On which method would tend to give the most generous budget settlement to Scotland, our analysis suggests that that would be the per capita indexed deduction—PCID—method in which you take the block grant adjustment in year 1 and increase it by the per capita revenue growth in the equivalent taxes in the rest of the United Kingdom. That offers more generous funding for Scotland than the other two methods because it takes account of population growth. Scotland’s population grows more slowly on average than that of the rest of the UK, so if you are trying to compare Scotland’s revenue growth to the aggregate growth in the rest of the UK and do not take account of the population growth, revenues per capita in Scotland would have to grow more quickly to keep up because of the population growth in the rest of the UK. By taking that into account, the PCID method is a bit more generous to Scotland.
We have called the other method that we consider in our paper the levels deduction method. It increases the block grant adjustment every year by the population share of the change in revenues of the rest of the UK. We chose to examine that method because it mirrors the Barnett formula, which allocates a population share of the change in spending in the rest of the UK. That method is less generous to Scotland than PCID because revenues per capita in Scotland start off lower.
For example, if revenues go up by £10 billion in England, that might be a 7 per cent increase. Scotland’s population share of that £10 billion is about 10 per cent, which is £1 billion. However, £1 billion growth in Scotland would not be 7 per cent growth, but would be more like 9 per cent, because revenues started off lower. Under the levels deduction approach, you need revenues in Scotland to grow more quickly in percentage terms to keep up with the block grant adjustment, which goes up on a cash terms basis.
The method that gives the most generous funding to Scotland under current conditions, where there is relatively slow population growth and lower revenues per capita to start with, is per capita indexed deduction.
Then there is the question of what is fair, which depends on what you think the degree of risk sharing and equalisation should be across the UK. If you think that the no-detriment principle means that you would not want to design a system that would lead to the unwinding of any redistribution that currently exists between Scotland and the rest of the UK, you would want to choose a system that keeps that level of redistribution built in. That might mean that if revenues go up by the same percentage points per capita—for example, revenues grow 5 per cent per person in England and Scotland—you might think that the Scottish budget would be the same as it would have been without devolution because revenues are growing at the same rate per person and Scotland is performing as well as the rest of the UK. You would want to choose PCID in that case.
On the other hand, if you thought that devolution of a tax meant that it was no longer right to redistribute that tax across the whole UK and that future extra tax revenues raised in England should not be partly transferred to Scotland, you would want to choose the levels deduction approach. That approach means that revenues raised in England stay in England, and revenues raised in Scotland stay in Scotland.
The PCID approach means that there would be some transfer of revenues from England in future years to Scotland, so it is clear what is better for Scotland in terms of the amount of budget, but what is fair depends on your view on whether there should be continuing redistribution of income tax around the UK.