Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Reports

“The 2013/14 audit of Coatbridge College: Governance of severance arrangements”

Wednesday 25 November 2015 Public Audit Committee About 09:00–11:45 Committee business 588 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

588 contributions · showing 1–200
Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Item 2 is oral evidence on the Auditor General for Scotland’s report, “The 2013/14 audit of Coatbridge College: Governance of severance arrangements”.

Before we begin, I want to say a few words about the email that we received late last week from the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council, which forwarded a copy of the Linkston report. I know that colleagues share my frustration that the report has only now been shared with us by the funding council, particularly as the council was in discussion with the cabinet secretary in July this year about its relevance to the governance issues at Coatbridge College. I appreciate that there might have been sensitive issues around the report, but nevertheless, in my view and the committee’s view, it would have been of assistance to the committee had the report been provided to us much earlier in our work.

The funding council also wrote separately last week with information that relates to principals’ severance arrangements. The council has undertaken to get the missing information to the committee by 7 December and advised that it did not see business cases because it relied on the audit process. I think that the committee will agree that it is imperative that we receive all the information and relevant documents that have been requested before we move on with our deliberations on our draft report.

I welcome our first panel of witnesses. John Doyle is the former principal and chief executive of Coatbridge College, and John Gray is the former board chair of Coatbridge College. I understand that Mr Gray wants to make a brief opening statement.

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

Thank you, convener, and good morning ladies and gentlemen.

The last time I was here I talked about setting this inquiry in the context of the college merger process. The merger policy was instigated by the Scottish Government, and once the groupings of colleges that were to be merged had been finalised, very little direction was given as to how the process should be managed. College groupings were left to get on with the process in the best way they could.

In Lanarkshire, the proposal started out being for a federation structure. It then changed to a merger proposal, and in the middle of that Cumbernauld College and Motherwell College agreed a merger without involving Coatbridge College or South Lanarkshire College. Coatbridge eventually capitulated and was, in effect, taken over. South Lanarkshire College, as I understand it, is still not an integrated part of New College Lanarkshire.

As the process evolved, many discussions took place on process and rule setting, particularly with regard to severance payment arrangements for the many staff who were clearly going to lose their jobs through no fault of their own. The board policy from the start was to try to ensure that Coatbridge College staff were fairly treated and given proper job opportunities in the new structure, and that there was a realistic severance scheme for those who would be forced to leave.

As far as I am concerned, the severance arrangements when I left are clearly described in the remuneration committee and board minutes of 23 October 2013. At no time was any suggestion made by anyone that the payment to John Doyle, in particular, was excessive or should be stopped or reconsidered.

In short, the important points for me are that, at the end of the day, all staff in Lanarkshire colleges who lost their jobs were to receive the same compensation. There was no proposal for any enhanced payment to senior managers. There was only one scheme.

For the principal, the contractual entitlement to six months’ pay in lieu of notice is a contractual matter and is totally separate from any severance pay agreement. There was no payment made regarding his pension.

The funding council made it clear that it would fund only up to the guideline amount and that if the board wanted to exceed that amount that would be its responsibility, and the college would have to fund any balance that was required. That was understood by the whole board and was agreed without question at the meeting.

I want to clarify one or two other wee points. John Doyle never asked me for a severance package, either verbally or in writing. I served as chairman of the board for almost 12 years without remuneration. I was not entitled to any severance payment and nor did I receive any—contrary to some reports.

The funding council confirmed that other colleges had made severance payments in excess of the guideline amount. Did their auditors comment on that, and will those colleges be subjected to the same audit process to which we have been subjected? I leave those questions with the committee.

In conclusion, I believe that there was on my part no failure of governance at Coatbridge College. The Auditor General for Scotland clearly did not examine the situation in sufficient detail before commenting in her report; she clearly did not see all the relevant documents and, in particular, she made no approach either to John Doyle or to me for explanation or clarification. The Auditor General’s comments have no foundation in fact. Her conclusions are entirely her own: they were insulting and damaging and should now be retracted. If they will not be, I would like to know the reason why.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Mr Doyle, I will open the questioning. Can you clarify for the record that you were the accountable officer for Coatbridge College?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

That is correct.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

For how long were you the accountable officer?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

That was for the period for which I was in post—from November 2004 until I left on 31 October 2013.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Is it correct that the responsibilities of the accountable officer are set out in the Scottish funding council’s guidance of 2000?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I understand that they are.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I take it that that is a document that, as accountable officer, you would have been familiar with. Is that correct?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I made myself aware of the document at the time through the clerk to the board. She sent me a copy—as she did for everyone else on the remuneration committee—and it was put on the board’s intranet. I read it at that point.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You made yourself aware of it, so can I refer you to paragraph 18 of the document? Part of it states:

“The college’s Accounting Officer has a personal responsibility to notify the Council’s Chief Executive if they consider that the college or the Board of Management plan a course of action that is in conflict with, or would infringe, guidance or instruction that has been issued to the college or appropriate best practice. This is particularly important if controversial or novel action is being contemplated in any severance package.”

That paragraph makes it clear that because the college was proposing to go beyond the principles of the 13-months severance package, you—as the accountable officer—had a personal responsibility to provide that information to the SFC. Is that correct?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Can I just confirm that everyone here has a copy of the submission that I sent in?

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

We have the submission.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I am going to address that, because I hope that in my submission on Monday I cover part of that. I will expand on that, if I may, convener.

The morning after the remuneration committee meeting—which was on 28 January 2013, if memory serves me right—Mr Gray came to the college and had a meeting with me about that committee and, in particular, the conversation about my proposed severance agreement. I had read the documentation and we had a long conversation about the decision-making process by the remuneration committee, and the rationale behind the decision that it had made. As I said in my statement, I went over every aspect of it in relation to suitability, affordability and the rationale. I thought that I had made that clear in my submission. However, I am happy to expand on it.

I was very aware of the SFC guidance. I wanted to make sure that I was engaged with the remuneration committee, in the context that the guidance provided—if there was something different from that guidance. The explanation that I received from the chair of the board, who had met the remuneration committee, was—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Can I just clarify the question that I asked you? I will allow you to come back later to the information that you have provided, but please answer the question that I put to you.

It is very clear that the proposal was to go beyond the 13-months severance package that was recommended by the SFC. Within paragraph 18 of the guidance it is made clear that you had personal responsibility because you were going beyond the recommended 13 months. I cannot find any legislation that says that you could decide at any point during that process that you were no longer the accountable officer. It is very clear that you had legal responsibility, as the accountable officer for the organisation, to advise the SFC that the board was proposing to go beyond the terms that the SFC recommended. Why did you not advise the SFC of that?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

On the basis that—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You are not being straight with us, Mr Doyle. That is one of the reasons why you are back in front of the committee. You are creating a smokescreen and sending us down all sorts of different pathways. It is a very clear question. Why, as the accountable officer, did you not provide that information to the SFC?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Well—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

And why did you not also provide it to the external and internal auditors? The SFC guidance document makes it very clear. I expected you not just to be aware of the document, but to know in detail that that was your responsibility as an accountable officer.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I take exception to the idea that I have in some way laid a smokescreen.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I think that you have.

09:15

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Let me answer the question—if I may, please—directly. I was advised by the chair of the board and the remuneration committee the next day that he had, in accordance with the guidance, spoken to Mark Batho, the then chief executive of the funding council, and advised him of the remuneration committee’s decision. It was quite clear to Mark Batho that the remuneration committee, or the board, was going down a path that was in excess of the 13-months guideline. I was made aware of that the very next morning. I had a long conversation with the chair of the board on those aspects, and I was satisfied that the funding council, at chief executive level, was well aware of the detail, because the chair, as per the guidelines, had spoken to the chief executive about it.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I refer to paragraph 19 of the SFC’s guidance, which says:

“It is not acceptable for the Accounting Officer”—

you—

“to abstain from their personal responsibilities by contending that they are not part of the Remuneration Committee or form any part of the decision process. As the intended beneficiary of the severance package, the Accounting Officer will, at some stage, be made aware of the settlement and he/she must then advise the committee on the appropriateness of their intended action.”

That makes it very clear that, after the decision is taken by the remuneration committee, you should give advice to the committee on the appropriateness of the action that it has taken. Should not you have advised the committee then that it was going beyond the terms of the guidelines, and that you would have to report that to the funding council? It was not the responsibility of the board chair to do that; it was your personal responsibility. You were paid £116,000 per annum to be the accountable officer—a significant responsibility—for the college. Why not take that seriously?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I take it very seriously. That is why I explained in my written submission—but let me explain again—that I had, before I signed any agreement, a long conversation with the chair of the board, in which we went over all the aspects appertaining to the decision-making process and, in particular, the rationale and affordability of a severance package that was in excess of the guidelines.

Only when I was satisfied—as I have written—that the remuneration committee had covered all the facts, that it had a business rationale for its decision making, that it had looked at the costs and the reserves and that the package was affordable—the chair of the college’s finance committee was in attendance—was I also satisfied that I had met, at that stage, all the requirements of the guidance. It was in no way a situation in which I was trying to hide anything. John Gray and I had a long conversation. Only when I was satisfied that everything had been discussed and had been realised by the remuneration committee’s members, and they had made a unanimous decision, did I say, “That’s fine. I am now satisfied.”

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

What is very clear from the SFC guidance is that you had personal responsibility. You were the accountable officer. The committee, the board and the federation were not accountable. That accountability is what you were paid for, but you did not carry that through by ensuring that the funding council was aware that your board—and you were the accountable officer for—

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I am sorry, convener.

I had just been briefed by the chair of the board that he had had a long conversation with the chief executive—

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I was satisfied that the funding council was aware at the highest level—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

It was pretty convenient, though, was it not?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I would not say that it was “convenient”.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

It was very convenient for you personally, was it not, not to have to advise the funding council that your board was going beyond the 13 months mentioned in the guidance?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

The guidance is quite clear—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

It is clear—absolutely.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

The chair of the board followed the guidance in contacting Mark Batho, the chief executive—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I am not referring to that guidance. I am referring to the SFC guidance that refers to you—I will speak to Mr Gray later—as having the accountable officer’s role. You had personal responsibility for that, not Mr Gray.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I considered that responsibility to have been met when I was briefed by the chair of the board that he had had that conversation and that the funding council was well aware of what the board proposed.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Finally, I move to your evidence to us on 28 October, in which you referred to the “federation action plan”. You advised us that that was the terms by which the severance package was agreed.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I am not sure what you mean.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You will see in the Official Report of our meeting that you referred to your terms being set out in the “federation action plan”. Is that correct?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I am sorry, convener; I do not mean to be obtuse, but my terms of what?

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I am referring to the action plan for Lanarkshire. If you read the Official Report, you will see that you referred to the federation action plan at columns 41 and 44.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Do you mean in the context of severance packages for the federation?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Absolutely.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So that document was agreed by everyone in the federation.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

From memory, I am sure that I advised you a couple of weeks ago that, in November 2012, South Lanarkshire College proposed a voluntary severance scheme, which was based on the Edinburgh model.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So, to clarify, that was a proposal.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Absolutely.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

To refresh your memory, you referred to

“a federation action plan—a scheme for all staff in all four Lanarkshire colleges—and ... it was the intention of my board for that plan to be made available to all staff”.—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 28 October 2015; c 41.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So that is the scheme that you eventually took advantage of. Is that correct?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

To finish answering your question, once South Lanarkshire College had presented a proposal to the principals forum of the federation, it was—as you correctly said—then given to the federation board, which consisted of the chairs and principals of the four colleges. The board had not had an action plan and, quite rightly, the funding council was asking us to progress the federation along more productive lines. The action plan that was tabled before the federation contained many things, including the severance package that South Lanarkshire College proposed. Coatbridge College intended to embrace that package for all the staff in Coatbridge.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Were you the person who proposed the action plan?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

No, I did not propose any action plan.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

New College Lanarkshire advised us that no such plan existed and referred to a

“document prepared by Mr Doyle in 2012”.

I understand that New College Lanarkshire will provide us with further information, but it advised us that the action plan was prepared by you and that you circulated it to other Lanarkshire principals.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

That is not technically accurate.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Well, tell us what happened.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I am happy to do so, convener. What happened was that all the chairs and principals were at a meeting with the funding council, the Scottish Government representative and Linda McTavish. John Kemp of the funding council advised and cautioned the federation board that there was not enough satisfactory progress on achievements by the federation. It was suggested that we required some sort of action plan. Coatbridge College agreed to produce a draft of that action plan, which contained all the actions for all four colleges and for the funding council if appropriate. Coatbridge produced a draft.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

When you say Coatbridge, you mean you.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I mean John Gray, me and the executive team.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

It says here that you were the author of that report.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I was not.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Was the author John Gray?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

No, that is not what I said.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Who prepared the document?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

The college management team and I did.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So it was the management team.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

When you are producing something for other colleges—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Did that document refer to severance arrangements?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

It included a number of things, including severance arrangements.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

How helpful do you think it was that you were the author of your own severance arrangements? Was that appropriate?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I am sorry, but I was not the author of my own severance arrangements.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

That is what you said that the action plan referred to.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

The action plan contained many things, convener.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

It also contained the severance arrangements.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Those were proposed by South Lanarkshire College.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

That is what I am saying. You were the author of a report—

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

No, that is not true.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

That is what New Lanarkshire College says. Are you saying that it is lying?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I did not suggest that. Let me clarify quite clearly. There were four colleges in a federation and the funding council advised us that we were not making satisfactory progress and that it was looking for a SMART action plan that would take the federation—which would bring together four individual colleges—towards seeing some collective benefit. There had not been satisfactory progress, according to the funding council, and it was agreed that we required an action plan.

John Gray and I said that Coatbridge would produce a draft. Any of the other colleges could have produced a draft. There were many things in that action plan. One of them was a severance agreement that was raised by South Lanarkshire College. I did not raise it; I did not recommend it to the federation. We simply included it in the action plan. The action plan then went back as a plan some time in December 2012 or January 2013.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Was it ever agreed—yes or no?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I cannot remember, to be honest. It was presented—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

The way that you presented it to us was that you agreed on the deal because it was the federation model, which your severance arrangements were based on, but that was never formally agreed.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I am sorry, convener—you are talking to the wrong person. I did not produce the severance package for myself at all. I had no insight into what was being discussed—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You said in your evidence to us on 28 October 2015 that you took advantage of that particular—

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I did not say that I took advantage—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You said that that was the basis on which you agreed your severance package. Representations were made on your behalf and the agreement was that you would take that package. There were two severance packages—that was one of them, and you took advantage of that one.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

What was the other one?

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You said that there were two severance packages.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

No, I did not.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I think that I saw that in the Official Report of our 28 October meeting.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I am sorry—I did not say that there were two severance packages.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You did. You said that there were two severance packages on the go and that was why you had to—

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

No, I am sorry—I did not say that there were two severance packages on the go. What is the other severance package that was on the go, as you say?

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You referred to the packages in the Official Report.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I have no recollection of another severance package apart from the Edinburgh model.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You said that DWF Biggart Baillie had to be brought in because there were two packages. Two proposals were on the table and that is why Biggart Baillie had to be brought in to advise the board—

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Oh—sorry. You are talking about what happened eight or nine months later, not about what happened in January—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Yes, I am—absolutely.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Forgive me—you did not say that. Nine months later, in September 2013, New College Lanarkshire decided to go down another route, which it was perfectly entitled to do. I was not aware that it was going down another route until the information was published. I thought that I had made that very clear.

On 28 January 2013, eight months before that, only one package was being discussed by the four principals and that was the package that South Lanarkshire College proposed. I had no input into its design or its development or indeed into the proposal. It was not until September 2013 that there were two packages. One was the federation package, which was lying there.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

That is the one that you took advantage of.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I am sorry, convener—I did not take advantage of anything. I did not propose my severance. I did not propose any aspect of my severance package.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

That was the severance package that you benefited from in the end.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I would have benefited from it, but I did not propose it.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I appreciate that but, in the end, the decision was to agree to the package based on that model. Is that correct?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I presume that it was based on that model. That is what the chair has said.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Mr Gray, did I hear correctly that you said in your opening statement that John Doyle never asked for a severance package?

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

That is correct.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Did you never discuss a severance package with John Doyle prior to the remuneration committee deliberations on 28 January 2013?

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

No.

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

No.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I have a letter here—the information is coming in by the hour. The letter was from you to the members of the remuneration committee. In regard to John Doyle, you stated:

“having talked to John at some length, it is now clear that John’s position in Lanarkshire is becoming ever more difficult ... we should now agree a severance package with him on”

that basis. In the letter, you proposed a pay increase of 6 per cent and you said:

“I am ... happy to recommend ... an arrangement based on 2 years gross salary which I would certainly not consider unreasonable”.

You went on to say:

“I believe that this ... will allow the Board, staff and students to celebrate John’s worth and success and would allow him to go out on a high without being ‘picked over’”.

You sent that letter to six members of the remuneration committee. We have the evidence here, so I thought that I was hearing things when you said that John Doyle had never asked for a severance package and that it had not been discussed. You openly admitted in that letter, in asking for the remuneration committee to agree to have a meeting about the issue, that you had

“talked to John at some length”.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

But not about the severance package.

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

But not about the severance package. It is absolutely not in that letter.

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

We talked to John Doyle about him leaving the college in the circumstances that were on the table. It was my duty to talk to him about his future with the college, which is exactly what that letter said—I talked to him about his future.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The letter to the remuneration committee states that

“John ... now believes that the best way forward for all concerned, and, bearing in mind that there will only be one Principal’s job ... that we should now agree a severance package with him”.

So you are adamant, despite everything that you said in that letter, that you never ever discussed a severance package with John Doyle.

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

That is correct.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

With whom did you discuss the 6 per cent pay increase and the two years’ gross salary? There was also a pension figure of £90,000, which in hindsight you decided not to pay. Did you just come up with all that on your own?

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

We discussed it with the remuneration committee, which was always—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Your letter to the remuneration committee asked for a meeting, and you even gave your home phone number. You stated in it:

“If you are happy with the proposal that we offer John voluntary severance as outlined above ... I will of course ask Lorraine to convene a Remuneration Committee meeting”.

That was the meeting on 28 January 2013. The letter is your invitation to the meeting that resulted in John Doyle getting £304,000, which is well over what the SFC’s guidance recommended. Your letter to the remuneration committee asked its members to come to a meeting, and you put in the letter the exact terms, with no mention of SFC or any other guidance.

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

SFC guidance was available to all members of the remuneration committee and all members of the board.

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

They did not do their homework as people should do.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You were the chairman. You wrote a lengthy letter to the remuneration committee. Why did you not mention the SFC guidance? You said in the letter that you had

“looked at the Edinburgh model”.

Why did you not mention that your offer was well over twice what the SFC’s guidance recommended?

We also have a letter from six members of the remuneration committee. I am happy to read out their names, but I think that you are familiar with them. The letter states:

“At the 28th January 2013 Remuneration Committee Meeting the SFC Guidance ... was not given to us at the meeting nor were we signposted to it ... during or after the meeting.”

There was no mention of SFC guidance in the notes of the meeting; there is no mention of consideration of SFC guidance in any notes. In my view, you misled the remuneration committee. Its members did not know anything about the guidance. They thought that when they were signing up to “celebrate John’s worth”, as your letter said, and letting him

“go out on a high”,

they were signing up to something that was statutorily acceptable and accurate. Is that correct?

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

The remuneration committee members did not read the papers that were prepared for that meeting, then. Those papers were circulated to them on the intranet; that is what we did with our board papers and committee papers—that information was in circulation. They did not read what was in front of them. They were provided with that information.

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

It was on their laptops.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Six members of the remuneration committee wrote to us on 24 November 2015 and told us that they were not provided with that information—they cannot all be wrong. One might have had a wee memory lapse, but they cannot all be wrong.

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

The information was in the papers that were circulated.

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

It was in the papers that were circulated to them before the meeting.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

It was not in the papers that were circulated.

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

The papers that were circulated for the meeting were on the board intranet; that is how we circulated papers. We did not provide piles of copies. It was all on their laptops.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

In their letter, the six members said, “nor were we signposted”.

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

Okay, that is—

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Mrs Scanlon, if I may—

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Of course.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I will give you a chance in a minute.

They cannot all be wrong, Mr Gray. Are they all lying? Did they all come along here and lie to us?

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

No, I do not think that they did. I think that what—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Well, somebody is wrong. Is it the remuneration committee? None of them were signposted; none of them knew anything about the SFC guidance, which would have been far less generous to Mr Doyle than your recommendation, but you said that they did. Someone is wrong. Is it the six members of the remuneration committee or is it you?

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

You can blame me for perhaps chairing a poor meeting, but the members of the committee had the papers in front of them.

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

If they chose not to read the papers, that is their business.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You came up with a 6 per cent pay increase and two years’ salary, which is even more than any Edinburgh model. How did you come up with that very generous severance package for John Doyle? Who did you discuss that with, if it was not John Doyle—despite your talking to him at length? What did you talk to him about, when his position in Lanarkshire was becoming more difficult, if not his severance package? Your letter to the remuneration committee was all about his severance package.

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

I talked to John Doyle about lots of things about the business of the college.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Why then did you say in your opening statement in your letter that you had

“talked to John at some length”

and go on to recommend the severance package?

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

As you have heard many times, the severance package information was based on the Edinburgh model as we understood it at that stage—that is, what people in Edinburgh had been offered and had received. That model had also been tabled by South Lanarkshire College as a proposal for what should happen in the four Lanarkshire colleges.

We were talking and meeting about John Doyle’s severance package at that point. We—you could say erroneously, if you like—thought that the Edinburgh model would prevail, and the board and the remuneration committee were happy to give John Doyle that offer. He did not concoct that offer himself in any way.

If I got information, it would have been not off the top of my head but from the human resources director, who was familiar with the sort of severance schemes that were around and were talked about at the time.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

In the same letter, which was all about a severance package, you started by saying that you had

“talked to John at some length”.

We will leave it there. We have the evidence and it will be for our report and for others to look over.

Did you say to the remuneration committee that the SFC had any objections to what was being proposed, or did you say that the SFC had no objections? What did you tell the committee?

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

What I discussed with Mark Batho was—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

No, I am asking what you discussed with the remuneration committee. What did you tell its members in relation to the SFC guidance, which you knew about and they did not? Did you tell them that the SFC had no objections to your generous offer to John Doyle “to celebrate John’s worth”?

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

What we talked about was my discussion with Mark Batho, which made it clear that, if we wished to pay more than the guideline, we were responsible for the additional cost ourselves in the college.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Did Mark Batho say that it was fine to give John Doyle a 6 per cent pay rise and that it was fine to pay 21 months’ salary plus three months’ salary plus an extra six months’ salary? Did Mark Batho endorse that?

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

It was in the discussion that I had with him.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Did he endorse the proposal? Did he agree with it?

John Gray Former Board Chair, Coatbridge College
link

Just hang on a second. I said at the very beginning that the six months’ pay in lieu of notice is nothing to do with the discussion. It is entirely a contractual matter. John Doyle had a contract that said that. I wish that you would not keep putting it all together.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

It is in the Auditor General’s report.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

It is in the Auditor General’s report. We would be failing in our duty as the Public Audit Committee if we did not cover it.

My next question is for John Doyle. As the accountable officer, why did you not inform the internal auditor or instruct the internal auditor to be informed about the severance arrangements and payments until an informal meeting on 28 October 2013, eight months after you had received your signed paper from the January meeting?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

As you will have seen from my written submission, I spoke to John Gray on the day after the remuneration committee meeting. We discussed the role of the internal auditors and I was aware that, as always, the dialogue would be between the chair of the internal audit committee and the internal auditors.

As everyone in the room is aware, the internal auditors are appointed by the board and generally report to the audit committee of the college. My understanding is that the audit committee is a separate function from the executive but that it is supported by the executive. Mr Brown—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I do not want a big lecture; I want to know why you, as accountable officer, did not ensure that internal and external audit were aware of your severance package. Why did you not do that?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I am absolutely convinced that internal audit was aware of a severance package. It is interesting that the only people who have not been interviewed by the Public Audit Committee are the two internal auditors themselves. I was well aware—

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

No—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

We called for evidence from internal audit.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

The internal auditors for Coatbridge College did not appear here. It was one of the partners, who actually did not engage—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

We had two internal auditors—we can clarify that later.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

To my knowledge, I have not met the chap who appeared. Interruption. I think that you are just about to get some—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am coming on to my final question, but my point is that it was your responsibility as accountable officer.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I am going to explain—

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

It is an important point, and I am going to explain in detail.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Yes, as soon as the convener is quite happy that the two internal auditors with whom I and the board engaged at Coatbridge—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Mr Doyle, let me clarify that we ask the questions and you answer them.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I am happy to do so, sir.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I will come back to you on the matter that you raised, after the meeting, to clarify the position for the record.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Right. My understanding was—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Will you please answer the question?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I will be delighted to do so. My understanding was that in January the internal auditors were engaged with the college as part of the merger programme. I was also aware that the internal auditors were engaged with the audit committee, which Tom Keenan chaired, on the annual audit programme.

I was also very much aware that the internal auditors, with Scott-Moncrieff—who you all found out about a couple of weeks ago—had done extensive due diligence, front and centre of which was the severance package. My clear understanding, right through the period from January, was that the internal auditors were not only aware of but had been engaging in various forms on severance packages.

It was also my understanding that Scott-Moncrieff, who did the due diligence, would have been liaising directly with the internal auditors on the action plan. Scott-Moncrieff cannot produce a due diligence report for merger without talking to the internal auditors about what has been progressing in the college.

You are quite right, in that the very last thing that I did in closing down was to meet the internal auditors—I did that just before I left. That was on the basis that I was not happy that Scott-Moncrieff had put—or I had been advised that it had put—all the costs of the severance package of all the executive team, including all the on-costs, without the SFC contribution. I raised that with the internal auditors. Mrs Scanlon, internal audit was well aware.

Finally, if I may, I refer you to Mr Brown, who said that the internal auditors were well aware of the severance package and that he had spoken to either Mr Gray or Mr Keenan. I spoke to Mr Gray, and Mr Gray will confirm that he did not speak to the internal auditors, which means that, as one would imagine, the chair of the audit committee spoke to the internal auditors.

I was aware that the internal auditors had been engaged in the process since January, all the way through. It is incorrect to say that I did not engage with them or in some way held the information back from them. That is not correct.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

It has taken you a very long time—taking up a lot of our time—to talk about awareness and engagement, but you still have not answered the question, which was whether you, as accountable officer, assumed your responsibility and notified the internal and external auditors. You talk about expecting them to be aware and engaged and all around the shop, but the responsibility was yours and Audit Scotland and the internal and external auditors were not aware of your severance payment. I leave it there.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I think that there is something far wrong there, Mrs Scanlon, if the internal auditors were not aware, having gone through a programme from January right through to October and having engaged with the chair of the audit committee throughout the summer and beyond. My understanding is that the internal auditors had a clear duty to protect the board, were well aware that we were going through a merger programme and had carried out similar work with New College Lanarkshire and Motherwell and Cumbernauld colleges, so it is absolutely erroneous to say—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You were well aware that you should have told them.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I was well aware that they were aware. There was no point in writing separately if they were aware.

09:45

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Mr Doyle, when you gave evidence to the committee on 28 October, we heard that the events leading up to your decision to leave were the result of a discussion with representatives of the Scottish Government and the SFC. You said:

“Everyone in this room understands the language of power. When you are invited by the Scottish Government and the funding council to discuss your leaving early, you know that your position is untenable.” —Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 28 October 2015; c 48.

I think that that was in August—correct me if I am wrong.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

It would have been in August, yes. That was me leaving early—not leaving.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Yet, at the 28 January 2013 remuneration committee, the chair presented a letter outlining your untenable position at that point and the package that was offered. Does that not contradict that?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Not at all. In the context that there can be only one principal when there is a merger and that three colleges were merging, the chair and the board had obviously decided that they would produce a severance package, if it was required for me. At that point there were no structures and no interviews were on the horizon. After discussion with the chair of the board—as per the SFC guidance—I agreed that I would accept that offer.

It was not until mid-July that the Scottish Government representative and Linda McTavish came to the college and, as I wrote in the evidence that I sent on Monday, presented the terms and conditions for a merger to form what was going to be New College Lanarkshire. Contained within that was the fact that I could not apply for the job of principal, because it had been given to Mark McGuire.

I have made that very clear in my correspondence with the committee on a number of occasions.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Clearly, the job was given to someone else because Coatbridge College withdrew from the merger at a critical point.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Yes.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I return to the letter that you were issued with on 29 January 2013. Was there a termination date on that letter?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

I have not looked at it for a couple of years. My understanding is that it was what I would call an enabling agreement, in the context that if the date changed—forgive me if I get this wrong; I cannot remember whether it was March or 31 July—it would allow me to progress. If there was a delay in the vesting day, as it is called, the letter would still be intact. I think that it was a continuation date, not a fixed date. I may be wrong about that; I have not looked at the letter for a couple of years.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Other senior members received offer letters that had a termination date of 31 July. I am asking whether your letter had that same termination date.

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

From memory, it had 31 July. I do not want to get the words wrong. I may get the words slightly wrong, but the message from my understanding is—it is easily enough checked. Do you have a copy of my letter?

John Doyle Former Principal and Chief Executive, Coatbridge College
link

Okay. It would have been helpful.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 588
  3. 11:45 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 88
  4. 12:15 Section 23 Report Committee business · 26

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.