Harpreet Kohli NHS Lanarkshire
link

NHS Lanarkshire’s board took a decision in December 2014 to end referrals of patients to the centre for integrative care, whose services include a range of interventions, including homoeopathy.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Why? What was the rationale for that decision? Was it to do with funding or making better use of money? Is there a clinical reason underpinning the decision?

Dr Kohli
link

The decision was absolutely not to do with costs, as the papers that we have given to the committee make clear. The board’s decision was based on the totality of the evidence on homoeopathy and on other interventions that are provided by the centre for integrative care. The decision was based on evidence, rather than on cost.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Can I get clarification on the decisions of the other two health boards?

Professor Alex McMahon NHS Lothian
link

NHS Lothian still refers patients to the centre for integrative care. We did not take a decision to stop as part of our process of consulting on homoeopathy. We have a service level agreement with NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde on that. NHS Lothian has a referral process that is done case by case.

Dr Hugo van Woerden NHS Highland
link

NHS Highland took a decision in 2010. A board paper took the position that homoeopathy would not continue to be funded by NHS Highland. We have a clinical advisory group that looks at all referrals, so there is an opportunity for individuals to make a case to be referred anywhere; if agreed to, those cases are referred. Over the past five years we have made about two referrals a year to the centre for integrative care. However, those referrals have not been for homoeopathy. A few requests—four or five per year—have not been supported by the clinical advisory group. There has been no recent change in NHS Highland’s position, which goes back to the board paper of October 2010.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Dr Kohli said that NHS Lanarkshire does not make any referrals to the CIC. Can you clarify whether you were talking about new referrals? We have heard in previous evidence that NHS Lanarkshire would continue to allow treatment of patients who had previously been referred prior to the board’s decision. Is that the situation?

Dr Kohli
link

I confirm that that is true, as is the case with other service changes. If patients are already receiving a service, we continue that service.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

On that basis, what evidence did the board hear that was conclusive in respect of its decision to stop future referrals to the CIC?

Dr Kohli
link

As part of the process, we undertook a review of the world literature on the interventions that are provided by the CIC, including homoeopathy and a range of other interventions, and we had discussions with the CIC, which was represented on our review group. We looked at evidence in other reports, and we undertook surveys of GPs and a selected sample of out-patients attending the two out-patient clinics in Lanarkshire. We made available to those who attended the CIC literature about our process of consultation. We took on board comments from the CIC and clinicians, and from patients who attended the CIC. Beyond that, the board decided to carry out a wider consultation to which just under 6,000 individuals responded.

The board considered the totality of the evidence, including the evidence of the effectiveness not only of homoeopathy but of the other interventions that are offered by the CIC. We came to the decision—which was not easy—that we should stop new referrals to the CIC from NHS Lanarkshire.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

You mentioned a number of groups and organisations from which the health board sought advice, information and reports. What was the response from patients in the surveys that the board carried out? The health boards and the national health service talk about a patient-centred approach to care and treatment. It would be interesting to find out what the patients themselves thought about the services that they were receiving, and the decision—or potential decision—by the board not only to withdraw referrals to the CIC but to withdraw homoeopathic treatment services completely in NHS Lanarkshire.

Dr Kohli
link

As the board’s paper—to which you have access—and the minutes of the meeting make clear, we were open and transparent about the feedback that we had received not just from patients but from the public in general. It is undoubtedly true that homoeopathy and the other interventions that are provided by the CIC are popular and acceptable among patients and the public, but that does not mean that they are effective. Otherwise, there would be no need for organisations such as the Scottish Medicines Consortium.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

You said that the treatments are not effective. Who determines whether or not a treatment is effective? Is it the patient or the clinician?

Dr Kohli
link

On how the effectiveness of interventions is measured, we need high-quality and unbiased studies, and we need to look at the literature that exists not just in Scotland and the UK, but worldwide. That is one part of the evidence that the board took on board.

11:15

The board also looked at the feedback from patients. As I have said, we made it absolutely clear that patients and the public find homoeopathy popular and acceptable, but that does not mean that it is effective. I point out that, if that was the case, there would not be a need to have organisations such as the Scottish Medicines Consortium, and there would not be a need for organisations that produce guidelines, such as the Scottish intercollegiate guidelines network or the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Those organisations assess the effectiveness of interventions. It is important to take on board the views of patients and the public, but if we are assessing effectiveness, we need to do it properly.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

If you had been here for our previous evidence session, you would have heard the committee unanimously agreeing that some guidance, including SIGN guidance, does not deal with the issues that patients deal with. The committee is trying to assess the benefits to patients in terms of their treatment and care in relation to how they feel, which allows them to participate in life as actively as possible.

I wish to move over to discuss the situation at the centre for integrative care and its continued viability. Given what we have heard today—that, with the exception of NHS Lothian, health boards are withdrawing or not making referrals to the centre—how financially viable is it for Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board to maintain the level of services for patients who may desire those services, despite the fact that other health boards are not making referrals?

Catriona Renfrew NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

There are two different elements to that. One is the routine business that we call cross-boundary flow, in which other health boards fund us for the services that their patients use. We need to consider the loss of income and how we will reduce costs to reflect that lost income, but the view that we have given the committee is that the centre and the services that it provides are still viable, because the majority of them are used mainly by NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde residents, anyway. There is a question around cross-boundary flow and the centre.

We have also indicated our intention to review ourselves the centre’s services and their costs. As part of our financial planning for 2016-17, we will run about 40-45 service reviews over the next few months to set our budgets for that year. There are two different processes in play, but we have been clear that the viability of the centre is not threatened by the loss of cross-boundary-flow income. It means that we need to reduce costs, because we cannot afford the service to run exactly as it is running at the moment, so we are doing a wider service review for financial planning for next year.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

How many health boards have signed up to make referrals to and will be providing funding to the CIC?

Catriona Renfrew NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

I think that only two or three boards send no referrals at all. As colleagues have said, other boards have cost-per-case arrangements, whereby their residents can flow through on an assessed basis.

NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde’s population is nearly a third of that of the whole Scottish health service and uses about half the capacity of the centre for integrative care. In our view, the viability of the centre will continue while NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde continues to commission it, although the CIC may provide a smaller service because fewer patients are coming in from elsewhere.

We have confirmed to the committee our view that, despite that loss of income, we will be able to continue to run the service, subject to our own review of the service as part of our work around what services we provide.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

It cannot be a satisfactory situation that Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS is providing the core funding, essentially, to have the facility there when some health boards are using it, or buying into it, only on a case-by-case basis and others have decided not to refer patients to it at all. That makes it very difficult for you to plan future funding and to maintain the funding that is required to ensure that the service is there, should anyone from another health board wish to access the services that are provided.

Catriona Renfrew NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

We work with other health boards on three-year arrangements in order to give some stability to the flow of finance and referrals. We have cross-boundary-flow arrangements with all the boards that use our services. An arrangement whereby some boards buy one aspect of a service and others do not, and in which there are different volumes from different boards, is not unusual. There is nothing unique about the cross-boundary-flow arrangements that the centre runs.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

By way of introduction, I want to ask Catriona Renfrew a question of clarification. In 2014, the cabinet secretary confirmed to Parliament that the new national centre for chronic pain will be located at the facility in Gartnavel. What stage of development is it at?

Catriona Renfrew NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

Detailed planning is being done, literally as we speak. There have been a series of discussions this week, and there has been engagement with the public and with patients. That work is going ahead.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

The Scottish Government does not have a national position on whether homoeopathic medicine is a good thing or a bad thing, or on whether it should be provided. Therefore, every individual health board has been left to take a view as to whether this is something that they wish to support. We are focusing on Dr Kohli, whose board supported homoeopathic medicine and has now chosen not to, but some health boards never supported it. I am interested in the inherent contradiction in all that.

It is clear that Greater Glasgow and Clyde Health Board believes that homoeopathic medicine has merits. In essence, Dr Kohli’s position was that the board had taken peer group studies of the effectiveness of homoeopathic medicine across the wider world, rather than the desirability—I will come back to him regarding his patients’ judgment—and concluded that it was not effective.

There seems to be an essential contradiction between the views of different health boards. If Glasgow is committed to continuing to provide that service at the centre for integrative care, it must have concluded that it is effective, otherwise it would not have done that.

Catriona Renfrew NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

As Dr Kohli said, I think that any health board that is doing such a review looks at a whole range of factors, which includes public opinion, patient opinion and an evidence review. The board will weight those factors when it makes its decision. Different boards weight those factors in different ways on a range of services, so you will find a different pattern of health services in greater Glasgow than in other areas. When you take on board patient opinion and public opinion and so on, there is no single scientifically correct answer. The evidence base, as Harpeet Kohli described it, is clear. NHS Lanarkshire considered that factor in making its decision.

We will review the services at the centre again. We said that it is financially viable as it stands, because the majority of its work comes from NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, but we need to look at the decisions and reviews that other health boards have done and revisit whether our position is correct. We will do that.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I am not quite sure where that leaves us in relation to the commitment that I understood you were giving to the centre. Given that NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde financed this treatment, is the treatment effective, in its view?

Catriona Renfrew NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

I suspect that we last looked at the service in detail about 10 years ago. At that stage, we concluded that we would stop providing homoeopathy. The board reviewed that decision as part of a process in which there was a great deal of anxiety and anger on the part of the public and patients. The board took the view that we would continue to provide it.

On the strict definition of effectiveness, I think that the evidence—in the way that Dr Kohli described it—supports NHS Lanarkshire’s position. However, there are a number of other factors that were considered in reaching that decision, which is now several years out of date. When we revisit our conclusions, we will look at the work that other health boards have done. I made the point that the centre is financially viable. That does not mean that it is not subject to review—along with everything else that we do—as we go into 2016-17, when we will need to set a balanced budget.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I appreciate that. Considering the pressures on NHS resources, I would be concerned if we invested in services that you ultimately concluded were not effective, if I can put it that way. I find that that is a difficult conundrum.

Dr Kohli talked about all the international evidence. He then said that he had taken advice from the patients whom he had referred for that treatment. How many of them said that the treatment they had received had been ineffective?

Dr Kohli
link

Did you say ineffective?

Dr Kohli
link

Most of the patients whom we contacted said that they thought that the treatment was effective.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Did you say that they thought that it was effective?

Dr Kohli
link

That was their opinion, yes.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

So you came to the conclusion that you did in spite of the evidence from the patients whom you had referred to the centre. That conclusion was drawn largely from the various other peer groups that you read.

Dr Kohli
link

As I said earlier, the board took on board a variety of evidence, including the literature on effectiveness. What individual patients say is important in terms of acceptability and whether they want such treatment, but it does not show that the treatment is effective.

Dr Kohli
link

They felt that they had benefited from it and the board took that on board. That is noted in the paper that we presented to the board but the critical point is that the board considered the totality of the evidence not only for homoeopathy but for other interventions that the centre for integrative care provides.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I understand the argument that goes on about homoeopathy. I guess that, when I am presented in a committee such as this with professionals who are taking such decisions, I find it slightly ironic that the patient base that was referred to the centre, from whom you can take direct evidence about the treatment that they received, said that it was effective but you discontinued the treatment notwithstanding that fact because there was a totality of evidence from elsewhere that said that it was not effective.

Dr Kohli
link

That is precisely the reason why there are organisations such as the SMC, SIGN and NICE to assess effectiveness. It is important that feedback from patients and the public form part of that, but it does not answer the question about effectiveness.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I suppose that I would conclude that what the patient said was not important at all, but that is just me.

Dr Kohli
link

Absolutely not.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

At the end of the day, it was set aside. The patients’ views were set aside in favour of the broader evidence. Is it just that you needed to save money and that discontinuing the treatment seemed like an obvious way to do it?

Dr Kohli
link

No. The decision was not about cost; it was about evidence. As a doctor and a director of public health, I can state that emphatically. It was not an easy decision for board members to make, because two elements of the quality strategy were in dissonance: the evidence that we have about the effectiveness of interventions, and patient-centredness. The board members’ discussion reflected the difficulties that that poses.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I respect that. What has been the consequence of not referring patients to the centre for integrative care? They must have been given some alternative treatment, which must have had its own consequence for the various services of which those patients will now be taking advantage. I refer not only to their initial appointment but, as I know that that can often be given within a timescale, the subsequent treatment that they receive. What is the prognosis for all the patients who would previously have been referred to the centre?

Dr Kohli
link

We made it clear in the consultation document that, if the decision was not to refer new patients to the centre for integrative care, such patients would have access to other services. We have ensured that they have access to psychological services, the chronic pain management services and self-management programmes within Lanarkshire and we have monitored those since we stopped new referrals to the centre for integrative care.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

What has your monitoring told you? I understand that the patients have access. We all have access in the sense that that is the health board’s provision. It is easy to say that the patients have access, but what has the monitoring suggested is the practical impact on the timeousness of the treatment that they receive?

Dr Kohli
link

Our monitoring has shown that people who may previously have been referred to the centre for integrative care have been referred to those other services and that there is no additional pressure on those services.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Okay, so all those patients will be treated without any additional delay having being created in their treatment or the treatment of others.

Dr Kohli
link

Yes, they have been offered alternatives.

11:30

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

I am getting a bit of déjà vu about the thyroid petition.

On the point that Jackson Carlaw was pursuing, more than 80 per cent of responses to the public consultation wanted the services to remain. I am particularly interested in the situation in Lanarkshire, because the clinic in Coatbridge stopped. In relation to democracy and the patient charter, do you think that it is right to ignore that number of people?

Dr Kohli
link

That was a consultation and not a vote on treatments provided by the centre for integrative care. When the board made its decision, it took on board the point that it has a duty of best value, including investing public funds on interventions that are based on sound science and evidence. It was not a vote. The board had to make a difficult decision that was based on the totality of the evidence and it was mindful of its duty of best value.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

You are saying that you did a consultation and the people who responded were ignored because it was not a vote, it was just a consultation. It seems to me that you just ignored the people who responded.

Can I move on then to—

Dr Kohli
link

No, we did not ignore them. It was brought to the attention of board members and it is noted in the minutes of the meeting. That is why it was such a difficult decision to make. You are weighing up evidence from a range of different sources.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

That is why I think that the issue should have been referred to Scottish ministers. MSPs who represent people should have been more involved in the decisions that were taken.

The other issue is about the conventional services where the patients now have to go. I have seen a response letter from Heather Knox to a plea from a Lanarkshire patient. It says:

“Regrettably there is continued increasing demand for chronic pain services in Lanarkshire which is outstripping the current available capacity.”

Does that mean that, because more people are forced to go to those other services, the delays are becoming commonplace? Is it acceptable for people to experience delays in their repeat treatment?

Dr Kohli
link

You are right that our chronic pain services face challenges, just as there are challenges in a range of other services. We have improved that service but there is more work to do on that. I can let you know about a range of things that we have undertaken to improve access to that service.

Psychological services is the other main service. Lanarkshire is the best-performing board in terms of patients who are waiting for treatment. They have access to a wide range of services, including self-management services.

However, you are right that we face challenges in providing a range of services. That is true not just of those services that patients who would have been referred to the centre for integrative care have been referred to, but of other services, too.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

Are you aware of how many patients the chronic services are having to cope with since the withdrawals in April 2015? If you have extra staff to deal with the demand, how many extra clinicians and nurses do you have?

Dr Kohli
link

To get the precise number of patients, we would need a review and survey of patients, which is not possible. However, we have taken on board the comments from the service itself about the pressure it is under. We have employed additional staff—a nurse specialist—and created additional capacity in medical input. We have revised, reviewed and remodelled the service model so that it is a community-based model rather a hospital-based service. We are also piloting a community service with three GP practices.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

Did you look at the extra costs that the other services would face before you took the decision not to refer?

You said that it is not possible to do a review. I just wonder why it is not possible.

I know that new patients will be given the guaranteed waiting time, so they will be dealt with—and that will include the patients who are moving over from the CIC’s services. Is that why repeat patients are not being considered?

Dr Kohli
link

I said that the decision was not based on cost. We considered the impact on other services, and that is exactly what we have been monitoring.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

That does not sound like a meeting of MSPs with NHS Lanarkshire.

We have witnesses here from other health boards, and I am interested in hearing how they arrived at their conclusions, which appear to be different. What I want to understand is whether those boards carried out similar consultations. Did you have the same access to extraneous considerations? Can you suggest why you arrived at a different conclusion, other than to say that there is something in the air and the water in Lanarkshire that led it to a different conclusion? I want to understand why there seems to be a difference.

Professor McMahon
link

When we did our consultation in 2012, we opened it to the public, staff and any other stakeholders, and almost 4,000 people responded, of whom 75 per cent said that we should not provide homoeopathic services in NHS Lothian. Similarly to Dr Kohli’s experience, the evidence that was presented to the board was the totality of the evidence. Not just the evidence from respondents to the consultation but the worldwide literature on the issue informed the board’s decision.

The continuation of our SLA with NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde in relation to the CIC related to specific therapies, not the totality of homoeopathic remedies. The majority of the patients whom we send currently are receiving mistletoe therapy, which is more for end-of-life-care. That is a specific service that the CIC offers.

We would not deny a patient the opportunity to be referred to the CIC, but we do not uphold every referral. Referrals are looked at clinically, individually. There is a slight difference in that regard, but the process was very similar to the one that NHS Lanarkshire undertook.

Dr van Woerden
link

The issue was discussed at the board in 2010. Since then, NHS Highland has set up a clinical advisory group, and any patient who wants to be referred outside Highland for a specific treatment goes through that group. There is an application process, and each case is considered on its merits.

I am aware that there were a couple of cases on which there was extensive focus in 2013, which NHS Highland referred to the Scottish health technologies assessment group, in relation to two specific forms of therapy by homoeopathy. As I said, we have a process for consideration of each individual case.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

In the context of the original decision to continue to refer, did you conduct a consultation that was similar to the ones that other boards conducted? What was the level of support from people who were receiving or might potentially receive support from the CIC? Did they want support to continue? Were the results similar to those in Lanarkshire and Lothian?

Dr van Woerden
link

I have been in NHS Highland for only a year, so I am not part of this history, but I understand from the chief executive that there was support from the GP community for the decision to be made and for there to be consultation with wider groups. I do not think that there was a formal patient consultation. The decision was made to set up a committee that would consider each request, so NHS Highland took a slightly different approach.

Hanzala Malik Lab Glasgow
link

Dr Kohli, I do not want you to think that I am targeting you, because I am not doing so. Your responses have been clear and I respect the board’s decision in the context of it having to deal with a lot of other issues. I am not looking for Catriona Renfrew to get business from your board, either.

People who attended the centre for integrative care in Glasgow were happy with the services that they received. Are the patients who are not being sent to the CIC equally pleased with the services that you provide in Lanarkshire? Have you carried out a survey of patient satisfaction in that regard? Do you get value for money by keeping patients in-house? I do not know whether you have that information to hand, but it would be helpful.

Dr Kohli
link

As with all our services, we monitor that. With regard to those patients who might have been referred to the CIC, short of following up individuals in a range of services, it would be impossible to track them down. It would be impossible to try to identify them. However, as I say, we monitor the services across all the care that we provide.

Hanzala Malik Lab Glasgow
link

A fuller assessment of the failure or success of a change to any service would determine whether the patient was benefiting from the steps that the authority has taken. In the absence of that, it is difficult to assess whether what the board decided was prudent from the point of view of the patient or in terms of resources. It would be interesting if we could get some follow-up information on that in due course.

An important aspect of all this concerns the satisfaction levels of patients who are receiving the service. As I say, without evidence in terms of facts and figures, it is difficult to judge whether the decisions that were made were fair and accurate. Further, it becomes difficult to assess how the CIC will continue to be a viable operation in the west of Scotland. Are you in any position to go back and get us that information? If so, what sort of timescale would we be looking at?

Dr Kohli
link

It would be difficult to undertake a study of patients who may have been referred. Considering the issues of identification and the difficulties of trying to follow that up, I think that it would be almost impossible to do in the context of NHS Lanarkshire. It might be possible to get that information through a research project that could be undertaken over a long period of time. That would require a significant amount of resources.

Hanzala Malik Lab Glasgow
link

Assessing whether the decisions that were made were wise, whether the patients benefited from the service and whether the service represented value for money is possible only if we have figures to substantiate what is being said about the end result of the delivery of the service.

Dr Kohli
link

As I said earlier, we monitor the services, particularly with regard to the places where those patients who might have been referred are being referred, which is to chronic pain management services and psychological services. That monitoring is not done specifically in relation to those who might have gone to the CIC; it is done more generally.

It is important to note that we have been monitoring complaints about the decision that was taken to stop referrals to the CIC. We have had three such complaints.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

I am sorry to come back to you, Dr Kohli, but you implied in response to Jackson Carlaw and Elaine Smith that the decision that you made was not down to financial issues. However, you made reference to best value. I often ask authorities and others who cite best value as a reason for doing something what their definition of best value is. What is your definition of best value?

Dr Kohli
link

As I said earlier, best value is investing public funds in interventions that are based on sound science and evidence. It is clear in relation not just to homoeopathy but to other interventions provided by the centre for integrative care that that evidence was lacking. It may be that such evidence will increase in the future, and we made that clear during the board discussions.

11:45

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Ultimately, the decision was based on sound science rather than on the patients’ experience of the treatment that they were receiving. This is where we get into the debate that I mentioned earlier about patients’ experience of the health service versus what clinicians and decision makers think is in the best interests of the patient. You have made the comment that you based your decision on sound science—as you see it—rather than on the patients’ point of view.

In response to a question from my colleague Hanzala Malik about whether you can measure the effectiveness of alternative services that Lanarkshire NHS Board is offering to those patients who felt that they may have benefited by being referred to the CIC, you said that you measure the services in general but that you cannot specifically measure the services that are offered to an individual patient in their course of treatment. You said that to do that would involve a large research project. Why can you not measure that? If you and your clinicians decide to refer patients on to services other than those provided by the CIC, why can you not measure those patients’ journeys of experience and the effectiveness of the treatments that they are offered instead of being referred to the CIC?

Dr Kohli
link

I see a practical difficulty in identifying patients who may have been referred to the centre for integrative care if we had not taken the decision. The board has already made the decision. It would be an almost impossible task to identify those people from information from GPs because the policy has changed.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

You said that you received three complaints from patients who were disappointed by the decision that Lanarkshire NHS Board took not to allow them to be referred to the CIC. The difficulty for many patients is that they accept the clinical judgments of the medical professionals because they do not know what other options may have been open to them. In effect, the health board has closed down the route for many patients to receive alternative treatments at the CIC.

The view of the professionals is that it is sound science for individuals to receive only treatments that the professionals believe are appropriate in their medical opinion, rather than their taking a patient-centred approach to treatment. We talk about the patient being at the centre of the treatment that they feel they require in order to make them better and allow them to live a better life.

This is a wider issue and it is one for the other health boards, too. They need to try to understand where the patient fits into the process. If we only take decisions based on the medical opinions of clinicians and GPs, many patients’ views, opinions and wishes will be denied. As Elaine Smith said in our discussion on a previous petition, there is a sense of déjà vu here. The health boards seem to be closing down an option that was previously available for a number of decades.

Dr Kohli
link

Our decision was based not on clinical judgments but on the totality of the evidence that we have. We undertook a review of all the evidence. We did a survey of GPs, and we made it clear in the board report that some favour homoeopathy. However, the decision was based on the totality of the evidence.

As I said, there are really difficult issues here, and different elements of the quality strategy run contrary to each other. The board needed to look at the totality of the evidence, including feedback from patients and the public. It was a difficult decision for the board to make, but it made the decision by weighing up all the evidence that it had.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Convener, I should have declared an interest in the matter. Twenty-two years ago, my daughter, who was two years old, was referred for an operation to have her adenoids dealt with and her tonsils removed because she continued to present with streaming colds and blocked sinuses. The medical profession’s response was that it would remove the adenoids and tonsils to resolve the problem.

At the time, my wife was attending a homoeopathic clinic in Glasgow, and the individual there said that perhaps we should keep our daughter off dairy products and see how she got on. Up to that point, my daughter had been in constant receipt of antibiotics to deal with the problems that she was having. When she went for pre-op, the doctor who saw her said that they could not carry out the operation because she had been on antibiotics within the past six weeks. After we took my daughter off dairy products, at the following visit for the pre-op, the doctor said, “This is a different child you are presenting to me. This child is clear of all the problems that we had identified and were going to operate on.”

I base my view on my experience of what happened to my daughter when she was two years of age. She would have had her adenoids and tonsils removed, but she still has them today and she knows how to manage the problems that she had—she stays clear of dairy products. That is a practical example that I know of. The operation would have cost the NHS money and time, but my daughter was treated in a fairly simple and straightforward way by someone outwith the medical profession telling us to keep our daughter off dairy products and see how she got on.

That is an example of why we need alternative options for many patients. Closing down those alternative options closes down a raft of alternative treatments that would save the NHS money and time and save patients hardship and frustration.

Dr Kohli
link

I respect your experience and views. Over time, the evidence changes. In fact, we are now carrying out fewer tonsillectomies as the evidence base on tonsillectomy has grown. There are alternatives for patients who are not being referred to the centre for integrative care, and we have provided an outline of those.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

I have a short supplementary question on that point, but first I will make an observation. Dr Kohli said that NHS Lanarkshire had made the decision, but we know that, in the past, if a board has made the wrong decision, ministers have overturned it. We know that that can be done.

In these times of stretched budgets, why did NHS Lanarkshire not carry out a cost assessment of the impact of switching the patients to conventional services, which will have involved additional staff and so on?

Dr Kohli
link

We were quite clear that it was not about the cost but about the effectiveness of the service. We identified costs of around £200,000, which we made clear in the board paper, but that was the best estimate of the centre for integrative care. That forms part of the service level agreement that we have with NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

It could be more cost effective to keep the services, and the patients want them, but the board decided not to keep them.

Dr Kohli
link

A fundamental point about cost effectiveness is that the service or the intervention needs to be effective in the first place. That is why we did not—Interruption.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Quiet, please. Members of the public are not allowed to intervene in the discussion.

Dr Kohli
link

That is why our focus and the board’s position were quite clear. We were interested in examining the effectiveness of the interventions that were offered by the centre for integrative care, among other things. We looked for cost-effectiveness studies relating not just to homoeopathy but to other interventions, and we found that they were very few and far between. As for work by Healthcare Improvement Scotland that considers evidence on homoeopathy on a clinical and cost-effectiveness basis, it was not possible to find that.

Notably, the decision on the evidence has been backed up by an Australian review that was undertaken just under a year ago, in March 2015, which concluded:

“there is no good quality evidence to support the claim that homeopathy is effective in treating health conditions.”

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

For clarification, can you tell us who commissioned the Australian study?

Dr Kohli
link

The Australian study was commissioned by a healthcare organisation in Australia. Evidence was examined from throughout the world.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Is that a private healthcare organisation?

Dr Kohli
link

No—it is a Government organisation. I can provide the details should the committee wish to have them.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Ms Renfrew has been wanting to make a point for a while now.

Catriona Renfrew NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

The issue around homoeopathy goes much wider than the balance between evidence and patient opinion. It is an incredibly complex area. To take the tonsillectomy example that was raised, we changed our policies on tonsillectomies and we stopped doing them. For people of my age, no child got to the age of five with their tonsils intact. The policy was that, if someone looked at somebody the wrong way, their tonsils were removed. Your daughter was extraordinarily lucky to live in a different era.

We changed that policy on the basis of new evidence, quite rightly, and we stopped doing tonsillectomies. Parents objected and petitioned health boards saying, “My child’s off school again—I want their tonsils out.” However, the clinical evidence was that that was not the right thing to do.

It is a difficult area of debate. There are many things that patients want that the health service does not provide. We are very focused on homoeopathy today as it is the subject of the petition, but there are a raft of alternative treatments that the NHS does not provide because they are not evidence based. As NHS boards, we try to cling to evidence as a basis for making decisions, because if we did not do that, we would have enormous difficulties in engaging with patients about what we deliver for them.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

We have occasionally been sucked into the idea that this is about the delivery of homoeopathic services, but it is not. Interruption. I do not need applause from the public gallery for saying that. It is about the delivery of integrated care.

You represent the health board—Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board—that provides the facility that we are discussing. How widely do you promote it to ensure that people are aware that the services are available, so that they might put pressure on their GP to be referred?

Catriona Renfrew NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

I do not see it as part of our role to market services. The GPs in our area know the range of services that we have available, and they will make decisions with patients about which services to refer to. We have enough demand for healthcare in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde without actively seeking referrals, but we ensure that GPs are well aware of the range of services that exist.

As I have said, we need to review the centre as part of our review of all the services that we provide, and that will be happening over the next few weeks and months.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

Will you clarify whether the review of the future of the centre for integrative care is happening in light of the reduced cross-border flows?

Catriona Renfrew NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
link

We are commissioning the review on the basis of our overall planning for next year across all our services. As I have said, we are carrying out 44 or 45 different reviews to determine how we can set a balanced budget and meet the needs of our patients in 2016-17. The review is not provoked solely by the cross-boundary flow issue, although that is part of the financial issue that we have. That issue is explicitly part of the reason for doing the review, as we have less income, but we would be doing it in any event.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

I thank all our witnesses for coming and answering the questions that we have put to them.

Some further questions have arisen as a result of our questions, and I think that we need to give the petitioner an opportunity to hear the evidence that we have taken this morning and to respond. If colleagues agree, we will continue the petition and look at the response that we receive from the petitioner and any other correspondence that we receive. A lot of people who are following the petition will have contributions to make to our discussions.

I appreciate your answering the committee’s questions this morning. Thank you very much.

12:00 Meeting suspended.

12:05 On resuming—

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 131
  3. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 99
  4. 11:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 20
  5. 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
  6. 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 35
  8. 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  9. 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  10. 12:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  11. 12:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  12. 12:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
  13. 12:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  14. 12:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  15. 12:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
  16. 12:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.