We now move to agenda item 3, which is oral evidence on the Auditor General for Scotland’s report, “The 2014/15 audit of the Scottish Government Consolidated Accounts”. I welcome Caroline Gardner, the Auditor General for Scotland, Mark Taylor, who is assistant director of Audit Scotland, and Gordon Smail, who is a senior manager at Audit Scotland. Caroline Gardner will make a brief opening statement.
Official Report · Committee
Section 22 Reports
“The 2014/15 audit of the Scottish Government Consolidated Accounts”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland 21
- Mark Taylor Audit Scotland 14
- Mary Scanlon Con 10
- Gordon Smail Audit Scotland 10
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 10
- Colin Beattie SNP 9
- Tavish Scott LD 5
- Nigel Don SNP 4
- Paul Martin Lab 3
- Stuart McMillan SNP 2
The record
88 contributionsAs the committee knows, the Scottish Parliament is currently developing its approach to scrutiny in order to reflect its increasing financial powers. The Public Audit Committee’s taking evidence on the Scottish Government’s consolidated accounts is an important part of that. This is the right time to strengthen parliamentary scrutiny of the consolidated accounts; I have provided the report to support your process.
12:00
The consolidated accounts are a critical component of the Scottish Government’s accountability to Parliament and the public. They cover over 90 per cent of the spending that is approved by Parliament each year and show the amounts that the Government spent against each main budget heading. They also show the assets, liabilities and other financial commitments that are carried forward to future years, and contain an annual report in which the Government gives a high-level account of its activities and performance.
My independent opinion on the consolidated accounts is unqualified, which means that I am content that they provide a true and fair view of the Government’s finances.
I will briefly highlight four areas that I address in my report. The first of those is financial management and reporting. The majority of the budget that is approved by the Scottish Parliament relates to spending programmes and administration costs that are covered by the Scottish Government consolidated accounts. The Scottish Government managed its budget for 2014-15 within the overall limit that was set by Parliament, and the accounts meet legal and accounting requirements. They show the financial position and budgetary performance from the perspective of the Government’s role in managing the budget that it controls directly.
However, it is becoming increasingly important also to understand the overall position of the devolved Scottish public sector as a whole. I have previously highlighted that there is no single set of accounts that shows that position, which means that it is difficult for the Scottish Parliament and taxpayers to get a full picture and understanding of the longer-term implications for public finances. It remains firmly my view that the case for enhanced reporting of Scotland’s public finances has never been stronger. Accounts for the whole of the devolved public sector would also complement the Scottish Government’s own accounts.
The second area that I will address is corporate governance. A governance statement that is prepared by the permanent secretary is a key feature of the consolidated accounts. That statement summarises how the core organisation is controlled and directed. In my view, the overarching governance arrangements that were in place during 2014-15 were generally effective and provided an appropriate framework for organisational decision making.
The third area in the report is performance. As I said, the consolidated accounts contain an annual report that summarises financial performance for the year, with particular emphasis on performance against budget. That report also signposts where more performance information is available, and refers to the Scottish Government’s national performance framework. The Government has been building on its arrangements in order to report better how it is directing resources towards its desired outcomes, and the impact that that is having. In my view, a more rounded account of the Scottish Government’s overall performance as part of an expanded annual report would enhance that reporting and help to strengthen accountability and scrutiny.
Fourthly, the other three significant issues that I highlight in my report are the continuing risk to the common agricultural policy futures programme, the suspension of European structural funds programmes, which provide financial support for improvement, and the ONS classification of non-profit-distributing projects and the potential implications for capital budgets.
Overall, the Scottish Government has a good record of financial management and reporting. Governance arrangements are generally effective and the national performance framework is well established. Together, those form a strong base to meet the challenges of tighter budgets and increasing financial powers. Nevertheless, my audit work has identified a number of areas for improvement from that base. We will continue to support independent scrutiny of Scotland’s public finances through all our work and through our engagement with the committee.
As always, convener, my colleagues and I are happy to answer the committee’s questions.
Thank you for your opening statement, Auditor General. We will go straight to questions.
I was surprised to read in paragraphs 34 and 35 that Scotland still does not have a balance sheet. We do not know our income, our expenditure or our pension liabilities in the public sector. I think that I have raised the matter with you before, but I have a serious concern about local government debt, which must be recognised somewhere.
Forgive me, convener, but we have been through a referendum campaign to which deliberations about Scotland’s balance sheet were pertinent, and we will face another referendum campaign sometime in the future, yet after nine years of a Government that is looking for Scotland to stand on its own, to have its own balance sheet and to be financially and otherwise independent, we do not know what Scotland’s income and expenditure are. Why is that?
One of the main messages of my report is that there is a need for that overall picture of Scotland’s public finances. A picture of both liabilities and assets would help Parliament to make better decisions for the longer term, and help taxpayers and citizens throughout Scotland to understand the risks and opportunities that we face. The new financial powers that are coming to Parliament under the Scotland Act 2012 and the Scotland Bill mean that the importance of that information is heightened.
I understand that the Government has accepted in principle the need to develop a more comprehensive picture. What I call for in this report is a more detailed plan and timescale to take that forward as a matter of urgency.
With all due respect, Auditor General, you have called for that before.
I have been reporting on the matter since July 2013, which is why I am now looking for—
I think that you are right; it is not just politicians who want to see the information. Scottish taxpayers have a right to see that information. When do you expect to get that information from the Government and why is there a delay?
The question why there is a delay is one that you might want to pose to the permanent secretary when you take evidence in December. My view is that the matter is becoming increasingly urgent, given the new financial powers that are coming to Parliament as we speak.
Absolutely.
I will just put my final two questions together, which are on European funding and the common agricultural policy. We are about to discuss information communications technology. The futures programme is now three times over budget—it was to be £62 million and the forecast is £178 million. Paragraph 50 in the report says:
“There remain significant risks to successful delivery.”
Paragraph 51 says that the
“risks will remain until full implementation and beyond.”
We have talked about that before. An update would be helpful.
I am very concerned about paragraph 55, which talks about
“the robustness of information being retained by some grant recipients about how ESF funds were being spent.”
Is there likely to be a clawback of funds? Your language is always very polite. Are you implying that funds have not been spent on what they were drawn down for? Would you give the committee a bit more clarity on that?
Certainly. You have asked about the CAP futures programme and the structural funds. I ask Mark Taylor to pick up the CAP futures programme first, then we will come back to your second question.
As Mary Scanlon said, we have brought information on the CAP futures programme to the committee before. Our intention is to report in the new year on progress on the system. We have previously identified concerns and we continue to have concerns that the project is facing significant risks. The Government recently set out its timeline for payments; we hope that arrangements will be in place to make those payments—
Will the payments be made in instalments?
We will stay close to that and report to the committee more generally in the new year.
How significant are the “significant risks”?
There are two issues that the committee will be aware of, but I will provide some confirmation. There are issues around delivery and value for money of the project in terms of how quickly systems can be put in place, how effective the systems are and the associated costs and management of the project. The committee has an on-going interest in that area.
I clarify that it is important to get the systems into play so that the Scottish Government can demonstrate to the European Commission that it is following the rules that it means to follow. As well as making payments to farmers, the real test of the systems will be whether the Government can demonstrate that it has followed the rules and has in place appropriate control systems. We have, as part of our wider programme of work, a responsibility once payments have been made to look at the controls and to report on them to the European Commission.
I know that other members want to come in, so I will leave that one for now. Could I get a response on ESF?
It is right that we highlight structural funds. A substantial amount of money flows from the European Commission in them—something like £81 million in the 2014-15 accounts that we are looking at today.
There have in the past been what are called “interruptions”: they are quite a common occurrence in schemes across Europe. What we are reporting is an escalation in a category called “suspension”. In direct answer to the question, I say that there is uncertainty about the implications of the situation. In an interruption, the managing authority—the Scottish Government—can self-correct for a relatively small amount, which can be recycled through the process. In a suspension, the managing authority—the Scottish Government—has to do a lot more; there are a lot more tests for the Government. For example, it has to produce an action plan for how it will resolve matters.
I explain all that to underline the uncertainty. At the moment, the action plan is with the EC, which will consider it and then decide what to do. It has a range of options available to it, including the self-correction option that I mentioned and the option to apply penalties to the Scottish Government. I emphasise that that will take some time to come through. If penalties are suggested, there will be negotiation between the Government and the EC about what they might be. However, it is a serious situation that we wanted to highlight.
Can you share with the committee today examples of projects in which funds that have been accessed through the ESF have been misused?
I will go down a level in order to provide a bit more detail. Audit is done of individual projects on the quality of evidence supporting expenditure and the procurement rules that were applied. On the basis of a sample, the audit work produces what is called an error rate, which determines the action that is to be taken.
Has the error rate increased in recent years?
It has. That is one of the reasons for the escalation from interruptions to suspensions.
Is that a result of the mismatch between what the funding was meant for and what it was used for?
That is exactly right. There is then a discussion about what the error rates mean, which relates to the amount of money that has to be either self-corrected or corrected through penalties. I am not avoiding your question about individual cases—I could not name any today, so I want to give you a sense of how the process works and how we got to this situation with our concerns about the funding.
link
The report is, as you might expect, a fairly good one for the Government, but with a few questions coming out of it. The figures that you have given for the CAP futures programme have not changed since your previous report, have they?
No.
link
The figures are the same. If I remember correctly, you said that you would come back to us on that at some point. When is your next follow-up due?
There are two critical dates. The first is the one that Mary Scanlon alluded to, which was for the initial payments to farmers. The Government’s intention is to get as many payments out the door as possible in December. There is a hard deadline at the end of June 2016, by when, under European rules, all payments must have been made. Our intention is to report to the committee more generally between those dates, when we have real evidence and are able to comment on the Government’s overall progress in advance of the June 2016 deadline. We will need to manage the timing in respect of the election and when we can report around that, but we have set out in the report that we want to report back in spring 2016.
link
Paragraph 29, which is on page 9 of your report, mentions £302 million for NHS clinical and medical negligence claims. I was quite surprised to see such a large figure. Is that directly linked to a potential liability, or is it a pot that is there just in case?
That relates to the scheme that is used to manage medical and clinical negligence across the NHS as a whole. It is always one of the largest provisions in the accounts. As always, I ask Mark Taylor or Gordon Smail to pick up on the detail of that to keep the committee straight on it.
The provision is an estimate of the amount that is liable to be paid out for medical and clinical negligence cases that have already been brought against NHS bodies. There is a well-established process, which is managed through the NHS’s central legal office, to risk assess each case—in essence, to assess the probability of its succeeding—and to assess the amount that might be payable in each case. That allows the Government to prepare an overall best estimate—I stress that it is an estimate—of how much it expects to have to pay out over time in respect of cases that have been raised.
link
So the figure is not an annual figure; the pot is an accumulation of potential liabilities.
It is a balance-sheet figure. It is the current balance; it is built up over a number of years and will be met over a number of years.
link
Approximately how many cases are there? Can you give me a ballpark figure?
I am afraid that I do not have that information. I can come back to you on that.
link
It is just out of interest. To me, £300 million is an awful lot of money.
12:15
As Mark Taylor said, it is an accumulated figure for all the cases across NHS boards in Scotland. It is updated at two levels—at the level of the Scottish Government’s balance sheet and at individual board level. However, we do not have to hand the figure on the number of claims.
link
Paragraph 35, on page 10, is about pension liabilities. In recent years, pension liabilities have become a problem because of changes in accounting and the way in which actuaries now treat some of the funding. Is there no feel at all for what the figure is nationally? In a small way, I am involved with local trusts and they are crippled by the costs of pension funds.
You are absolutely right about the scale of the liability. The Scottish and UK Governments have taken action to try to manage that liability in the longer term. I ask Gordon Smail to say a bit more about the figures that are available and what is not available in Scotland.
It is right that we raise the issue. In fact, it is a good example that shows why we think that, across the public sector, we need such information to be available in a transparent way so that informed decisions can be made. In our report “Developing financial reporting in Scotland” back in July 2013, we were able to do that calculation based on good-quality audited information and, at that time, the accumulated liability was £66 billion, so it is a substantial figure.
link
Is that just for Scotland?
Yes.
link
Gulp! Thank goodness that we are not likely to become liable any time soon.
In the consolidated accounts, the value of the assets has been increasing over the years as a result of capital investment, but you say that the liabilities have stayed broadly consistent. Why is that? I would have thought that the liabilities would edge up proportionately with the assets.
I think that the asset increase is largely to do with capital budgets being applied and expenditure through the NPD programme and other similar programmes. That increases the amount of public funds that are invested in assets that will have a continuing benefit, which is what the asset balance measures. The liabilities are largely but not exclusively independent of that. In the report we highlight how those liabilities are established in the general business of Government and the organisations that are part of the consolidated accounts.
As part of the overall picture, it is important to understand some of the individual trends within the liabilities that Mr Beattie has highlighted. Clinical medical negligence is one of the areas. We have also highlighted the area of provisions, for example. It is important that there is an understanding of what is happening at the headline level and in the individual balances. Again, through good reporting on the balance sheet, there is an opportunity to have a greater understanding of that.
I have a couple of questions. The first is on paragraph 29, which mentions
“early departure costs of £155 million”.
I presume that that is not just for John Doyle, and that there are a few others in there.
In paragraph 38, the Auditor General makes a point about the need for the Government to come up with a clear plan and timescale for a single set of Scottish accounts. Is it for the Government to produce that single set of accounts or should it be the Scottish Fiscal Commission? Ultimately, should the accounts be independently produced to allow the openness, transparency and scrutiny that you described in your earlier remarks?
I absolutely think that it should be the Scottish Government that does it. There is a useful parallel in that, for a number of years, the UK Government has produced UK whole-of-government accounts, which carry out that consolidation. Indeed, they include the Scottish elements. However, we do not have that picture at a Scottish level, and it is increasingly important that we should have that.
What about the £155 million for early departure?
The £155 million does not relate just to Mr Doyle. It is the figure across the accounts, which are consolidated to the Scottish Government’s consolidated accounts at the moment.
It is a pretty big number.
It is a large number.
Has it gone up?
I do not know. Perhaps Mark Taylor can add to that. I put it in context by saying that we are at a time of reducing the scale of public services and there is a cost associated with that.
Sure—thank you.
Hello again, Auditor General. I want to pick up again the issue of the balance sheet. From the helpful background information that the Scottish Parliament information centre has given us, it looks as though two thirds of the assets are the road network and a substantial other part is buildings. Given that one of the NHS’s on-going problems is valuing its buildings, so that it can balance its books—we will explore that matter again soon—are you comfortable that the buildings’ valuations are meaningful? I do not doubt that they are professionally done, but what assurance can we have that the buildings’ valuations are realisable if needed?
I will ask Mark Taylor, who is my expert on these matters, to respond.
We have of course confirmed that the valuations are professionally and appropriately prepared. To answer the question on meaningfulness, those valuations estimate how much it would cost us to replace the buildings, the road networks and the bridges. That is the fundamental basis on which most of the operational assets, but not all the assets, in the accounts are valued. It gives us a sense of what the cost would be to replace them in their current state of repair if they disappeared tomorrow. That is meaningful in giving a sense of the investment that was made previously in those assets and their value to the public sector.
So they are not assets in any realisable sense, nor do the estimates value what you might be able to get as income if you were to part with them to somebody else; it is actually a shadow liability for what it would cost to replace them.
I do not know whether I would recognise the term “shadow liability”, but it would be the cost of replacement.
No accountant would recognise that term.
We make it clear in the report that the assets that are declared as surplus get valued on the different basis of how much they would bring if they were actively marketed, which is an estimate of what they would realise. From memory, I think that the figure for that is £42 million. However, the vast bulk of the assets have been built and are established and will continue to be used for public services.
Can I just add to that very briefly, Mr Don? It is worth noting that, as we say in the report, because there is no single picture of the overall assets and liabilities for Scotland’s public sector, the figure for assets is not complete. Probably the most obvious example of why that does not quite make sense is the roads network, in that the national roads network is on the consolidated accounts balance sheet but a large chunk of the roads network is the responsibility of local authorities and is on 32 different balance sheets and valued on a different basis. There is a real need to pull that together.
Thank you for pre-empting my next question.
I suppose that the same thing applies to the figures for the private finance initiative in respect of schools and hospitals, because one is on the local balance sheet and one is on the national balance sheet.
Local authority assets and liabilities are, for good reasons, on local authorities’ own financial statements. NHS assets and liabilities are within the consolidated accounts, but we do not have an overall picture of them.
That makes the same point. One of the largest aspects of the sum for financial liabilities is of course PFI. The figure for the early PFI contracts, and even some public-private partnership contracts, will be reducing, but of course there is the additional sum for new NPD contracts. Is the overall figure increasing or decreasing?
The reports that I have published on developing financial reporting have included a graph that shows, by year, the pattern of committed liabilities that are in place. As you would expect, it moves up towards a peak in the early 2020s, and then it starts to tail off. However, it is added to as new commitments are made.
I want to ask about financial assets. The largest financial asset is the student loan sum, which is £2.685 billion. What are the risks associated with that? Have you calculated how much of that sum is likely to be collected and how much is not?
That is a particularly complicated area. I ask Mark Taylor to do his best to talk you through it.
Thank you, Auditor General. Laughter.
Sorry, Mark.
Briefly, that liability is estimated on collectable debt, and we are happy with the Government’s estimated figure for that and are happy that that amount is currently collectable. There are provisions against non-payment of debt in the estimate of that amount.
So the £2.685 billion excludes a certain amount. Do we have a figure for that?
I do not have the figure for it, but I can provide a bit more depth. Modelling is done that looks at a range of things, including the profile of people who still have amounts outstanding, which covers things such as their income and their likely income. We do a lot of work on that model to satisfy ourselves that the figures that the Government produces and includes in the accounts are materially correct. There is a process for doing that.
Do we have a figure for the amount that is being written off every year, for whatever reason?
Yes—it is in the accounts.
I missed that.
There is a movement shown in the accounts for that.
I have another question about the on/off issue. With the European system of accounts 2010 process, the ONS is looking at whether assets should come on balance sheet or go off balance sheet, and that is holding up a number of projects. Is that having any effect on the consolidated accounts?
For complex reasons, that is an issue that affects budgeting much more than it affects financial reporting. I will ask Mark Taylor to talk you through it.
The question of whether assets are on balance sheet or off balance sheet is one for the accounts. Generally, the answer to that question is that they are on balance sheet and are recognised in the accounts. As the Auditor General says, the ONS issue relates to the way in which budgetary control and spending controls are currently applied. In effect, the accounts already adopt the approach that the ONS is moving towards.
Are the problems with VAT and the centralisation of the police service and with the fact that it has been announced that the colleges are on rather than off balance sheet having any effect? Those are separate issues.
You raise a whole bunch of questions. Essentially, those bodies currently fall outwith the consolidation boundary for the accounts, so the extent to which the accounting for those issues applies to those bodies lies outwith the consolidation framework. To come back to one of our central points, a wider set of accounts would wrap those up in one place.
That point has been made three or four times, and I think that it needs to be addressed urgently.
link
I found the report very useful. There is something in it for all of us. You are complimentary about what the Government does. In paragraph 60, on the national accounts classification, you say:
“The Scottish Government has applied the correct accounting treatment in preparing the accounts.”
However, there is the issue of ESA10, and in paragraph 64 you say that the Scottish Government
“is currently in discussion with HM Treasury on contingency arrangements”.
Are you aware of how those discussions are progressing?
I think that that is a question that it would be best for you to explore with the permanent secretary next month.
link
Okay.
Notwithstanding the balance sheet issue that has been raised, in paragraph 67, which forms part of the conclusion, you say:
“The Scottish Government has a good record of financial management and reporting, governance arrangements are generally effective and the National Performance Framework is well established.”
Given that additional powers are to come to the Scottish Parliament through the Scotland Bill, are you content that the existing arrangements represent a good framework to build on, albeit that some additional reporting mechanisms will be required as a consequence of those further powers?
I should make it clear that I am focusing on financial reporting and that there is a much wider framework to be agreed around the new financial powers.
My conclusion is that what we currently have in place on financial reporting and performance reporting provides a good basis, and I have identified a number of areas in which improvement is urgently required in order to underpin the new powers and the decisions that the Parliament will have to make about them.
I thank the Auditor General and her team for their evidence. We will consider the evidence that we have received in private under item 5.
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Nov 2015 →- 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 588
- 11:45 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 88
- 12:15 Section 23 Report Committee business · 26
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.